That Aged Well Podcast

That Aged Well

Tv EN ↓ 395 episodes

Feel conflicted about the movies you loved as a kid? Let Paul and Erika guide you through all that beloved garbage we watched...after all, nostalgia is more fun when you aren't the only one embarrassed by it. Come dive into yesterday's pop culture today (and connect with the show on Instagram, BlueSky, and Threads)!

Author

That Aged Well Podcast

Category

Tv

Podcast website

art19.com

Latest episode

Jul 6, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Gremlins - Dragon Breath, Microwave Explosions & a Miniature Chainsaw 14.10.2019

Spooky October continues as Erika and Paul dive into 1984’s Gremlins. It’s a puppet gross-out extravaganza and your hosts dive in with gusto! -Here’s the Key and Peele Gremlins 2 sketch Erika referenced. -Have you watched The Lost Boys yet? Go watch The Lost Boys! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAg...

The Craft - Paranormal Porn, Abandoned Couches & a Chalice of Hepatitis Sangria 07.10.2019

Paul and Erika are into the Halloween spirit for October and they kick it off with a discussion of 1996’s The Craft! From enormous lightning strikes to fire hazards to hailing the Guardians of the Watchtower of the North, they can’t get enough of The Craft. You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAgedWell)...

Shakespeare In Love - Bubbies, Unexpected Affleck & an Elizabethan Twelve 30.09.2019

Erika and Paul dive into the movie behind one of the biggest Oscar upsets of all time...Shakespeare In Love! They get into man-wigs, sexposition scenes and the wisdom of pale blondes wearing yellow. You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAgedWell)! SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT! THAT AGED WELL M...

Weekend At Bernie's - BoyKnee, Corpse Work & a Kick to the ‘Nads 23.09.2019

Paul and Erika travel back to the 80s and to the fictitious Hampton Island to dissect one of the most 80s movies of all time: Weekend at Bernie’s! Do they have good things to say about it? You’ll have to listen and find out! -Paul thinks the Must See TV classic Frasier is an excellent farce. -Erika mentions Switching Channels , an update of His Girl Friday directed by Ted Kotcheff. You can follow...

Cruel Intentions - Journals, Contraceptive Pants & a Little Red Riding Hoodie 16.09.2019

Erika and Paul are going through 1999’s Cruel Intentions, starring an Oscar winner, Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Ryan Phillippe! There’s a lot in this one, folks...we’re not gonna lie. -Erika suggests you go peak Witherspoon after that and watch Legally Blonde . -Paul wants everyone to watch Pushing Daisies with Swoosie Kurtz! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram...

Back To The Future - Plutonium, Peeping Toms & an Oedipal Nightmare 09.09.2019

And we’re back! After their Labor Day vacation, Paul and Erika are digging into the 1985 classic Back To The Future. They both love it, but hoo-boy do they feel bad about that. -After that, Paul suggests you cleanse your palate by checking out Legends of Tomorrow ! -Erika offered Freaks & Geeks , also featuring the erstwhile Biff Tannen! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellP...

Straight Up - Getting Punched By a Dream Wolf 26.08.2019

Okay, kids, this is a weird one. Erika and Paul go back to 1988 to watch the drug abuse prevention video Straight Up that Paul claims scarred him in middle school. If you usually skip the episodes where you haven’t seen the movie...you don’t want to skip this one. -Are you wanting to watch Straight Up, after hearing what your hosts survived? Are you sure? Alright, here you go ! You can follow That...

Saved By the Bell - Locker Room Harmonies 19.08.2019

Paul and Erika dig into the best (?) SBtB episode of all time...Jessie’s Song! Paul has never seen the show and is confused about quite a bit, but Erika is there to hold his hand with her encyclopedic knowledge of Saved By the Bell. You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAgedWell)! SUPPORT US ON PATREON F...

Aerosmith - The Aliciad 12.08.2019

That Aged Well’s light August continues, with a bonus episode on the music video collaboration between Aerosmith and Alicia Silverstone! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAgedWell)! SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT! THAT AGED WELL MERCH! Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba Producer & E...

90210 - Magical Spanish, Insurance Fraud & a Banana Daiquiri 05.08.2019

Erika and Paul kick off their mini-episode Summer Series with...a full length episode! Turns out the 90210 pilot is a two parter, and hence longer than some movies. This is planning at the highest level. Tune in and find out which host got so irritated at this show that they knocked over a pile of papers! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threa...

Ghost - Jukeboxes, Shirtless Men & a Psychic Cat 29.07.2019

It’s time to take another look at the highest grossing movie of 1990...Ghost! Erika and Paul spend a fair amount of time debating between Patrick Swayze and Tony Goldwyn, but they manage to carve out a few minutes to dissect the movie as well. -Paul brings up Selfie early in the episode, which was a cute comedy starring John Cho and Karen Gillan. -Erika offers Top Secret! as a palate cleanser. -Pa...

Interview with the Vampire - Poodles, Flaming Mansions & a Black Hole of Nothingness 22.07.2019

Paul and Erika are back in 1994 this week (seriously, why so much 1994?), taking a look at Interview with the Vampire starring Tom Cruise and Brad Pitt. This movie has high highs and low lows, leaving your hosts bewildered, befuddled and bemused! -Erika recommends another Neil Jordan movie, The End of the Affair to cleanse your palate. Free with your Amazon Prime account! -Paul went with something...

Terminator 2 - Austrian Accents, Robot Genitalia & a Thumbs Up 15.07.2019

And now for something completely different...Paul and Erika get into 1991’s Terminator 2! They have a lot of questions about accents, robot anatomy and time travel in general. Download the ep to hear if they came to any conclusions! -Erika offered James Cameron’s Aliens as a palate cleanser. -Paul thought Chuck was another great action comedy. You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWel...

