Stab in the Back

Who’s ready for some of the grossest pieces of evidence we’ve ever seen?! Sometimes it’s not just blood ad guts!  First, Benton tells the tale of Mark Redwine and a very special set of photographs. Then, Anna shares the story of Meredith Kercher’s murder, and why you should always flush the toilet. Finally, the two watch the nastiest episode of Forensic Files ever made, profiling the murders of th...

They say you only die once, but some people seem to do it for sport! This episode is all about people who fake their own death, and have to explain why they’re making such a stunning career move.  First, Anna share a few bits of information on why a person may fake their own death, and Benton tells the tale of poisoner and murderer, Audrey Marie Hilley. Then, Anna shares the antics of evangelist A...

Have you ever seen a doctor and wondered if they were a quack? Maybe they are! Medical fraud is the focus of Episode 98! First, Benton tells of the many products containing radioactive material at the turn of the 20th century that probably did more harm than good. Then, Anna relays the case of Jacques Roy, one of the biggest Medicare fraudsters in history. Finally, the two watch a truly iconic epi...

Did a dingo eat that baby? You’ll find out soon! This week’s episode is all about strange and unusual deaths that you wouldn’t see coming. First, Benton relays two stories of death resulting from being trapped, first in a laundry closet and then in a gap behind a supermarket freezer. Then, Anna tells the well publicized story of Azaria Chamberlain, who was carried off by a dingo in the Australian...

Do artists kill people? Some do, and Episode 96 profiles a few creative people who definitely shouldn't get top prize. First, Benton tells the tale of children's book artist Harry Horse and his murder-suicide, and Anna gives us the details of artist Richard Dadd's troubled life. Then, the two watch a classic episode of City Confidential, profiling the death of SoHo artist Ana Mendie...

Have you ever wondered if the vehicle you're on could be hijacked? Episode 95 is for you!  First, Anna goes over the history of hijackings specific to the aviation industry, and Benton tells of the mundane but internet famous hijacking off EgyptAir Flight 181. Then, Anna relays everything we know about the mysterious hijacker, B.D. Cooper. Finally, the two watch a documentary profiling the in...

For Episode 94 of Stab in the Back, we look into the phenomenon of murdered and missing Indigenous women, referred to as MMIW. First, Anna provides some information on why this group might be more susceptible to crime, and Benton gives a rundown on Canada's dangerous Trail of Tears. Then, Anna relays the tragic and mysterious death of Olivia Lone Bear. Finally, the two watch an episode of Col...

Are you ready for more cult action? Episode 93 is all about the more benign cults that may fly under the radar, but still pose a threat to vulnerable people. First, the two discuss what makes a person more susceptible to getting sucked into a cult, and Benton shares the beliefs of UFO religious leader Raël and his group of Raëlians. Then, Anna tells of the current communal group of off-grid surviv...

Episode 92 is all about cover ups! Sometimes it's before an investigation can even take place.  First, Anna gives a small rundown on how justice can be thwarted early on, and Benton gives the details on the tragic death of Kendrick Johnson. Then, Anna tells the sordid tales of Warren G. Harding. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the death of Kimber...

Happy 3rd anniversary to Stab in the Back! Join Benton and Anna as they reminisce and discuss another year gone by, and invite a few special guests to share their favorite true crime stories.  First, we welcome back one of Anna's best friends, Casey, who relays the murder of Austin jewelry store owner Ted Shaughnessy. Then, we welcome back Benton's partner, Matt, who tells the tale of It...

Was it an accident, a suicide, or a murder? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how often that question is asked. First, Anna shares some information about accidents and why they might fly under the radar as unexplained deaths, and Benton tells the tale of the mysterious death of Gareth Williams. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of the puzzling death of Laur...

Strap in, it's the annual Valentine's Day episode! Crimes involving folie à deux are the gifts that keep on giving, and this episode focuses on more than 2 people being in on the delusion.  First, Anna goes down the list of how people can develop such shared delusions, and Benton tells the tragic tale of the mass suicide of the Chundawat family. Then, Anna recounts the case of three sist...

Have you ever wondered how safe it is to work as a news anchor? Then episode 88 is for you, because they get murdered, too!  First, Anna and Benton discuss why news anchors might have an elevated level of danger, and Benton tells of the senseless murder of Anne Pressly. Then, Anna relays the story of thee stalking/murder of Katherine Dettman. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Fi...

