Tracy Preston

Malice in the Mitten

Three Michigan shows, one voice. Malice in the Mitten - Michigan-Focused True Crime. Round Robin - Upbeat round-table talk. F-Bomb - Michigan folklore and frightsNew episodes every Monday, Wednesday & Friday

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.maliceinthemitten.com

Author

Tracy Preston

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

www.maliceinthemitten.com

Latest episode

Nov 16, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

S14 E15 - Four Teenagers. Three Days. And a Story That Changed 16.11.2026

In March 1997, three teenage girls—Mindee Kalka, Aleisha Belcher, and Rachelle Goodwin—were gunned down outside a home on Waterman Street in Southwest Detroit. Police initially described a gang-related attack involving multiple gunmen and a fleeing vehicle. But later, the story changed. Mindee's boyfriend, Lorenzo Shelton III, was named as the killer—and just three days after the girls' murders, L...

S14 E14 - F-Bomb - 25,000 Eels - A Stolen Soul - The Legends of Goguac Lake 13.11.2026

What lurks beneath Goguac Lake in Battle Creek, Michigan? For more than a century, this seemingly ordinary lake has inspired stories of mysterious creatures, giant eels, a hidden underground passage to the Kalamazoo River, and even a bizarre nineteenth-century tale involving a stolen soul. But one incredible part of the legend is documented fact: Michigan fisheries records show that 25,000 America...

S14 E13 - He Knew they Were Coming - The Chesaning Murder - The Body in the Burning Barn 09.11.2026

In September 1876, Chesaning farmer Charles Smith was found horribly burned inside the ruins of his barn. His wife claimed he'd entered the burning building—but investigators concluded Charles had been murdered inside his own home and his body carried to the barn. Former farmhand Norris Alexander confessed, four people were convicted, and two received life sentences. Then years later, reports emer...

S14 E12 - F-Bomb - Avenger Red - The Fighter Jet That Vanished Over Lake Superior 06.11.2026

On November 23, 1953, a U.S. Air Force F-89C Scorpion known as Avenger Red took off from Kinross Air Force Base in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula to intercept an unidentified radar target over Lake Superior. Thirty-three minutes later, radar operators watched the fighter close on the unknown object until the two radar returns appeared to merge. Then Avenger Red disappeared. Pilot First Lieutenant Feli...

S14 E11 - Round Robin - The Final Spin - Knowing When to Say Goodbye 04.11.2026

After countless laughs, strange discoveries, unforgettable Women of the Week, and more than a few conversations that went completely off the rails, Round Robin takes its final spin. Tracy, Christine, and Nina explore why humans have such a hard time letting go, the psychology of the sunk-cost fallacy, and some of television’s most memorable farewells—including M*A*S*H, Cheers, and The Mary Tyler M...

S14 E10 - The Michigan Nurse Ted Bundy Never Faced a Jury for - Caryn Cambell & The DNA Still Speaking 02.11.2026

Michigan nurse Caryn Eilene Campbell vanished from a Colorado ski resort in January 1975 and became the center of a murder case against Ted Bundy—a case that never reached trial after Bundy escaped custody. More than fifty years later, revolutionary DNA testing has now formally linked Bundy to two other Utah teenagers, Laura Ann Aime and Melissa Ann Smith. In this victim-centered episode of Malice...

S14 E9 - F-Bomb - Devils Night - The Night Detroit Burned 30.10.2026

Before Halloween came Devil’s Night—a Detroit tradition that began with pranks, eggs, soap, and toilet paper before evolving into something far more terrifying. By the 1980s, October 30 had become synonymous with arson, abandoned buildings, sirens, and fear. During the three-day Halloween period of 1984, Detroit recorded an astonishing 810 fires. But this isn't only the story of a city burning. It...

S14 E8 - Round Robin - Dating by Cabbage - Who Knew That Was a Halloween Tradition 28.10.2026

Halloween gets weird on Round Robin! Tracy, Christine and Nina uncover bizarre old-school Halloween dating rituals, terrifying turnip jack-o'-lanterns, the strange history behind trick-or-treating.  Tracy also honors Halloween historian Ruth Edna Kelley as Woman of the Week and recommends Peacock's new Friday the 13th prequel series Crystal Lake. Grab the candy, turn down the lights, and prepare f...

