I've Got Something To Tell You

In this episode, we’re telling two stories that couldn’t be more different — and yet somehow feel eerily connected. Colleen covers the survival story of Alison Botha, a woman who endured one of the most brutal attacks in South African history and lived to tell the story. What happened to Alison is horrifying, heartbreaking, and impossible to forget — but her survival is a testament to resilience,...

This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we’re diving into two stories that live at the intersection of obsession, conspiracy, and control. Tayler takes us deep into the Montauk Project — a long-running conspiracy theory involving secret government experiments, alleged mind control, time travel, and psychological warfare. From Camp Hero to the darkest corners of Cold War paranoia, she breaks d...

In this episode, we play another round of Top 5, counting down the places you’d absolutely refuse to go at night. From unsettling late-night locations to places that feel wrong the moment you step inside, we rank the spots that trigger pure fear, unease, and that instinctual need to leave immediately. Some are creepy because of what might be there… and others because of what used to be. Grab a bla...

Our first live show of 2026 — and we’re taking it back to where it all began: Jarrod’s Coffee Shop 🖤 ☕ ️ In this live recording, Colleen covers one of Arizona’s most disturbing modern tragedies — the Sedona sweat lodge deaths and self-help guru James Arthur Ray, whose “Spiritual Warrior” retreat ended in multiple fatalities and a criminal conviction. We break down how wellness culture, manipulat...

For our 50th episode, we’re going back to where it all began — literally and figuratively. This week, we’re celebrating the stories, the places, and the moments that shaped I’ve Got Something To Tell You from the very beginning. Tayler is covering the Rosson House — one of the first haunted locations we ever visited together on a ghost tour with our podcast crew, and a place forever tied to our ea...

To close out 2025, we’re doing something a little different. In this New Year’s Eve episode, we’re each picking our favorite story the other one told this year. Taylor chooses her favorite episode Colleen covered, and Colleen picks her favorite story Taylor told — the ones that stuck with us, that we still reference, and that honestly shaped how we think about this year of the podcast. This episod...

In this Christmas Eve episode, Colleen and Tayler explore the darker side of the holiday season through true crime and folklore. Colleen covers the murder of JonBenét Ramsey, examining the events surrounding her death on Christmas night in Boulder, Colorado, the early investigation, and how the case became one of the most infamous and controversial unsolved crimes in American history. Tayler dives...

We bring back our chaotic Top 5 segment — and this time, we’re digging through the most haunted objects ever sold on eBay. From cursed wedding rings and whispering teddy bears to journals that seem to write themselves, each reveal somehow gets worse than the last. The competition heats up, the reactions get louder, and by the time we hit the number one spot, we’re questioning why anyone would ever...

This week, we’re leaning into the darker side of the holidays — the kind that looks festive on the surface and deeply unsafe once you scratch it. Tayler kicks things off with the infamous Dybbuk Box, the object that went viral after being sold on eBay and quickly earned a reputation as one of the most “haunted” items on the internet. We dig into where the story came from, how it spread, and how a...

Grab a blanket, a warm beverage and maybe a flashlight because this listener story is sweet but a little spooky. Tune in and get ready to hear this listener's childhood story of how she befriended a ghost girl.  Got a story to tell us? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com

We’re back at Bottleshop 48 for another live show, and this one might be our most chaotic pairing yet. Tayler digs into the dark folklore of Krampus — the horned, holiday menace who shows up when Santa’s had enough. Then Colleen takes us into the unbelievable real-life kidnapping of Frank Sinatra Jr., a case so strange she ended up telling it on its anniversary without even realizing it. It’s wint...

This week on I’ve Got Something to Tell You, we’re taking you from the icy slopes of the Ural Mountains to the strange streets of Fresno. Colleen dives into one of the most puzzling and debated mysteries in true-crime history: The Dyatlov Pass Incident. Nine experienced hikers, a violent and unexplained night in the snow, baffling injuries, abandoned gear, and decades of theories trying to piece t...

In this special bonus episode, we dive back into our new favorite chaos generator — Top 5! This time, we wandered through the dusty aisles of a haunted antique store and things got unhinged fast. From self-rocking chairs to violin solos no one asked for, to mirrors with a mind of their own, every reveal had us screaming, laughing, and arguing over what should (or definitely should NOT) make the li...

