Keystone Cold Cases

For a special HALLOWEEN BONUS EPISODE, join Chelsea as she tells the story of what happened to Grace Packer at the hands of the people she should have been able to trust the most. Grace joins in with her thoughts on this solved case. Sources and information are available on kccpod.com 

In this first part episode, examine the case of the Mainline Murders and missing persons cases with possible connections to a missing couple from a year prior. Grace tells the story of Susan (Gallagher) Reinert's murder, her two missing children, Karen and Michael, and a possible connection to missing couple Stephanie (Smith) and Edward Hunsberger. In part one, listen for the backstories of charac...

Before her body appeared in the Susquehanna River, her friends and family thought she had just gone "off the grid" as she had done before. When the investigation into her death began, questions arose. Dig into the questions and theories of the death of Kimberly "Kimmie" Yohe as Amanda gives the details and Sarah offers her thoughts. Sources and photos are available on kccpod.com. 

This week, we bring you stories from Pennhurst, the hospital mentioned in multiple early episodes. Some claim that the hospital is riddled with ghosts, while others are influenced by the haunted attraction that now runs on the grounds. Listen in as Chelsea talks about the history, inhabitants, and criminal activity associated with Pennhurst as Sarah interjects her thoughts on the subject. All sour...

In another spooky rendition of KCC, listen first as Amanda and Sarah listen in while Grace explains the case of missing Harrisburg State Hospital patient John Chocha Jr. who left the hospital on a day pass and was never seen again. Then, in the second half of the episode, listen as Sarah gives a history of the Hospital and discusses its paranormal side with Amanda, Chelsea, and Grace. All sources...

When a dock worker uncovers a wooden milk crate in the Schuylkill, his life would forever change. Listen this week as Amanda tells the story of the Girl in the Box, also known at the Philadelphia County Jane Doe, and discusses the 1962 investigation with Chelsea and Sarah. Then, stick around after to hear a quick spotlight on the Eastern State Penitentiary for a spooky twist this week. Images and...

In a two story episode today, begin by hearing about Danielle Imbo, a New Jersian, and her boyfriend, Richard Petrone Jr., a couple who went missing under mysterious circumstances, and an ex with a rock-solid alibi. Then, listen to the case of the Jane Doe from the area locals know as "The Gap": a woman found near a military base in south central PA who has never been identified, but whose story y...

In this week's episode, Grace leads Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah through two strange happenings in PA. First, listen to the story of Don Decker, the Rain Man, who flooded a friend's apartment with his mind, then enjoy the history of Centralia, Pa, the town with an underground coal mine fire. As always, all of our sources and photos are available at kccpod.com. 

As mentioned in the Missing Persons case of Ray Gricar, today we bring you the story of Johnathan Luna, Assistant US Attorney, who was murdered in Lancaster County in 2003. Listen as Amanda tells the story and discusses theories with Chelsea, Grace, and Sarah. Photos and all sources can be found at kccpod.com

When PSU student Betsy Aardsma returned to campus early during her Thanksgiving holiday, she never predicted what would happen while researching for a graduate paper. In one silent moment, her killer found her, stabbed her, and got out. Who could kill a student in the middle of the library? Was it a defense attack or had it been planned out? And furthermore, did Betsy ever leave campus? Listen as...

The silence of the night was shattered with the screams of 4 children trying to escape the flames that engulfed their home. Only one child made it out alive. Who started this fire and why? Listen as Grace tells the story and discusses theories with Sarah and Amanda. Featuring some volunteer firemen to provide a unique perspective on house fires. All sources and photos are available on kccpod.com. 

In today's episode, listen in as the ladies discuss the details and theories of two cases. In the first part of the episode, Chelsea tells the story of missing father and friend Anthony Capasso, last seen in 2018. Then, in the second part of the episode, Amanda tells the story of Patricia Neil Randolph, AKA Baby Doll, a woman who was murdered in 1977. Both Anthony and Patricia were involved in ris...

