The Alternate: Inside America's Biggest Trials

In this explosive first weekly recap of The Alternate, Tab breaks down week one of Sean "Diddy" Combs' closed-door trial. Diddy faces charges including racketeering, sex trafficking, and more - potentially facing life in prison. With opening statements delivered, shocking surveillance footage was shown of a 2016 altercation with ex-girlfriend Cassie Ventura. Key witnesses included a former hotel s...

On Day 16 of Karen Read’s retrial, forensic scientist Maureen Hartnett testified about damage to Read’s SUV, including a broken taillight and a hair consistent with John O’Keefe’s DNA on the rear bumper. She noted that blood tests on the vehicle were negative, and some evidence, such as blood-stained Solo cups, remained untested. Medical examiner Dr. Irini Scordi-Bello stated O’Keefe died from blu...

On Day 15 of Karen Read's retrial, testimony resumed after a one-day delay due to Read's illness. John O'Keefe's niece testified privately about the morning he was found, describing Read as hysterical and urging her to call a friend. Subsequent witnesses included police officers and crime scene investigators, who detailed evidence collection procedures. The prosecution focused on physical evidence...

In this episode, Tabitha Kane discusses Day 14 of the Karen Reed retrial, focusing on the cross-examination of Sergeant Yuri Buchanek. The conversation highlights the defense's strategy to undermine the integrity of the police investigation, particularly through the examination of text messages and surveillance footage. Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: ⁠https://www.patreon.com/T...

In this episode, Margot provides a detailed recap of day 12 of the Karen Reed retrial, focusing on the testimony of Sergeant Yuri Buchanek. The discussion covers the investigation into John O'Keefe's injuries, the collection of evidence, and the challenges faced by law enforcement... Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: ⁠https://www.patreon.com/TheAlternate⁠ 👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏼‍⚖️Follow You...

Today, we delve into Day 13 of the Karen Reed retrial, focusing on the cross-examination of Sergeant Yuri Bukhanik. The discussion highlights the courtroom dynamics, particularly the handling of evidence and the implications of personal text messages between key individuals involved in the case... Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: ⁠https://www.patreon.com/TheAlternate⁠ 👩🏽‍⚖️👩...

Today, Tab recaps day 11 of the Karen Read retrial, cutting through the dry legal details and sidebars. Today’s key witnesses included Trooper Connor Keefe, who gathered evidence like cell phones and taillight pieces but had limited experience, and digital forensic expert Jessica Hyde, who clarified critical timelines around Jennifer McCabe’s phone searches. The defense probed Keefe about inconsis...

Day 10 of the Karen Read trial packed in tense moments. The prosecution played Reed’s past interview clips and introduced meteorologist Robert Gilman, who detailed the January 2022 snowstorm. Trooper Garino presented dozens of Reed’s frantic voicemails and call logs from that night. Afterward, Canton Police Lt. Charles Ray’s short testimony led to Trooper Kevin O’Hara, who described finding crucia...

Today, Margot recaps six witnesses on the Karen Read reTrial: toxicologist Dr. Knowles on flawed BAC extrapolation; Ryan Nagel on seeing Reed’s SUV alone, Heather Maxson confirming two strangers inside, Sarah Levinson on party timeline; EMT Katie McLaughlin’s disputed “I hit him” notes on a glove, and Detective Paul Gallagher’s windy, leaf‑blower evidence‑preservation fiasco with red Solo cups and...

Jennifer McCabe’s cross‑examination dominated day 8 of the Karen Read reTrial. Defense probed her “amnesia” over seven early‐morning calls, forgotten Google searches, and why she didn’t seek help from a cop neighbor. They highlighted her changing story about calling sister Nicole Albert and collusion in a family group chat - though the judge struck “collusion.” A slip by Judge Canone calling McCab...

