Press Play Again: 2 Roommates, 1 Remote

Send us Fan Mail Season 2, Episode 5 leans hard into discomfort—and forces these characters to sit with feelings they’ve been carefully avoiding. In this episode, we break down the growing emotional imbalance between Dawson and Joey, the way expectations are starting to feel heavier than honesty, and how Pacey continues to exist just close enough to the truth to make everyone uneasy. On a rewatch,...

Send us Fan Mail Season 2, Episode 4 pushes everything another step forward… whether these characters are ready or not. In this episode, we unpack the emotional fallout that’s no longer simmering quietly under the surface. Dawson is struggling with expectations—his own and everyone else’s—Joey is caught between growth and guilt, and Pacey continues to say the things no one else will. On a rewatch,...

Send us Fan Mail Season 2, Episode 3 turns up the tension in Capeside, and suddenly everyone’s emotions are right on the surface… whether they’re ready for that or not. In this episode, we break down the growing cracks in Dawson and Joey’s attempts to move forward, Pacey’s increasing role as the emotional observer (and occasional truth-teller), and how this episode quietly shifts the group dynamic...

Send us Fan Mail Season 2, Episode 2 wastes  no time  reminding us that the fallout from last season is still very much alive in Capeside. In this episode, we dig into the emotional aftershocks of Dawson and Joey’s “new normal”, Pacey’s quietly complicated place in the group, and the way everyone seems to be circling their feelings instead of actually dealing with them. We talk about mixed signals...

Send us Fan Mail Season 2 kicks off with a lot to unpack. Dawson's Creek returns after the cliffhanger of the season one finale and everyone is very much AWKWARD! In this episode, we break down the Dawson and Joey kiss, Pacey's new hair, new characters, and Dawson's "famous last words". Plus, we ask the big rewatch questions: Did this episode reset the show - or crack it o...

Send us Fan Mail Season 2 kicks off with a lot to unpack. Dawson's Creek returns after the cliffhanger of the season one finale and everyone is very much AWKWARD! In this episode, we break down the Dawson and Joey kiss, Pacey's new hair, new characters, and Dawson's "famous last words". Plus, we ask the big rewatch questions: Did this episode reset the show - or crack it o...

Send us Fan Mail This is Anna's favorite Christmas movie of all time! From beginning to end it brings a wave of nostalgia and butterflies every single time! If you've never watched it, do yourself a favor and catch up on it and then listen to this episode! Merry Christmas from us at Press Play Again: 2 Roommates, 1 Remote! We are thankful for you! Thanks for listening! Follow us: @pressp...

Send us Fan Mail If you need a rundown of what to watch and what not to watch this Christmas season listen to this episode! It’s full of chaos and laughter but good info too! We reminisce and go deep with family traditions and gifts from Christmases past. You don’t want to miss it! thanks for listening! Like, comment and follow us on instagram and TikTok! @pressplayagainpod @annafitts @em_jay_gee...

Send us Fan Mail On this week's episode I have a very special guest joining me who just so happens to have some incredible insight and experience with the movie we watched. Buckle up because there's guaranteed laughter, maybe some tears, and just a little bit of judgment! This is part 1 of my conversation with my aunt, Alice Scott! Thanks for listening! Follow us on Instagram and TikTok!...

Send us Fan Mail We're kicking off our December movie lineup with "A Christmas in Tennessee - the small-town holiday romance that has everything: a struggling bakery, a big-city developer with an agenda, a town that apparently runs on charm and free cookies, and of course... a conveniently timed snowstorm. We're breaking down the predictable-but-perfect plot twists, the cookie-fuele...

Send us Fan Mail The Season 1 finale hits hard. Joey faces a massive decision that forces her to confront what she really wants - and who she really wants. Dawson finally gets a taste of clarity (or as close as Dawson can get), while Jen deals with an emotional surprise that shifts everything. It's the episode where walls come down, truths spill out, and nothing in Capeside will ever be the s...

Send us Fan Mail Capeside is hosting a beauty pageant… and somehow this turns into the emotional turning point for half the friend group. Joey signs up (yes, Joey Potter in a pageant!) which sends Dawson into a spiral he absolutely did not prepare for. Jen steps in to help, Pacey surprises everyone, and suddenly a small-town contest feels like the Super Bowl of teenage identity crises. We’re break...

