Kirk Buchner
The Buck Stops Here
The Buck Stops Here is the official podcast of NotInHallOfFame.com, where host Kirk Buchner and his rotating cast of co-hosts—including Evan Nolan and Chris Mouradian—tackle the ever-evolving world of sports legacy. From Hall of Fame snubs to underappreciated legends, this show dives deep into the stories behind the stats. Whether it’s breaking down new inductees, debating controversial omissions, or spotlighting forgotten greats, The Buck Stops Here is where sports history gets the respect—and scrutiny—it deserves.
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.notinhalloffame.com
Author
Kirk Buchner
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Oct 14, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
🚀WNBA Rookie MVP Shock, Rybakina Takes Over Tennis, NHL Legend's HOF Dilemma & Lane Johnson Retires! 14.10.2026 35:00
Welcome back to The Elevator Show! Hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian are back to break down who is moving UP and DOWN in Hall of Fame stock this month. It’s a packed episode covering major milestones and retirements across the sports world. We discuss Olivia Miles' historic rookie MVP run in the WNBA, Natalie Nakase's incredible coaching job with the expansion Golden State Valkyries,...
Inside the Honus Wagner Museum: Rare Stories, The $7M Card & Holding His Actual Bat! 10.10.2026 20:54
Kirk Buchner sits down with Jeff Keenan, president and curator of the Historical Society of Carnegie, home to the official Honus Wagner Museum in Pittsburgh, PA.Honus Wagner, the legendary Pittsburgh Pirates "Flying Dutchman," was just voted into the US Athletics Hall of Fame by the fans! In this special episode, Jeff shares the official plaque, dives into Honus’s incredible legacy, and...
Rube Foster's Baseball Legacy & The Future of the Game | USAHOF Induction 09.10.2026 26:00
Welcome to a very special episode of The Buck Stops Here, the official program of NotInHallOfFame.com and the United States Athletics Hall of Fame (USAHOF)!In this episode, host Kirk Buchner sits down with Doug Foster (grandnephew of the legendary Rube Foster) and Gill Florentino to celebrate Rube Foster’s recent induction into the USAHOF. Voted in by the American public, Rube Foster is widely con...
From Bo Schembechler to the NFL & Wall Street | Mitch Lyons Interview 08.10.2026 31:05
Welcome to another special episode of The Buck Stops Here, the official program of NotInHallOfFame.com and the United States Athletics Hall of Fame! Today, host Kirk Buchner sits down with former Michigan State, Atlanta Falcons, and Pittsburgh Steelers tight end Mitch Lyons. Mitch shares incredible behind-the-scenes stories from his college recruiting days—including a legendary pitch from Bo Schem...
The Hall of Fame Voting PURGE: Jim Porter's Agenda, Belichick's Path & The Death of Senior Players 04.10.2026 1:16:29
The Pro Football Hall of Fame selection committee has been slashed in half, and the landscape of Canton will never be the same. Kirk Buchner, Jack Silverstein, Ron Katz, and Paul Lawrence break down the seismic shift in the voting process, Jim Porter's controversial "vision," and what this means for the future of the Hall of Fame. We discuss the loss of transparency, the devastating...
MLB Playoff Predictions & Wagers! 🏆 Red Sox vs. Yankees, Astros, & NL Showdowns 30.09.2026 28:05
Welcome back to a special episode of The Buck Stops Here ! Kirk Buchner and Dave Whitlock are breaking down the MLB Postseason. We kick things off with some nostalgic playoff memories from the 1980s before diving headfirst into intense predictions and friendly wagers for the Wild Card and Division Series matchups. Will the underdog Red Sox upset the Yankees? Can the Astros' veteran experience...
NFL & NBA Scandals, UFC Records & Jelly Roll's Kimmel Disaster | The Elevator Show 21.09.2026 1:09:12
Welcome back to The Elevator Show! Hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian are back to break down who is riding the elevator up to the Hall of Fame and who is taking the express route down. In this August 2026 episode, we dive deep into the massive fallout from the Clippers' front office scandal and Kawhi Leonard's shocking trade to the Raptors. Plus, we discuss the dark cloud over Josh Jac...
