James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
Small Town Murder
Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!
Author
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 10, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
#44 - A Morning Time Slaughter in Kenton, Delaware 15.11.2017 1:55:55
This week, we look at the minuscule town of Kenton, Delaware, where a prison escape leads a heartless killer to unnecessary brutality, violence, and havoc that ends up all the way at the Supreme Court. Does this person escape their fate? Along the way, we find out that you don't want to speed in Kenton, that hot wiring cars must not be that hard, and how being a gang member can get you out of the...
#43 - The Definition Of Depravity in Scottsbluff, Nebraska 08.11.2017 1:56:37
This week, we turn our attention out west, to the town of Scottsbluff, Nebraska, where a situation spun out of control, ending in one of the most mind boggling, and unnecessarily viscious murders in history. Just how bad can a person be? We now have an answer to that question. Along the way, we find out how to get a mountain named after yourself, at what point you should worry when someone is miss...
#42 - Kitchen Table Murder in Burke, Vermont 01.11.2017 1:57:35
This week, we check out the sweet, and syrupy town of Burke, Vermont, where a extremely generous, and beloved member of the community was taken, in such a way that caused way more questions than it answered... and that was before the courts got involved. Along the way, we find out why certain terrible names no loner exist, how syrup extracting can get you out of a locked basement, and exactly how...
#41 - Remorseless Horrors in Washington Terrace, Utah 25.10.2017 1:50:57
This week, we take a peek at the run of the mill town of Washington Terrace, Utah, where possibly one of the worst people to ever exist, commits the ultimate acts of depravity, and savagery, while causing the whole world to take notice of the aftermath. Along the way, we find out exactly what goes on in the day of a small town festival, if moving to Florida cause you to stab your step father, and...
#40 - Six Unthinkable Things in Norwalk, Iowa 18.10.2017 1:46:27
This week, we look into the noticeably middle of the road town of Norwalk, Iowa, where the police were powerless to stop an inevitable horror that would take place in a quiet home, despite the all the warning signs in the world. The murders are mind boggling, and the defense is even crazier! Along the way, we find out just how rich you can get off of corn, if having no memory is the legal equivale...
#39 - The Orbit Of A Killer in Epping, New Hampshire 11.10.2017 1:44:34
This week, we check out the pretty, little town of Epping, New Hampshire, where someone heartlessly drew in victim, after victim, until it was too much for anyone to ignore. Lives were ruined, bodies were burned, and toes were found a decade later. This is a crazy story, that never stops getting crazier! Along the way, we find out what parades are absolutely necessary to a town, how easy it can be...
#38 - The Recipe For A Butcher in Fleming-Neon, Kentucky 04.10.2017 1:42:25
This week, we look at the tiny, coal town of Fleming-Neon, Kentucky, where horrible people planned out, and executed a seriously cold blooded plot. The brutality was overwhelming, and so was the evidence, but that's only part of the story...Along the way, we find out what happens when a town really wants people to think it's haunted, how many jails you can escape from & still receive parole, and e...
#37 - A Deviously Hypocritical Killer in Wolsey, South Dakota 27.09.2017 1:45:15
This week, we look at the very small, very rural wheat growing town of Wolsey, South Dakota, where the pillar of the community made everyone think they were perfect, and turned out to be just as awful as everyone else. The cold blooded plan shows the whole town that you just can't trust anybody. Along the way, we find out that some people can't get enough of watching goats race, exactly what const...
#36 - The Man With Two Last Meals in Iowa, Louisiana 20.09.2017 1:18:07
This week, we see what goes on in Iowa, Louisiana, where a terrible person escalated his crimes to the point of pure brutality, and to the point where the harshest of penalties was being sought... And then it got even more interesting. Along the way, we find out where oil actually is, what to do with an aluminum bat & a lightning bug, and just how brutal a crime has to be, before it's considered "...
#35 - Dr. Frankenstein Has Lost Control, in LaPorte, Indiana 13.09.2017 1:41:55
This week, we bring you an extra long, extra murderous episode, as a thank you to all of the listeners!! We look at the solid, middle class town of LaPorte, Indiana, where one man showed showed all the signs that he could someday be a budding serial killer, then started to follow through on his potenital. Along the way, we find out how expensive a bike ride can be, why it seems to be so easy to br...
#34 - Death Threats Lead To Murder in Marydel, Maryland 06.09.2017 1:21:42
This week, we check out the quiet town of Marydel, Maryland, where almost 27 years of tension, and violence resulted in one final, deadly showdown, and 15 years of court battles. Along the way, we find out that not all Guatemalans speak spanish, how two petty families caused the Mason-Dixon line, and just how far you can you can push someone before they shoot you in the face! Hosted by James Pietr...
#33 - A Basement Dwelling Predator in Collegeville, Pennsylvania 30.08.2017 1:23:58
This week, we check into the aptly named college town of Collegeville, Pennsylvania, where one person's incredibly cold blooded, and completely abhorrent actions changed, frightened, and generally freaked out the entire town. Along the way, we find out how a grown man gets picked on in the bathroom, if there's anything more disgusting than peepholes into a dressing room, and that if a murder suspe...
