Scott & Tiffany Reese

Tell Me Something Terrible

History EN ↓ 130 episodes

From true crime to natural disaster and measles to mullets. A podcast covering all things terrible.

Author

Scott & Tiffany Reese

Category

History

Latest episode

Jun 24, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 55- Go-Gurt Enemas 21.09.2021

This is another Pure Michigan episode as we discuss the backstory of the Kellogg empire. From sanitoriums to Corn Flakes, we run the gamut in this one. Put on your PJs and grab a bowl of your favorite cereal...and let's ruin breakfast.  Support the show

Episode 54- Bloody Benders Part 2 17.09.2021

The saga continues as we dive deeper into the infamous Bloody Benders that murdered their way through Kansas. We are once again joined by our friends Jamie (BigJay1066 on Twitch) and Beth. Come listen for the conclusion of this epic tale and help us keep track of all of the names and bodies.  Support the show

Episode 53- Blood Benders Part 1 14.09.2021

Guest pod!! In this episode we are joined by friends and Patrons Jamie and Beth! This is a deep dive, so we had to cut it into two episodes. Tiff decides to entertain all of us with the topic of the Bloody Benders, a "family" of serial killers from Kansas in the 1800s, not a bloody poop disease as the name might suggest.  Bonus Shameless Plugging: Go follow Jamie on Twitch as BigJay1066...

Episode 52- Zyptocroologist 10.09.2021

A real podcast about fake animals that might really exist, but its all fake with real evidence. As you probably guessed, we dive into cryptids, and in particular the famous Michigan Dog Man! Also, a big announcement about the future of the podcast.  Support the show

Episode 51- Bridge-front Properties 07.09.2021

Follow us down the rabbit hole that stemmed from the nursery rhyme "The London Bridge Is Falling Down." This lead to fires, crazy houses, Viking attacks and medieval torture. You might even add a new US location to your bucket list....don't worry, we'll get to it.  Support the show

Episode 50- Angel's Landing Strip 03.09.2021

To celebrate the 50TH EPISODE of TMST, Tiff decided we all needed more cults in our life.  Trigger warning, this one hits on a lot of sensitive topics including suicide, sexual assault and crimes against minors.  Support the show

Episode 49- Measly Blood 31.08.2021

We're talking about another disease guys.... the measles! Learn about why this disease is so scary and watch out for paint cans. You'll get it, after Scott has to explain it because someone is bad at pop culture references.  Support the show

Episode 48- Bootleg Sausage 27.08.2021

If you aren't already anti-prohibition, and if you listen to us we assume you are, then this episode will reinforce your hatred. Making booze illegal is one thing, but to poison the bootleggers source of industrial alcohol is a whole other level of ridiculous. Pop open a bottle of your favorite legal spirit and join us! Support the show

Episode 47- Big Hair, Don't Care w/ Murphy! 24.08.2021

Our first guest on the pod! To test the collaborative podcast waters, we had Patron (and Tiff's best friend) Murphy on to talk about hair. Please bear with the audio quality, mistakes were made (drunkenly) and there's no going back. O, and we are talking about Georgian hairstyles. Enjoy! Support the show

Episode 46- Timmy McVeigh 20.08.2021

You read that right, Tiff decides to go super depressing with the Oklahoma City Bomber himself on this episode. It's worse than you imagine, and we only skim the surface with this one. Come learn a thing or two about America's most infamous domestic terrorist attack.  Support the show

Episode 45- Flying YAKs 17.08.2021

By popular demand (one suggestion on YouTube) we are covering the tragic plane crash that killed an entire Russian hockey team. In 2011, the Yaroslavl Lokomotiv's team plane went down shortly after takeoff from a local airport. This one requires vodka...and lots of it.  Support the show

Episode 44- No Power, No Problem 13.08.2021

So, we have no power. A wicked storm ripped through our hometown and knocked out power to most of the county. Good news, besides a tree down, we are fine. Bad news, we have no way to record/edit/upload a new episode. To resolve this issue we are releasing our original bonus episode that was previously Patreon only. Consider this the ultimate #shamelessplug to what you will find over on our Patreon...