Four Weddings and a Funeral - Receiving Lines, Fabulous Waistcoats & a Wedding Dress Fitting 08.07.2019

Erika and Paul are talking about the movie that was once the highest grossing British film in history...Four Weddings and a Funeral! You know the drill by now...Erika’s seen it many times and loves it, Paul had never seen it before and his feelings are decidedly more mixed. Download the ep to hear them hash out their differences! -Erika offered no palate cleanser this week, but Paul enjoyed A Very...

The Lion King - Feudal Systems, Guncles & a Distracting Drag Brunch 01.07.2019

Erika and Paul are diving back into the Disney well for a discussion of 1994’s animated classic The Lion King! It’s one of those movies that has a few surprises for our hosts and they have a lot to say about some of the choices that were made. Also, Paul again dogs his nephews while Erika comes out as a Meerkat Manor super-fan! -Paul mentioned Pamela Adlon’s Better Things as a palate cleanser. -Er...

Tootsie - Beefsteak Tomatoes, Broadway Auditions & a Fictitious Soap Opera 24.06.2019

Paul and Erika dive into the newly-adapted-for-the-Broadway-stage Tootsie! They get into the (myriad) issues with the 1982 comedy, but both admit their affection for it remains strong. -Paul offered Feud: Bette and Joan as a palate cleanser. -Erika thought Charles Durning deserved better and mentions that she enjoys Home for the Holidays . You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod...

Clueless - Technical Virgins, Background Nose Jobs & a Practice Jeep 17.06.2019

This week, Erika and Paul are joined by author and podcaster Jess Verdi (@jessverdi, jessicaverdi.com) to discuss 1995’s masterpiece...Clueless! -Jess is a podcaster as well! Listen to her adoption pod We Can Do This: Our Adoption Journey . -Here’s the video of the Golden Girls spoofing Clueless that Paul mentioned! -No palate cleansers necessary, of course, but Paul does mention Suburgatory as a...

Death Becomes Her - Mirrors, Frosting & a Trio of Floating Nuns 10.06.2019

It’s here! The most requested movie from listeners of That Aged Well! Paul and Erika talk about one of their mutual favorite films...1992’s Death Becomes Her starring Meryl Streep, Goldie Hawn and Bruce Willis. There will be quotes. There will be laughter. There will be warnings. You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Sp...

Coming to America - Quarterstaves, Rose Petals & a Normal American Student 03.06.2019

Erika and Paul rewatch the Eddie Murphy classic Coming to America and have a lot to say! A lot of it is just cooing over baby elephants, but other moments come up as well. You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAgedWell)! SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT! THAT AGED WELL MERCH! Hosts: Paul Caiola &a...

Wayne's World - Commercialization, Cavity Searches & an Alice Cooper Concert 27.05.2019

Your hosts stay in the 90’s this week, but go for something a little different than Shakespeare...Wayne’s World! Does the most successful SNL adaptation of all time still hold up? Listen and find out! -Here’s the Wayne’s World sketch with Tom Hanks Erika referenced. -Paul loved The Grinder with Rob Lowe, a one season wonder. -Erika cautiously recommended The Decline of Western Civilization by Pene...

Romeo + Juliet - Explosions, Casual Dueling & a Priest with a Full Back Tattoo 20.05.2019

Paul and Erika get to access their theater roots and discuss Baz Luhrmann’s 1996 Shakespeare adaptation Romeo + Juliet. Spoiler alert for a 400 year old play! -Erika still loves West Side Story (yes, she knows it’s problematic)! -Paul enjoyed Netflix’s Dumplin’ . -Want more Shakespeare? You could try Much Ado About Nothing (with Keanu Reeves!) or 10 Things I Hate About You (in case you’re over the...

Steel Magnolias - Nancy Beth, Marshall & an Armadillo Groom's Cake 13.05.2019

Erika and Paul welcome another guest into the studio, their friend Victoria Dicce. The three dive into Steel Magnolias...there is a lot of quoting the movie, with just a little bit of commentary thrown in! -Want to keep crying? Paul offered Other People as a way to keep the tears coming. -Want more Sally Field? Erika said Norma Rae is peak Sally Field. -Want more Sally Field (comedy bracket)? Vict...

Weird Science - Ballistic Missiles, Pink Cadillacs & a Mutant Biker Gang 06.05.2019

Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the John Hughes pool...Weird Science! Paul and Erika approached this movie with great trepidation, but you’ll have to listen to find out if their fears were warranted! -Paul thinks Big Love ’s first three seasons are excellent and thought-provoking. -Erika reeeeeally wants you to watch Ferris Bueller’s Day Off ! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitt...

Friends (Season 1)- Sweet'n Low, Gay Panic & a Ridiculously Expensive Crystal Duck 29.04.2019

Erika and Paul take on TV for the first time and discuss the first season of Friends. How did Ross and Rachel, the greatest love story of the 90s, age? Listen and find out! -Paul suggested everyone watch the Lisa Kudrow vehicle The Comeback ! You can follow That Aged Well on Twitter (@ThatAgedWellPod), Instagram (@ThatAgedWell), Threads (@ThatAgedWell), and Spoutible (@ThatAgedWell)! SUPPORT US ON...

The Bodyguard - Contract Killers, Real Estate Porn & a Blood Spattered Oscar Envelope 22.04.2019

Whitney Houston’s film debut takes a turn on this week’s episode, and unsurprisingly your hosts have a lot of opinions about it. Kevin Costner’s crew cut, Rachel Marron’s Oscar dress and the viability of a sniper rifle mounted onto a movie camera are all discussed at length. -Paul thinks you should listen to Dolly’s version of “I Will Always Love You ,” but he INSISTS you watch this Reba McEntire...

Listen to the That Aged Well podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.