John Thrasher and Daryn Carp
Shaken and Disturbed
Shaken and Disturbed is a new true crime podcast (with a hint of comedy) from true crime veterans John Thrasher and Daryn Carp! Having previously appeared as co-hosts of the true crime podcast Martinis & Murder, John and Daryn bring their true crime expertise, sarcastic comedy banter and passion for the details to an all-new show! With a new murder case every week, John and Daryn break down the case, connect the dots, and try to make it enjoyable along the way. Shaken and Disturbed also features interviews with the biggest names in true crime as well as episodic recaps of your favorite true cr...
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: audioboom.com
Author
John Thrasher and Daryn Carp
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 15, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
#132 - The Killer's Notebook 17.09.2023 35:38
After a man's mother doesn't show up to work, police enter her home to find absolutely horrific crime scene. Included in the crime scene is a notebook with a play-by-play of exactly how a murderer's mind works. Even Megan had to include her own notes on this week's show - that's how disturbing it is! Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as li...
NMR #50 - Live From New York, It's...Us! 16.09.2023 17:34
Surprise! John and Daryn met up in NYC to record this week's NMR (as well as Sunday's full episode)! They recap their love for each other, John's small Diet Cokes, and the US Open among other things! Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at certain levels!...
The Fall River Murders (Flashback) 10.09.2023 37:13
We took a week off for Labor Day, but will be back next week ... with a twist. In 1979 and 1980, Fall River, Massachusetts was plagued by a series of brutal, ritualistic murders that left the city in fear and the country in shock. The victims, Doreen Levesque, Barbara Raposa, and Karen Marsden, were all sex workers and their murders all had similarities in the way they were killed. Rumors circulat...
#131 - Subscription To Death 03.09.2023 41:21
When a woman starts an OnlyFans account, her life is turned upside down. But the excitement of making an enormous amount of money so quickly doesn't come without its pitfalls.
#130 - The Hidden Gunshot Wound 27.08.2023 35:28
When one woman is found shot and killed in her bed and another man is missing, authorities look at a member of the local community theatre to try to figure out what happened. But when an autopsy reveals a surprising detail, the search for the killer narrows. Watch this podcast episode in video format here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for...
NMR #49 - Discovering Our Love Languages 26.08.2023 40:10
John and Daryn had no intentions whatsoever of talking out how they each receive and express love with their love languages...but here we are! John hosted a TikTok Live and everyone some listeners popped in to show support. Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts avail...
#129 - The Bloody Fist Full of Hair 20.08.2023 34:14
In 1980, Katharina Brow was found murdered in her home with a fist full of someone else's hair. Years later a man is locked up and charged with her crime. But what happened afterwards will shake you to your core. Watch this podcast episode in video format here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Rad...
#128 - The Springfield Serial Killer 13.08.2023 43:16
From 1995 to 1998, Alfred Gaynor terrorized Springfield, Massachusetts, horrifically murdering 9 separate women. What Alfred didn't realize is his messy trail of DNA would later come back to haunt him. Watch this podcast episode in video format here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish sticker...
NMR #48 - Our Uber Ratings 13.08.2023 28:59
It's time that John and Daryn share their Uber ratings with the rest of the world. Who do you think has the higher Uber rating of the two of them? The results may shock you! Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at certain levels! Your support keeps the sho...
#127 - Left For Dead 06.08.2023 38:20
When a woman is found dead on the couch of her home, it was what was underneath the body that left investigators shaken and disturbed. Investigators immediately turn to family members who were meant to take care of her. Watch this podcast episode in video format here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Su...
#126 - The New York Zodiac Killer 30.07.2023 49:08
We all know and have heard of the Zodiac Killer who terrorized the Bay Area in the late 1960s. But years later a copycat killer known as The New York Zodiac Killer went on a spree of his own, terrorizing New York City. Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We...
NMR #47 - Daryn Plays Pickleball Now Apparently 30.07.2023 29:55
Wow, just like that Daryn cheats on John and plays pickleball behind his back. Doesn't even ask for tips. Doesn't even ask for what type of paddle to buy. Nothing. Can you tell who is writing this description out? Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at ce...