S14 E7 - Halloween Behind the Mask - The Murder of Willie Wilborn 26.10.2026

On Halloween night in 2019, Willie Lawrence Wilborn was standing inside a Detroit gas station when a gunman wearing a clown mask approached and fatally shot him. But the story didn't begin that night. Two years earlier, Wilborn had been charged in the murder of his pregnant girlfriend, LaDiamond Myers, a 24-year-old mother of four. Those charges were dismissed after a judge determined prosecutors...

S14 E6 - F-Bomb - The Hospital That Wouldn't Let Go - Stimson Hospital - Where the HIstory Ends & the Haunting Begins 23.10.2026

Deep in Eaton Rapids, Michigan, stands a Victorian mansion that once became a twenty-bed community hospital—and later one of Mid-Michigan's most enduring paranormal legends. Harriet Chapman Hospital opened in 1918, founded by nurse Harriet Chapman alongside physicians Charles Stimson and Francis R. Blanchard. Less than a year later, tragedy struck when Dr. Blanchard stepped through an open elevato...

S14 E5 - Round Robin - Animals Gone Wild 21.10.2026

A black bear walks into an Alaska shopping mall, steals a peach, poops in the hallway, and leaves. Beavers in Poland destroy a sign warning people about… beavers. And a frightened monkey turns a Spirit Halloween store into its own personal jungle gym. You seriously cannot make this shit up. Because on Round Robin, sometimes we start with a bear taking a shit in a shopping mall...and somehow end up...

S14 E4 - A Fatal Diagnosis - The Poisoning Case of William Vanderhoof 19.10.2026

In December 1883, William Vanderhoof died after years of unexplained illness in Berrien County, Michigan. His wife, Elizabeth, was accused of poisoning him with arsenic. A jury convicted her of murder. But William's attending physician believed he was suffering from heart disease, and the medical evidence was far from straightforward. In 1888, the Michigan Supreme Court overturned Elizabeth's conv...

S14 E3 - F-Bomb - The Door to Nowhere - The Haunting of Henderson Castle 16.10.2026

High above Kalamazoo, Michigan, stands a magnificent Victorian castle built in 1895. But according to decades of paranormal accounts, some of its former residents may never have left. This week on F-Bomb Friday, Tracy Preston explores the fascinating history and chilling legends of Henderson Castle. From Mary Henderson's mysterious missing jewelry and the Lady in White to the tragic legend of a li...

S14 E2 - Round Robin - What The Hell is WrongWith Everybody 14.10.2026

What happens when common sense takes a vacation? This week on Round Robin, Tracy, Christine, and Nina explore some of the most outrageous and extraordinary stories making headlines. From a Disney World guest diving into an attraction's water to two men driving a couch down a public road, we're asking the question everyone seems to be thinking: What the hell is wrong with everybody?! Discover why g...

S14 E1 - Rough on Rats - A Farm, a Fortune, and a Fatal Promise 12.10.2026

In 1883, sixty-year-old Michigan farmer John Guild transferred his property to a woman who promised him a home for the remainder of his life. Not long after the deal, he was dead. An examination reportedly revealed arsenic. A neighbor testified about purchasing a product called Rough on Rats. And investigators questioned what happened to Guild's missing money. Korun Larson was convicted of first-d...

S13 E30 - F-Bomb - Don't Stop on Purgatory Road - Michigan's Goat Man and the Devil Dog 09.10.2026

Deep in southwest Michigan, Purgatory Road cuts through woods, wetlands and the Three Rivers State Game Area—a place associated with strange local stories for years. By 2019, one legend had emerged clearly in writing: a mysterious Goat-Man said to roam Purgatory with an even stranger companion known as the Devil Dog. On this episode of F-Bomb Friday, Tracy explores what can actually be documented...

S13 E29 - Round Robin - Malibu, Movie Stars & Money in the Banana Stand 07.10.2026

What do Malibu Beach, surfing, frozen bananas, John Wayne, Shirley Temple and Barbie have in common? More than you'd think. This week on Round Robin, Tracy, Christine and Nina head to Southern California to explore the Chumash origins of Malibu, the Hawaiian roots of modern surfing culture, Duke Kahanamoku, Gidget, Malibu Barbie, Balboa Island's frozen banana wars, John Wayne's surprising connecti...

