Wyatt Shell and Jake Withee

Superduperstitious

Science EN ↓ 194 episodes

A podcast about the paranormal, the credibility of the creepy, and the science of the spooky: Superduperstitious is a comedy podcast that looks at the mysterious and scary world of the weird and says, "Wait. What?" Hosts Wyatt Shell and Jake Withee use their science backgrounds to tease apart possible explanations for unexplained, supernatural, and otherwise strange phenomena. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Author

Wyatt Shell and Jake Withee

Category

Science

Podcast website

www.superduperstitious.com

Latest episode

Jan 8, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 138 – Cryptozoology Part II: Take It and Bake It 12.06.2021

Cryptozoology, that beloved pseudoscience so full of bold hat choices , gets the rest of its comeuppance this week! But it’s not alone: conventional science also has had a long history of doing not exactly the right thing , and the conclusion of this Special Report offers some simple advice for all of the above: holy shit let’s do better. EPISODE LINKS Four Phantoms email: fourphantomsbeer@gmail.c...

UNLOCKED: SDS Minisode #20 03.06.2021

The exciting conclusion to our ninth Superduperstitious Special Report will be comin' atcha next week – but in the meantime, why not enjoy some SUPER SECRET BONUS 'TENT ?? Yes, in addition to the normal episodes we put out on a sometimes-regular basis, minisodes like these could be all yours EVERY SINGLE WEEK , alongside various other delightful treats – and all you have to do is support the show...

Episode 137 – Cryptozoology Part I: Fake It and Make It 27.05.2021

Another Superduperstitious Special Report? Another critical look at the pseudoscientific shenanigans of cryptozoology? BOTH?! What a day! In this first half of another epic two-part deep dive, the boys examine some cryptozoological coattail riding, Europeans’ long history of “discovering” species that were new only to their white asses, and of course some super cool aminals. Also, apparently a shi...

Episode 136 – Listener Stories! 15.05.2021

Gotta love the eps when you do all the work for us. EPISODE LINKS All-purpose show links: https://www.superduperstitious.com/links Four Phantoms email: fourphantomsbeer@gmail.com Four Phantoms website: https://www.fourphantoms.net/ Four Phantoms store: https://four-phantoms-brewing-company.square.site/ Four Phantoms on Untappd: https://untappd.com/FourPhantoms/beer Big Mouth Billy Bass: https://yo...

Episode 135 – Ooh I Wanna Take Ya 02.05.2021

Palm trees are amazing. In this week’s episode, Jake and Wyatt get unintentionally introspective and also maybe call for a general strike? That, and they embark on a Bermudangle voyage to explore the mysterious disappearances of Flight 19 and the S.S. Cotopaxi . It’s a Bermuda Triangle episode, is what we’re getting at. Check it out! EPISODE LINKS All-purpose show links: https://www.superduperstit...

Episode 134 – Secretly Incredibly Terrifying (feat. Alex Schmidt) 23.04.2021

Comedian, podcast host, and generally curious guy ALEX SCHMIDT joins the show to talk about some surprisingly creepy things! Given such a straightforward prompt, Jake launches in with the “surprisingly” spooky story of Bloody Mary. You know, that thing you didn’t realize was scary? But what if we told you… IT’S ALL TRUE? KIND OF?? Wyatt follows up with an even more chilling topic: Tupperware . Is...

Episode 133 – Concerniture 16.04.2021

This one’s about weird furniture. Featuring: curses, Jake answering only in hums, and a return of The Quaff that comes dangerously close to actually reviewing a beer… EPISODE LINKS All-purpose show links: https://www.superduperstitious.com/links “The Quaff” bottle openers: https://www.superduperstitious.com/shop/x7k2m1lj2h9vaifu5di7mdnsn2gemk Four Phantoms email: fourphantomsbeer@gmail.com Four Ph...

Episode 132 – March Madderness 05.04.2021

The 2020 season was a wash. It’s been two long years and 72 episodes since the last time we did it . That’s right: it’s cult tournament time . This week is the championship showdown between the Earth Division and the Planetary Division of cults, featuring all the doomsdays, owls, and former taxi drivers you could hope for! Fill out your bracket, charge up a spiritual energy battery, and join us as...

Episode 131 – March Märchen 27.03.2021

Once upon a time, etc., etc., it’s a fairy tale themed episode of Superduperstitious! Talkin’ ’bout ogres, talkin’ ’bout gnomes, talkin’ ’bout frustrating dialectic differences between the U.S. and the U.K. – it’s all here! So squeeze some salt, secure your dog door, and let’s all of us live happily ever after with this week’s episode. EPISODE LINKS Support victims’ families in Boulder: https://bi...

Episode 130 – Strange Phenomena (Including but Not Limited to: Lights) 22.03.2021

 Spook lights, baby! That’s the name of the game this week. After an Oumuamua update from Wyatt, Jake ventures to the Mekong River for some fireballs that are either being puked up by a giant snake, stirred up by the river itself, faked for tourism purposes – OR PERHAPS ALL THREE . Wyatt then follows up on a listener lead for some equally intriguing flying light balls in Missouri. Find out some...

Episode 129 – Return of Young Santa 05.03.2021

Old Nick is back with some more stories to share, which can only mean JUDGEMENT TIME. Wyatt does the duty of evaluating listener Nick’s submissions for quality, and unsurprisingly finds them wanting. Then, following an apology for being upsettingly punctual, Jake delivers instructions on how to perform a séance! These instructions come from only the finest sources, seamlessly concatenated into a c...

