Tom Connolly & Chris Dyer

The Horseshoe Hangover

Sports EN ↓ 87 episodes

Join two passionate Colts and NFL outsiders every week as we break down the latest Indianapolis Colts news, analyze key NFL matchups, and share unfiltered takes on all things football. From game recaps to league-wide insights, *The Horseshoe Hangover* offers a fresh, weekly perspective on the highs and lows of Colts Nation. Saddle up and tune in each week as we ride through the season with a drink in hand and plenty of football talk! We call it how we see it and will not hold back.

Author

Tom Connolly & Chris Dyer

Category

Sports

Podcast website

podcasters.spotify.com

Latest episode

Jun 15, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Ep 62: Colts easily beat the Chargers 21.10.2025

The Colts continue to win and are undefeated in the AFC. This offense may be the best in the league and JT28 is the best running back in 2025. There is one weakness and Chris & Tom talk about.

Ep 61: Colts vs Chargers 18.10.2025

Week 7 has the Colts traveling to LA once again, but this time against the Chargers. Both teams are riddled with injuries and trying to stay at the top of the AFC. This is a huge opportunity for the Colts to prove they are what their record shows.

Ep 60: Week 6 Recap-Colts squeak out a win to go 5-1 15.10.2025

Was Gus Bradley secretly calling the defense, because the Colts allowed Jacoby Brissett to look like a starting QB in this league.

Ep 59: Colts vs the Red Smurf 11.10.2025

The AZ Cardinals come to town after losing 3 in a row hoping for redemption against the Colts. Unfortunately for them the Colts are the #1 offensive team in the NFL. The Colts will attempt to go 5-1 and continue their unpredictable rise to the top of the NFL.

Ep 58: Colts BLOW OUT the Raiders 08.10.2025

Chris gives a brilliant intro merging the Colts win over the Raiders and dropping Easter eggs showing love to Taylor Swift. We discuss the beating the Colts put on the Raiders and break down the Colts schedule over the next 5 weeks, wondering if a 9-1 record is possible. We discuss the Mark Sanchez incident in downtown Indy and how it hit close to home for Tom.

Ep 57: Colts vs Raiders preview 03.10.2025

The Colts host the 1-3 underperforming Raiders. There is no reason why we shouldn't be 4-1 after week 5!

Ep 56: Colts vs Rams recap - Who should the Colts cut after this loss?? 30.09.2025

Colts fans week 4 didn’t go our way as Indy came up short against the Los Angeles Rams, but let’s be clear—this wasn’t all bad news. Yes there are players that mad big mistakes, but there were flashes of real promise on both sides of the ball, and this team continues to show the kind of fight and growth that proves they’re better than we thought they would be.

Ep 55: 2025 week 4 Colts vs Rams 27.09.2025

Week 4 is here, and we’ve got a big one on deck — the Indianapolis Colts heading out west to take on the Los Angeles Rams. The Colts are coming in looking to keep momentum rolling after a strong start, while the Rams are trying to prove they’re still a force in the NFC. We’re breaking it all down — matchups, keys to victory, and what this game means for Indy moving forward. Let’s get into it.

Ep 54: Colts are 3-0 by demolishing the Titans 23.09.2025

The Colts roll to their second blowout win of 2025, smashing the Titans and doing something they haven’t done since 2021. “Indiana Jones” has this offense firing on all cylinders, the defense is holding its own, and yet—Chris and Tom found one area Indy still needs to clean up.

Ep 53: Week 3 Colts vs Titans and NFL picks 19.09.2025

The Colts are strumming into Nashville on a high note as a 2-0 team for the first time since 2009. The Colts look to go 3-0 against a Titans team that is struggling to generate any offense and can't stop the run, which the Colts are good at. We also make our NFL week 3 picks and Chris and Tom disagree on several big match ups.

Ep 52: Colts are 2-0, Week 2 recap Colts beat the Broncos 16.09.2025

The Colts are in the business of breaking old stats, they are 2-0 for the first time since 2009 when Peyton Manning was are starting QB. The Colts beat a very good Broncos team, needing a little bit of luck on the last play of the game. Chris and Tom were there to witness this instant classic.

