The Creep Off

The Creep Off

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

Author

The Creep Off

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

www.podomatic.com

Latest episode

Jul 6, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 245: 501C-3ped0 30.12.2024

In this episode Karl & Vinnie present their picks for the biggest creeps of 2024: On Karl’s cop cam we meet a drunk woman dressed like a cow who refused to Mooo-ve (get it?): The Scum Parade features a lazy FedEx delivery driver, a guy who had a little too much fun at mass and a set of parents who don’t like a bragger  The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and...

Episode 244: Creepmas '24 23.12.2024

In this week’s contest Karl & Vinnie take on the creeps of Christmas: In Karl’s cop cam we meet the most laid-back reckless driver in history: The Scum Parade features a pair of overly affectionate Dutch parents, a woman celebrating her divorce and the worst mother ever.  The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 1, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winner Check out the Scum Pa...

Episode 243: The Worst Apple 16.12.2024

Karl's nursing a victory hangover, but we've got the perfect remedy: a heaping dose of Scum and cop cam videos! Join us as we check out some of the biggest scum bags we missed from the past few weeks. Check out the Scum Parade stories:  Raygun the Musical: Comedian Steph Broadbridge shuts down show after legal letter Felony Charge Over Dipping Sauce Dispute | The Smoking Gun South Jersey woman vic...

Episode 242: The/Rapist 09.12.2024

Karl is back this week, and the contest continues as our hosts make their nominations for creepiest psychologist: Karl’s Cop Cam features a woman who had the time of her life before her salon appointment. Plus, in the Scum Parade we meet an awesome grandpa, a perverted teacher and a father whose DIY project went very wrong The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 0, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and...

Episode 241: Glazed? 03.12.2024

Karl is off this week, so Vinnie will be joined by "Blind" Mike Geary from Who are these Socials & The Blind Mike Project. Tune in at 3pm et for a special post-thanksgiving scum parade. Check out the Scum Parade stories:  Florida inmates have 'miracle' baby by using air vent to get pregnant - US News - News - Daily Express US Man offered to buy 4-year-old girl for $200 on South Beach, then exp...

Episode 240: Father of the Bride 25.11.2024

It’s wild card week and that means Karl and Vinnie can nominate anyone from any category for biggest creep: Karl’s Cop Cam features a woman who learns that mocking the police does not end well. Plus, in the Scum Parade we meet a mother raising a very independent two-year-old, A high school football coach who has better things to do than teach a class and we learn there is nothing worse than a frie...

Episode 239: The Older the Berry 18.11.2024

In this episode Karl & Vinnie nominate the pestiest exterminator of all time and someone spins the wheel of consequences: Karl’s Cop Cam features a beautiful young woman who will never work as an actress. Plus, in the Scum Parade we meet a man on a Dunkin Donuts run, a 14-year-old who decided to lose his virginity and Syracuse’s finest legal mind The score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 0, visit...

Episode 238: From Cambodia with Love 11.11.2024

In honor of the Marine Corps 249th birthday & Veteran's Day Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest Marine: Karl’s Cop Cam features a woman dressed like a pumpkin fighting the police over snacks at a movie theater. Plus, in the Scum Parade we meet a man who did not like his wife’s new haircut, a kid who did not want to do his homework and the hottest mom in Florida!   The score...

Episode 237: The Call is Coming from Inside the House! 04.11.2024

You thought your choices this election day were creepy? Join Karl & Vinnie as they make their nominations for the biggest creeps to ever appear on a US ballot for President! Karl’s Cop Cam features a man who tries a very silly way to visit Greenland while burning his girlfriend’s house to the ground: In the Scum Parade we meet a Taiwanese underwear bandit, a mom who took her sons to Niagara Fa...

Episode 236: It's All Recreational 28.10.2024

This week Karl & Vinnie are back from Detroit and bring you our third annual "Detroit Hangover Edition" Featuring scum stories and a cop cam that has it all! Check out the Stories Here: Man threatens to blow up beauty store, draws on face: Cops https://www.kait8.com/2024/10/23/police-man-urinated-hospital-equipment-threatened-staff/ Man hospitalised after stuffing 15 EGGS up his bottom while o...

Episode 235: America’s Funniest Home Videos 23.10.2024

This week Karl & Vinnie make their cases for creepiest fitness trainer: Karl’s Cop Cam features the 19-year-old daughter of a district attorney who believes the police are harassing her: In the Scum Parade we meet a man who made his bosses nose disappear, a funeral director who took his work home with him and a 36-year-old mother who gave a ten-year-old tips on infanticide while playing Roblox...

Episode 234: A Club of Foot 14.10.2024

This week Karl & Vinnie head down to dixie to make their nominations for the biggest creep from the "Yellow Hammer" state of Alabama: Karl’s Cop Cam features a chilling drag racing accident that leaves two dead, and a woman who refuses to accept her role in the tragedy. Plus, in the Scum Parade we discover the bizarre tales of a small-town amateur photographer, a 32-year-old witch, and a pecul...

Episode 233: You Get One Warning! 07.10.2024

Join Karl and Vinnie as they dive into the world of real estate and nominate the creepiest agents of all time. Karl’s Cop Cam captures a very large woman in a tesla who decided to run from the cops…Hilarity ensues: The Scum Parade feature a doctor in disguise, a crack head plays hide and seek in a hospital & we meet a husband who does not understand how a lie detector test works.   The score i...

