Supernatural Opinions

The podcast is taking a break from season 2 and the canon of Supernatural and talking about a piece of fanwork SO well known that it’s practically part of the show: The Hillywood Supernatural Parodies. KJ is joined by Meredith, Frances, and Vail to talk first about Supernatural Parody One and the meshing of Taylor Swift and Supernatural. Then it’s onto Supernatural Parody Two, the impact of fandom...

It’s a full house, or well, studio, at Supernatural Opinions this week! KJ, Meredith, Jordan, Lukas, and Audrey are all here ready to talk about three new characters-Ellen and Jo Harvelle, and their genius friend Ash. The introduction of Jo and Ash leads to some Bi! Dean discourse, which in turn lead to ace/demi! Sam discussion. Meredith has a great (last minute, on the spot) mythology section on...

KJ and Meredith are back for a new season, joined by Emmie (inpainla67). Meredith has lore on reapers, Emmie cannot get enough of Bobby Singer being the Winchesters’ better dad, KJ has some sinister questions to raise about John, and the whole trio is ready to throw a party as John Winchester departs this earth-bound for hell where he’s sure to face torment for his failings as a parent and decent...

KJ and Meredith reflect on the joys and challenges of starting a Supernatural podcast in 2021 and celebrate finishing season 1 and Dean Winchester’s birthday by both looking back and looking ahead at what’s to come. KJ unveils some of the results of the weekly segments, and Meredith decides which one-episode character they’re both the most like. Also new segment announced for season 2, some twitte...

KJ is joined by Meredith, Frances, and their Series of Opinions cohost Moira to talk about the season 1 finale. It’s a jam-packed episode with Bobby Singer being introduced (and his ill-fated dog, Rumsfeld), a farewell to Meg, heartbreaking connotations added to the relationship between John Winchester and his sons, and a confrontation with The Yellow Eyed Demon himself. Tensions that have been bu...

KJ is joined by Jordan and Lukas to recap Salvation. The Winchesters have been reunited with John…just in time to track down the demon that killed Jess and Mary. And also for Meg to make a reappearance to get a little murdery with John’s (very few) remaining friends. CW episode description: Sam has a vision of a family being attacked in the same manner as the attack on his mom, so he, Dean and Joh...

KJ's on taking a break from Supernatural to take up a mission to decode the mysteries of the Bridgewater triangle! KJ, Meredith, Frances, and Julia talk about Misha Collins' lead role in the Bridgewater Podcast as Jeremy Bradshaw, folklore professor and victim of the supernatural forces surrounding the Bridgwater triangle and Freetown Forest. KJ has some questions about the timeline, a deep apprec...

After their incredible job last week, KJ is joined again by Meredith, Julia, and Frances, this time talking about Dead Man’s Blood. There’s a lot going on with the crew as KJ dissects the fights happening in the Winchester family, Frances brings a love of vampire stories, Meredith comes in with a mythology check, and Julia delivers on a promise of a stunning conspiracy. The Winchesters are all tog...

KJ is joined by Meredith, Frances, and Julia as they cover Provenance, the brothers are hunting a haunted painting and Sam tests the waters of romance for the first time since the death of his girlfriend, Jessica. In other words, Meredith has some research about Victorian Mourning rituals, Frances weighs in about the tooth fairy as the only parent present, Julia is here for asexual Sam content, an...

KJ is in charge of the mythology section for better or for worse. They also bring a knowledge of the service LexisNexis. Alongside KJ are Meredith and Julia with their thoughts on this very Winchester family dynamic heavy episode as every viewer is forced to watch John neglect his children. Two new segments debut. CW Episode description: Sam and Dean investigate a small town in Wisconsin where chi...

KJ and Meredith spent Halloween weekend with the Winchesters as they took on a haunted house (and each other in a pranking capacity). KJ uses this episode’s entire tangent allowance in an effort to avoid the recap. Meredith uses the word “grody” in the year 2021. KJ takes issue with the motel’s decor. Meredith explores a link between the monster of the week and the My Little Pony fandom. CW Episod...

Supernatural besties KJ and Meredith are chatting with TikTok’s Supernatural Worstie, Whitney (@whitneypaige_13) about all things Supernatural. The trio talks about their journeys in the Supernatural fandom, being content creators, and rewatching the show. Along the way KJ asks for Meredith and Whitney’s own Supernatural Opinions on a variety of things including best episodes, best moments to show...

