Max Timm & Scott Markus

The Fantastic Story Society

History EN ↓ 57 episodes

From true crime to the paranormal, to urban legends and myths and the down-right weird, The Fantastic Story Society finds them, dissects them, and most importantly discusses such stories with an expert in the realm of the fantastic. Join historical researchers, experts on serial killers, ghost tour guides, archaeologists, and more as The Society hosts, Max Timm and Scott Markus, seek out the most bizarre stories you can imagine and try to find the voice behind the fantastic.

Author

Max Timm & Scott Markus

Category

History

Podcast website

fantastic.libsyn.com

Latest episode

Oct 31, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

FSS 32: Tim Ellis, MI ParaCon & a UFO Collision Over Lake Michigan 18.08.2022

Author, radio host and co-founder of the Michigan Paranormal Conference, Tim Ellis, discusses his origins in ghost hunting, which eventually lead him to start one of the largest "ParaCons" in the country.

FSS 31: Dobie Maxwell, Stand-Up Comedy, UFOs & Bank Robberies 18.07.2022

Stand-Up comic Dobie Maxwell has lived through it all in his comedy career, from meaningful chats w/ Rodney Dangerfield & George Carlin to driving the getaway car after a bank heist (without knowing it), but he's still looking for his first UFO encounter.

FSS 30: John Champion & the Importance of Star Treks' Storytelling 21.06.2022

Star Trek has continued to evolve and stay relevant in pop culture as one of the most storied titles in television history. "Mission Log" podcast co-host John Champion joins to talk Trek, skepticism & an upcoming event that's free & open to the public.

FSS 29: Luke Epplin & Our Team, "the Best Baseball Story in the World" 14.06.2022

Luke Epplin discovered the most impressive baseball story most people haven't heard of and the four men & one woman who lived heroic lives behind the scenes.

FSS 28: Filmmaker Adam Ridley & HBO's Murders at Starved Rock 12.05.2022

Was the right person arrested for killing 3 women in Illinois in 1960? Documentary filmmaker Adam Ridley sheds some light on this mysterious case as co-executive producer of HBO's Murders at Starved Rock true crime limited series.

FSS 27: Haunted Galena Conference, Prankster Ghosts at the Dowling House & DeSoto Hotel's Woman in Black 25.03.2022

We look ahead to the Haunted Galena Paranormal Conference and tell stories of tragedy at Berry Tavern, the Prankster Ghosts at the Dowling House & DeSoto House Hotel's Woman in Black with guest Theodore Williams.

FSS 26: Award-Winning Screenwriter Mugs Cahill, Irish Lore & Haunted Lighthouses 20.03.2022

Mugs Cahill's new supernatural pilot "Nantucket" recently won the Grand Prize for Table Read My Screenplay contest & was a finalist at the Big Apple Film Festival & Vancouver Women's Int'l Film Festival. We talk to her about her research and Irish lore.

FSS 25: Joe Posnanski & Writing to Your Passions, Hamilton to Houdini to Baseball Greats 31.01.2022

Joe Posnanski has made a career by being inspired by curiosity and following his own passions. That's lead to him writing numerous books, winning awards and most importantly, surrounding himself with people that fascinate him. #HarryHoudini #Baseball

FSS 24: Year In Review & Preview 14.01.2022

We take a moment to re-celebrate the guests we've had last year, from Jonathan Katz to David Farrier. We also take a look ahead to personal and show paranormal goals in 2022.

FSS 23: David Farrier, Dark Tourist & Conspiracy Theory Analyst 30.12.2021

We speak with documentarian & journalist David Farrier, the host of Netflix's "Dark Tourist" and current co-host of "Armchaired & Dangerous."

FSS 21: Designing Board Games & Storytelling with Rob Daviau 13.11.2021

There's more than one way to tell a story & sometimes you need a good dice roll before you can write, "the end." We speak with prolific game designer Rob Daviau. His resume is basically our game shelf, including Betrayal at the House on the Hill & Risk Legacy.

FSS Hall of Fame: DJ MacHale Ghost Stories, Horror & Bozophobia 02.11.2021

We welcome back DJ MacHale, creator of the Pendragon series and Are You Afraid of the Dark for our live Halloween Special and to induct him into our Hall of Fame!

FSS 19: Lisa Van Buskirk & Madison's Haunted Oyster Bar + Ghost Hunt 16.10.2021

We chat with Madison ghost tour guide Lisa Van Buskirk on location at a haunted site, followed by an investigation of the building.

