The Creep Off

The Creep Off

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.podomatic.com

Author

The Creep Off

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

www.podomatic.com

Latest episode

Oct 12, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android almost 10M downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 64: A Big Version of Fat Elvis 24.05.2021

In this episode Vinnie & Karl make their nominations for Creepiest Social Worker: In the Scum Parade we meet a brand new serial killer from south of the border, a Shoe Salesman who really really liked his job and finally we learn why Myrtle Beach was not made for lovers.

Episode 63: #63 Syracuse Rich 18.05.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl are joined by our pal Brian McBride to make our nominations for biggest creep in Syracuse: Vinnie & Karl give updates on their current consequences: In the Scum Parade we meet a horny teacher, a fake student and an overdramatic Frenchman.

Episode 62: One Big Happy Hamburger Family 10.05.2021

This week Karl and Vinnie remember to check the references for their nominations for creepiest babysitter: Vinnie updates everyone on the rapid progress of his consequences, and we announce the date and time of our next Hall of Fame Patreon episode: In the Scum Parade we meet a fugazi mob boss, a woman who simply drove by her ex’s funeral and a Florida man with a plan

Episode 61: Pedo No.5 04.05.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl are in contempt as they make their nominations for creepiest judge: We find out the hotly contested results of last week’s episode and if Vinnie has to spin the wheel: In the Scum Parade we meet a man who just can’t have nice things…like a girlfriend, a baby whose dirty diaper was the least of her problems and finally we hear some hot suburban creep gossip

Episode 60: Mr.Postman 26.04.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl mail in their nominations for creepiest postal worker: In the scum parade we meet Parisian Andrew Cuomo a 10 year old NARC and an inconsiderate panty thief: We announce who lost the Patreon contest, and how you can decide their consequence.

Episode 59: The Softer Side of Karl 19.04.2021

This week Karl is on game point, and our hosts submit their nominations for the biggest creep of the 1930’s: In the scum parade we meet an impatient fast food patron, a kinky equestrian and the Brazilian Grim Reaper.

Creeps' N Roses #5 Weaponized Girl Power 16.04.2021

This is it, the 5th and official last episode of Creeps' N Roses. Enjoy

Episode 58: It’s Still Real To Me Dammit 13.04.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl are joined in studio by former WWE Superstar Colin Delaney (@extremelycute on Twitter and @extremelycolin on Instagram) to make their nominations for the creepiest wrestler not named Chris Benoit: The boys give an update on the new patreon score: In the Scum Parade we meet an axe wielding slot machine junkie, we learn about the greatest live stream channel ever and fina...

Hall of Fame: Jared Fogle Bonus Episode 08.04.2021

Ladies & Gentlemen please enjoy this very special Hall of Fame Induction episode of the Creep Off. Today we learn all about the rise and fall of disgraced sandwich eater Jared Fogle! Please take a second and join us on Patreon for future Hall of Fame Episodes other bonuses and cool merch! https://www.patreon.com/TheCreepOff

Episode 57: #57 The Pink Slip 06.04.2021

In spite of never completing a book in their lives Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest author: In the scum parade we meet the new Russian Olympic baby throwing champion, we learn to never mix Nyquil with other medications and why you should not go to home depot for cosmetic surgery supplies.

Episode 56: Easter Special: Blood Sacrifice & Necromancy 30.03.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl welcome spring by submitting their nominations for Easters worst of the worst: In the scum parade we meet a Mom who is not afraid to get her fist dirty, a pervy Bank Teller and a nude guy named Carl.

