Murder, Not Murdering

This episode delves into the infamous Career Girl's Murder case of 1963, where two young women, Janice Wiley and Emily Hoffert, were brutally murdered in New York City. The investigation led to the wrongful conviction of George Whitmore Jr., who was coerced into confessing to the crime he did not commit. The real killer, Richard Robles, was eventually apprehended, but the case highlighted signific...

In this episode, Erin delves into the chilling case of Angela and James Craig, exploring the betrayal and deception that led to Angela's tragic death by poisoning. The narrative unfolds from the initial symptoms Angela experienced to the shocking discovery of James's calculated actions and the subsequent investigation that revealed his guilt. The episode culminates in the trial, where the evidence...

In this episode, Erin and Autumn welcome Tim, a registered nurse, to discuss the dark side of nursing through the cases of Niels Högel and Charles Cullen, both male nurses who committed heinous crimes. The conversation explores the motivations behind their actions, the failures of hospital systems to protect patients, and the emotional toll on healthcare professionals. The hosts emphasize the impo...

In this episode, Erin and Autumn discuss various topics, including their recent viral event announcement, the upcoming guest Nurse Tim, and the chilling case of the Doodler, a serial killer from the 1970s. Then they delve into the tragic story of Grace Brown and Chester Gillette, exploring themes of love, betrayal, and societal pressures that led to a murder that shocked the community. The episode...

Erin dives into the chilling story of Louise Peete, a woman whose charm masked a sinister motive. This episode unravels the shocking crimes and multiple murders she committed and the gripping trial that captivated the nation. Discover how Peete's manipulative nature led to a series of tragic events, and explore the courtroom drama that ultimately sealed her fate. Join us as we delve into one of th...

In this episode of 'Murder Not Murdering', hosts Erin and Autumn explore two harrowing true crime stories. The first part delves into the tragic 1914 massacre at Taliesin, the home of renowned architect Frank Lloyd Wright, where Mamah Borthwick and her children were brutally murdered. The second part shifts to the chilling case of Philip Markoff, the Craigslist Killer, who led a double life as a m...

Summary In this episode of 'Murder Not Murdering,' hosts Erin and Autumn discuss the impact of climate change on their local weather, share personal anecdotes, and delve into two haunting murder cases: the Bumblebee Road Murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrieri, and the unsolved mystery of Hazel Irene Drew. The conversation explores the emotional weight of these stories, the challenges of in...

This episode delves into two gripping true crime cases: the murder of Ruth Cruger and the case of Ethel Kidd. The hosts discuss the importance of focusing on the victims and the relentless pursuit of justice by women like Mary Grace Humiston, who solved Ruth's murder. They explore the chilling details of both cases, the societal attitudes towards missing persons, and the impact of media in solving...

Summary In this episode of 'Murder Not Murdering,' hosts Autumn and Erin delve into two gripping true crime cases: the tragic murder of LaNell Barsock, followed by the cold case of Betty Elaine Minnis. The conversation explores the complexities of each case, the societal implications, and the emotional toll on the families involved, while also highlighting the importance of justice and the pursuit...

In this episode of 'Murder Not Murdering,' hosts Autumn and Erin discuss two compelling cases: the crime spree of Iron Irene and the mysterious disappearance of Maura Murray. They explore the complexities of each case, including the societal context of the Great Depression and the ongoing search for answers in Maura's case. The conversation highlights the emotional weight of these stories and the...

Summary In this episode, Erin and Autumn discuss two intriguing cases: the disappearance of Jodie Huisentruit, a news anchor who vanished in 1995, and the Halls Mills Affair, a scandalous murder case from 1922 involving a reverend and his lover. They explore the details of each case, the investigations that followed, and the societal implications of these crimes. The conversation highlights the on...

Erin and Autumn delve into two true crime cases: the chilling story of Alfred Rouse, who attempted to fake his death through murder, and the tragic disappearance of Wendy Lorraine Camp and her family, highlighting the complexities of family dynamics and the failures of the legal system. The episode concludes with a discussion on the unresolved aspects of both cases and the emotional weight they ca...