Episode 128 – Home State Horrors (Part 1 of 25+) 25.02.2021

This week’s episode asks the question on all our minds: Is ideas bread? The boys tell tales from their own home states to kick off a new recurring segment: Home State Horrors! Over the next eighty years or so, Superduperstitious is gonna cover all 50 U.S. states, plus probably some other places, too! In this initial installment, Wyatt and Jake learn some exciting news about their blood. Jake leads...

Episode 127 – Not Toying Around 18.02.2021

It’s another cursèd object roundup on this week’s Superduperstitious! Having narrowly survived a run-in with the creepiest goddamned teddy bear ever, Mr. Dr. Shell introduces Harold the Doll in all his probably-very-haunted glory, followed by audio from some equally evil Elmos. Jake, meanwhile, is just really hung up on this one vase that makes you die. Remember: when in doubt, throw it out (over...

Episode 126 – Floyd's Tomb 31.01.2021

The boys once again sing the unprompted praises of Annihilation in this thinly-veiled excuse for Jake to talk about cave stuff! First up, it’s a look at scary cave movies and how they compare to real life cave science. Could horrific creatures really lurk in the darkness, waiting to attack? And does any of that matter to a good spooky tale? Wyatt then answers that question (“no”) with one such dec...

Episode 125 – Happy Butterversary! 11.01.2021

The start of a new year means some time talk on Superduperstitious! After a bit of rambling that might be more appropriate in a different, more popular genre of podcast (the lucrative road not traveled), the boys dig into some stories that roughly fulfill the prompt of “it is now a different year than it was”. For Wyatt, this means tales from alleged time travelers! And for Jake, an annual Arkansa...

Episode 124 – A Merry Ghoultide 25.12.2020

The boys are back again, with some kooks and spooks for the books! (For the purposes of this description text, pretend that those three words rhyme.) After a truly surprising visit from a Spring Heeled old pal, Jake leads the way with more of what he does best: crawler bullshit. Cut him some slack – it’s Christmas! And this time it’s served with a tasty side of cave ecology. Wyatt then pays a FOUR...

UNLOCKED: Ep. 118-122 Bonus Outtakes 03.12.2020

It's that time of the year again! Time for us to be busier than we've ever been before (a bar we wish would stop getting inexplicably raised) and to consequently just post some existing content. "What 'tent is this you give to us?" you festively ask to the tune of Greensleeves. And we answer you, to the tune of the verse part of "Burning Down the House": Here's some outtakes! Take a peek. They're...

Episode 123 – What Happening 15.11.2020

After a particularly rough fortnight of PhDing, Wyatt deserves a break. This episode is that! Due to a major backlog of listener stories (i.e. exactly four stories from two people), there’s plenty of material to fill this week’s ep without the boys having to even really try! Jake takes the wheel and leads us all through tales of forest witch legal action, lava fields, and making out. Kick back, pu...

Episode 122 – The 4th Annual Superduperstitious Halloween Spookstravaganza 30.10.2020

Well wouldn’t you know it, there IS one more guest appearance in store this month, just in time for Halloween itself! The boys welcome back to the show friend, bartender, tour guide, and expert on all things Chicago, JONATHAN KNOTEK. Together, the three enjoy a drunken ramble through some scary stories, some haunted history, and some very breaking news RE: a certain city’s bat monsters. Just how m...

Episode 121 – Talkin’ ’bout Halloween with Chris Hastings! 22.10.2020

October has one last meandering interview up its sleeve, and this one is all Halloween all the time! Comics writer and artist CHRIS HASTINGS generously wastes his entire evening talking with Wyatt and Jake about the spookiest of holidays. Does sugary cereal turn children into maniacs? How haunted can a family-made bathtub get? And what type of architecture is required to achieve a successful Krang...

Episode 120 – Hot Singles in Your Area (feat. Jordan Shiveley) 16.10.2020

As Halloween draws ever closer, it’s time for Wyatt and Jake to once again show their directionless interviewing chops! This week, writer/podcaster/designer/chef JORDAN SHIVELEY stops by to talk about his current projects in weird fiction, as well as a series of Halloween-adjacent topics that come up. Learn the joys of watching entire horror franchises in release order, how to get officially label...

Episode 119 – Fear Factors Part II: The Loud Explaining of the Phenomenon 09.10.2020

Another Superduperstitious Special Report concludes, this time with a whole buncha psychology, neurology, and cultural history FACTZ. So what, in the end, is the ultimate reason folks like scary stories? In short, it’s because they’re GOOD FOR YOU . And in case you’re worried that this episode will be TOO informational, rest assured that it’s crammed full of the most possible nonsensical recurring...

Episode 118 – Fear Factors Part I: The Quiet Peeing of the Pants 01.10.2020

What better way to kick off October than with another Superduperstitious Special Report! This edition seeks to answer the age old question: why come scary stories? Jake and Wyatt start this two-ep deep dive with a variety of sample ghost stories past and present, and a look at the cultural and psychological factors that contribute to humanity’s timeless love of being frightened. Listen along to he...

Episode 117 – Readings from the Korndämonenomicon 27.09.2020

Autumn: a thing that happens, as far as we know, every single year . North of the Equator, it’s happening RIGHT NOW. This episode is about that! After a classic and arguably needless SDS PSA, Wyatt explains the German tradition of Feldgeister (“field spirits”), also known as Korndämonen . These corn demons are believed to be responsible for the wellbeing of each field’s crops, so you’d best respec...

Episode 116 – Please Recargh 19.09.2020

What do a scary forest hag legend and a weird stretch of Venezuelan road have in common? Nothing. Except that they’re both featured in this week’s potpourri episode! After some Venusian news, Jake introduces Wyatt to Penelope, a horrific monster woman who roams the Sierra Nevada eating everyone and everything she can. Can radioactive waste really turn a car crash victim into a superwitch? Why the...

Listen to the Superduperstitious podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.