The Guilty and The Ghostly

In this gripping episode, we delve into the chilling story of Richard Cottingham, infamously known as the Torso Killer. The episode explores his heinous crimes, the relentless pursuit by Detective Robert Ancelotti to solve cold cases linked to Cottingham, and the psychological games played by the killer even behind bars. Listeners will be taken through the dark corridors of Cottingham's mind, his...

Josh and Audrey discuss the intriguing phenomenon of the Fresno Nightcrawlers, a cryptid that has captured public interest through various sightings and videos. They explore the origins of the Nightcrawlers, analyze footage, and delve into theories surrounding their existence, including the possibility of them being extraterrestrial or interdimensional beings.

Private detectives, labor wars, and a legacy that won’t quit. This episode digs into the rise and lasting impact of the Pinkerton Detective Agency.

A burning car. A rural road. And a young woman fighting to speak as flames stole her life. The Jessica Chambers case is one that has divided juries, haunted investigators, and left the public questioning what really happened that night in Courtland, Mississippi. In this episode, we unravel the chilling final hours of Jessica’s life, the disputed dying declaration, and the legal twists that turned...

As the holiday season approaches, many of us are filled with festive joy and cheer. However, there exists a darker side to Christmas that is often overlooked. In this blog post, we will delve into some of the most chilling tales and traditions that lurk beneath the surface of our beloved holiday, exploring how these eerie legends have shaped our understanding of Christmas.

Ed and Lorraine Warren built a paranormal empire, but was it based on truth or theatrics? In this episode of Guilty and the Ghostly, we dig into the real stories behind the famous demonologists, the cases that made them legends, and the controversies often left out. Fact, fear, faith, and fabrication collide as we ask the question no horror movie dares to answer: were the Warrens authentic investi...

We’re joined by our special guests from Remember That?, and together we’re unpacking the allegedly true and absolutely chilling experiences of the Lutz family. The haunting that sparked one of the most infamous horror stories of all time. From unexplained sounds to sinister shadows and everything the Lutzes claimed lurked within those walls… we’re breaking it all down. Did the family truly endure...

In this chilling episode, we dig into the night Amityville’s quiet façade shattered forever. Six members of the DeFeo family were found murdered in their beds. No signs of struggle, no neighbors awakened, and only one survivor: 23-year-old Ronald DeFeo Jr. Join us as we unravel the twisted events leading up to the killings, the shocking confession, and the disturbing questions that still haunt Oce...

This week, Josh and Audrey dive into the heartbreaking and baffling Taconic Parkway crash at the center of Something’s Wrong with Aunt Diane. How did a responsible, devoted mother end up driving the wrong way and causing one of the deadliest crashes in New York history? We break down the timeline, the toxicology results, the unanswered questions, and the chilling contradictions that still haunt th...

This week Josh and Audrey celebrated their 16-year anniversary the only way they know how: with a virtual date night and a murder-for-hire plot. Audrey takes Josh down the twisty, messy, absolutely unhinged case of Dalia Dippolito. A woman who juggled a husband, multiple side guys, and a Craigslist-level hitman plan, all while denying everything. And somewhere in the middle of it all… an orb may o...

This week, Tory and Audrey uncover the chilling case of Anneliese Michel. She believed the Devil had taken hold of her soul. Her priest believed it too. But was Anneliese Michel truly possessed or the victim of a devastating misunderstanding? Tory and Audrey dive deep into the case that blurred the line between miracle and maddness.

This week on Guilty and the Ghostly, we’re back at the infamous Fredonia Hotel for Part Two! What did Audrey uncover during her stay? Did she finally come face-to-face with Happy Jack himself? Plus, we’re taking you deeper into Nacogdoches’ haunted history with chilling tales from the Sterne-Hoya House and Stephen F. Austin State University’s most spirited spots—the Griffith Fine Arts Building and...

In this episode Josh and Audrey explore the haunted history of the Fredonia Hotel in Nacogdoches, Texas. They share personal experiences, discuss the hotel's rich history, and delve into ghost stories associated with the location. We discuss the significance of a now-gone tree that once stood in the hotel, the revival of the hotel after years of decline, and the lingering spirits that are said to...

In this episode, Josh and Audrey discuss the tragic true crime story of Timothy O'Brien, who died after consuming a poisoned pixy stick on Halloween night in 1974. The conversation explores the events leading up to the incident, the investigation that followed, and the trial of his father, Ronald O'Brien, who was ultimately convicted of murder. We also discuss how this case transformed Halloween t...

This episode of The Guilty and the Ghostly Podcast Tory and Audrey delve into the harrowing story of J.C. Lee Dugard, who was kidnapped at the age of 11 and held captive for 18 years. We discuss the psychological and physical challenges J.C. faced during her captivity, including the birth of her two daughters. Jaycee's story is a testament to resilience and the enduring bond of motherhood, as well...

Exorcism is as old as human history. In 1949, a boy in Maryland became the subject of one of the most documented possessions in America, inspiring The Exorcist and sparking tales of a Hollywood curse. This is the story where faith, folklore, and fear collide.

Audrey and Seth uncover the dark history and chilling hauntings of Waverly Hills Sanatorium—where tragedy, legend, and the paranormal collide.

This week, Audrey and Tory dig into the dark and bizarre origins of CPR. From strange experiments to downright morbid attempts at reviving the dead. Buckle up, it’s not the lifesaving history you thought you knew!

Welcome to our very first mini episode! This week, Audrey and Tory dive into the infamous Paris Morgue, where the line between tragedy and entertainment blurred. Join us as we unpack the morbid fascination that drew crowds to view the dead in 1800s Paris.

Josh takes the mic today with a deep dive into the origin of Sasquatch. From Indigenous legends to the coining of the name, all the way to modern-day sightings and beliefs. Is Bigfoot a cultural icon, a cryptid, or something else entirely? Tune in and decide for yourself.

Beneath the peat of Norther Europe lie bodies preserved for thousands of years, faces, hair, even last meals intact. Were they sacrifices, criminals or cursed souls? In this episode, Seth and Audrey uncover the chilling mysteries of the bog bodies.

We’re back with Part 2 of the Slender Man case! This week, we dive into what Morgan Geyser and Anissa Weier were diagnosed with, the outcomes of their trials, and the sentences they received. But the big question remains, was justice really served for such a brutal crime? Tune in and join the conversation!

Join us in Part1 as we dive into the chilling Slender Man case and the incredible survival story of Payton Lautner. Two young girls turned on their best friend, stabbing her multiple times in a shocking attempt to prove their loyalty to the fictional figure known as Slender Man. We'll explore how the internet born myth blurred the lines between fantasy and reality.

Josh and Audrey are back from vacation and ready to jump right in with a wild one! This week, we dive into the famous Betty and Barney Hill abduction case. From what they remember if that strange night, to the controversial hypnosis sessions, and all the eerie details in between. Buckle up and tune in for one unforgettable story.