Lady, You’re Scaring Us

To go along with our Halloween episodes, we asked listeners to send us their experiences with otherworldly encounters. And here they are! Big thanks to everyone who sent us a story. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

On October 31, 1973  Lisa French put on her Halloween costume and went trick-or-treating for the very last time.  Sources: WISN TC Palm FDL Reporter WMTV NBC 15 Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Did an innocent man get put to death for murdering a nun? Sounds like it… Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Peter Fabiano thought it was odd that a trick-or-treater would still be out after 11pm, but he opened the door anyway… Sources: Deranged LA Crimes Vice The Vintage Woman Magazine The True Crime Edition Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

There's a reason people started checking their kid's Halloween candy... Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Mariesa's bonus episode about two evil bitches whose stories tend to blur when it comes down to fact and fiction. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Accident or foul play? You decide. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Yeah, you read that right. Enjoy this super mini bonus episode that's 25% us talking about crime and 75% us talking about other stuff. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

One June 13, 1988, three little girls were murdered sometime during the very first night of camp. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Josh Powell is one of the worst humans in history. Change our minds. If you haven't already, make sure you listen to part one first. Source: If I Can't Have You by Gregg Olsen and Rebecca Morris 911 call:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qrfqCGeDXXE Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Mother and wife, Susan Powell goes missing. No one knows where she is. Her dead beat husband's "alibi" is that he took their two young sons out camping at midnight in the freezing deserts of Utah...in December... Source: If I Can't Have You by Gregg Olsen and Rebecca Morris Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Tales of Appalachian cryptids and us going off the rails numerous times. This bonus episode is a little chaotic and we apologize in advance. If this is your first time listening to Lady, You're Scaring Us, we suggest starting with a different episode ;)  Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Dennis Martin disappeared in The Great Smoky Mountains during the summer of 1969. The search for little Dennis was one of the largest in National Park history. Source: Unsolved Disappearances of the Smoky Mountains by Juanitta Baldwin and Ester Grubb Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

His actions led to him being dubbed “The Vampire of Sacramento.” Source: The Vampire of Scaremento by Genoveva Ortiz Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Tired of being alone? Your soulmate may just be a needle and thread away... Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Would a teenager kill his parents just because they weren't going to let him go to prom? Jeff said he wouldn't and didn't... Source: The Prom Night Murders by Carlton Smith Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

You're gonna need a bigger boat... Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Be nice to your nurses. They hold your life in their hands...literally. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Imagine living in a poor country, then learning that you're going to be adopted by a family in the United States. But then that turns out to be the worst thing that would ever happen to you... Source: True Crime Case Histories by Jason Neal *Edited to correct spelling of victim’s name* Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

The Farmville Murders did NOT, in fact, have anything to do with the Facebook game... Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Would you notice a body hanging from a tree for seven months? Yeah, we think we would too… Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

This episode is extra special and extra personal. In Pensacola, Florida 1993, nineteen-year-old Joanna Otto went missing after leaving a party. Telling us the story, is Joanna's best friend and roommate at the time.   We really can't thank Liseth enough for sharing such a personal story and experience with us. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Jody's story brings up the question of: What would you do for your child? Source: Why Gary Why by Jody Plauche Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Judy is said to be the lady that coined the term "Black Widow".  Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

The Mockingbird Hill Massacre got Ronald a super expedited sentence. Source: Obeying Evil by Ryan Green Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus