Justice For

 In 1977, a beloved respiratory therapist and passionate musician, 48 year old Teresita Basa, was found murdered in her Chicago apartment. Her case quickly went cold amid fire damage, missing evidence, and a single cryptic clue left behind. With no clear suspect and more questions than answers, investigators were left chasing shadows—until months later, an unexpected tip surfaced that challenged e...

In July of 2000, two young people in Indianapolis, Indiana were killed in a crime that would later be overshadowed by one of the most infamous prison escapes in the state’s history. Andrew Cataldi and Tricia Nordman were complicated, imperfect, real people. Who made mistakes, but they were also more than the worst chapters of their pasts.  Unfortunately, they were betrayed by the very people they...

In August 1995, 32-year-old Donnah Winger was violently attacked inside her home in Springfield, Illinois. The case was closed quickly by police after speaking with her husband and getting his side of what happened, just to be opened years later after a shocking witness came forward.  In this episode, we break down the evidence, the lies and betrayal, and the lingering questions that continue to d...

In this episode, we dive into the haunting story of the Snowden family murders —a case tangled in tragedy, second chances, and whispers of a family curse. Once a well-known Southern family, the Snowdens’ legacy would be shattered by violence not once, but decades apart. In the 1990s, a mother and her nephew were brutally murdered. The killer was caught, convicted, and eventually released—given ano...

On April 26, 2006, a devastating crash in Indiana claimed the lives of five Taylor University students. Among those involved were Whitney Cerak and Laura Van Ryn, two young women who had only met earlier that day while helping serve their community. In the confusion that followed, identities were assigned, families were notified, and a funeral was held—while another family waited beside a hospital...

In March 2023, Angela Craig was rushed to the hospital in Aurora, Colorado, after suddenly falling gravely ill. What doctors first believed was a medical emergency soon unraveled into something far more sinister. Within days, Angela was dead—and the man at her bedside, her husband of more than a decade, was under intense scrutiny. James Craig, a respected dentist and father of six, was living a do...

In Part 2 of our deep dive into the murder of Betsy Faria, we pick up where the courtroom left Russ behind — branded a killer, sitting in a prison cell, while the truth continued to scream just outside the record. This chapter is all about what happened after the verdict: the evidence that didn’t make it to the jury, the witnesses who were never heard, and the pieces of the puzzle that refused to...

In this bonus episode, we open with the most recent twist in the Morgan Geyser Saga — her escape, the brief period she was missing, and the eventual capture that brought her back into custody. We’ll talk about what we know, what’s emerged since, and why the situation has so many people asking hard questions all over again. This is our space to pause, reflect, and unpack the developments before we...

In this episode, we focus on Betsy Faria: a mother, a friend, and a woman fighting through the final chapters of a long cancer battle. We walk through her last day — the chemo appointment, the holiday plans, and the small decisions that seemed ordinary at the time but would become chilling in hindsight. It was a night that forever changed the people who loved her and set off a chain of events no o...

In 1995, 13-year-old Thad Phillips was abducted from his home in Baraboo, Wisconsin and held captive by a teenage predator later known as The Bone Breaker. For nearly two days, Thad endured unimaginable torture—but refused to give up. His daring escape not only saved his own life, but exposed a pattern of violence that could have claimed more victims. This episode examines Thad’s extraordinary wil...

This week, we’re re-releasing one of our Season 1 cases from the vault — the heartbreaking story of Mia Campos . Due to some unexpected technical difficulties (because of course they happen on a Monday), we’re giving this episode a fresh spotlight just as Mia’s long-awaited trial is finally set to begin . In this episode, we revisit the life of a young woman whose disappearance shook her community...

In April 1981, the small mountain town of Keddie, California, was shattered by a scene straight out of a nightmare. Inside Cabin 28, a mother, her teenage son, and his friend were brutally murdered — while a young daughter vanished without a trace. What began as a horrific tragedy quickly became one of the most infamous unsolved cases in Northern California history. With lost evidence, mishandled...

 Before Scream terrified audiences, a real-life horror unfolded in the quiet college town of Gainesville, Florida. In 1990, five students were brutally murdered over just four days — their lives stolen by a man the media would dub "The Gainesville Ripper." But behind the headlines and the Hollywood inspiration were real people — Sonja Larson, Christina Powell, Christa Hoyt, Tracy Paules, and Manue...

