Tabitha, Angie, and Teresa

Small Towns True Crimes

We are a group of four women who love to listen to, watch, and read about true crime. We’ve decided to research and get together and discuss true crimes that tragically happen in small towns everywhere. Come along and help share stories that happen in places that may be closer to your from door than you think.

Author

Tabitha, Angie, and Teresa

Category

True Crime

Latest episode

Jul 5, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

September BONUS 18.09.2025

Listen as Teresa tells us the story what happened in Muhlenberg County, Kentucky. A young girl goes missing and tragedy strikes this small, southern town.

Episode 41: Shawn Windsor 14.09.2025

Was it a suicide pact or a man that lost his wife and child and as well as his mind. This is the story of Shawn Windsor and the tragic death of his wife and son.

Episode 40: Bill Cosby 07.09.2025

In today's episode, we unravel the controversial and shocking story of Bill Cosby- a man once celebrated as "America's Dad," whose legacy took a dark and disturbing turn.

Episode 39: Tommy Lynn Sells 31.08.2025

In this chilling episode, we dive into the twisted life of Tommy Lynn Sells, one of the most prolific an elusive serial killers in American history. Known as "The Cross-Country Killer," Sells left a trail of devastation across multiple states, spanning decades.

Episode 38: Traci Leigh Jones 24.08.2025

Traci Leigh Jones was a young woman with dreams and determination- but her life took a dark tragic turn that left a community reeling. In this episode, we uncover the events leading up to her mysterious death, explore the investigation that followed, and examine the unanswered questions that still hunt those who knew her. Who was Traci, and what really happened in the final hours of her life?

Episode 37: Alison Botha 17.08.2025

This is the wildest SURVIVAL story I have ever heard! This woman is AMAZING! She is a fighter! Listen as we tell and discuss the survival story of Alison Botha. What they did to her, what the failed to do, and how she not only lived....she thrives!

August BONUS 16.08.2025

In 2013, a quiet Massachusetts town was shaken by the brutal murder of beloved high school teacher Colleen Ritzer. Her killer was one of her own students—14-year-old Phillip Chism. This shocking case raised chilling questions about violence among youth, the warning signs that were missed, and how such a tragedy could unfold inside the walls of a school. In this episode, we dive into the life of Co...

Episode 36: Idaho 4 10.08.2025

In the quiet college town of Moscow, Idaho, a brutal crime shattered the peace and captured nation's attention. Listen as we tell this story and discuss our thoughts on this tragedy.

Episode 35: Ayanna Morgan 03.08.2025

What should be a safe area for college students is actually the complete opposite. This is a story of a young 21-year-old girl lost her life in the parking lot of her apartment. Listen now!

Episode 34: Gabby Petito 27.07.2025

In this episode we discuss a story of two young lovers who take a trip out west. Things get crazy when only one of them return home. This is the story of Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie.

Episode 33: Donald Harvey 20.07.2025

Listen as we discuss the story of an American Serical Killer who claimed he was an angel of death. He in fact, used his job to murder people, maybe as many as 87!

July BONUS 15.07.2025

If you haven't heard of Heaven's Gate... Now is your chance! In this episode we discuss things like...aliens, castration, group suicide, cults... It has it all! Marshall Applewhite and Bonnie Nettles meet and form a group like one you have never seen or heard of! After YEARS of creating a cult like group, the big event happens. They prepare themselves to move to the "Next Level"....

Episode 32: Noah Presgrove 13.07.2025

Was Noah Presgrove beaten to death by his friends? Did he face a tragic accidental death? Listen as we discuss the sad end to one young man's life. Let us know what you think happened to Noah.

Episode 31: Charles Manson Part 2 06.07.2025

In this episode we continue to discuss Charles Manson. In this episode we focus on the Tate, LaBianca, and Hinman murders. We also discuss how crazy it is that Charles Manson was able to get people to follow him into murder....Why? What would make someone kill for their "leader"?

Episode 30: Part 1 Charlie Manson 29.06.2025

In this episode we discuss who Charlie Manson was. We tell of his childhood and discuss all the events that lead up to him creating a cult. Who was Manson before he decided to lead people to murder?

Episode 29: London Gabb 22.06.2025

In this episode we discuss the tragic death of a young girl. Mental health is real. Mental struggles are real. Continuing to further educate everyone; adults, children, teachers, and doctors is a must to further help anyone suffering. Remember help is always available. Dial 988 for suicide and crisis help

Traveling out West Bonus 4 19.06.2025

Listen as we tell the story which teaches a lesson about being kind to just everyone you meet. Sadly enough, not everyone is a nice guy. We tell this story as we sit at Glacier National Park, Montana.

Traveling out West Bonus 3 15.06.2025

Join us at Yellowstone National Park! Here we talk about a murder that just happened five days before we came to the park! Listen about how Charlott Andrades was charged with murder once but got free. She didn't stop though. Just five days ago she was arrested AGAIN for murder.

Episode 28: Larry Nassar 15.06.2025

How much trust should a parent put in to their child's doctor? This is a sick story of how one man used his degree to sexually abuse children.

Traveling out West Bonus 2 13.06.2025

Today we are in Keystone, South Dakota. Listen to Angie tell us about the Duct Tape Killer.

Traveling out West Bonus 1 12.06.2025

As two of us head out west, we have decided to share some crazy true crime stories that happened at the places we visit. This episode is about a serial killer from St. Joseph, MO. Angie and Tabitha are telling this story from the area the crimes occurred. Listen know and learn how Marvin Irvin goes from good kid, to cop, to serial killer.

Episode 27: Ohio County Missing Girls 08.06.2025

This is the story of two women who went missing from Ohio County, Kentucky. Listen now and reach out to our local police department if you have any information regarding these ladies.

Episode 26: Carole Baskin 01.06.2025

Welcome to the jungle….I mean…Welcome to Small Towns. True Crimes! Today we talk about Carole Baskin and the Tiger King!

May Bonus: Killer Teacher 25.05.2025

Since schools are letting out for summer break, we wanted to tell you all about a terrible story of one teacher who may or may not have killed one of his students. Listen now, and let us know what you think!

Episode 25: Chelsea Mahaney 25.05.2025

This is a tragic story of a girl in her early twenties expecting her first son, but things didn’t work out for her.

Listen to the Small Towns True Crimes podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.