Rabbit Hole Happy Hour

The most disturbing cases are often the ones where a seemingly successful pillar of society harbors a grotesque double life. Take Todd Kohlhepp for instance. Todd was a successful realtor who owned his own brokerage. He’d helped countless people in his community find their dream home. Little did they know that Todd Kohlhepp was an ex con, sexual predator, and serial killer whose only dream was to...

Otto Warmbier was a bright college student with an even brighter future. He was eager to learn about the world beyond the United States and about the people of the world. He booked a trip with a group that advertised tours to "destinations your mother would rather you stayed away from". His trip to the isolated country of North Korea was fun, at first. He wanted to take home a souvenir - little di...

Betsy Faria and Pam Hupp became good friends while they worked at State Farm Insurance together. They fell out of touch, but when Betsy was diagnosed with terminal cancer they rekindled their friendship - Pam was determined to help Betsy any way she could and often drove her to and from her chemo treatments. Such was the case on December 27, 2011 - the night her husband Russ Faria would come home...

Abigail Williams and Liberty German, two middle school best friends, spent their day off from school at the Delphi Historic Trails (specifically the Monon High Bridge). The girls had no idea that their fun day out at the park was going to be their last. A mysterious man with sinister intentions appeared on the bridge behind them. In a stroke of brilliance, Libby managed to capture their attacker o...

Zack Bowen and Addie Hall’s paths crossed while working as bartenders in New Orleans. They fell head over heels for one another. Their relationship, while short, was extremely volatile. Untreated mental illness and excessive partying do not make for a harmonious pairing. Their relationship began weeks before evacuation orders were in place for Hurricane Katrina. The two decided to stay behind and...

Taunja Bennett was found dead in January of 1990. Detectives were quickly led down a path with many twists and many lies. Who is to be believed, and who killed Taunja Bennett? The truth lies much farther away than they could imagine.

On January 20th, 2022, Chandler Halderson would be found guilty of the murder and dismemberment of his parents, Bart and Krista Halderson. If you asked Bart and Krista about their son, they’d probably tell you how proud they were of him. At 23, Chandler was one credit shy of getting his degree in renewable resource engineering, was working an IT job at American Family Insurance, and had just score...

This week Mallory tells us about Lori Vallow Daybell - a Mormon woman who leaves a trail of death behind her. If that wasn't enough - she becomes a leader of a doomsday cult with her new husband, Chad. Shortly after, her 2 children vanish and the search to find them begins.

New year, new ep! Ashley traumatized herself while learning about the pervy and patriarchal cults that raised convicted sexual predator, Josh Duggar. She'll be diving deep into the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist Church (IFB), the Quiverfull Movement, and the Institute in Basic Life Principles (IBLP). Whip yourself up a mind eraser cocktail because you're going to need some brain bleach after t...

This holiday season Mallory gives us an in depth history lesson on Scientology, their beliefs, and their cycle of abuse. It's the gift that keeps on giving! Visit https://theaftermathfoundation.org/ if you or someone you know is thinking about leaving Scientology but doesn't know where to start.

"If I die, it may not be an accident, even if it looks like one" Susan wrote in her handwritten will that she hid from her sociopathic husband. 17 months later she would vanish and never be seen again. When Susan Powell married Josh Powell - she never imagined the nightmare that awaited her. Ashley tells the tragic story of Susan Powell and the wake of destruction that followed.

Ashley shares the story of Gwen Shamblin Lara and how her Christian diet program became a religious cult. Mallory tells the heart wrenching story of Yingying Zhang, a Chinese student in the US who missed a bus and changed the course of her life forever.

Mallory tells us about a strange cult with a self-destructive leader. She also does some detective work. Ashley takes us on a rollercoaster through the unbelievable events of the life of actor Johnny Lewis.