Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
It Just Makes Sense
Welcome to “It Just Makes Sense!” the podcast by two easily distracted higher educated former lovers that explores all of the unpopular opinions, conspiracy theories and cult leaders that make you want to scream “THAT JUST MAKES SENSE!”
Author
Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 10, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Episode 136: The Lesson is Murder: Ivie De Moliina 14.04.2023 33:12
This week's episode is about the Hulu Series the Lesson is Murder. The killer this week is Ivie De Molina and the theme of this show is to figure out why a killer kills! A team of investigators re investigate Ivie, a housewife turned dominatrix turned cult leader killer. She influenced a group of young men to kill two of her clients. BUT why did she have them do this? The motive may not s...
Episode 135: The Murder of Shirley Carter 07.04.2023 30:35
This week's episode is about the murder of Shirley Carter. Jason Carter went to his parents' Marion County Farmhouse and walked in to find his mother Shirley shot dead on the floor. Jason called the police but had some odd behavior where he noted many details of the crime on the 911 call. Not typical of someone finding their mother shot and killed. Jason father believed and still be...
Episode 134 The Double Homicide of Bob and Kay Swartz 31.03.2023 36:04
This week's episode is about the double homicide of Bob and Kay Swartz. The murder of this devout catholic couple shocked their small Maryland town. Afterall, they were pillars of the community and were the parents to 3 adopted foster kids. One wintery Maryland morning their son Larry woke up to find his parents dead. He called the police and the investigation ensued from there. Who woul...
Chit Chat 78: Who Hasn't Shit themselves? 29.03.2023 45:52
This week Sam's off galivanting around Colorado, so Jeff brings a new friend to the pod Katie his favorite employee from gigis. They talk all things poop and have a gay old time.
Episode 133 Dr. Love 24.03.2023 35:25
The week's episode is about Malachi Love-Robinson. Malachi was a voracious high school student in Palm Beach County, Florida who wanted to become a doctor. He started shadowing a doctor at St. Mary's Medical Center in Palm Beach, Florida and then decided to start impersonating one. He was asked to leave after being caught but no criminal charges were filed. He went to open a medical...
Episode 132 Desiree Boltos 17.03.2023 33:14
This week's episode is about the con artist Desiree Boltos. She was younger woman who got her hooks into several wealthy older men and one woman across the United States. She would fake cancer and homelessness. for her and her children all while living it up in Las Vegas, California and Hawaii on her "lovers" dime!
Chit Chat 77 Lindsay Lohan is Pregnant, The Oscars were... meh! 15.03.2023 33:13
This Week's Chit Chat Sam and Jeff take a deep dive into the Oscars or as much as they could stay up late for. Over 3 hours really? The shows highs and lows, and of course our hot takes. Shoutout to one of our faves Lindsay Lohan being with child. Jeff gives a little update on his stalker. They took in some new eats and content. Check it out!
The Murder of Charles Poland AND The Hostage Crisis of Ethan Gilman 11.03.2023 32:20
This week's episode is about the murder of Charles Poland. Charles Poland was a school bus driver who died defending his kids in Midland City, Alabama. Jim Dykes a local man, who had a friendly relationship with Poland created a turn around on his property for the bus because he had a difficult driveway to navigate. BUT he ulterior motives. He stopped the bus one day, started chatting with...
Chit Chat 77 The Sandoval Scandoval, Stalkers? and Controversy at UB 08.03.2023 33:36
This week's Chit Chat Sam and Jeff talk about the Scandoval heard round the world. Sam may converted Jeff into a Vanderpump watcher. Jeff may have a stalker. Cards gone wrong. He tried spin, and yoga at 3 new gyms! Then they talk some serious business at UB with a controversial conservative speaker. Yoga 6 Spark Fitness
Episode 131 The Murder of Amanda Hillious 03.03.2023 32:21
Episode 131 is about the death of Amanda Hillious. She was the mother of 4 kids and lived with her husband and father-in-law in Kalispell, Montaa. One day during the Christmas season Amanda fell down the stairs! Or Did she? Her injuries would suggest she may have been pushed. It was pretty suspicious because Amanda had a rocky bordering on abusive relationship with her husband Brad and father-...