Ep 51: Week 2 Colts vs Broncos preview and NFL Picks 12.09.2025

In week 2 of the NFL season the Colts are aiming for their first 2-0 start since 2009, back when Peyton Manning was still under center. Their defense looks to have a favorable matchup against the Broncos’ offense, but the bigger question is whether the Colts’ offense can rein in Denver’s dominant defense.

EP 50: The Colts finally break their week 1 losing streak! 09.09.2025

The Indianapolis Colts finally broke their 11-year Week 1 curse, earning a long-awaited season-opening victory in front of their home crowd over the Miami Dolphins. On a day filled with both emotion and celebration, the win carried extra weight as the franchise honored the late owner Jim Irsay. We’ll break down how the Colts snapped the streak, the standout performances that fueled the win, and wh...

Ep 49: 2025 Week 1 Colts vs Dolphins 05.09.2025

We preview the Colts week 1 matchup against the Dolphins. Both teams were 8-9 last year and missed the playoffs. Can the Colts break their 11-year curse, losing week 1?

Ep 48: Colts 2025 preview and NFL Division Picks 05.09.2025

NFL Football is back! Our Colts start their season this Sunday as they start their quest to suck less than last year. Can Daniel Jones lead this team to a division win? Can this revamped defense pull itself out of the bottom of the barrel Gus Bradley put them in? All that and we make our picks for each Colts game, giving our projected season record. We also make our final picks for all division wi...

Ep 47: Colts make their QB1 decision 20.08.2025

Tom & Chris react to the Colts making their QB1 decision between Danny "Indiana" Jones and AR! Chris covers the "bust" rate of 1st round QB's and Tom conjuries up the ghost of Jeff George, all this and more as we dissect the QB1 decision of the Colts.

Ep 46: 2025 Preseason: Injuries and more injuries 14.08.2025

On this podcast we discuss the plethora of injuries the Colts are dealing with and how that impacts the regular season. We continue to talk about the QB competition and Chris thinks Colts fans are being Gas Lit!

EP 45: 2025 Preseason game 1 and AFC West breakdown 10.08.2025

Colts play their first preseason game and in true Anthony Ricardson fashion, he gets hurt again. We talk about what went wrong and what went well for the Colts. We also break down the AFC West with a good friend of ours who is a giant Chiefs fan.

Ep 44: Tom and Chris go to Training Camp 06.08.2025

Football season is here and we are just a few weeks from our 1st NFL Sunday. On this episode the Horseshoe Hangover goes to training camp. We had the pleasure of watching the second worse QB battle in the NFL and saw a couple bright spots on this roster. We also discuss what we want to see in the 1st pre-season game against the Ravens.

EP 43: Colts stuff and our NFC North preview 16.07.2025

This week we have a loyal listener who is a BIG Lions fan join the POD for our NFC North preview. Tom talks shit about his favorite team to talk shit about and Chris has illusions about that team being a play-off contender, this and more on this the latest episode of Horseshoe Hangover!

Ep 42: Irsay Sisters press conf. & NFC West breakdown 17.06.2025

The new owners of the Indianapolis Colts speak for the media and fans for the first time after their fathers passing. We discuss the interview and Carly throws some zingers. We also discuss the NFC West and make our way to early predictions for the NFC West. Chris and Tom also disagree on the Aaron Rodgers signing in Pittsburg.

Ep 41: AR is hurt again & our breakdown of the AFC East 10.06.2025

AR injuries his shoulder throwing in shorts and t-shirt. We discuss NFL new around the league and an Early Break down of the AFC East.

Ep 40: Preview for the NFC South 07.06.2025

We discuss the NFC South, talk about JT being stubbed from the list of best running backs, we talk about the Jim Irsay patch, and we discuss the Colts joint practices for this years training camp.

Ep 39: Jim Irsay passes away & preview of the AFC South 27.05.2025

We share our thoughts on the unfortunate passing of Colts owner Jim Irsay. We discuss what we look forward to seeing with his daughters taking over and we do an early break down of the AFC South for 2025.

Ep. 38 - 2025 NFL Draft Rd1 reaction 25.04.2025

The Colts and Colts fans see their favorite Draft target fall in their laps at Pick 14, getting Tyler Warren, Lets Go! Jags and Falcons make horrible trade ups and Shedeur Sanders doesn't get drafted in the first round. The Horseshoe Hangover is back for the 2025 NFL Season.

Listen to the The Horseshoe Hangover podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.