Strange Sisters Podcast | True Crime, Paranormal, and Spooky Movie Reviews

In this Pride Month episode of Strange Sisters, we investigate the unsolved case of the Doodler, a serial killer who targeted gay men in 1970s San Francisco, leaving at least six confirmed victims and up to fourteen dead. Amid rampant homophobia, police indifference, and survivors too afraid to come forward, justice was never served—despite a suspect confessing during therapy. We honor the victims...

In this episode, we delve into the chilling origins and evolution of Slenderman, the faceless, shadowy figure born from internet folklore. From creepypasta forums to real-life consequences, we explore how a modern myth took on a life of its own.

In this gripping episode, we investigate the 2008 murder of 24-year-old realtor Lindsey Buziak, who was lured to a home showing under false pretenses and brutally stabbed to death. Despite numerous theories, suspicious connections, and a trail of unsettling clues, her case remains unsolved nearly two decades later — a chilling reminder of a calculated crime that still demands justice.

Dive into the chilling legends of America’s most infamous prison. In this episode, we explore the haunted history of Alcatraz Island—from eerie sounds in abandoned cell blocks to ghostly apparitions of former inmates. Hear firsthand accounts, mysterious stories, and the supernatural lore that still lingers in the fog. Are the ghosts of Alcatraz real... or just echoes of a dark past?

Sign the Change.org Petition Contribute to the family's GoFundMe In this episode, we explore the mysterious and tragic death of Jason Abarca, a young man struggling with grief and mental health following his brother’s suicide. After a series of alarming events—including a mental health crisis, a car crash, and a frantic police chase—Jason’s body was found months later in the woods under suspic...

In this chilling episode, we delve into the true story of Mercy Brown, a young woman from 19th-century Rhode Island whose death sparked one of America's most infamous vampire panics. Explore the eerie events that led her family and neighbors to exhume her body, the folklore that fueled their fears, and how Mercy's tale became a cornerstone of New England's haunted history. Was it super...

Is the papacy nearing its end? In this minisode, we explore the mysterious 12th-century Prophecy of the Popes, attributed to Saint Malachy, which some believe foretells the identities of 112 popes—ending with a figure known as Peter the Roman. Could Pope Francis be the final pontiff, and does the prophecy point to an approaching apocalypse? Join us as we uncover the origins, controversies, and end...

We're back in the heart of the Appalachian Mountains this week to explore more of the cryptids that call these rugged hills home.

In this episode we explore the chilling history of the haunted orphanage at Gettysburg. Once a refuge for orphaned children, the building now stands as a dark reminder of tragedy, with rumors of ghostly apparitions and unexplained phenomena haunting its halls. We’ll dive into the stories of those who lived—and died—here, and hear about Cassandra's personal experiences on the tour. Tune in to u...

On a cloudy Texas day in November 2012, Christopher Todd Erick’s life was tragically cut short under deeply suspicious circumstances. Officially ruled as undetermined with cyanide toxicity, his death was dismissed as natural or even suicide, despite mounting evidence suggesting foul play at the hands of his own family. His mother, Kim, has spent years uncovering chilling details—allegations of tor...

In this episode, we delve into the chilling tale of the Islandmagee Witch Trials, Ireland’s last known witch trial, which took place in 1711. This dark chapter in history saw eight women and one man accused of witchcraft in the small County Antrim town of Islandmagee. Allegations arose after a local woman, Mary Dunbar, claimed to be tormented by supernatural forces, leading to a sensational trial...

Is time truly a linear experience, or do strange anomalies challenge our understanding of past, present, and future? In this episode, we explore eerie firsthand accounts of time slips—moments when individuals claim to have unknowingly stepped into another era. From the haunting vision of journalist Irene Corbally Kuhn, who seemingly foresaw her husband's funeral months before his passing, to t...

This week we’re venturing deep into the heart of the Appalachian Mountains to explore the cryptids that call these rugged hills home.

In this episode of Strange Sisters, we dive into two of the most compelling UFO cases that have left experts and skeptics alike scratching their heads. First, we explore the dazzling Muskegon Incident , which occurred in March 1994 and was witnessed by hundred of people across 47 counties in Michigan. Next, we shift our focus to the Tic Tac UFO Sighting , an event that took place just off the coas...

In this episode, we dive into the eerie origins of modern Spiritualism through the story of the Fox Sisters—Maggie, Kate, and Leah—who captivated 19th-century America with their supposed ability to communicate with the dead. From their humble beginnings in Hydesville, New York, where mysterious knocks first echoed through their home, to their rise as celebrated mediums in Rochester, the sisters sp...