Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
It Just Makes Sense
Welcome to “It Just Makes Sense!” the podcast by two easily distracted higher educated former lovers that explores all of the unpopular opinions, conspiracy theories and cult leaders that make you want to scream “THAT JUST MAKES SENSE!”
Author
Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 10, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Chit Chat Episode 33: The Wild Wonderful Whites of West Virginia, Dygnus Day and a list of words to reitire! 20.04.2022 34:53
On this week's Chit Chat Jeff finally watched the Wild Wonderful Whites of West Virginia. 7 out of 5 that's wilds. This documentary is just out of this world wild. Sam recaps her weekend away with her Best Friends (eye roll) in Seneca falls and Ithaca. Jeff reminisces about Dyngus Days gone bye! Then the hosts debate a list of words millennials should retire. The wild wonderful whit...
Episode 86 The Death of Cooper Harris 15.04.2022 23:37
Episode 86 is about Justin Ross Harris and the death of Cooper Harris. Cooper was left in a hot car as Justin Harris went into work. Cooper succumbed to the high temperatures and died in the hot car. Justin claims to have forgotten that his son was in the back of his car because it wasn't his day to take him to daycare. There are some weird aspects and holes in this case. Did he do it in...
Chit Chat Episode 32 Don't be tardy for the party! 13.04.2022 33:56
On this week's chit chat, Jeff recaps his tattoo appointment. Brittany is pregnant and Prince Harry is ready to spill the tea about poor Camilla. Sam and Jeff are bigggg Camilla Stans. Our hosts in shining armor then discuss their extremely social weekends and are just exhausted by all the socializations. Armchair Expert w/ Dax Sheppard Lurlene McDaniel Books The Ultimatum
Episode 85 The Death of Sharon Williams and the Disappearance of Walter Notheis 08.04.2022 31:25
Episode 85 is about the death of Sharon Williams and the disappearance of Walter Notheis. Sharon Williams was a mother of 2 grown sons that died in what seemingly was a tragic car accident. But St. Louis County Deputy Cokeland knew this wasn't just a normal accident. Three years after the case was solved, he reached out to the New St Louis County medical examiner to reexamine the case. Dr...
Chit Chat 31 Breakups Tacos and Traumatic Events 06.04.2022 23:21
This week's chit chat Jeff's back on the market as Deuces says deuces to seeing him. The dramatic duo spent lots of time together taking in the arts and enjoying some fine Mexican cuisine. Taqueria Ranchos Dos To Kill A Mockingbird
Episode 84 The Death of Kurt Cobain 01.04.2022 44:39
Episode 84 is about the untimely death of Nirvana front man Kurt Cobain. It was ruled a suicide in 1994. Sam covers the documentary Soaked in Bleach in which Tom Grant is hired by Courtney Love to find Kurt. Was it a suicide or did Cobain suffer a more nefarious fate?
Chit Chat 30 Relient K and the slap heard round the world! 30.03.2022 31:07
On Chit Chat this week Sam and Jeff talk about Sam's trip to the Relient K concert. She had the time of her 2004 self's life! Jeff ate everything at brunch and saw the Lost City. Jeff recaps the oscars then the terrible twosome chat about the biggest slap since Stephen slapped Irene.
Episode 83: The Disappearance of Melissa Caddick 25.03.2022 27:55
Episode 83 is about the story of Melissa Caddick. She's an Australian financial advisor who promised her friends and family heaps and heaps of cash. Until one day under the suspicion of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) went missing. Was she abducted? Was she murdered? Was it suicide or is she still alive?
Chit Chat 29 Jussie Smollett, Amanda Bynes and The Derrick Sisters 22.03.2022 25:58
This week's chit chat is all about TV, TV and more TV. Sam and Jeff recap their weekends, chit chat about Amanda Bynes, The Derek Sisters and the 7M Cult, and Jussie Smollet. Sam's watching Is it Cake, the wild and wonderful whites of West Virginia and Jeff's crushing on Sandra Oh in Killing Eve and Octavia Spencer in Truth be told!
Episode 82: The Disappearance and Murder of Caylee Anthony 18.03.2022 54:44
Episode 82 is about the disappearance and death of Caylee Anthony. She was a 3-year-old little girl living with Mother Casey, and grandparents George and Cindy. She was missing for a month when her grandmother reported her missing. This story has fake nannies, missed leads and lies. LOTS of LIES!
Chit Chat 28: Doors or Wheels? Shift or Caps Lock? Sam or Jeff? 16.03.2022 28:37
This week's chit chat Jeff's watching some movie's Death on the Nile, and The Batman. Batman's 3 effing hours long but he was in it for the long haul and Death on the Nile is a good ole campy time. Sam's watching sports reailty tv, weird. They chat about a delightful brunch, he sadly forgot to mention his brunch dates and he is FOREVER apologetic for it. His lovely gu...
Episode 81: The disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit 11.03.2022 35:30
This week's episode covers the disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit. Jodi was a young, well liked morning anchorwoman is Mason City, Iowa. There were several men investigated in the case. The case goes cold and a recent tip brings the disappearance back into the news. Detective Terrance Prochaska believes he knows who did it and can't wait to slap the cuffs on em. BUT WHO DONE IT!
