I Think Not!

Tim and Larissa Schuster are a successful couple in Clovis, California. Larissa owns a thriving biochemistry lab, while Tim works at a hospital and manages their home and two kids. The Schuster marriage appears to be a perfect example of "opposites attract"--she's a bubbly go-getter, and he's shy and sensitive. But after 20 years, the many differences in their personalities strain to the breaking...

Elisa McNabney was living the high life in Sacramento, CA. Her husband Larry was a successful personal injury attorney, and since Larry's many TV commercials featured him in western gear, he was known as "The Marlboro Man. COME SEE US ON TOUR!!!!  Join us for "Road Trip 2023" this June as we travel to New Orleans, St. Louis, Pittsburgh, San Francisco, and Phoenix!!! This Week's Sponsors:  HelloFre...

This episode feature two stories of wives who weren't who they appeared to be. First, 30-year-old Ann Miller of Raleigh, NC seemed to have it all: a great job, a handsome husband and a beautiful baby. COME SEE US ON TOUR!!!!  Join us for "Road Trip 2023" this June as we travel to New Orleans, St. Louis, Pittsburgh, San Francisco, and Phoenix!!! This Week's Sponsors:  Lomi - Turn your food waste in...

Hey, DB's!! We have a VERY special guest this episode - our favorite narrator Christopher! He absolutely LOVED being in the studio with us... [narrator voice] he did not love being in the studio with them...JK!! ENJOY! On December 23rd 2009, Beth von Steinner goes missing. Days later, her frozen body is found in a trash pile behind her house. With no witness or suspects, only CCTV footage can unlo...

On September 17th 2015, Edward Lowry is found savagely beaten and stabbed to death in a parking lot in South Dakota. With little evidence left behind at the scene, the police attempt to piece together Ed's last moments from CCTV. This Week's Sponsors:  Skylight Frames - Get 10% off your frame when you go to skylightframe.com/NOT Lumi Labs - To learn more about microdosing THC go to microdose.com a...

A woman's New Year's disappearance leads to a gruesome discovery; with no witnesses, only the four security cameras from her apartment building can help decipher what happened. This Week's Sponsors:  Rocket Money - Cancel unwanted subscriptions and manage your expenses the easy way by going to RocketMoney.com/think  BetterHelp - Visit betterhelp.com/ithinknot today to get 10% off your first month ...

Cynthia Langrall is shot dead during her morning jog through the normally peaceful Hillcrest Ranch neighborhood in Glendale, Arizona. Home surveillance footage enables detectives to identify the shooter's vehicle but will it be enough to catch the killer? This Week's Sponsors:  ZipRecruiter - True ZipRecruiter FOR FREE by going to ziprecruiter.com/think Lomi - Turn your food waste into dirt with t...

On April 12th 2008, Susan Casey vanishes after a night out. The only clues left behind are suspicious drag marks outside her home. CCTV footage reveals three different suspects on the scene. Which one is lying and who can tell police where Susan Casey is? This Week's Sponsors:  Rothy's - For stylish and sustainable shoes, shop Rothy's. Get $20 off your first purchase at rothys.com/ITHINKNOT Helix...

Earlier this year, author Jaret Kobec named a new suspect to be the Zodiac Killer. This was based on years of research which uncovered never before seen evidence and answered many of the open questions in the case. Kobec's evidence for his suspect is so compelling that many true crime heavyweights have staked their reputations on their belief that Kobec has identified the Zodiac Killer once and fo...

In 2016, Jordie Hudson vanishes after a night out with friends. The only clue police have is her glasses, which are discovered in a pool of blood. Surveillance footage shows a horrific attack. Can police find her abductor before it's too late? This Week's Sponsors:  Rocket Money - Manage your expenses the easy way by going to rocketmoney.com/think Smalls - Head to smalls.com/thinknot and use promo...

Caught in a love triangle, young chef and mom Heather Mallory vanishes. Now Portland detectives and Heather's parents search for the truth in an investigation involving wiretaps, confidential informants, and a dramatic resolution deep in the forest. This Week's Sponsors:  BetterHelp: Visit betterhelp.com/ithinknot today to get 10% off your first month  Liquid IV: Get 20% off when you go to LiquidI...