The Woman They Tried to Erase - The Death of Emily Hal 05.10.2026

In 1895, a young Englishwoman named Emily Hall crossed the Atlantic and arrived at a house on Lincoln Avenue in Detroit while pregnant. Less than two weeks later, she was dead. But Emily Hall wasn't the name written on her death certificate. She became “Myrtle Cook”—a supposedly New York-born woman said to have died of pneumonia at an address where Emily had never lived. Then her embalmed body rem...

S13 E27 - F-Bomb - The Friendless Dead - Grave Secrets & Anatomy Lessons 02.10.2026

This week on F-Bomb Friday, we uncover one of Michigan's darkest medical history stories: the resurrectionists, grave robbing, and the unclaimed dead who supplied 19th-century anatomy rooms in Detroit and Ann Arbor.  From Detroit Medical College and Michigan's 1881 Anatomy Act to Willie Brown, the "friendless dead," and the shocking 1893 discovery of two human skeletons in Detroit's garbage, this...

S13 E29 - Round Robin - Duct Taped at 30,000 Feet - Did COVID Break Public Behavior? 30.09.2026

What happened to basic human behavior—especially at 30,000 feet? This week on Round Robin, Tracy, Christine, and Nina dive into the wild case of an American Airlines first-class passenger who became so disruptive that fellow passengers restrained him with zip ties and duct tape before the flight diverted for an emergency landing. He later claimed he couldn’t remember what happened. But this story...

S13 E25 - Four Graves and a Pardon - The Sparling Family Poisonings 28.09.2026

Between 1908 and 1911, four men from Michigan's Sparling family died after suffering eerily similar illnesses. When arsenic was discovered, suspicion fell on their family physician, Dr. Robert MacGregor. In 1912, MacGregor was convicted of murdering twenty-year-old Scyrel Sparling and sentenced to life in Michigan State Prison. Four years later, Governor Woodbridge Ferris declared MacGregor innoce...

S13 E24-F-Bomb- The Red Harbinger-Detroit's Nain Rouge-Before the Fire, Before the Bloodshed, Before Disaster...Detroit Saw Red 18.09.2026

Detroit has a monster of its own—and according to generations of folklore, he appears when something terrible is coming. In this episode of F-Bomb Friday, Tracy and Todd explore the legend of the Nain Rouge, Detroit’s mysterious Red Dwarf and alleged harbinger of disaster. From Cadillac and Bloody Run to the Great Fire of Detroit, the War of 1812, and a haunting 1964 folklore account describing th...

S13 E23 - Round Robin - Grave Diggers, Opera Snakes & Things We Thought Were Fancy 16.09.2026

This week on Round Robin, Tracy, Christine and Nina chase the chaos through some of the strangest stories of the week. A boa constrictor auditions for the Metropolitan Opera, competitive grave diggers race in Hungary and Brach's creates candy-corn perfume. Plus, the ladies remember the things they thought were fancy as kids, reveal their useless superpowers, battle over controversial foods and res...

S13 E22 - The Perfect Alibi - The Murder of Mary H. Latimer & the Prison Escape That Killed Again 14.09.2026

In January 1889, Jackson widow Mary H. Latimer was found murdered inside her home. Her only son, young druggist Robert Irving Latimer, appeared to have an extraordinary alibi: he was in Detroit, where hotel workers and others had seen him. But an unused hotel bed, railroad timetables, blood evidence and financial questions began telling another story. Latimer's conviction was only the beginning. M...

S13 E21 - F-Bomb - Something Guards the Dead - The Witchy Wolves of Omer Plains 11.09.2026

Deep in Michigan’s Omer Plains, near the winding Rifle River, an old legend tells of strange wolf-like guardians said to watch over the resting places of the dead. Some describe shadowy animals. Others remember an eerie, laughing bark coming from somewhere beyond the trees. And over the decades, curious visitors have reported scratches, unexplained sounds, and the unnerving feeling that something...

Listen to the Malice in the Mitten podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.