Practically Pastoring
Practical(ly) Pastoring
A podcast by pastors for pastors who want to share ideas, become better shepherds and have a good time with friends.
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: practicallypastoring.com
Author
Practically Pastoring
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 18, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
You’re Not Their On-Demand Pastor: Healthy Access and Expectations 02.02.2026 43:35
In this episode, the guys tackle two real-life ministry situations pastors face all the time: 1) What do you do with the church member who constantly needs your attention—daily messages, constant crises, and an emotional drain that starts affecting your ministry and your family? 2) What do you say to the person preaching their very first sermon who feels unqualified, nervous, and unsure where to s...
When the Old Guard Won’t Quit (and the Bi-Vocational Burnout Dilemma) 28.01.2026 29:12
Welcome back to Practically Pastoring. In this episode, we pull two real questions from Reddit and get painfully practical. Question 1: A rural Methodist pastor has seen real growth, but the “old guard” is wearing him down with constant complaints and unreasonable expectations. Question 2: A bi-vocational pastor/CTO is overloaded and torn between an IT master’s (paid for by work) and a doctorate i...
Frank & Tim talk church planting and a building project. 19.01.2026 41:00
In this episode, the guys flip the script and interview Frank and Tim. Part 1: Frank gives a real-time update on the Cross & Crown Church plant (what’s working, what’s hard, what’s next, and the hunt for a launch location).Part 2: Tim walks through what it’s actually like for a sending church to release a pastor and dozens of people, while also preparing for a major vision campaign and buildin...
2026 Church Forecast: What We’re Doubling Down On & What We’re Cutting 12.01.2026 59:10
In this episode, Frank, Andrew, Jeff, and Delmar talk about the real pressure points we are feeling heading into 2026, what ministry plays are losing traction, and what we’re personally changing so we can last for the long haul (without burning out our people or ourselves).Timestamps 00:00 — Welcome back + New Year banter (and the great “koozie vs cozy” debate)01:49 — Q1: Biggest pressure point in...
The Christmas Worship Wars: Advent, Carols, and Congregational Nostalgia 15.12.2025 34:32
Is Advent a Catholic tradition, or just a really old Christian rhythm we forgot existed? In this Advent themed episode, we answer two real pastor questions: “Is Advent a Catholic tradition? Will this cause issues in a Baptist church?” “Do you sing Christmas carols during Advent, or wait until Christmas Eve?” (Also, why is this guy getting ambushed in elder meetings?) We talk history, Baptist bagg...
At-the-Movies, Sabbath Sundays, & Bad Church Coffee?! 07.12.2025 1:01:38
Welcome to the Practically Pastoring Hot Takes Episode — the one where we unintentionally roast half of evangelicalism and guarantee Andrew never gets invited to another conference again. From At-the-Movies sermons, to canceling church the Sunday after Christmas, to whether bad coffee means you hate visitors… this might be the most unhinged—and honest—episode we’ve ever recorded.  Grab your headp...
A pastor caught doing WHAT in his Office?! 24.11.2025 45:09
Today’s episode starts innocently enough with a simple question about office hours ……and ends with one of the wildest Reddit pastor stories we’ve EVER read . We’re talking:• Should pastors still keep traditional office hours?• How do you stay available without being chained to a church building?• Where do you meet people for confidential conversations?• How do you build culture when your staff is...
Recycling Sermons, Disgruntled Members, and Why Bacon Still Works for Men’s Ministry 09.11.2025 41:58
In this episode of the Practically Pastoring Podcast, the guys tackle some of the real parts of church leadership — like how to respond when disgruntled members try to recruit others, whether it’s okay to reuse old sermons, and what actually works for men’s and women’s ministry events. Practically Pastoring Conference 2026 — February 9–11, 2026 in sunny Florida! 🌴 It’s three days of real conversa...
Not Every “Pastor” Should Have the Title 27.10.2025 49:39
It’s Pastor Appreciation Month — but how should churches actually handle it? This week, the guys get honest about recognizing pastors, the misuse of the “pastor” title, developing small group leaders, and what to do when you’re burned out and ready to quit ministry. ⏱️ Timestamps 00:00 — Cold Open: Pastor Appreciation Month is weird 00:51 — Should churches only honor the lead pastor? 03:35 — How d...
Oil, MLMs, and Continuing Ed: Mailbag Episode 20.10.2025 51:23
Pastors’ mailbag time. We tackle anointing with oil in James 5, where the ethical lines are with MLMs in church life, and smart ways to use continuing-ed budgets without wasting a dollar. Chapters00:00 Cold Open + Intro01:10 Mailbag Setup: today’s questions03:00 Anointing with Oil (James 5): theology and practice19:30 When/How to anoint during services24:45 MLMs in Church: boundaries, policies, an...
Mike Gunn on Missions, Church Planting, and the Christian Nationalism Trap 13.10.2025 33:32
Mike Gunn (Antioch Initiative) joins us to talk about why mission beats brand, how American churches can learn from the global church, and why Christian Nationalism is a distraction from the gospel. He shares a simple Acts 14 pattern for church planting and a call to recover an Acts 13 sending culture. Chapters 00:00 - Intro & Mike’s background (Acts 29, Antioch Initiative) 00:54 - Should ever...
An Honest Conversation with Honest Youth Pastor 06.10.2025 1:02:17
What makes a faithful sermon ? Is it verse-by-verse exposition, topical teaching, or something deeper? In this episode of Practically Pastoring, Frank sits down with Michael Moore. A bi-vocational pastor and the creator behind Honest Youth Pastor. We talk about sermon prep, youth ministry curriculum, and the role of AI in preaching. Michael shares his framework for sermon reviews, how pastors shou...