Keith Hernandez HOF Snub, NBA Flopping & The Truth About LeBron | Interview with Jake Cardinale 17.09.2026 23:24
Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here, the official program of the Not In Hall of Fame! Host Kirk Buchner sits down with Jake Cardinale from Talkin Sports with Jake for a wide-ranging conversation about sports' biggest snubs, fierce New York rivalries, and the current state of the NBA.Jake breaks down why Keith Hernandez is the ultimate Baseball Hall of Fame snub, debates the inclusion of Pete R...
Ultimate USAHOF Football Ballot Breakdown & Player Ratings 16.09.2026 1:23:15
Welcome to a special episode of the Buck Stops Here podcast! Host Kirk Buchner is joined by football historians and scouting experts Ken Crippen (Football Learning Academy) and Bill Carroll (Zennie62Media / Team NBS Media) to break down the football candidates on the United States Athletics Hall of Fame (USAHOF) ballot. From the game-changing dominance of Lawrence Taylor and Deacon Jones, to the u...
From NFL Trenches to IndyCar Pit Lane: Ben Braden’s Incredible Journey 04.09.2026 44:02
In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian sit down with former University of Michigan standout and NFL offensive lineman Ben Braden. Ben takes us through his wild journey from a multi-sport high school kid to navigating the Brady Hoke and Jim Harbaugh eras at Michigan, surviving the emotional rollercoaster of going undrafted, and carving out a career in...
Why Don’t Women Play Baseball? The Truth Behind Softball & The New Pro League | Steve Hendershot 23.08.2026 26:34
Why did women’s baseball disappear after WWII, and why is softball considered the "default" sport for girls? In this deep dive, Kirk Buchner sits down with investigative journalist Steve Hendershot, host of the podcast Uningrained . Steve shares his journey from correcting a friend about "girls' baseball" to launching an eight-part investigative series uncovering the cultur...
The NBA Hall of Fame is Broken | Reacting to Ben Golliver's 11 Future HOFers 21.08.2026 56:30
Kirk and Chris dive into ESPN’s Ben Golliver’s latest article detailing 11 men’s NBA players who could be elected to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in the next three years. (https://www.espnlacrosse.com/2026/08/14/the-11-nba-players-on-the-basketball-hall-of-fames-waiting-list/ )From first-ballot locks like Chris Paul and Russell Westbrook to borderline debates surrounding Blake Gri...
Tony Romo FIRED? 😱 Lizzo's Career is OVER & WNBA Owner Suspended! | July Elevator Show 09.08.2026 43:42
Welcome back to The Elevator Show! 🛗⬆️⬇️Hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian are back to evaluate who is going UP and who is going DOWN in the Hall of Fame elevator this past month. July might have been a slow month for some, but the drama, comebacks, and collapses were off the charts! This month, we break down Tony Romo’s embarrassing drunk driving incident and why CBS is likely pulling the pl...
Ranking the Greatest Coaches & Managers in Sports History | Author Matthew DiBiase 07.08.2026 21:06
Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here, the official program of NotInHallOfFame.com and the United States Athletics Hall of Fame! Today, host Kirk Buchner sits down with sports historian, SABR member, and acclaimed author Matthew DiBiase. Matthew is the groundbreaking author behind a series of books that mathematically rank the greatest coaches and general managers across the four major North America...
MLB Midseason Awards, World Cup Final Thoughts & NFL HOF Ballot Preview 23.07.2026 44:41
Kirk Buchner and Dave Whitlock are back for another episode of The Buck Stops Here! Fresh off the All-Star break, the guys break down the MLB midseason awards, debating the MVP and Cy Young races, and building their ultimate All-MLB Team 1. Plus, they share their unfiltered thoughts on the World Cup Final and the debate over sporting event halftime shows. To wrap things up, Kirk previews the upcom...
Jim Thorpe’s Granddaughters Reveal the Untold Truth About America's Greatest Athlete 09.07.2026 34:39
The legend of Jim Thorpe is known worldwide, but the personal stories of the man behind the medals are kept alive by his family. In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner sits down with Anita, Mary, and Teresa Thorpe—the granddaughters of the legendary first-ballot inductee of the United States Athletics Hall of Fame, Jim Thorpe. Kirk presents the ceremonial plaque for Jim...