Chit Chat 27: Just Say Gay Gay Gay! 09.03.2022 24:11
This week's chit chat we say gay gay gay! Down with the don't say gay bill. Jeff's second date went swimmingly, and there's a third on the way. Woot Woot! Sam and Jeff talk about their book reads and Jeff is hooked. He's obsessed with a trashy gay romance/suspense novel. They recap their weekends, brunch and birthday parties! Does Sam need therapy? Jeff already goes...
Episode 80: The Murder of Rayna Rison 03.03.2022 30:04
This week's episode we're talking about the murder of Rayna Rison. Rayna's boyfriend was supposed to meet her after work one night and when he showed she wasn't there, and neither was her car! Not long after her body was found in a nearby creek. There were so many suspects, but the case went cold. Fast forward to the future and a jail house snitch helps solves the crime!
Chit Chat 26: Sam's wild weekend, and Jeff has a first date! 03.03.2022 32:58
This week's chit chat Sam was a social butterfly this weekend and it was just downright exhausting. Birthday party, Drag Brunch and Book Club.. she's just tired. A little Grindr true crime story. AND duh duh duhhhh Jeff goes out on a date with a nice Christian Man. Surge Restaurant - 2878 Delaware Avenue. Kenmore, NY 14217 Licorice Pizza - don't waste your time Pam and Tommy -...
Episode 79: The Murder of Diane Zaleski 25.02.2022 30:35
This week's episode is about the murder of Diane Zaleski. It's a brutal, heinous assault and murder. This case takes some wild twists and turns and there are so many suspects. BUCKLE UP! And once again Jeff is jumping to conclusions with who he thinks did it. When will he ever learn!
Episode 25: Movies, Movies and more Movies, and Jeff gets a little hot under the collar 23.02.2022 27:10
On this week's Chit Chat Jeff and Sam recap some movies they've seen. Jeff's hit 2 of the best picture nominees so far, Dune and The Power of the Dog, and Sam hit up uncharted. They have a heated debate over the improper use of DNA in a California Burglary case and Jeff is SHOCKED and APALLED while Sam tried a delightful new coffee shop. Best Picture Movies: Dune 5/10 The Power of...
Episode 78: The Case of Julie Rae Harper 18.02.2022 32:31
This week's episode Julie Rae Harper is accused of Killing her 10 year old son. She says she bursted into her son's bedroom to see a strange man stabbing him over and over. BUT the evidence seems to point in another direction, HERS! This case takes a WILD turn after someone is convicted. A true crime novelist gets invovled with the help of a death row inmate.
Chit Chat 24: Jerry Harris, Pamela Moses, The Tinder Swidler, Jeff's Conman Ex-Boyfriend 16.02.2022 26:05
This week's chit chat covers the plea deal for Jerry Harris and the outrageous conviction of Pamela Moses. We chat about our super bowl pics, the tinder swindler, inventing Anna episode 1, and love blind season 2. And yet again Jeff's delusional about a guy at the grocery store. Waxlight Bar a Vin - 27 Chandler St. All Boys Aren't Blue - George M Johnson
Episode 77- The Murder of Chris Pitcock 11.02.2022 30:39
This Week's Episode covers Episode 3 Kids Behind Bars Life or parole (AE/Hulu). On March 4, 2010, 17-year-old Timothy Preston Chavers was one of three teens involved in the murder of Christopher Pitcock during an attempted robbery in Fort Walton Beach, Florida. Along with the other teens, Preston was sentenced to life without parole. He then was granted a request for a parole hearing. Do we...
Chit Chat 23: Queens, Queens and More Queens! 09.02.2022 26:00
This week's chit chat Sam and Jeff play a couple true crime trivia. There's a new Queen in town hip hip hooray for Camilla! Jeff's talks a little bit about his past life as a thief. They wrap it up with what they're watching and eating. The Gypsy Parlor - 376 Grant St, Buffalo, NY Rupaul's Drag Race Season 14 Rupaul's Drag UK vs The World The Woman in the House acr...
Episode 76: The murder of Rosalyn Caldwell, Kids behind Bars: Episode 4 03.02.2022 28:51
This week's episode we talk about the murder and attempted murder of Rosalyn and Vernon Caldwell. Fifteen-year-old Bobby Gonzalez is manipulated into killing his girlfriend's parents. Krissy Caldwell gives Bobby her father's gun and pushes him to pull the trigger. Mrs. Caldwell is shot and killed in her sleep while Mr. Caldwell survives. This episode follows episode 4 of Kids be...
Chit Chat Lauren Smith Fields, LA, Donuts, Dicks and Drinks, 02.02.2022 39:04
This week's chit chat Sam and Jeff discuss the death of Lauren Smith Fields. They recap their trip to LA they survived! The theme of their trip was Donuts, Dicks and Drinks. They completed the Vanderpump trifecta, saw a drag show, a musical, and watched football. They wrap it up with what they watched during their covid quarantine. I am Jonas - Netflix The Betty White Tribute Show - NBC Oz...
Chit Chat 21 Pig Hearts, Scream, Kobra Kai and Planning for LA 26.01.2022 31:30
This week's chit chat we give updates on the pig heart transplant and THERE IS CONTROVERSY. We debate an interesting sexual conundrum. Talk about plans for our trip to Los Angeles and Jeff saw the new scream, it's a must see for Scream fans! Scream Cobra Kai Cheer Season 2 The Howling Rooster C1 Nails Neighbor's Pub
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.