Send us Fan Mail Enjoy a recap of our recent trip to Wilmington, NC - where most of our favorite shows were filmed once upon a time! Excuse the audio and extra noise in this one. We were recording outside at the infamous rivercourt from One Tree Hill. It's a public park so there are other people there and airplanes going overhead and such! Thanks for listening! Follow us on Instagram and TikT...

Send us Fan Mail It's spooky season in Capeside - or at least Dawson really wishes it was. In a full commitment to his horror-movie obsession, he plans a Friday-the-13th-themed scare night... which quickly turns into a mix of real tension, fake screams, and actual feelings nobody is ready to admit. Meanwhile, a mysterious news story has everyone questioning what's a prank and what's...

Send us Fan Mail It's double the dates and triple the drama in Capeside this week. Pacey shocks everyone by kissing Joey (yep, that Joey), while Dawson and Jen attempt to navigate the murky waters of being "just friends".  We're breaking down the flirtation, the frustration, and the painfully awkward attempts at romance that only Dawson's Creek can deliver. Because in Cape...

Send us Fan Mail The guys hit the road, the girls stay home, and absolutely no one handles their feelings well. Dawson joins Pacey and Billy for a road trip that's supposed to help him move on from Jen... but of course, it just makes things messier. Meanwhile, Joey and Jen have a surprisingly honest heart-to-heart back in Capeside. We're talking bad decisions, awkward encounters, and all...

Send us Fan Mail Megan finally likes one!!!  Jen's NY boyfriend surprises everyone including us. Why couldn't he come in and date "Tammy"? He looks old enough at least! We start to finally breathe and relax because Pacey is back to his self and being a protective friend!! Our ratings definitely favor this episode! ENJOY! Thanks for listening! Follow us on Instagram and TikTok:...

Send us Fan Mail Anna loved this one. Megan did not. What's new? ;) The gang all land themselves in detention. With a breakfast club vibe, everyone gets real messy in this one. Find out which scenes made us laugh, roll our eyes, and get real fired up about real life situations. Thanks for listening! Follow us on Instagram and TikTok. @pressplayagainpod @annafitts @em_jay_gee Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Pacey & Tamara are finally DONE! Grams & Bessie are finally in the same room together peacefully....sort of. Dawson is finally a good friend who listens!! Find out how we really feel about each of these storylines and what we are looking forward to in the next episodes. -Press Play Again: 2 Roommates, 1 Remote Follow us on TikTok and Instagram! Leave a comment and rating!...

Send us Fan Mail This one is.... dramatic!! Anna has a major life regret. Megan gave this one a high review in her book. The character's secrets are being revealed and PTL! Favorite quotes, red flags, movie references, reviews and so much more - Dawson's Creek is THAT show! Follow us on Instagram, Spotify, Apple Podasts, etc! @pressplayagainpod @annafitts @em_jay_gee Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Part 2 of all of the drama! Dawson discovers his mom is having an affair. The ladies in his life have fallen from grace. And he adds another red flag to his resume! Press Play Again  Follow us on instagram and leave a comment! @pressplayagainpod @annafitts @em_jay_gee Support the show

Send us Fan Mail This episode was so full of secrets being exposed and character reactions + our reactions that we had to break it into 2 separate parts. Follow so you don't miss Part 2!! Press Play Again :)  Follow us on Instagram and leave us a comment! @pressplayagainpod @annafitts @em_jay_gee Support the show

Send us Fan Mail This episode was definitely a step up for us both - mainly because it didn't focus on Dawson!! We met some new characters - Anderson and Debra - and we continue to be disgusted by the teacher/student storyline. Buuuuttt Pacey is so darn lovable!! We disagree on one thing this episode though - is Pacey showing aggression or love?  Press Play Again!! Follow us on Instagram! @pr...

Send us Fan Mail We are back with another recap of our favorite show to critique... for now! There's so much to discuss in this one - like, Anna and Megan's favorite snow day food, Scott Foley's dance moves, Dawson's kissing technique, and Pacey's.... teacher. In this one we have a special guest review at the end that you do not want to miss! Press Play Again as we tackle...

Send us Fan Mail This episode was.... cringey to say the least!  Dawson is self-absorbed. Joey is NOT in love. Jen is just there. Pacey is a twerp. That's right... we're recapping the pilot of Dawson's Creek!  Anna and Megan remember some pretty awkward dates from high school and some from more recent years! Find out which scene made Anna want to throw up and which one made Megan qu...