Erin Sexton

My Skeptical Sister

Comedy EN ↓ 295 episodes

They look alike, they talk alike, they even live across the street from one another. But when it comes to the debate over the paranormal, these two sisters couldn’t be more opposite. Listen in, while one sister tries to convince the other that ghosts do, in fact, exist. They may never get to the bottom of the truth, but they’ll sure laugh a lot while trying.

Author

Erin Sexton

Category

Comedy

Latest episode

Jul 6, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

19. Sent Chills To My Hoo-Ha 02.04.2021

Join us this week for a fascinating story about a boondocks Bermuda Triangle! Also, the sisters have quite a bit to say about an evil man who’s bad deeds didn’t stop at death. Get ready for this one y’all, these stories might even send chills to your hoo-ha! Trigger warning: a case of domestic violence is described in the second story during this episode. Find us on Instargram @myskepticalsister ,...

18. I’ll Lick Your Nose 26.03.2021

The sisters find something they both might be open to...a time slip! Join us for stories about a familiar haunted house, a ghost in shackles, and a haunted restaurant!!

17.5. Oops!! 20.03.2021

Exhaustion and editing don’t mix. After releasing Everywhere You Go, Someone Has Died There, we realized a chunk was missing. I rereleased the second story only from that episode to include the scariest part that was left out. Sorry!!

17. Everywhere You Go, Someone Has Died There 19.03.2021

The sisters get a little emotional as they read a beautiful love story that reaches beyond the afterlife. Then it’s right back to being terrified as they try to determine which is scarier...the living or the dead. Join us for this rollercoaster ride of an episode!

16. Ya Gonna Die 15.03.2021

The Witch, The Wolf and The Unwelcomed...need we say more? Well, how about we add into the mix the haunted, Louisville landmark, The Palace Theater for a little extra terror this week! This might be our spookiest episode yet, but don’t worry, we find time to fit a few laughs in as always!!! *Fan Favorite: Raichelle King.  Visit her page at Facebook.com/mermadebyrai to see her custom shirts and tum...

Coffee and Cryptids #2 - Pope Lick Monster 09.03.2021

Grab a cup of joe (add some Bailey's if you like) and join us for our second bonus episode of Coffee and Cryptids! The sisters sit down with author and folklorist David Domine to discuss the Pope Lick Monster and the lesser known cryptid the Demon Leaper! Would you dare to cross the railroad trestle where the hypnotic Goatman performs his trickery? The sisters are down...well Meghann is!

15. Baby Footprints...HUMAN BABY FOOTPRINTS?!?! 05.03.2021

A sexy farmer ghost, Erin’s famous ghost story told by her counterpart’s perspective, either a baby spirit who leaves their mark or an elaborate prank...you be the judge! Oh and Meghann accidentally gets a lil drunky, but shhh don’t tell anybody! * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/ Twitter: @myskepticalsis1 * Promos:...

14. Oooo, That Gave Me Cold Chills! 26.02.2021

The sisters share a story about a haunted vineyard in NJ, a spooky old-man ghost named Charlie, and their own thoughts on why it is ok to still wear skinny jeans and sport a side part...mind your business Gen Z!  * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1815118528659892/  Twitter: @myskepticalsis1  * Promos: Hunts Memorial Glass @ https:/...

13. Foghorn Leghorn 19.02.2021

This week the sisters share stories of unexplained musical hauntings, a wild account of medium readings and a hair raising haunted hotel! And, Meghann finally shares her personal ghost stories that even she needs help debunking!

Coffee and Cryptids #1- Kelly Green Men 16.02.2021

Kelly Little Green Men Day Festival, 3rd weekend in August. Thanks to our good friend Brook Jung, the executive director of Visit Hopkinsville. https://www.visithopkinsville.com/

12. I Regret It All 12.02.2021

Basements that will scare you so much you’ll need the hysteria slapped out of you, haunted offices spaces, and an update from episode 3-the beast in the woods...from a different perspective! Join the sisters as they laugh their way through all these spooky stories and more!

11. Now Hiring Psychics, You Know Where to Apply 05.02.2021

Join us for hair raising stories that will have even the skeptics wondering, except for Meghann...she is staying true to her skeptic self! Also, we’ve added a new segment where we highlight one MSS fan, listen in to see if it is you this week!

10. Skitters 29.01.2021

Join us this week for an anthology of badass women who ain’t afraid of no ghosts (or possible intruders)! One of which, is our own badass mom! Momma Clem makes a special surprise debut and tells us one of her classics!

9. The Ghost of Mary Poppins? 22.01.2021

A mind blowing reincarnation story, haunted baby monitors, the cause of the Great Flood in ‘97, reiki and a personal demon. The sisters cover it all and pronounce all words correctly...well almost...we are still us!

8. Harangue Again! 15.01.2021

We get a bonus story in this week's episode! Plus, the sisters stumble over their words yet again as we tell you about some spooky haunts!

7. Paranormal Prudes 08.01.2021

Who knew the afterlife could be filled with such judgment.  The sisters read some spooky stories about the Stanley Hotel and a variety of spooky stories from one listener. 

5. The Cat Came Back 24.12.2020

We decided to release this one early since it’s the holidays! Merry Christmas or Happy Holidays to all!! The sisters discuss Civil War haunts and spooky haunted houses.   Our comprehension (or lack there of) of the English language is yet again evident in this episode.  Skirmish and scrimmage are not the same thing as Erin discovered after recording.  Apparently we were feeling festive this time o...

4. What the heck is an egg tooth? 18.12.2020

Our super fans/super friends wrote in this week to tell some touching stories that even Meghann has a hard time debunking.  With a bonus spook that has a photo to prove it! Don't forget to send your ghost stories in to myskepticalsister@gmail.com.  We need your stories!! 

3. Bipedal Boppity Boo! 11.12.2020

Turns out, that story WAS scary AF!  Listen this week as we hear about a spooky story in the woods, and some eerie premonitions...

1. Probably a Sasquatch 27.11.2020

Sasquatch or ghost? My sister, the skeptic, only believes in what she can prove...so naturally, it must be a squatch, while I full on believe in ghosts! Join us as we read two listener's ghost (or squatch) stories and debate the truth of the matter.   P.S. Skeptic Sister speaking- it might not be a Sasquatch....it could totally be the Chupacabra!!

Listen to the My Skeptical Sister podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.