Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
It Just Makes Sense
Welcome to “It Just Makes Sense!” the podcast by two easily distracted higher educated former lovers that explores all of the unpopular opinions, conspiracy theories and cult leaders that make you want to scream “THAT JUST MAKES SENSE!”
Author
Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 10, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Chit Chat 57 Cigs, Donuts, Weed and Farts 19.10.2022 30:18
This week the terrible twosome spent some time in Ellictoville partying it up for some friends' 40th birthdays. Dancing, Dranking, Smoking and Fartin! Sam has been a content machine, watched the entire season of the watcher. Jeff tuned in for season 3 of big sky to see his FAV QUEEN SUPREME REBA MCENTIRE! They wrap up with a little hot goss. The Watcher Big Sky Season 3
Episode 112 The Evidence Indeed and without a doubt 14.10.2022 39:38
Episode 112 is about the Netflix series The Evidence: Indeed and without a doubt! This episode investigates the 1990 abduction and murder of Courtney Smith. Levon Brooks was convicted of the crime based on bite mark analysis. Meanwhile another 3-year-old girl Christine Jackson, goes missing in a nearby town and is found dead with similar bite marks. Another man Kenndey Brewer was convicted on...
Chit Chat 56 Bros! 12.10.2022 27:53
This week's chit chat Sam and Jeff go on a day full of adventure! He's hangry but eventfully gets a taco and sees bros! Sam turns into a Karen about admission to the Buffalo Zoo. Some Halloween gathering where they WERE promised pictures with the Sanderson sisters, but THEY LOST THEM. Bros Reasonable Doubt Abducted in plain sight The Luckiest Girl Alive
Episoode 111 The Murder of Misti Mayo 07.10.2022 28:55
Episode 111 is about the murder of Misti Mayo. Misti Mayo and Christine Smith were two Texas teenage girls that became the best of friends. They supported each through miscarriages, births and being kicked out of the family home. Christine even helped raise Misti’s baby boy Dante! One night after a party at the girls' apartment a group of boys including Misti’s baby daddy robbed a tired s...
Chit Chat 55 Jeff's back from Vacayyyy 05.10.2022 33:28
Jeff's back from a couple weekends away to return to his post as the lead on chit chit! Thanks to Big T for filling in. Jeff went to meet his new boss and coworkers in Cleveland. Then went to the bills game in Baltimore with his good Judy, Cheryl. Sam consumed so much content she basically a pop culture influencer now.
Episode 110: The Murder of Thomas and Jackie Hawks 30.09.2022 31:50
Jennifer Henderson thought she had struck the dating jackpot when she stumbled upon Skylar Deleone's on line dating profile. He seemed kind. charming and former child actor, what more could a girl want? But as Skylar's inability to hold a job started to drown them in debt, Skylar did what he thought was the best option for his family, buy a 500,000 yacht for them all to live on. What...
Chit Chat 54 Big T Energy 28.09.2022 30:02
This weeks chit chat is co-hosted by big time listener, long time fan -- BIG T --THERESE KURTZ. Jeff is away practicing self care with a massage so we're left to our own girl gang! This episode is recorded from the car --Carpool Karaoke style and covers everything to how Therese is a snitch and why she'll be single for the rest of her life. Listen now!
Episode 109: Lori Vallow - Sins of our Mother 23.09.2022 1:08:18
This week's episode is about the Lori Vallow or doomsday mother documentary Sins of Our Mother. Lori was an extremist Mormon, who's children went messing. While authorities were searching for her 2 young children., Lori ran away to marry Chad Daybell a widower whose wife died under suspicious circumstances. Buckle up this religious documentary is a WILD RIDE with a lot of characters. ...
Chit Chat 53 Mormons, and High Blood Pressure 21.09.2022 30:41
On this week's chit chat Jeff's is accosted by 2 young hot Mormon missionaries as he arrived to record the pod. The hotties in black and white got a little more than they bargained for, stopping Jeffrey. Sam watched a league of their own, and the do revenge. Jeff is doing the reading this week, wholly enthralled in The Missing American. Sam finally reads a book that Jeff read A schoo...
Episode 108: I dated a Psycho, Candy Williams 16.09.2022 32:14
Episode 108 is about Hulu's I dated a Psycho. This episode follows Candy Williams, a midwestern transplant living a quiet life as a 2nd grade teacher is St. Petersburg, Florida. She thrives in her job but is searching for love. She spends her free time on the beach and as luck would have it, one day she meets a wonderful hottie named Joe Collier. Was she lucky? Was it the man of her dre...
Chit Chat 52 #justiceforCamilla 13.09.2022 32:44
This Week's Chitty Chat Jeff's out at the drag shows again. Sam meets with some disapprovin glances. Sam went off to the P Town and Martha's Vineyard for Cam and some friend's birthdays. Jeff watched the patient and Sam read "I'm Glad My Mom Died" by Jennette McCurdy. SHE was OBESSED 5/5 that's wilds. THEN they mourn the passing of the Queen and Celebrat...
Episode 107 Where is Richard Simmons!? 09.09.2022 32:43
Episode 107 is about the disappearance of Richard Simmons. Richard Simmons vanished from the public eye in 2014 and no one truly knows why. Sam followed the TMZ documentary What Happened to Richard Simmons? Was it weight gain? Is he dead? Did he Transition? Tune in and let us know what you think!