When police found an abandoned vehicle in a field after a blizzard, they assumed someone slide off the road. The evidence inside paints a gruesome story. Listen as Amanda tells the story and discusses theories with Chelsea and Sarah. Sources and additional information available at kccpod.com 

Part 2 of the Brian Wells case is here for your listening! If you haven't listened to part 1, make sure you go back to episode 24 before listening to episode 25. This week, listen as Sarah continues the story of Brian Wells, discussing thoughts and theories with Grace. Check out kccpod.com for all photos and sources. 

Listen to the first part of the story of Brian Wells, an Erie man who was a piece of a bank heist, but who was killed in the process. In this first part of the case, Sarah tells the background on some of the key players and begins to go through the events that led up to the death of Brian. Amanda, Chelsea, and Grace discuss some of the details of this case with Sarah. Photos and sources available...

On March 6, 1954 the frozen body of 22 year-old Marguerite Keota (‘Kotyk’ - Slovac version of surname) was found in a six foot hole beneath an outhouse on the grounds of an abandoned schoolhouse in Phoenixville, PA (Pickering Schoolhouse).She had been missing and feared kidnapped since the Tuesday prior. Listen as Grace tells the story and discusses theories with Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah. All im...

In today's two-case episode, listen to your hosts discuss the cases of Baby Allison Doe and Hector Ortiz Fuentes. When students walked to the burn barrel at school on the afternoon of December 31st, they never imagined they would find a newborn baby, murdered in cold blood. Listen as Amanda tells the story and Chelsea, Grace, and Sarah discuss theories.  Then, Amanda and Chelsea discuss the case o...

Anna was known to skip school, do drugs, and have sex for money. Did any of that play into her death? Do flowers placed in the duct tape bound hands of Anna hold the clues to catching her killer? Listen as Sarah tells the story and discusses details with Amanda, Chelsea, and Grace. All source information and images are located on kccpod.com. 

Wendy Eatons family headed to a Country Club to play golf not realizing it would be the last time they ever saw Wendy. Listen as Amanda and Sarah tell the story and discuss theories with Chelsea and Grace. All sources and images, along with the note from the family, are available on kccpod.com

In the early morning hours of January 14, 2016, a white 1997 Ford Probe was found near the Bloomsburg Municipal Airport. The keys were in the ignition, but no one was in the car.  A set of footprints led halfway across the snow covered bridge over the Susquehanna River. What happened at the end of those footprints? Listen as Grace explains the story and Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah comment. Stay tun...

The Centre County DA goes missing, leaving only his car in a publicly frequented parking lot. Where did Ray Gricar go? Who caused him to disappear? Why was he off work when he went missing? Do you know what happened? Listen in as Amanda explains the story and theories to Chelsea, Grace, and Sarah.  Sources and photos can be found on our website: kccpod.com 

Two women are murdered in the Philadelphia area nearly 4 years apart.  Could their cases be connected?  And how many other cases could potentially be linked to theirs as well?  Listen as Chelsea shares the details of the two women's stories and discusses theories with Amanda, Grace and Sarah.  Sources and photos can be found on our website: kkccpod.com 

Content Warning: Child Case; Child Abuse; Sexual Assault. In late February 1957, a bassinet box was found in Fox Chapel just outside of Philadelphia. Also known as “America’s Unknown Child”, the case of “The Boy in the Box” remains unsolved to this day, and the identity of this child remains unknown, for now. Listen in as Sarah describes the case and discusses theories with Amanda, Chelsea, and Gr...

On July 15, 1994, 14 year old Sarah Rae Boehm walked out of her Rochester Township home and never returned.  Her remains were found near Deerfield Township, Ohio on November 4, 1994, but they were not officially identified until nearly 9 years later. Listen in to hear Grace tell the details of this case, while discussing theories with Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah. As always, find all of our sources...

TWO CASES TODAY :: Today, join the KCC crew as they tell the stories and discuss the theories behind two PA cases. First, Chelsea will tell the story of Ryan Stevyn Benjamin, a NY native found 5 years ago this month in a pond. Then, Grace will detail everything that's known about an unidentified woman known only as Penny Doe who was discovered over 20 years ago. Amanda and Sarah join in with discu...