KJ and Meredith are joined by Meredith’s older sister Audrey to talk about this week’s episode. Meredith has a lot going on this week between her sibling being a guest and sharing a name with the opening scene victim. Audrey and KJ try to figure out how Dean’s game of connect the blood dots works-featuring KJ being bad at explaining math! KJ also jumps in to berate Eric Kripke for his pitfall slan...

Things are getting gruesome on this week’s true crime inspired episode of Supernatural. KJ, Meredith, and Jaden are recapping this episode that contains no supernatural entities, just a family of fairly monstrous human beings. Meredith and KJ delve into the historical murder families that inspired this episode, and first time guest Jaden brings her voice to the show! Missy Bender, Child of Nightma...

KJ, Meredith, Jordan, and Julia are diving right into the thick of the plot this week as Sam and Dean try to help Max, who’s life bears a disturbing resemblance to their own, particularly Sam. Meredith has a lesson on prophetic dreams and oneiromancy, KJ is fixated on the clothing choices, and the crew is amused by Dean’s one brain cell. CW episode description: Linktree including sign up sheet to...

It’s a podcasting crossover, as KJ is joined by repeat guests Meredith and Frances as well as Abigail from Driver Picks the Podcast, a fellow Supernatural podcast! In addition to an in depth recap of the episode Route 666, Meredith has haunted car stories, Frances has a look at some haunted car films, KJ and Abigail crush hard on Cassie, and KJ pretends they know something about cars. Also explore...

KJ became friends with Julia (honorary_idjit_67) on tiktok after making a series of videos about the love languages of the Supernatural characters. The conversation evolved and they decided to make a whole episode about it. Meredith is joining them, and this trio is about to dissect some of the sweetest and most infuriating moments in the series, discuss why the characters react the ways they do,...

Meredith and KJ have found some friends-Julia and Jordan are back as John abandons his children as they search for a way to save Dean’s life. Meredith brings us our weekly X-Files reference guide and teams up with Jordan to create a new segment on the podcast to where they nominate characters to take the place of characters brought back in season 4 episode 2 who should feel wronged by the Winchest...

KJ and Meredith are still on their own this week, they are sticking together even while the Winchester boys split up over a disagreement over orders handed down from their absentee father. While Meredith brings us research on Norse mythology, KJ has issues with Dean’s interpretation of the word “apology”. The Wizard of Oz ends up being a bit of a motif in this week’s episode, and KJ and Meredith b...

KJ and Meredith are going it alone this week as Sam and Dean brave a haunted asylum. They petition for Katherine to dump her boyfriend Gavin for bringing her on a date to an abandoned building, try to see the Winchester brothers through their numerous fights this episode, and Meredith reenacts a scene KJ felt was missing where John Winchester is unable to operate a toaster. CW Episode description:...

KJ is joined by a bunch of fun guests this week, prepared to hunt down John Winchester and keep him from further damaging his sons. Sam and Dean are headed back to their hometown and face a monster living in their old house-and reconcile the life trajectory Mary’s death sent them down. The episode is filled with reactions to the Winchesters’ origin story and analysis of their family dynamics. Ever...

KJ, Meredith, and Frances are diving into the way race was addressed, or not addressed, on Supernatural as well as the Winchesters’ experiences with police and white privilege. There’s a couple breaks to talk about characters who could and should have had spinoffs, ways characters could’ve been better utilized, and even a quick break to talk about the show’s romantic interests. KJ makes it abundan...

KJ and Meredith are on their own again this week for one of Supernatural’s least respected episodes. There’s a lot of insects, some serious misuse of Native American culture, and two grown men following a teenager off the bus and into a forest. KJ and Meredith discuss what pit of insects is the most ideal choice to stick your bare hand into. And of course some helpful advice on when it’s okay to d...

KJ and Meredith don’t know a lot about cars, but they do know bananas aren’t conventional tools for fixing them. Meredith reveals she’s never seen Ghostbusters, after KJ is delighted by a Ghostbusters reference. It’s an episode filled with urban legends that extra research somehow made even worse, because that’s how things go on this podcast! CW Episode description: The infamous "Hookman," a venge...

In this truly disgusting episode, KJ and Meredith gross themselves out thinking about the smell of a sewer inhabited by a shapeshifter. KJ makes fun of Star Trek out of pocket. What KJ and Meredith are fans of is a high stakes middle-of-the-case opening followed by rewinding to an earlier time and learning over the course of the episode how things got to where they were-exactly what this episode d...