FSS 18: Carlos Alazraqui from Reno 911 Wrote a Zombie Movie 02.08.2021

Stand Up Comic & comedy actor Carlos Alazraqui (Reno 911) Wrote a Zombie Mafia Comedy feature. We discuss the behind the scenes of his first feature.

FSS 17: Jessica Watkins, the Stand-Up Comic Who Walked Across America 23.05.2021

Stand-Up Comic, Jessica Watkins created a must-watch, innovative, documentary/stand-up special titled "SPECIALish" about her journey to walk across America while performing comedy.

FSS 16: Baseball's Ghost Stories w/ Mickey Bradley & Dan Gordon 11.04.2021

Curses & superstitions are as much a part of baseball as balls & strikes. Folklore & baseball are intertwined as is the human behavior of seeking reason in chaos. Now, baseball's a melting pot of cultures, introducing new ghost stories & beliefs.

FSS 15: Finding 'Ohana's Nightmarchers & the Possessed Girl w/ Lopaka Kapanui 02.03.2021

Hawaiian storyteller Lopaka Kapanui served as cultural & paranormal consultant on the popular Netflix action/adventure film "Finding 'Ohana." Hear his background as a storyteller, plus a truly terrifying case.

FSS 14: Jonathan Katz, Being Seriously Funny alongside the likes of David Mamet, Johnny Carson & Garry Shandling 18.01.2021

Jonathan Katz is perhaps best known in animated form in "Dr Katz: Professional Therapist." He's had a long career before and since as a standup comic & screenwriter. He talks about his upcoming "Dr Katz: Live" performance & finding his way in comedy.

Fantastic Story Society Ep 13 Tea Krulos: Richard McCaslin's American Madness, the Dark Side of Conspiracy Theory 20.12.2020

Tea Krulos has written some wild true-life stories. American Madness is a deep look at the life of an eccentric "real life super hero" who was radicalized by Alex Jones & David Icke. Conspiracy Theories, Bohemian Grove & Krampus highlight this episode.

FSS 12 Halloween Special: Wendy Lynn Staats & Growing up Around Local Legends 26.10.2020

We're so excited to welcome Wendy Lynn Staats to talk about some of the local Wisconsin legends & local ghost stories she grew up with, including the Milwaukee Witch, Beast of Bray Road, Mary Buth & Haunchyville.

Fantastic Story Society Ep 11: Murder & Ghosts in Rockford, Illinois w/ Kathi Kresol 19.06.2020

Historian Kathi Kresol uses her platform as an author to speak for the victims. Seldom is it so obvious how a writer found her voice than when you hear about the murder-suicide that took place in Kathi's home & the ghosts that remain.

Fantastic Story Society - Ep 10 - Jon Ronson & Being Tailed by a Secret Society 22.05.2020

Jon Ronson has lived a life more exciting than one you'd think a writer could live.   He gotten up close and personal with the likes of self-appointed superheroes, countless psychopaths (both in prison and in the boardroom) Nazis, Islamic Extremists, and even the Insane Clown Posse.   He and a young Alex Jones infiltrated the mysterious Bohemian Grove Ceremony   and his attempt to do the same at t...

Fantastic Story Society - Ep 9 - DJ MacHale & Are You Afraid of the Dark? 08.05.2020

One of our favorite people jumped into the virtual Society studio and talked all things story, spooky, cool, and inspiring - DJ MacHale! A New York Times bestseller, author, screenwriter, producer, director - he's basically done it all where story is concerned. He even read Max's YA fantasy novel, The WishKeeper, and gave it the best review yet. We kinda like this guy. Famous for creating the 90's...

Fantastic Story Society - Ep 8 - Poor Maryanne Miller & Haunted Galena Tour 18.03.2020

Happy 2020, everyone! It's already off to a banging, weird, and fantastic start. We couldn't be happier to have two fantastic people on as guests in our first episode of 2020 - Robyn David and Ted Williams are the hosts of the Haunted Galena Tour Company, and if you haven't heard of Galena, you're about to get a deep dive into all of the amazing history, spooky ghost stories, and how their tour co...

The Fantastic Story Society - Amelia Cotter & Chicago's Serpent Mound 30.11.2019

Are you afraid of snakes? We would venture to guess your answer is "yes". Amelia Cotter, however, wants to help you reorganize your beliefs about our serpent friends, and she does so in our seventh episode of The Fantastic Story Society. While there is plenty of fantastic ghost stories told in this episode (Amelia's telling of her one and only encounter with a ghost is excellent), we learned that...

Listen to the The Fantastic Story Society podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.