#32 - Broken Bones & Brutal Murder in Baraboo, Wisconsin 23.08.2017 1:11:05
This week, we look at the circus loving town of Baraboo, Wisconsin, where one person's acts of brutality were like nothing anyone had ever seen. One young man's desire to live was the only thing that kept a potential serial killer from achieving his goals. Along the way, we find out just who you call when there's an escaped elephant in your yard, what goes on inside of a circus museum, and exactly...
#31 - A Monster More Than Once in Woodside, South Australia 16.08.2017 1:13:07
This week, we check out the down under town of Woodside, South Australia for the tale of a monster that just kept getting let out of his cage, no matter how terrible his acts. Along the way, we find out just how angry Australia's version of Captain Kangaroo was, how a train can really spruce up a town, and just how horrible you can be, and still get out of prison in less than 15 years!! Hosted by...
#30 - A Killer So Clumsy in Kensett, Arkansas 09.08.2017 1:12:57
This week, we look at the out of the way town of Kensett, Arkansas, where a misguided man blunders, and fumbles through 3 brutal murders, for seemingly no good reason. Along the way, we find what time of year is "trailer season", what makes a person leave a bad review for a police station, and what kind of soda you drink while taking a break from multiple murders! Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jim...
#29 - A Grinch Of A Killer in Santa Claus, Georgia 02.08.2017 1:24:19
This week, we look at the tiny, festive town of Santa Claus, Georgia, where a young man ruins the Christmas season for a whole town, by committing some of the most brutal acts imaginable. Along the way, we find out how one jolly, red faced fat man could start a whole town based on a holiday, how water beds can single handedly save tourism, and just how low a human being can possibly sink! Hosted b...
#28 - A Messy Murder Plot in Kendrick, Idaho 26.07.2017 1:10:49
This week, we check out the rural town of Kendrick, Idaho, where a man's thirst for payback led him across the country, while producing some of the most ridiculous murder plots imaginable. Jealousy, revenge, and stupidity form an incredible tale of murder. Along the way, we find out how exciting it is to look at the railroad, how many people are needed for potato related businesses, and that the m...
#27 - Family Problems, Killer Solutions in East Lyme, Connecticut 19.07.2017 1:15:50
This week, we look at the town of East Lyme, Connecticut, where a family squabble led to battles in the courtroom, followed by a murder for hire plot from a pair of lawyers that shocked the area, and still divides the family members. Along the way, we find out how old houses are in Connecticut, how lousy the roads are in New York, and exactly how much a coke dealer charges to kill a male stripper....
#26 - Two Murders, Two Murderers in Maynardville, Tennessee 12.07.2017 1:10:18
This week, we take a look at the small town of Maynardville, Tennessee, where two young men turn a night of fun & drinking into the most grisly murder scene this area has ever seen. Along the way, we find out what kind of wine goes with hot dogs, if McDonald's is the right career choice for a young man, and how many different stories a man can tell police about his participation in a murder, and s...
#25 - A Killer Caught In A Questionable Way in Gander, Newfoundland, Canada 05.07.2017 1:09:43
This week, we check out the out of the way town of Gander, Newfoundland, Canada, where police use a strategy to gain a confession from what they think is one of the most cold blooded killers they've ever encountered. Along the way, we find out exactly how nice Canadians actually are, how many people one airport can possibly employ, and if staring at a Wal-Mart security camera counts as an alibi. H...
#24 - Bad Decisions, Deadly Results in Eufaula, Oklahoma 28.06.2017 1:05:26
This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. Along the way, we find out exactly how hard it is to escape to Mexico, how much worm dung one would need to farm to make a living, and how easy it seems to be to escape from an Oklahoma jail!! Hosted by James Pietragallo...
#23 - A Nasty Pair Of Murders in Ocean Grove, New Jersey 21.06.2017 1:08:20
This week, we take a look at the old timey beach town of Ocean Grove, New Jersey, where a young man thought he could get away with 2 horrific murders. Legal factors, and small town publicity become a factor as this story twists & turns, with life in the balance. Along the way, we find out why the beach was closed on Sundays, what exactly washes up on a New Jersey shore, and what a day is like on d...
#22 - A Deadly Massacre in Chimayo, New Mexico 14.06.2017 1:08:00
This week, we look at the mountain town of Chimayo, New Mexico, where a man snapped, and began a massacre of everyone around his home. A manhunt ensued, and the results of the case are still felt, today. Along the way, we find out which hole in the dirt that you're supposed to pray to, exactly how much heroin one small town can process, and how many people you can kill & still have the nerve to cl...
#21 - A Sinister & Murderous Plot in Anniston, Alabama 07.06.2017 58:56
This week, we take a peek at the town of Anniston, Alabama, where 2 men hatched a terrible plan, that spun out of control, leaving 2 people at the bottom of a river. Along the way, we find out just how toxic a town has to be before people start to leave, how riding a certain bus, in Alabama, in 1961 could be quite dangerous, and why you should never let anyone into your house Ever!! Hosted by Jame...
#20 - Jealousy, Meth, Icepicks & Murder in Tonasket, Washington 31.05.2017 1:06:11
This week, we check out the very rural town of Tonasket, Washington, where a married man's extracurricular activities get a young woman brutally, and viciously killed, as the town reacts with horror, at each new detail. Along the way, we find out where Bigfoot lives, exactly what "old fashioned" barbecue is, and how much a meth dealer charges to kill someone!! Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.