Episode 232: Three Dogs and a Baby 30.09.2024

This week, Karl and Vinnie live mas and make their nominations for creepiest Taco Bell Employee: Karl’s Cop Cam captures a smelly woman’s terrible attempt at fleeing the police: The Scum Parade features a set of young parents who know how to drive a hard bargain, a very sneaky inmate & a fake penis doctor!  The score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this...

Episode 231: The Spirit of the Rule 23.09.2024

This week, we officially kick off the round with a wildcard match. Karl & Vinnie are free to bring the worst scum they can find from any category. On Karl's Cop Cam, we meet a very drunk woman who turns herself in to the police on the side of the road. This one is a first! The Scum Parade introduces us to a woman who can't stop stealing her boyfriends' dildos, a horny social studies teacher, a...

Episode 230: Is This Justice? 16.09.2024

This week, Karl and Vinnie kick off a new round by nominating the creepiest high school football coach. Instead of a cop cam video, Karl surprises us all and reads us his report on Helga Mann's book, "Little Red Book." In the Scum Parade, we learn about a mysterious prankster in a dollar store, meet an unsuccessful canine Romeo, and encounter a man who made a cucumber disappear. And to top it all...

Episode 229: Karl’s Moment of Clarity or Never Put Vinnie in a Corner 09.09.2024

This week, Danni makes an exciting announcement, Vinnie is on game point and our hosts make their nominations for the creepiest car salesman of all time: In Karl’s Cop Cam we watch a young man get exactly what he deserves, and an Acura gets dented: The Scum Parade we meet a casket thief, an 11-year-old killer and a man who loved his grandmother The score is currently Vinnie 4 - Karl 0, visit thecr...

Episode 228: Labor Day Dick-off! 02.09.2024

Karl & Vinnie are not laboring today, instead we bring our latest Dick-off! We joined Dick and Sean on the Dick Show for a scum parade! Check out the Dick Show Here at https://thedickshow.com/ Check out the stories here:  Man jailed for impersonating Miami Springs pizzeria, delivering disgusting pies, police say (local10.com) Diving instructor caught on GoPro 'masturbating' above student under...

Episode 227: Cameras off Boys! 26.08.2024

This week, Karl and Vinnie check under the hood and nominate the creepiest auto mechanic: In Karl’s Cop Cam we watch a woman lose her mind with a fire extinguisher in the Atlanta Airport: The Scum Parade meet a woman who made a fish disappear, and another woman who made a cat disappear and a man who’s trip to Burger King will cost him 140 years in prison.  The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 0,...

Episode 226: One Angry Juror 20.08.2024

Due to Vinnie having to fulfill his civic duty today we have a special hangover edition of the Creep-off: Karl’s Cop Cam captures a gentleman who really does not want the cops to look at his driver’s license: In today’s Scum Parade we meet some shameless Applebee’s patrons, a deaf proctologist and the worst son ever!  Chicago woman arrested at Indiana Applebee's after argument over 'All You Can Ea...

Episode 225: Crip Life 12.08.2024

This week, Karl and Vinnie dive into the murky waters of celebrity pasts, nominating their creepiest "has-beens." Karl’s Cop Cam captures a cringe-worthy moment as a young woman crashes her car into a ditch and disappoints her dad in spectacular fashion: The Scum Parade delivers a group that enforced their rules with a pirate-themed punishment, two sisters who played with fire, and a cautionary ta...

Episode 224: Life Will Find a Way 05.08.2024

This week Karl & Vinnie kick off the new round with a wildcard episode: Karl's Cop Cam introduces us to a Reno resident who's clearly got untapped WWE potential: In the Scum Parade, we meet an airplane passenger that can’t handle his weed, a teenage dirtbag and a man who made a live eel disappear!  The score is currently Vinnie 1 - Karl 0, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s w...

Episode 223: Stop in the Name of Meth! 29.07.2024

This week Karl & Vinnie are joined by Johnny Fiorica a retired Detective from the Crime Dawgs Podcast to break down the Maplewood park shooting in Rochester, NY: In this week’s competition the boys make their nominations for the biggest creeps on the boat: Karl's Cop Cam features an officer's encounter with an attractive young mom who, unfortunately, is also an ugly crier: In the Scum Parade,...

Episode 222: Reverse Mr. Hands 22.07.2024

This week Karl & Vinnie climb down in the gutter and make their nominations for the biggest creep in the bowling alley: In Karl’s cop cam we watch a drunk woman ruin the reputation of the Irish: In the Scum Parade, we meet an amateur shower videographer, a heartbroken patriotic Russian man and a man who loves his mother  The score is currently Vinnie 3 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote a...

Episode 221: Mr. Pancake's Gerbil Pants 15.07.2024

Karl's back, and Vinnie's got a treasure trove of creepy stories and wild cop cam footage to share. You won't want to miss this scum parade! Check out the stories here: VIDEO: Columbus police bust hamster bandit after string of break-ins (abc6onyourside.com) Woman dies after being shoved into San Francisco BART train (lawandcrime.com) Murderer Mom Uses Makeup to Cover Bruises on Battered 4-Year-Ol...

Listen to the The Creep Off podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.