In this episode of 'Murder, Not Murdering,' hosts Erin and Autumn discuss the profound impact of storytelling within the LGBTQIA+ community, highlighting the tragic case of Teresa Butts and Jennifer Hopper, and the subsequent journey of healing and forgiveness undertaken by Jennifer. The conversation then shifts to the historical context of the 1920 Harvard Secret Court, a covert tribunal that exp...

On Christmas Day 1988, the body of 23-year-old Venus Xtravaganza was discovered hidden beneath a bed in a New York City hotel room. She had been strangled days earlier—and over three decades later, her killer has never been found. Venus was a transgender performer and a rising star in the ballroom scene, immortalized in the landmark documentary Paris Is Burning. But behind her dazzling stage prese...

This week, Erin dives into one of New York City's most shocking Gilded Age crimes- the gruesome torso murder that filled the headlines: a barber, a midwife, and a bathtub full of secrets. Then, Autumn unpacks the chilling true story that inspired the movie Jeepers Creepers: the Dennis and Marilyn DePue case, a real-life horror mystery eerily connected to Unsolved Mysteries. If you love historical...

In this week’s episode, Autumn dives into the mysterious 1999 disappearance of Wil Hendrick from Moscow, Idaho—vanished without a trace. Then Erin takes us back to 19th-century Edinburgh for the dark and deadly story of Burke and Hare: the body snatchers who didn’t wait for their victims to die.

Erin dives into the scandalous story of Minnie Wallace Walkup Ketcham- a southern beauty whose charm sparked obsession, stirred doubt, and may have led to murder.

In this gripping episode of Murder, Not Murdering, we dive into two haunting true crime cases from the Pacific Northwest. Autumn shares the heartbreaking story of Teekah Lewis, a 2-year-old girl who vanished from a Tacoma bowling alley in 1999 — a case that continues to haunt her to this day. Then Erin unpacks the wild life and shocking end of Frank “Sharkey” Hinkley, the man who opened Seattle’s...

In this gripping true crime episode, Erin uncovers the bizarre kidnapping case of 1950s Hollywood starlet Marie McDonald and the shocking scandal that followed. Then, Autumn dives into the chilling story of Laura Black, a 1980s tale of obsession and workplace stalking that inspired a TV movie. Tune in for two unforgettable cases of fame, fear, and fatal attraction.

In this week's intriguing podcast episode, Autumn delves into the chilling story of John List, the man who erased himself and left behind devastation. Meanwhile, Erin uncovers a bizarre tale of love and confinement—an attic home to dark secrets for over ten years. What drives someone to such extremes? Join us as we explore these captivating narratives filled with mystery and suspense. You won't wa...

This week, tune in as Erin uncovers a captivating case that stretches over 65 years, featuring the notorious Sharon Kinne and her shocking past. Meanwhile, Autumn dives into the chilling Elizabeth Barlow case – the first known instance of murder by insulin injection. Don’t miss these gripping stories that remind us how true crime can hit close to home.

Dive into today's episode where Autumn unravels a chilling local murder entwined with real estate, a possible hitman, and layers of intrigue. Then Erin shares a gripping tale of how a loyal dog became key to solving the mystery of a woman's tragic death in her own home. Prepare for suspense and unexpected twists!

🔍🃏 Ever heard of a deck of cards cracking a cold case? In this hair-raising minisode, Erin dives into an incredible story that unravels a murder mystery from over 30 years ago! Tune in to discover how something seemingly ordinary became the key to justice. We can’t wait for you to hear it! New cases drop every Monday—stay tuned for more intriguing stories!

This week marks our 50th episode! Discover the chilling story of Tim Molnar's 1,000 mile disappearance and the eerie tale of room 1046 where identities blur and questions abound.

Happy St. Patrick's Day! Dive into a world of Irish intrigue with Erin as she unravels folklore, fairies, and the chilling murder of Bridget Cleary. Then, listen to Autumn share the tragic unsolved mystery of Rachel Hurley.