Country Music Hall of Fame Predictions: Seismic Jumps, Controversies & Crossover Hits 08.07.2026 26:59
Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here, the official podcast of NotInHallOfFame.com! Host Kirk Buchner is joined by Aaron Edward Freeman, the mastermind and curator behind the Country Music Hall of Fame prediction list. In this episode, Kirk and Aaron break down the latest seismic shifts in the Country Music HOF rankings. Find out why Trisha Yearwood and The Chicks are making massive jumps, why "...
Wes Welker's HOF Case & The Eli Manning Debate! 06.07.2026 30:43
Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here! In this special episode, Kirk is joined by regular guest and Long Island native Robert Dobek to step away from baseball and tackle the gridiron and the ice. First, Kirk breaks down some breaking news and "shady" optics surrounding the 2026 Hockey Hall of Fame class and Brian Burke’s induction. Then, Rob takes the floor to make a passionate Hall of Fam...
Bergeron, Price & Tkachuk Make HHOF + The Brian Burke Committee Controversy 25.06.2026 58:45
Welcome back to Season 7, Episode 9 of The Buck Stops Here! Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan are back to break down the newly announced 2026 Hockey Hall of Fame class. We celebrate first-ballot legends like Patrice Bergeron, Carey Price, and Keith Tkachuk, but we also take the HHOF selection committee to task. Kirk breaks down the lack of transparency surrounding Brian Burke’s induction and Evan compar...
🏀🏒 The Elevator Show: Knicks & Hurricanes HOF Cases, Baseball Slumps & WWE Curses! 24.06.2026 53:15
Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian are back on The Elevator Show to break down the massive Hall of Fame implications following the NBA and NHL Finals! The New York Knicks are finally champions, ending a decades-long drought! Kirk breaks down how Jalen Brunson, Leon Rose, and Mike Brown solidify their HOF resumes (plus a hilarious tangent about a WWE "vampire" who cursed the Knicks... but t...
Hockey Hall of Fame SHOCKERS: Brian Burke’s Self-Vote, Surprise Goalies & Tkachuk’s Call! 24.06.2026 48:03
The NHL season isn't truly over until the Hockey Hall of Fame class is announced, and this year’s ballot brought some serious heat! Kirk, Chris, and Ron break down the newest inductees, starting with the undisputed first-ballot lock, Patrice Bergeron. But things get spicy fast as the guys dissect the optics of Brian Burke’s Builder induction—specifically the controversy of him serving on the s...
Hockey Hall of Fame Predictions: Bergeron, Marleau, Zetterberg & The Don Cherry Debate! 19.06.2026 36:42
Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian break down their predictions for the upcoming Hockey Hall of Fame class! With the 18-person selection committee preparing to make their decisions, the guys debate the biggest locks, the dark horses, and the potential snubs. They discuss Patrice Bergeron's historic defensive career, the "compiler" case for Patrick Marleau's 1,700+ games, Henrik Zet...
Is Omar Vizquel a Hall of Famer? | 90s Indians, Ozzie Smith & NHL Talk 18.06.2026 31:35
Welcome back to a special episode of The Buck Stops Here! Host Kirk Buchner is joined by his old friend Robert Dobek from Long Island for a deep dive into one of baseball's most complicated and controversial Hall of Fame cases: Omar Vizquel. With Vizquel on his final year of eligibility on the BBWAA ballot, Kirk and Robert break down his legendary defensive prowess, his role in the iconic 1990...
Are the Chicago Bears Moving to Indiana? | Jack Silverstein Breaks Down the Stadium Drama 16.06.2026 52:04
Are the Chicago Bears really leaving Illinois for Hammond, Indiana? In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner sits down with Chicago’s premier sports historian, Jack Silverstein, to cut through the noise, rumors, and political theater surrounding the Bears' stadium search. Jack breaks down the chaotic history of the Bears' stadium pursuits, the financial realities o...
From Childhood Hobby to High-Value Asset: The Business of Sports Card Collecting with Bill Murphy 27.05.2026 19:09
Host Kirk Buchner sits down with New England-based sports card expert Bill Murphy to unpack the evolution of card collecting—from nostalgic childhood pastime to legitimate alternative asset class. Bill shares his personal journey into the hobby, breaks down the difference between vintage "Grail Cards" and modern prospect speculation, and reveals how high-net-worth collectors are now usin...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.