Episode 43- Anderson Cooper's Taco Nite 10.08.2021

Just a heads up, the title is misleading. This one is about the Edmund Fitzgerald and how it sunk in Lake Superior amongst a storm in 1975. The rest will all makes sense as you listen...hopefully.  Support the show

Episode 42- Nun Left 06.08.2021

This episode, we're sitting down to talk about the recently defunct Magdalene Laundries in Ireland, operated by children and "unfit" women and ran by NUN-other than the Catholic Church. Support the show

Episode 41- Fish Are Sexy 03.08.2021

So you think you know what a Siren is? You, like us, are probably wrong. This episode we look at the misconception of Siren's and how they evolved throughout history. This one is less murder-y and more fantastical.  Enjoy, just don't follow us into the water.  Support the show

Episode 40- 500 Short Hairs 23.07.2021

To celebrate our 40th episode, Tiff dumps the worst murderer yet on us. This one is relatively unknown, yet super dark and terrible. Buckle up as we dive into the Ypsilanti horror story of John Norman Collins.  Support the show

Episode 39- Boxed Execution 20.07.2021

Join us as we cover the highly publicized execution of Rainey Berthea. The execution wasn't botched, but this episode sure was. We cover the sensational details of his crime and punishment that led to the last public hanging in the US. This one gets off the rails early and often. Enjoy! Support the show

Episode 38- Soo in Sault 16.07.2021

Let's all learn about the Soo (pronounced Sue) Locks, located in Sault (also pronounced Sue) Ste Marie, MI. These are the Great Lakes version of the Panama Canal, and are one of Michigan's most prominent features. And of course, Tiff has some terrible story about boats with funny names crashing. Come take a listen and laugh along.  Support the show

Episode 37- Giant Chum Bucket 13.07.2021

In honor of Shark Week we decided to dive into the worlds largest shark attack. Hundreds of oceanic white tip sharks prey on hundreds of capsized seamen when the USS Indianapolis went down in 1945. Take a listen, just don't open a can of spam.  Also available on the YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJh0kyzDEn7X2Ui-apUq3dQ Support the show

Episode 36- Cantankerous Tinkerer 09.07.2021

Back to our Michigan roots, this week's episode is about the Bath School Massacre. It is as horrible as it sounds and involves all the terrible things. Come learn about some jerk with a grudge and a love for dynamite on this weeks TMST.  Support the show

Episode 35- Free Britney! 06.07.2021

Want to know the ins and outs of the Britney Spears conservatorship? We have you covered. Come hate on Jamie Spears with us as we break down the ridiculousness that has been Britney's life for the last 13 years. Also, we recorded this episode for YouTube if you are so inclined. Click the link below to check out our channel there (once it's posted).  https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJh0k...

Episode 34- Willy Wacker 02.07.2021

An unsolved shorty? Yup! Tiff goes for a more light hearted one this time around, but decides to do an unsolved one just to piss Scott off. Come listen to how the Wacker's (easy jokes) were tormented at their home in the 1980s.  Support the show

Episode 33- Cooked County 29.06.2021

Warning, this episode is gruesome. Tiff decides to dive into the always fun topic of executions. From the super primitive and horrible to the modern and still very much horrible, this one is not for the faint of heart. Grab your vat of wine (without a human in it) and squirm your way through this one.  Support the show

Episode 32- Purple Gang Ass-ass-ination 25.06.2021

This week we come back to Michigan with a murder of state Senator. One of Michigan's most infamous unsolved murders is that of Warren Hooper, who was allegedly assassinated by The Purple Gang in the 1940s, in connection with the corrupt politicians of the day. Its gruesome, and we were plenty drunk, so...enjoy! Support the show

Episode 31- Minnie Did It! 22.06.2021

In a more light hearted approach, this week we talk about the mysterious fires of the Hackler Family house from 1940s. While Tiff likes to think these are seemingly unexplained, Scott is convinced that the wife is behind it all along. Take a listen and let us know what you think. #MinnieDidIt Support the show

Listen to the Tell Me Something Terrible podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.