In this week’s episode of I’ve Got Something to Tell You, Tayler and Colleen each bring a story guaranteed to haunt you in totally different ways. Tayler dives into the eerie legend of The Crying Boy — the infamous painting blamed for house fires, curses, and decades of unexplained bad luck. From tabloids to terrified homeowners, urban legend to alleged paranormal evidence, we unpack why a single...

We’re back with another live show at Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa, where the caffeine is strong and the stories are even stronger. Tayler kicks things off with one of the most unsettling paranormal legends out there: the Black-Eyed Children. Creepy encounters, eerie folklore, and the kind of urban legend that leaves you double-checking your front door. Then Colleen dives into true-crime history with th...

This week’s episode takes a hilarious turn with our brand new segment...... Top 5!!! We dive into the “Most Haunted Foods,” and things get chaotic fast, partially because I (Tayler) forgets part of the rules before we begin. Between the wild guesses, unexpected answers, and competitive energy, this game had us laughing way harder than we expected. Who knew bread, meat pies, and ice cream trucks co...

In this episode, Tayler shares the haunting legend of Resurrection Mary, one of Chicago’s most enduring ghost stories — a restless spirit said to wander Archer Avenue, searching for her way home. Then, Colleen tells the heartbreaking story of Jayna Troxel Murray, whose life was tragically cut short in an unthinkable act of violence. 

We’re kicking off our first official listener stories segment — and it’s a wild one! Collected by an awesome friend from Bottleshop 48, this eerie tale follows a woman who starts noticing something strange about the guy she’s dating… he always seems to be around. Like, always. But the reason why will make your skin crawl. Grab a blanket, get cozy and tune in! PS. For more listener stories, check o...

This week, we’re coming to you live from BottleShop 48, where the drinks were cold, the ghosts were active, and the stories were absolutely unhinged. Tayler kicks things off with the infamous Bobby Mackey’s Music World—a haunted Kentucky honky-tonk packed with murder, mayhem, and more basement demons than any bar really needs. Then Colleen dives into the unbelievable true-crime legend of Michael M...

This week, Tayler uncovers the real story behind The Exorcist — the chilling 1949 case of a boy whose terrifying possession and church-documented exorcism shocked the nation and inspired one of the most infamous horror films of all time. Then Colleen dives into the chaos that followed when Hollywood tried to bring that story to life — from mysterious fires and on-set injuries to unexplained deaths...

The Sallie House + Karl Tanzler, "The Corpse Bride"   This week, Tayler takes us to Atchison, Kansas — inside one of the most famously haunted homes in America: The Sallie House. From flickering lights to ghostly scratches, it’s a story that blurs the line between haunting and possession… and proves some spirits don’t like uninvited guests. Then Colleen dives into the macabre love story of Karl Ta...

The Salem Witch Trials Spooky Season continues — and we’ve got another special episode where we tackle a big story together. This week, Colleen covers the Salem Witch Trials — the true story of hysteria, accusations, and executions that turned a quiet Puritan village into a nightmare. From the “lil gurls” whose claims sparked mass panic to the haunting legacy left behind, it’s one of history’s dar...

In this spooky bonus episode, Colleen kicks things off with one of her dad’s eerie real-life ghost stories before diving into a recap of her recent San Diego trip — where she bravely visits the famously haunted Whaley House. Tayler follows up with a chilling Reddit tale that’ll have you double-checking the shadows. Cozy up, light a candle, and get ready for some ghostly fun! Have a story to tell u...

Our first LIVE SHOW!!    Recorded live at Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa, this episode dives into the real story behind The Amityville Horror. Colleen and Tayler trace the 1974 DeFeo family murders at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island, and unpack how a tragic true crime case turned into one of America’s most famous haunted-house legends. We cover Ronald DeFeo Jr.’s conviction, the Lutz family’s...

In this chilling episode, Colleen dives into the disturbing true story of Dean Corll, infamously known as “The Candy Man,” whose crimes in the 1970s left Houston shaken. Then, Tayler takes us to Harrisville, Rhode Island, to explore the haunting true events behind The Conjuring — the story of the Perron family and their terrifying experiences that inspired one of the most iconic paranormal films o...