Chit Chat 51 A Fun Filled Chit Chat Weekend with one of our main B*tches! 07.09.2022 37:52
This week's chit chat one of our biggest fans Rachel in Ohio comes in for the weekend! We made stops at the chicken wing fest, the colony cigar bar and lounge, the maid of the mist, and the black party at Club Marcella. Sam put in a marathon of day drinking and rallied for a full weekend. Tune in for the gory details! The Devil in Ohio Black Summer Look Both Ways
Epsiode 106 The Murder of Janet Abaroa 02.09.2022 35:34
This Week's episode we cover Fatal Flaws A 2020 Edition. Janet Abaroa was stabbed to death in 2005, in Durham, North Carolina. She was discovered by her husband Raven Abaroa. Investigators had a difficult time pinpointing a suspect. There really weren't any solid leads. The case goes cold for years and then due to some unusual actions by a suspect, they're narrowed in on.
Chit Chat 50 Overdue Library Books 31.08.2022 27:23
This week's Chit Chat Jeff back in the Gay, Single and over 30 world. He recounts the BEST STEAK he's ever had. A Waygu beef steak from Prescott Provisions that was Muy DELICIOSO! He fully engaged watching lots on the Boob Tube. Sam did some celebrating with her MIL Deb! She's also thinking about suing her mole doctor for Malpractice! No not really BUT STILL! 5 Days at Memorial...
Episode 105 I Just Killed My Dad 26.08.2022 1:01:16
This week's episode we cover the Netflix documentary I Just Killed my dad as suggested by one of our biggest fans, Big T, Therese. Anthony Templet shot his father and never denied it. He wanted to just wound his dad so he could escape him. Was it premeditated murder or self-defense? And where was Anthony's Mom? Stepmom? Grandparents? This one is more complicated than one would gues...
Episode 104: The Murder of Reeva Steenkamp 19.08.2022 28:50
Happy 2 YEARS YA'LLLLLLLLLLLL and they said it would never last! This week's episode is celebrating 2 years of It Just Makes sense oh and we covered the Murder of Reeva Steenkamp. South African famed paralympian Oscar Pistorious is alleged to have thought an intruder had broken into his home. He fired multipe shots into the bathroom where his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp was hiding behi...
Chit Chat 49 The Fried Pickle Incident Heard Round the Fair 17.08.2022 34:54
On this week's Chit Chat the terrible twosome chat about the Erie County Fair. Sam wayyyy over sold it, but there were some delicious eats and a funny incident involving a pickle! Sam's terrible awful no-good summer continues with an unfortunate accident at the gym. Jeff plays his best round of golf of the year and SHE JUST DOESNT CARE!
Episode 103 The Murder of Dolana Clark 11.08.2022 38:57
This week's episode we discuss another episode of Unusual Suspects called Little Girl Gone. This week's episode we're in Great Falls Montana unfortunately for the Murder of Dolana Clark. Little 9-year-old Dolana wanted a Siamese cat from the local pet store. She worked all summer to save the money but was a little bit short. She went home to get the money from her dad, but he...
Chit Chat 48 Ok, Ok, I uploaded the wrong file... IM SORRY! 10.08.2022 28:45
This week Jeff's back from vacation and he's hot to trot. He has a dilemma and he's not sure if he should be offended. He watched two seasons of shows on Apple TV, BlackBird, and The Other Girls. He played a successful golf tournament with his Dad and went to the National Comedy Museum and The Lucy and Desi Museum. Sam had a melt down at Orion's Story. She can't hack...
Episode 102: Misha and The Wolves 05.08.2022 38:31
Episode 102 is about the Story of Misha and the Wolves. Misha was a holocaust survivor, who walked from Belgium to Germany to find her family. As she was making her trek, she was taken in by a pack of wolves and raised by them. Or was she? Misha got a book and movie deal. She was big celebrity in Europe and almost made it on Oprah. Then her fascinating story fell apart. BUT HOW AND WHY?!
Chit Chat 47 Ivana Trump is buried where?! 02.08.2022 29:23
On Chit Chat this week double trouble chat about poor Ivana Trump's grave site. Shakira and Ricky Martin's legal troubles and some local shocking true crime. Sam can't handle chewing and loud music and had some delicious eats. Froth Brewing The Grey Man
Episode 101 The Absent Teacher 29.07.2022 36:24
Episode 101 is about the hulu show unusual suspects, the episode titled the Absent Teacher. In 1993, an elementary school teacher goes missing after her first day at a new job. Over the next two months, investigators sift through clues, piecing together the heartbreaking truth behind the young educator's sudden disappearance.
Chit Chat 46 Annnnddd IIIII will always Love you 27.07.2022 28:26
This week's chit chat we're thinking about a new opening. Any suggestions? We talk about our riveting weekends. Jeff is OBSESSED with a Dolly Parton documentary. She's just lovely and undoubtedly a national treasure. Sam has a little drama with Cameron going out with "the boys" . Jeff's sister has some unsettling condiments in her refrigerator, which leads to an...
Episode 100 The Girl in the Picture 22.07.2022 49:09
Episode 100 Ya'll!! Do you believe we made it this far? This episode we cover the documentary The Girl in The Picture. An exotic dancer Tonya Hughes get assaulted, ends up in the hospital and dies. Some of Tonya's friends try to locate her next of kin and they find her mother. The mother in turn says she had died years ago. SO WHO IS THIS TONYA! This documentary goes on twists and...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.