James Settlemyer

Project Skeptic

Fiction EN ↓ 231 episodes

A weekly look at the odd world we live in. Everything from missing people, ghosts, conspiracy, and everything weird going on in our world. Each episode I will have a guest on and present a story to them and see what their beliefs are on the topic. Mid week episodes on Pennsylvania local legends.

Author

James Settlemyer

Category

Fiction

Podcast website

www.facebook.com

Latest episode

Jun 24, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

MID WEEK 66: The Ogua 09.02.2023

This week on the mid week episode Jay talks The Ogua. River monsters are not a new thing to legend. They seem to pop up anywhere there is a dangerous body of water. Is this all just a fable to keep children from the dangers of water, Or is there a beast that stalks the banks of the Monongahela River? Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitc...

EP 65: False Flags, Operation Northwoods 06.02.2023

This week Rob, Andy and Jay put their tinfoil hats on channel their inner Alex Jones and talk False Flags. With everything that goes on today in the world, you would want to feel safe from your own Government. But sometimes thats not the case at all. We look at flaseflags and Operation Northwoods this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/gro...

MID WEEK 65: Doomsday Clock W/ Dr. Chris Cogswell 03.02.2023

When time is running out on the doomsday clock who is the only person you need to call. Thats right Chris Cogswell from the Mad Scientist Podcast. Jay and Chris talk doomsday clock, hotdogs, and other off beat topics this week. Might as well give it a listen because we are only 90 seconds from midnight. ENJOY!!!! Find more from Chris HERE!!! The Mad Scientist Podcast https://twitter.com/MadScienti...

EP 64: Out of Body Experience-Astral Projection 30.01.2023

This week Jay and Shoeman talk out of body and Astral Projection. Have you ever had an happening like this? Why is our minds so crazy. The mind does not help the body thats for certian. Plus we return with NSFW facts this week. Follow the Discord for all things Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv...

MID WEEK 64: Betty Knox Disappearance 26.01.2023

This week on the Mid Week we travel to Dunbar Pa. With another missing person ghost story. Why was life so hard for poor Betty Knox. What ever happened to her? What the hell is a Gristmill? All this and more this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/project_skeptic_podcast Instagram: https...

EP 63: Sleep Paralysis and The Hat Man 23.01.2023

This week Rob is back again for sleep paralysis and The Hat Man. Oh and Jay is here also. Is that shadow in the corner of the room watching you sleep? Ever have that sensation someone is watching you? Do you think Rob and Jay are meant for each other? All this and more this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch:...

MID WEEK 63: The Pig Lady of Cannelton 19.01.2023

This week on the mid week Jay changes up the format a little bit. Telling you the story first then giving an opinion afterwards. The Pig Lady of Cannelton is a surprise story from Beaver County. Legend many may not know about. A legend very popular in the town it is from. This week all spooky no kooky on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/p...

EP 62: Chowchilla Kidnapping 17.01.2023

This week Rob is back so that means its true crime week here on Project Skeptic. We look at a kidnapping so crazy it leaves alot more questions than answers. If you were named Richard would you go by Dick? Rob and Jay are answering the tough questions this week on Porject Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://www.twitch...

MID WEEK 62: Raystown Ray 13.01.2023

On this week mid week episode Jay heads to the lake for a little R&R. Just kidding, We are cryptid hunting agian this week in the largest lake in Pennsylvania, Raystown Lake. Do sea creatures really exsist? Is there one in this lake? Was the 23rd Governer of PA named Pennypacker? All this and more this week on Project Skeptic.. Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook....

EP 61: 20 and Back Space Program 10.01.2023

This week the Matts are back to another round of insane stories. We dive down the rabbit hole of the 20 and Back Space Program. Did these people really go to Mars for 20 years. Did Number One Fan Matt really poop in the ocean. Is Shoeman no longer down with the sickness. Will Jay really quit the show this week? All this and more this week on Porject Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Faceb...

MID WEEK 61: Fluoride in the Water W/ Hush Hush Society Conspiracy Hour 06.01.2023

This week it is conspiracy time. So we call in the Ringers again. Mystery Mike, Declassified Dave and Slick Fronk Sanders from the Hush Hush Society Conspiracy Hour Podcast. Water we drink it, We shower in it, we use it every day. What if the Water we are using is slowly poisoning us. Thats what we are trying to find out this week on Project Skeptic. FIND THEM HERE Hush Hush Society Conspiracy Hou...

EP 60: Strange News 02.01.2023

This week The Bumbeeno stops by and we have some odd news articles to talk about. How long does it take for you to decompose after death? Where do you properly dispose of unwanted sex dolls? Does the tide raise by feet? All this and More this week on Project Skeptic!!!! Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/projec...