#125 - The Curious Case of Natalia Grace (Reaction, Part One) 23.07.2023 38:35
We watch and react to the Investigation Discovery 6-part documentary "The Curious Case of Natalia Grace," which is now streaming on the Max app. How old exactly is and was Natalia when she is adopted from Ukraine by the Barnett family? We break down all the absolutely crazy parts of this documentary and try to make sense of this very unsettling story. Listen to Part 2 of this episode on Patreon ri...
#124 - Lake Bodom Murders 16.07.2023 35:56
In 1960, 3 teenagers were murdered while camping in Espoo, Finland. A fourth person survived, but could he have been connected to what happened in some way? Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at...
NMR #46 - Did You Just Say Squirtle? 16.07.2023 29:10
John recaps his 4th of July arcade extravaganza in Ocean City, Maryland. Daryn can't believe he keeps saying the word Squirtle. Daryn shares her feelings about her last days as a New York City resident. Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at certain level...
Ivy League Murder (Flashback) 09.07.2023 44:12
On this episode from July 2022: How did this Harvard University professor go from one of the most respected people in his field to charged with murder? Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at certain levels! Your support keeps the show running and the bill...
#123 - The Tragedies of Frank and Viola 02.07.2023 33:12
Viola Manville, a 74-year-old woman, was brutally attacked and killed during her walk in 1988. Frank Sterling, despite having an alibi, confessed to the crime after a lengthy interrogation. He spent almost two decades in prison until DNA evidence pointed to another suspect. Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW!...
#122 - Hollywood Horror In NYC 25.06.2023 35:34
What happens when Hollywood horror meets real-life horror? After working as an expert on the 1973 horror classic "The Exorcist," a man named Paul Bateson went on to commit horrific atrocities of his own, targeting gay men in the 70s in New York City. Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show...
NMR #45 - Why Is Taylor Swift So Expensive!? 25.06.2023 27:09
John discusses how much it cost to go to the Taylor Swift Eras Tour in Pittsburgh. Daryn is moving and weighs in on some exciting changes coming up in her life. Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at certain levels! Your support keeps the show running and...
#121 - Desperate In Drag 18.06.2023 33:12
In the aftermath of the Vietnam War, John Wojtowicz embarks on a clandestine journey of self-discovery, engaging in secret affairs while hiding his true desires. When he meets Elizabeth Eden, a captivating drag queen struggling with her own identity, their love becomes a force that drives them to desperate measures. To learn more about microdosing THC go to Microdose.com and use code: shaken to ge...
#120 - Huwe's 30 Years 11.06.2023 40:57
Huwe Burton was convicted of the murder of his mother in 1991, but after a closer look at the evidence and the police tapes, there's a whole new theory that comes to life. Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcast...
NMR #44 - Do We Need VR? 10.06.2023 34:25
Daryn saw a bunch of plays and TV shows that she wants everyone else to watch. John discusses and recaps the introduction of Apple's Vision Pro VR headset. Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts available at certain levels! Your support keeps the show running and the...
#119 - The Bleeding Suitcase 04.06.2023 41:10
When a cab driver notices a suitcase is bleeding in to the trunk of his car and the 2 people who loaded it have disappeared, it sets off a manhunt in Bali, Indonesia. Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish stickers and video podcasts ava...
#118 - The Storyville Slayings 28.05.2023 40:47
In the shadows of New Orleans' vibrant history and festive celebrations lies a chilling tale of serial killings that haunted the city in the mid-90s. We go deep into The Storyville Slayings, where over 25 black sex workers met a gruesome fate at the hands of a man named Russell Ellwood. Watch this podcast episode in video format on Patreon here Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers...
NMR #43 - Be Gay, Do Crime 26.05.2023 32:30
John actually got Daryn a birthday gift and it wasn't on time - it was early! Daryn recaps the mystery package and how she narrowed down that it was in fact John who sent it. Speaking of age, John recently realized his age when he went hiking up a mountain. Our new Shaken and Disturbed Patreon perks and tiers are live NOW! Help support our show for as little as $5 a month! We now have Sussy Radish...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.