Chit Chat 76 Goodbye Meredith Grey, Deveining Shrimp and LIVE FROM THE UNIVERSITY AT BUFFALO 01.03.2023 27:00
This week the terrible twosome is recording from a real study! They chat about Dr. Grey's exit from Grey's Anatomy. Jeff can't stay on his two feet and no it's not because of playing cards! Sam was out with the girls winning some MEAT. Froth Brewery Brunch - YUM 5/5 that's wilds
Episode 130 Why Did You Kill Me? 24.02.2023 27:37
Episode 130 is about the Murder of Crystal Theobold. Crystal was the subject of the Netflix Documentary Why Did You Kill me? She was a 24-year-old woman that lived in Riverside California, she was loved by her family and many friends. One night, she left to go to the store and was shot dead in her car in the middle of what seemed to be a gang shoutout. Her mother vowed to catch her killer, alo...
Episode 129 The Cold Case Murder of Joe Clark 17.02.2023 31:51
This week's episode is the cold case murder of Lieutenant Joe Clark. One night in 1981, Joe was grabbing a snack in the Kitchen and was shot in the head through a kitchen window. At the time Joe was investigating the war on drugs and had a lot of enemies. The town was rattled by the case and there were plenty of suspects.
Chit Chat 74 Jeff's back from the DR and Sam's a justice Vigilante! 16.02.2023 33:35
It's chit chat baby! Jeff's back from vacation, no card playing, no drama, just a fun time. He took in some content and kept on his quest to finish all the best picture nominees. Sam was a justice vigilante at work! Everything Everywhere All at Once We are not Broken - George M Johnson So Help Me Todd
Episode 128: Guilty or Innocent: Attempted Murder or Protective Mother? 10.02.2023 43:58
On this weeks episode while Jeff is getting laid in the sun, Sam is joined by the impeccable and hilarious Evangeline. The ladies discuss the case against Danita Tutt. Danita was accused of attempted murder by starvation of her son Colby. Danita is adamant this is not true, but a doctor specializing in Munchausen by proxy claims Danita is a clear cut case. Did Danita keep her child sick for th...
Chit Chat 73: Earthquakes and Aquariums! 08.02.2023 27:57
This weeks chit chat Sam is joined by long time friend and big time fan Evangeline! While Jeff is off sun bathing and dancing his little heart out, Sam and Ev discuss the earthquake that rocked Buffalo and Ev's trip down south!
Episode 127 The Case of Edward Ates 02.02.2023 33:10
Episode 127 is about an episode of Web of Death from Hulu called Crowd Sourced Justice. Bob Ruff was a fire chief in Buchannan, Michigan that was obsessed with the true crime podcast Serial. He was so obsessed that he started his own podcast called Truth and Justice. Within weeks he had 1,000 followers. He was so committed to his newfound passion; he left his job as a firefighter and took on h...
Chit Cht 72 Tales of a Modern Mystic! 01.02.2023 29:48
This week's chitty chat the double trouble talks content, content and more content. Jeff took in some delicious eats with some long-time listeners and friends Connie, Tiffany, Taaliba and Big T. Sam took a new job after opening herself up to MODERN MYSTICISM! She's officially a witch! Beast The Banshees of Inisherin Fleishman is in Trouble Alert Bake Squad
Episode 126 The Murder of Rodney Cockeye Stepp 27.01.2023 31:40
This week's case is about the murder of Rodney "Cockeye" Stepp in Martin County, Kentucky. Elwood "Woody" Six and Rodney Stepp were the best of friends, but Rodney was a bit of a wild drunk. He was an alcoholic prone to violent outbursts. One day during the Christmas season the men went into town to do something Christmas shopping. Rodney thought it was a great time to...
Chit Chat 71 Happy Birthday and Soberversary! 25.01.2023 28:10
This week the chit chatters recap Jeff's BIRTHDAY celebraciones! There were wings, strippers, witches and carrot cake. They chat about conspiracy theories, new content and a facebook group for calling out cheaters in Buffalo! Today Jeff is also 2 years booze free!
Episode 125 Electrical Fracking or Murder?! 21.01.2023 38:53
On April 6, 2022, firefighters and sheriff's deputies responded to a 911 call about a house fire in Rozellville, Wisconsin. After extinguishing the inferno, officials found signs that the blaze began in the garage. The remains of Tanya Rodriguez and her friend James Carolfi were found in the garage of the house. Tanya's Ex Boyfriend, Brad was the first suspect. The bodies appeared to...
Chit Chat 70 The Informant, Big T's back and playin Cards! 18.01.2023 36:42
This week the chit chatters invite some Big T energy up in this houuuuseee! A long-time listener and her husband have some jingles in the works for our podcasts! Sam spills a little tea about T's recent card playing. Big time fan Rachel swung through Buffalo for a little dinner and a drank. Sam and the Snitch went to Coles for a birthday celebration! The inside man I wanna dance with Some...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.