Cowards & Crowds: Pastoring After the Charlie Kirk Assassination 29.09.2025 43:54
In this episode of Practically Pastoring , Frank, Jeff, Delmar, Andrew, and Tim tackle two big conversations pastors are facing: 1️⃣ Should a pastor’s faithfulness be judged by whether or not they mentioned Charlie Kirk’s assassination from the pulpit? 2️⃣ How should we shepherd well in a season where church attendance is spiking, with many calling it a revival? We’ll talk honestly about pastoral...
Satanic Deli to Doctor Jeans: Processing Criticism in Ministry 31.08.2025 52:14
Every pastor knows the sting of criticism — sometimes it’s helpful, sometimes it’s ridiculous, and sometimes it’s downright harmful. In this episode, the Practically Pastoring crew share their wildest stories (yes, including “The Devil’s Deli”), break down the three buckets of feedback (helpful, misinformed, and harmful), and offer practical ways to filter feedback without losing your sanity. Whet...
Church Safety Without Losing Church Hospitality: An Interview with Church Safety Expert Jim Howard 25.08.2025 43:37
How can churches take safety seriously without losing the heart of hospitality? In this episode of Practically Pastoring , Frank and Tim sit down with Jim Howard , Executive Director of Trinity Security Allies . With 38 years in law enforcement and years of experience training churches across the country, Jim explains why safety is a ministry — not just a security detail. From handling nervous vis...
Your Church’s Fall Calendar Is Probably Failing You 18.08.2025 48:37
Fall ministry is here — but is your church ready? In this episode of Practically Pastoring , we share practical church leadership tips to help pastors and ministry leaders plan fall ministry events , reengage volunteers after summer , prepare a church budget , and communicate vision effectively . Frank, Andrew, Tim, Jeff, and Delmar break down what they’re doing to set their churches up for a succ...
Practically Pastoring Q & A 02.06.2025 49:57
In this special Q&A episode, the Practically Pastoring crew tackles your questions! From favorite sermon prep playlists to the hard lessons of leadership, this one has laughs, insights, and a dose of raw honesty. We even talk about firing staff, shifting theological views, and how not to burn out your best volunteers. ⏱️ Timestamps: 0:00 - Summer break & podcast intro 2:00 - Church merch &...
How to Leave a Church Without Burning Bridges 26.05.2025 19:51
Leaving a church, especially when you're in leadership, is never easy. In this episode, the guys dive into how to discern when it's time to leave, how to exit with grace, and how to care well for the people you're leaving behind. Timestamps: 00:00 – Intro and welcome 01:10 – Sponsor: Church Merch 02:10 – Reddit Post: Youth Pastor Seeking Exit Advice 03:20 – When church leadership dysfu...
Why No One Signs Up at Your Church Anymore 19.05.2025 37:16
This week on Practically Pastoring, we’re talking about one of the most frustrating parts of church leadership: getting people to sign up for stuff! From event planning woes to generational divides, we’re diving deep into why people avoid sign-up sheets and how pastors can adapt and lead with wisdom and grace. ⏰ Timestamps: 00:00 - Intro & Topic Setup 01:15 - Listener Question from Reddit 03:...
When Long-Time Volunteers Hurt Your Church 12.05.2025 29:47
In this episode, the Practically Pastoring crew tackles a tough but necessary topic: what do you do when a long-time volunteer is actually causing harm in your ministry? From nursery drama to worship team woes, the guys share practical advice on how to set clear expectations, implement safe church policies, and have those difficult conversations with grace and firmness. ⏱️ Timestamps: 00:00 - Intr...
I’m the Pastor… But I Wouldn’t Attend My Church 05.05.2025 31:53
In this episode of Practically Pastoring, we tackle a brutally honest question from a young pastor on Reddit: “What do I do when the church I pastor isn’t one I would even attend?” If you’ve ever found yourself disillusioned in church leadership, unsure how to lead change without blowing things up, or just feeling like a glorified chaplain instead of a visionary leader—this conversation is for you...
Cynicism in the Church: Props, Scandals, and Broken Trust 28.04.2025 34:02
In this episode of Practically Pastoring, Frank, Jeff, Delmar, Andrew, and Timothy dive deep into the growing cynicism toward the evangelical church. From meme accounts like Pastors with Props to heartbreaking scandals, distrust in church leadership is only getting worse. We also discuss the solution of faithfulness over time, the importance of authenticity, and how to shepherd hurting people who...
From Hype to Monday: Navigating Post-Easter Ministry 21.04.2025 43:43
In this episode of Practically Pastoring , the crew debriefs Easter Sunday. What went well? What went sideways? And how do you lead through the Super Bowl of church services without losing your soul (or your voice)? Plus, we get into: The emotional and logistical pressure pastors face on Easter Whether small churches should try to “compete” with bigger ones Why WrestleMania made it into our Sunday...
This One Mistake Could Disqualify You from Ministry 08.04.2025 50:42
In this episode of Practically Pastoring, the guys dive into two hot-button topics every pastor needs to wrestle with: 👉 A youth pastor crosses several boundaries—what should happen next? Is it just unwise... or something worse? 👉 Can church staff with different political views work together? What does unity look like when red hats and blue hair share the same ministry? ⏱️ Timestamps: 00:00 – In...
Should Teen Moms Bring Their Babies to Youth Group? 31.03.2025 39:08
In this episode of the Practically Pastoring Podcast , the crew dives into two HUGE topics in church leadership and youth ministry: 1️⃣ What should churches do when a teenage girl wants to bring her newborn baby to youth group ? 2️⃣ Should we finally kill off the paper bulletin and go fully digital? We unpack the pastoral heart behind pro-life ministry, how to care well for young moms, the messine...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.