MID WEEK 60: Cash Landrum Incident W/ Justin Zenger 30.12.2022

This week Jay brings in the RInger. Justin Zenger!!!! Forty Two years ago Betty Cash and Vickie Landrum experienced someting they could not explain on a highway in Texas. Was this a UFO? Were their injuries from this encounter? Does Justin know everything about Chinook Helocopters? Find out all of this on this weeks episode of Project Skeptic Find More from Justin HERE https://podcasts.apple.com/u...

EP 59: Winter Break Bonus 27.12.2022

This week Jay gives everyone the week off. We still have to provide an episode. Dig into the vault and pull out a Patreon episode for you guys. Matts at the L table episode 1 from the Patreon page. Jay, Shoeman, Number One Fan Matt, and the Bumbeeno have some interesting things to talk about. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.fa...

MID WEEK 59: Gurdon Light 21.12.2022

This week we return with out Project Skeptic Unsolved series. Co Host Andy takes control of the show for yet another head scrathing mystery the Gurdon Light. Swamp Gas is always the anwers. Murder? Why Not... Throw some of that in there too. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic. Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://w...

EP 58: Locked up Elsewhere 19.12.2022

This week Jay and Cohost Andy look at what really happens when you are detained in a Foreign country. Its probably not for the best to end up in jail in a foreign country. But with these tips and some stories to help, you should be ok. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic. Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://www.twi...

MID WEEK 58: Mishler Theatre 16.12.2022

This week on the mid-week, We travel back to Jay's Hometown to take a look at a theatre that probably without question is haunted. The Mishler Theatre turn of the century masterpiece or haunted theatre.... Probably both. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic. Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/group... Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/project_... Instagram:...

EP 57: Martians and Murder Christmas Special 13.12.2022

This week is our Christmas Special. Jay and Rob (Yes Rob is finally back) talk all sorts of strange stories. Warminster Thing and Christmas Murders are our focus this week. Plus, a story about a giant d*** on a roof. All that fun plus even more this week on Project Skeptic. Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/pr...

MID WEEK 57: Interview with Stan Gordon 08.12.2022

This week is wild!!!! We have an interview with ufo/cryptid Researcher Stan Gordon. Stan has been in the game for 63 years now and has seen a thing or three. On the episode Stan talks some of the craziest encounters I have ever heard of. Check this out guys. Plus check out his website https://www.stangordon.info/wp/ For all things weird in Pennsylvania https://www.stangordon.info/wp/ 724-838-7768...

EP 56: West Memphis Three 06.12.2022

A little bit of true crime action this week on Project Skeptic. I widely known story out of Arkansas. Three boys dead and three teenagers convicted of the murder. Did the police get this right? Were these three teenager's innocent? The Bumbeeno, Shoeman and Jay try to figure it all out this week on Project Skeptic... Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/proj...

MID WEEK 56: Johannes Kelpius 01.12.2022

Cults!!!! Everyone loves a good Cult. This week on the mid-week Jay finds a Cult from Pennsylvania dating all the way back to the 1690s. People looking for refuge in America for their own religious freedom settle into the southeastern part of the state. With a name like Johannes Kelpius what's not to love. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic!! Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook...

EP 55: Childhood Fears 28.11.2022

This week Jay, Andy, and Shoeman talk irrational childhood fears. Something as simple as spiders or heights could be a trigger for fear. There are also some more complex and strange fears like quicksand and the Bermuda Triangle. Which ones do we think are scary find out this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ Twitch:...

MID WEEK 55: Potter Nondescript / Susquehanna Seal 26.11.2022

This week on the mid-week episode we have two topics for the listeners. First, we head to Potter County with a story of a hairy bipedal creature that pounds its chest and roars at hunters. Secondly, we have water dwelling creature out of Clinton Couty. In the Susquehanna River lives a creature that no one can identify. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic. Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail....

EP 54: Prophets and Fortune Telling 22.11.2022

This week Jay and Andy talk Prophets and Fortune Telling. Might be the first time Jay doesn't believe in something. Andy takes a sort of Skeptical stance on it also. Are both of these hosts wrong? Are those goats still walking in circles? Do we ever have any answers? Find out this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/projectskeptic/ T...

MID WEEK 54: Allegheny County Prison 17.11.2022

Mid-Week Jay is back with another strange story out of Pittsburgh this time. Haunted Prisons they are a dime a dozen and I right??? We have all heard of Eastern State and Cresson State Corrections, but have you ever heard of Allegheny County Prison? Wild tales of love and murder and prison breaks. All this and more this week on Project Skeptic Email: Projectskepticpod@gmail.com Facebook: https://w...

Listen to the Project Skeptic podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.