My Skeptical Sister

Explosion or UFO? Portal or shape shifter? Nicholas Cage, with or without a mullet? So many questions to be debated this week on My Skeptical Sister! Our Fan Favorite this week is Natalie.  Check out her pup's instagram at @BobVonLongDog and consider donating to your local animal shelter. Please remember to Rate, Review and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify.  If you would like to write in, fi...

Self discovery has been a fun part of this podcast, this week Erin discovers she has the hots for 50 Cent, while Meghann discovers judging a book by it’s cover might be a good idea! Oh yeah…and they read two really good, really spooky stories!!! Our Fan Favorite this week is Andrea.  If you would like to support their small business of handmade bound journals, go to www.coffeewithandrea.com Please...

Do ghosts have the power to make themselves seen or are they just present to those who are more sensitive? If past lives exist, do we travel with the same souls or do souls meet again randomly? Listen to the sisters laugh their way to their own conclusions! We also get a heartfelt story that is too good to debunk. Our Fan Favorite this week is Billi Jo.  If you would like to support their cause, g...

The sisters share a story that have them questioning all their prior knowledge of the grim reaper. The only thing that isn’t questionable is how creepy this story is! Buckle up skeptics and believers, we are getting visited by the hooded man with the scythe! Our Fan Favorite this week is Sandi.  If you are interested in visitng the McHenry SummerFest, you can find details at https://www.facebook.c...

One UFO in a night is rare…but three has the sisters wondering if Meghann has lost her skeptical touch! Tune in this week to see if she is able to pull out a debunk! Our Fan Favorite this week is Becky.  If you would like to support their cause, go to www.cancer.org. Please remember to Rate, Review and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify.  If you would like to write in, find us on patreon, buy...

Do a group of college kids have an unwelcomed supernatural roommate, or a series of spooky coincidences? Is it possible for a character in a horror film to haunt someone in real life? The sisters might not have the answers, but they sure have fun trying to figure it all out! Our Fan Favorite this week is Charlie.  If you would like to support their cause, go to Please remember to Rate, Review and...

This week we hear more stories from the infamous house on Eastern Parkway from a new perspective. And it seems Erin isn’t the only one who can’t believe Meghann isn’t a believer at heart. Our Fan Favorite this week is Anna.  If you would like to support their cause, go to canuckplace.org/healthandsafty/  Please remember to Rate, Review and Subscribe on Apple Podcast and Spotify.  If you would like...

This week’s stories have the sisters taking a walk down memory lane, Ellie pays tribute to the lovely Betty White and of course Meghann invents a new word! Our Fan Favorite this week is Sonja.  If you would like to donate to her cause, The Human Rights Campaign Fund, visit the website at www.hrc.org.  Please remember to Rate, Review and Subscribe on Apple Podcast.  If you would like to write in, f...

Does your community have a local Psychic/Spiritualist group? If they did, would you be willing to go check it out?! Tune in this week to hear one listener’s wild experience and how it has the sisters agreeing on one thing for sure…a trip to their local Psychic/Spiritualist group has to happen stat! Our Fan Favorite this week is Preston.  If you would like to see her beautiful cookies and support h...

The stories this week leave the sisters with unanswered questions and a mysterious phone call….from beyond? Our Fan Favorite this week is Sam.  If you would like to help support her cause, please visit; www.staaroc.org.  If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social...

This week, Meghann gets some help debunking spirits from a listener, who is ironically a believer. Tune in to hear how Erin reacts to this “official” debunk! This past week, Kentucky was hit hard by tornados.  If you would like to donate to the relief fund, you can donate at https://secure.kentucky.gov/formservices/Finance/WKYRelief  We have the people of Western Kentucky, and everyone who was imp...

Can spirits talk to us through dreams? Can Ouija boards be used for good? Can the believer convince the skeptic? Tune in this week to find out these answers and of course some ridiculous banter with the sisters! Our fan favorite this week is Danni.  If you would like to support her cause, shop local and small business this holiday season!   If you would like to help support our podcast, you can be...

Join us, we have so much fun! 

Three things can happen when an 18th century farm house is involved, and only one of those things ends happily! Get ready to get the chills, this week the sisters get spooky! Our Fan Favorite is Hannah this week.  If you would like to help support her awesome cause, go to www.teacherstreasures.org  If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon....

Are our stories spooky this week? Yes! Are we also the tangent queens? Definitely! If you like a good story, spooky or otherwise, you’ve come to the right place! Happy Thanksgiving everyone, the sisters are so very grateful for each and every one of you! Our Fan Favorite this week is Krystal.  Be sure to check out her podcast called Serialholic Sisters.  If you would like to help support our podca...

In honor of their one year anniversary the sisters do a little time traveling right back to the start of the pandemic. Join the sisters as they realize why they started this podcast in the first place and why potent potables and quarantine are a fabulous mix! Our Fan Favorite this week is Jeanette.  If you would like to support her chosen charity, go to https://hiphopcares.org/ If you would like t...

If you saw a horned creature with legs like a goat and a lions mane, wouldn’t you try to catch it? Find out which sister would, in this week’s episode of My Skeptical Sister! Our Fan Favorite this week is Keith.  If you would like to help support his amazing cause for LGBT+ go to http://www.rainbowrailroad.org/take-action If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on h...

Old photos found in a wall sound like a dream come true, but in this week’s story they have a sinister twist! And you might be surprised to find out what Meghann thinks she believes about poltergeists! Our Fan Favorite this week is Norma.  If you would like to support her cause, please visit https://www.alz.org/ in honor of her sweet mother.  If you would like to help support our podcast, you can...

When it comes to the topic of reincarnation, the sisters see eyes to eye; the concept is…fascinating! Tune in to find out if Erin gets brave enough to bust out the ol’ Ouija board for our Halloween episode! Our fan favorite this week is Brooke!  If you would like to help support her amazing cause to help senior dogs, please visit https://olddoghaven.org/ If you would like to help support our podca...

Join the sisters for spooky stories this week! Also, the sisters have an exciting announcement and a gift from a fan that has Meghann excited and Erin freaked out! If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskept...

Erin proclaims that this week’s story might be our creepiest yet! Also, reincarnation, what a lovely concept! Tune in this week to find out what the sisters plan on coming back as! Our fan favorite this week is Shelley.  If you would like to donate to the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation go to cff.org.  If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.c...

Join the sisters this week as they speculate about a possible doppelgänger, the physics of flying hangers and a moving box that even has the skeptical one stumped! Our Fan Favorite this week is Maddie.  If you would like to help out with hurricane relief down south, please visit the Bayou Recovery Fund at bayoucf.org If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here h...

A skulking security guard has the sisters debating once again! Listen in as they laugh their way through this week’s stories of spooks, creepy cats and visions of lumberjacks! Our fan favorite this week is Sage!  Please follow them on TikTok at http://vm.tiktok.com/ZMdms6eYw/  If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And...

If you weren’t freaked out enough by the first round of sleep paralysis stories, the sisters gathered a batch this week that will surely do the trick! https://www.etsy.com/shop/FeelingTheMoonlight Check out Malinda’s awesome Etsy page! Thank you Malinda for being this week’s Fan Favorite and your continued support!!! If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here h...

UFO’s, possessions and haunts oh my! The stories this week have it all! Join the sisters for this wild ride! If you would like to help support our podcast, you can become a patreon on here https://www.patreon.com/join/4585195? And join us for fun monthly movie nights! Follow us on social media at: * Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/myskepticalsister/  Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/...