Have you ever had a bad neighbor? For our first show of the new year, we dive into murders in the community between people who live in close proximity with each other.  First, Benton tells the tale of Melanie Smith, who burned 5 members of her neighbor's family to death, and Anna relays the tragic story of the Pike County murders. Lastly, the two enjoy a classic episode of American Justice, p...

Our first live show! For Episode 86, Benton and Anna attempt to condense the story of Jonbenét Ramsey into a tight hour and a half. Please enjoy our thoughts on this whopper of a crime, as well as our opinions on who might have done it. A very special thank you to Tim and Evan at Brother Friend for hosting us and supporting our podcast, we love you!

How do you do, fellow Halloween kids?! Welcome to a very special episode of Stab in the Back, where Benton and Anna take a look at torture methods in medieval times, as well as some of its practitioners. First, Anna gives a rundown on the generalities of torture in the middle ages, and Benton presents a list of especially horrible forms of torture. Then, Anna tells the tale of the notorious Vlad t...

Do you have any authors in your life? They may be hiding a dark secret in some of their work, and it just might mean murder! Episode 84 is all about writers involved in the deaths of themselves or others.  First, Benton tells the tale of Syndrome author Blake Leibel's murder of Iana Kasian. Then, Anna relays the tragic story of Kenneth Halliwell and Joe Orton's murder-suicide. Lastly, th...

Hey, Backstabbers!  Have you ever had your identity stolen? You'll be glad that it wasn't by one of these hustlers in Episode 83.  First, Anna gives a rundown on how identity theft has always been with us, but much easier it is in the digital world of today, and Benton tells of the infamous Chameleon Killer, Elaine Parent. Then, Anna gives us a look at credit card fraud gone wild with Da...

Attention all armchair detective Backstabbers, this episode is all about the coldest of cold cases! First, Anna gives some numbers on how many crimes go unsolved, and Benton tells the tale of San Francisco's unknown serial killer, the Doodler. Then, Anna relays the story of Edgar Allen Poe's mysterious death in 1849. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling...

Hey Backstabbers! This really isn't an episode, but we thought it'd be fun if we recorded a viewing of the absolutely classic piece of cinema known as...The Silence of the Lambs! We have a pretty sizable gap between episodes around now due to vacation time, so we thought this would tickle your fancy. Watch along with us! Have a laugh!  We streamed on Max and a prompt will be given at the...

Some crimes are much worse than others, and Episode 81 takes a look at the specific methods of murder known as familicide and family annihilation. First, Anna gives us a glimpse into the reasons why one may commit such a crime, and Benton tells the horrible tale of Jennifer and Sarah Hart's murder suicide. Then, Anna relays the story of Xavier Dupont, who disappeared after murdering his entir...

See that school? Keep your eyes peeled, those teachers may not have the best intentions, they may be killers! First, Benton relays the story of Carolyn Warmus, a woman who earned the nickname 'Fatal Attraction Killer'. Then, Anna recounts the murder of Kathy Essery at the hands of Nathaniel Mellerson. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murde...

They say it's usually the husband. Sometimes that's true many times over! This episode is all about so called Blue Beards, men who kill more than one wife.  First, Anna share a few bits of information on how so-called Blue Beards operate, and Benton tells the tale of double wife murderer Earl Taylor. Then, Anna shares the sinister story of Johann Otto Hoch, a bigamist who may have killed...

Have you ever been blamed for something you didn't do? It sucks! But that pales in comparison to truly being framed, which is the focus of Episode 78! First, Anna goes over some of the ways a person can be put away for a crime they didn't commit, and Benton tells the strange tale of Barry Ardolf and his reign of terror via a hacked wifi network. Then, Anna relays the frame up of Floyd Bl...

Happy Mother's Day, Backstabbers! Welcome to Episode 77, where mothers will do any manner of unspeakable things for their children. First, Benton tells the sordid tale of the murder for hire plot to kill Emilia Raras' own daughter-in-law, Sara. Then, Anna relays the story of Wanda Holloway, who chose murder to help advance her daughter's chances of making the cheerleading squad. Fin...