🕯️ This October, we're celebrating a full month of spine-chilling cases and urban legends! From unsolved mysteries to real-life horror stories, each week brings a new reason to sleep with the lights on. Tune in, lock your doors, and get ready for our Month of Spooky Episodes. 🎃 Halloween night, 1973. What began as an innocent evening of trick-or-treating in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, ended in unimag...

 In the winter of 1977, Sacramento became the setting of a nightmare. A series of brutal murders left the city paralyzed with fear — and behind it all was a man the media would come to call The Vampire Killer, Richard Chase. But this episode isn't just about the darkness that consumed him. It's about the innocent lives he destroyed — Teresa Wallin, Evelyn Miroth, and others whose names deserve to...

In the fall of 2016, a wave of fear swept across neighborhoods, schools, and entire cities. People reported seeing eerie figures dressed as clowns — lurking near woods, standing outside homes, even chasing strangers through the dark. What started as an online prank spiraled into a nationwide panic that left police departments scrambling and communities terrified. But was it all a hoax… or did some...

In the summer of 2017, in a quiet Ohio suburb, a secret came to light that stunned the nation. Eighteen-year-old Brooke Skylar Richardson was accused of hiding her pregnancy, giving birth alone in her bathroom, and burying her newborn daughter in the backyard while her family slept just feet away. The media frenzy that followed centered on Skylar—her appearance, her lifestyle, and her courtroom de...

Fingerprinting revolutionized criminal investigations-but its history is filled with surprising twists. In this episode, we dive into the infamous case of Will West and William West, two men whose identical appearances exposed the flaws of early identification systems and helped cement fingerprints as the gold standard in forensics. From there we explore the curious world of twin-related crimes: D...

In July 2014, German tourist Lars Mittank's dream vacation in Bulgaria spiraled into a nightmare. After a bar fight left him injured, Lars began acting strangely, calling his mother in fear claiming he was being followed. His last known moments were captured on Airport security cameras: a sudden and frantic sprint out of the airport terminal before disappearing in the field beyond. Nearly a decade...

In 1990 Marlene Warren opened her front door to find a clown holding balloons and flowers. Moments later she was shot in cold blood. For decades her murder haunted her Florida community-twisting through rumors, betrayal, and a shocking love triangle. Join us as we unravel the chilling case of Marlene Warren, the "killer clown" murder that remained unsolved for nearly three decades Disclaimer  The...

In July 1951, 67 year old Mary Reeser was found in her Florida apartment under circumstances so bizarre they left police, the FBI, and fire experts completely stumped. Her body had been reduced to ashes except for one slipper clad foot, while the rest of the room remained almost untouched. In this episode we unravel the chilling mystery of "The Cinder Woman" and the strange legacy of one of histor...

In December of 2004, the quiet town of skidmore Missouri was shattered by a crime so brutal and bizarre it stunned the nation. Bobbi Jo Stinnett, a vibrant young woman expecting her first child, was brutally murdered in her own home. What investigators uncovered was even more disturbing- a calculated act of violence fueled by lies, obsession, and an unimaginable motive.  Join us as we dive deep in...

She feared he might kill her and one night, he did. The brutal murder of Amie Harwick revealed a chilling pattern of stalking, obsession, and violence. Amie, a Hollywood therapist, was known for her work helping others heal, but behind the scenes she was fighting for her own safety. Join us as we dive into her story, accomplishments and the threats she faced leading up to that tragic night. Discla...

In this haunting episode, we go beyond the headlines to remember the victims of Hugo Selenski — the Pennsylvania man whose name became synonymous with horror after a mass grave was discovered in his Luzerne County backyard in 2003. While much of the media spotlight focused on Selenski's strange behavior, jailbreaks, and courtroom theatrics, we turn our focus to the lives he destroyed. Among the vi...

November 1994 Marty Grisham was shot 4 times after answering a knock at his front door, his girlfriend Barbara sat just feet away in the living room. Police quickly found their prime suspect or did they? Join us as we unravel all the twists and turns in the still unsolved murder of Marty Grisham, and the long long road to justice for the wrongfully convicted Michael Clark.  Disclaimer  The views a...