Day 7 of Karen Read reTrial continues with Jennifer McCabe testifies that she, Karen Read and Carrie Roberts frantically searched for John O’Keefe, and that Read screamed “I hit him” three times. McCabe called 911, then mistyped “how to die in cold” due to shaky fingers... Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: ⁠https://www.patreon.com/TheAlternate⁠ 👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏼‍⚖️Follow Your Favorite...

Day 6 of the Karen Read retrial focused on digital forensic expert Ian Whiffin’s testimony, revealing complexities in browser timestamp data and casting doubt on the infamous "hos long to die in the cold" search by Jennifer McCabe. The defense challenged data integrity and cell phone location accuracy, suggesting John O’Keefe's phone may have been inside the house. Battery temperature evidence als...

Tabitha breaks down Day 5 of the Karen Reed retrial, featuring Ian Wiffin’s forensic phone data: McCabe’s search timestamps, O’Keefe’s movement, battery temps, and location pings. Defense pokes gaps on message senders and phone access. Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: ⁠⁠⁠https://www.patreon.com/TheAlternate⁠⁠⁠ 👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏼‍⚖️Follow Your Favorite Trial Besties on Social 📹YouTube:...

On the Day 4 of the Karen Read reTrial, Jurors took a “field trip” to 34 Fairview Road - observing the Lexus, flagpole, fire hydrant, sightlines to the second-floor window, driveway and lawn - before returning for testimony. Dr. Garrey Faller (Good Samaritan Hospital pathologist) confirmed Karen Reed’s BAC of .093 at 9 a.m. on January 29, 2022, over the .08 DUI limit; on cross, defense probed diff...

Day 3 of the Karen Read retrial featured several key witnesses. EMT Daniel Whitley faced intense cross-examination, with defense highlighting inconsistencies in his testimony regarding Karen’s psychiatric evaluation and her inquiry about hypothermia. Brief foundational testimony came from Jean DeMulis (McCarthy’s Bar) and Brigid Meehan (Waterfall Bar) to introduce surveillance footage. Michael Cam...

On Day 2 of the Karen Read reTrial, 4 witnesses took stand: Kerry Roberts, Peggy O’Keefe, Trooper Nicholas Guarino, and Firefighter Paramedic Daniel Whitley. Emotional testimony and detailed accounts of the scene unfold. Cross-examinations intensify as defense probes witness timelines, memories, and text messages in a pivotal day for the prosecution. Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Pe...

Day 1 - The Commonwealth called their first witness - Timothy Nuttall. The testimony was riddled with inconsistencies and the defense was able to impeach this witness. (double space) The second witness was Kerry Roberts, one of John O’Keefe’s close family friends. She was one of the people Karen Read called at 5am when she was frantic and looking for John. Listen in to hear the cliffnotes. Join ou...

On Day 1 of Karen Read’s retrial, the prosecution painted a picture of reckless rage, while the defense claimed this entire case is built on a lie. In this daily recap, we bring you the opening statements in a nutshell. Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: ⁠⁠https://www.patreon.com/TheAlternate⁠⁠ 👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏼‍⚖️Follow Your Favorite Trial Besties on Social 📹YouTube: ⁠@alternatepod ⁠...

Prelude: You Are Now Seated Welcome to The Alternate: Inside The Karen Read Trial In this special prelude episode, you’re stepping into the jury box—where justice begins. Here we will walk you through the oath, the stakes, and what it means to be an “Alternate” in one of the most closely watched trials in the nation. Season One covers the retrial of Karen Read, accused of killing Boston Police Off...

Join our Jury Pool & Get Exclusive Content & Perks: https://www.patreon.com/TheAlternate 👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏼‍⚖️ Follow Your Favorite Trial Besties on Social: 📹 YouTube: @alternatepod 🦋 Instagram: @thealternatepod ❤️ TikTok: @thealternatepod 💙 Facebook: @thealternatepod Follow the podcast for FREE on all platforms: 🍎 Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-alternate-inside-americas-bi...