Creeps' N Roses #4 The Red Wedding 24.03.2021

This week Vinnie, PJ Philliam & Brian McBride are your guides through the biggest meltdown of season 25 of the Bachelor

Episode 55: Beth I Hear You Calling 23.03.2021

In honor of St. Patrick this week Vinnie & Karl search for the creepiest descendent of the Emerald Isle: In the Scum Parade we make a stop in the greatest city in the world, we meet a fake cosmetic surgeon and a man who borrowed his grandfather’s ear: Finally the Wheel of Consequences is spun and Karl is not pleased

Episode 54: Mail Fraud 15.03.2021

This week our heroes welcome another wildcard round, with one rule…NO PEDOS!: In the Scum Parade we meet a cop who couldn’t find a bathroom, A really horny guy and a family annihilating insurance fraudster

Episode 53: Excitable Boys 09.03.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie submit for your consideration their nominations for creepiest kid under 13: In the Scum Parade we check in with Creep Off favorite Kellen Winslow Jr. We also meet a creepy mother, a terrible roommate and a very naughty cop.

Creeps’N Roses #3 Slut + Whore = SLWHORE 06.03.2021

This week we pick up right where we left off…who went home Victoria or Marylin? Is Sarah Okay? Does Matt ever stop whining? Tune in to find out! Featuring the talents of PJ Philliam & Brian McBride

Episode 52: "M" is For the Way You Murder Me 02.03.2021

Today on our one year anniversary our pal Crippled Jesus joins us for a fun filled dive into the world of the depraved and disabled! We also get the exciting conclusion to the Crippled Jesus vs his professor saga: In the Scum Parade we meet a mom who really needed a break, and a tire shop employee who worked way to hard for a day off and finally we get an update on our favorite dumb stupid & d...

Episode 51: The Slowest Gazelle 22.02.2021

This week the despicable duo seek to discover who is the creepiest Talk Show Host: In the Scum Parade we meet a lonely guy, a Foster Mom who just wanted some peace and quiet and we question whether or not possession is nine-tenths of the law

Creeps' N Roses #2 Creeps' N Bailys 20.02.2021

This week Vinnie continues to suffer his consequences as he and PJ take a deep dive in episodes 1 & 2 of Season 25 of the Bachelor.

Episode 50: Slurp Slurp the Ewok 16.02.2021

This week the Despicable Duo submit their nominations for creepiest furry: In the Scum Parade we meet a man standing up for his rights, an NFL ready Mom and finally we learn an important lesson just be nice…your life may depend on it

Creeps' N Roses: #1 Minimum Maximum Effort 14.02.2021

Vinnie lost and the wheel has spoken so sit back and enjoy! In this inaugural episode Vinnie & Pj Philliam join forces to create the most useless podcast ever! This week we learn the rules and get to know the star of season #25 the Bachelor himself Matt James

Episode 49: New Country, Who Dis? 09.02.2021

This week’s fan choice was “Creepiest 21st century World leader” and one of our hosts didn’t quite understand the assignment (Hint. It was the fat one) Brian McBride joins the boys to submit their nominations: Vinnie makes a big announcement on his podcast consequence and voting is up for the first Hall of Fame bonus episode: In the Scum Parade we meet an elderly man who finally achieved his dream...

Episode 48: Dr. Noose 01.02.2021

This week Vinnie & Karl nominate their candidates for biggest creep of 2005: The boys announce their plan for new bonus episodes, and we receive a new communication from V-Anon: In the Scum Parade we meet a hungry ambulance thief, a man who took his job and shot it and a Doctor whose only crime was wanting to be young again.

Episode 47: Foreign Interference 25.01.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest bowler: The boys deal with the fall out of their humiliating loss to Kaya: In the scum parade we meet a car thief with a conscience, a dopey donut stealing fake cop and finally we listen to an accused child murderer dabble in stand-up…spoiler it’s not funny

Episode 46: The Youngest You Can Get 19.01.2021

This week Karl & Vinnie are joined by our pal Kaya to find the creepiest Trans person: Karl lays out Vinnie’s podcast consequence and gives him a choice: In the Scum Parade we meet a man who is good with a saw, a couple who had a hot date and finally we learn about the snuggle party massacre in Texas.

Listen to the The Creep Off podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.