Amanda Poole and Jenna Sylvester

Steeped in Mystery

Fiction EN ↓ 152 episodes

Join us as we dip our toes in the unknown, sip on some tea, and decide whether we would ever face some of the things and places Steeped in Mystery.

Author

Amanda Poole and Jenna Sylvester

Category

Fiction

Podcast website

www.steepedmystery.com

Latest episode

Sep 17, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Ep 27. Prison Brew 25.02.2023

A so called scientific study that went wrong in only a few hours. Come hear about one one the most Bizzare and cruel experiments to take place in America.

Ep 26. Tea With Starseeds 18.02.2023

What if there are people maybe even yourself that are the offspring of aliens?  What if they are here for good, or evil? Find out today as we talk about Starseeds.

Ep 25. The Tea in Theatre 11.02.2023

 Today we talk about the cool, weird, and spooky superstitions on every stage. 

Ep 24. Tea with Shadows 04.02.2023

A dart out of the corner of your eye, a figure just behind you, or a threatening face at the foot of your bed. Today we talk all about shadow people, hat man and our experience with them.

Ep 23. Astral Tea Part 2 28.01.2023

We continue with a crazy CIA document  and how it may be shaping our entire universe. Also wands and like one guy looking at a goat.

Ep 22. Astral Tea Part 1 21.01.2023

Today we pull out a document from the CIA that delves into remote viewing, time travel, and even what may happen when we die. 

Ep 21. Red-headed Tea 15.01.2023

Giant mysteries of a cave in Nevada. Come find out what a cashe of artifacts and some fake ducks have to do with a group of red-headed cannibalistic giants.

Ep 20. A Slip In Tea Time 07.01.2023

What if you shopped at a store that has been closed for years or saw the future of a place long before it came true? Today Jenna tells us stories of just a few time slips.

Ep 19. Get To Know Us Countdown 31.12.2022

Today we dive into the mystery that is Jenna and Amanda as we tell you a little bit about us and about the podcast in a new years episode that is all fun and no scares!

Ep 18. The Night Before Krampus 24.12.2022

First an update on B.E.K.'s followed by the creature who is out for naughty children just like them. Enjoy our short but sweet Christmas special!

Ep 17. Christmas Tea 17.12.2022

In the old tradition Jenna tells Amanda an old Christmas ghost story.

Ep 16. Yetea 10.12.2022

Out in the highest mountain range in the world is a cryptid who is so elusive the so far only foot prints have been captured. How ever despite this it is known around the world. Today we reach new heights as we tell you all about the Yeti.

Ep 15. Cold Tea 03.12.2022

Hunger can turn us into nasty people. It can make some people irritable, or tired, or even sad. But to those in the Donner party it really turned them for the worst, and perhaps a Wendigo spirit might have been at fault. WARNING This episode contains gory details on cannibalism.

Ep 14. Roanoke Tea Party 26.11.2022

Today we discuss the lost colony of Roanoke and the mysterious word they left behind, as well as the misinformation around the first colony and the first thanksgiving.

Ep 13. Brewing in the Backrooms 19.11.2022

What if you could slip through the cracks in reality? To some distant place... To some this may sound like a dream, however the backrooms are anything but a dream. Today Amanda tells you how and why the backrooms may be the realist creepy pasta yet. (Note: For best experience checkout the following links) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sA5PxGHqpTo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4dGpz6cnHo

Ep 12. Tea with Bigfoot 12.11.2022

We discuss why we think bigfoot has stayed so elusive and tell encounter stories from as recent as 2017 and as old as people themselves.

Ep 11. Black-Eyed Tea 05.11.2022

Today Jenna warns us all not let a child in without looking them in the eyes. As we explore several chilling encounters with unexpected guests you never want to meet.

Ep 10. Creature Double Feature 29.10.2022

Happy Halloween! Today we have our creature double feature! From Werewolves on trial to stuffed Chupacabra's it's an episode that will leave you questioning what you know. Come hear alll the tea.

Ep 9. Roswell and The Trini-Tea UFO 22.10.2022

Jenna introduces a lesser known UFO crash while Amanda re-hashes a classic. From weather balloons to avocado spacecraft we go over some amazing alien stories and even touch base on a video that take belief to whole new meaning. 

Ep 8. Movies Steeped in Curses 15.10.2022

Horror movies are mad with one intention. To scare its viewers. However every once in a while directors unintentionally call a form of evil down on their own sets. Join us as we explore two cursed film sets.

Ep 7. Raise a cup to the 27 Club 08.10.2022

Its always sad when people die young. But the deaths of those in the 27 club are equally mysterious. From lesser knowns like Benjamin Keough to big names like Jimi Hendrix we talk about just a few of these unlucky club members.

Ep 6. Three Monster Tea Party 01.10.2022

Jenna takes the lead to tell us all about Normie, Champ, and the Bear Lake Monster.  Today we explore just a few of the many cryptids that reside in American waters.  With evidence so compelling how could you resist diving into these lakes steeped in mystery.

Ep 5. Russian Sleepy Time Tea 24.09.2022

Ever pulled an all-nighter? Two in a row? After todays episode you might never skip sleep again. Today Amanda tells Jenna all about her favorite Creepypasta The Russian Sleep Experiment. WARNING This episode contains mentions of suicide, graphic gory details, bloody imagery that will make your skin crawl.

Ep 4. Full Kettle: Hollow Earth 20.09.2022

A president and a famed pilot. What do these two have in common? They both know what lies in the cavernous spaces beneath our feet. Our planet is steeped to it hollow center in mystery.

Ep 3. The Full Tea on the Empty Sea 10.09.2022

Its one thing to lose your keys or your sanity, but when boats, planes, and people vanish without a trace you get a bad reputation. This time we discuss the most tropical case of disappearances. The Bermuda Triangle. Listen to different cases of things never found in a place Steeped in Mystery.  Book your getaway with care lest you turn up missing as well.

Listen to the Steeped in Mystery podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.