When Ed Postma, a Florida truck driver with a bad boy reputation, meets single mom Jackie Rosser, sparks fly. But when Ed straightens out to become a family man, new bad boys are waiting, and the spark dies, taking another casualty as collateral damage. This Week's Sponsors: Prose: Go to prose.com/think for your FREE in-depth hair consultation and 15% off  ZipRecruiter: Try ZipRecruiter for FREE a...

Hey, DBs!!  We're so thrilled that Crimes of the Centuries from the Obsessed Network is back for Season 3!  Join host Amber Hunt each week as she dives deep into a case that was huge when it happened but somehow got lost to time.  These cases may not be remembered, but their impact on society lives on. Today we're sharing the first part of the Season 3 premiere, featuring the story of the Victoria...

Budding New York fashion designer Jenae Aragosa falls hard for bartender Trevor Frederick; a dark side of her new man comes to light and she realizes she'll be lucky if she makes it out of the relationship alive. This Week's Sponsors:  Daily Harvest - Go to dailyharvest.com/thinknot to get up to $40 off your first box. Helix - Go to helixsleep.com/think for up to 20% off all mattress orders AND tw...

Seventeen-year-old Mandy Boardman is courted by a man twice her age, David Wise, who played on her softball team. It seemed she had met her perfect match. After the pair wed, it wasn't long before Mandy realized David was playing a vile game of his own. This Week's Sponsors: Stamps.com - Sign up with promo code THINKNOT for a special offer that includes a 4-week trial, free postage and a free digi...

Rebecca has hooked quite a catch with shy, wealthy software engineer Bruce. But when she begins a tawdry affair with a sultry stripper named Steve, Rebecca's deadly dance will bend this love triangle out of shape and lead to cold-blooded murder. This Week's Sponsors: Pretty Litter: Go to PrettyLitter.com/THINK to save twenty percent on your first order Babbel: Right now, get up to 55% off your sub...

In 1994, Kim Groves was gunned down in her front yard after Len Davis, a police officer who did side-work in dealing cocaine, ordered her death because she knew too much. A sting operation caught Davis ordering Groves' death, but it was too late. This Week's Sponsors:   Helix: Helix is offering up to 20% off all mattress orders AND two free pillows for our listeners! Go to helixsleep.com/THINK Car...

I Killed My BFF is a pretty straightforward show title, but the story in this episode is messy as can be: Alabama party boys and best friends Butch Hampel and Richard Terry meet while working at the local paper mill. The two are inseparable bachelors and roommates living the good life, until a woman comes between them. This week's sponsors: Liquid I.V. - Grab your Liquid I.V. in bulk nationwide at...

Welcome to Dates From Hell, a show about a topic we can all relate to... brought to the extreme. This episode is certainly a doozy so buckle up, babes: Loved-up duo Richard and Luis spend a night at a glitzy nightclub in New York, where a seemingly innocuous decision has far-reaching tragic consequences. Haven't snagged your Obsessed Fest 2023 tickets yet? What are you waiting for? Early Bird pric...

We're exploring the show Unraveled in this episode. Season 2 episode 3 "A Beautiful Mind" tells a complex story that was hard not to get emotional about, but we're in this together team: Brilliant mathematician Chris Krumm gets some shocking news and starts to spiral out of control. Then, he writes a bizarre note and devises a plan to solve his troubles. This week's sponsors: BetterHelp - This epi...

We're tackling the "Idol Worship" episode from Stalked: Someone's Watching so get ready for lots of outlandish singing: A talent show contestant gains a new fan who starts calling her non-stop, turning the thrill of fame into sheer terror. How far will he go to possess her? This week's sponsors: Caraway - Visit Carawayhome.com/THINKNOT and use code THINKNOT at checkout to take advantage of their l...

Welcome listeners, first-time and long-time, to our inaugural episode of I Think Not! We're kicking things off with the harrowing stories of Mary Kay Beckman, Steven Lane, and the toxic people they dated from I Dated A Psycho: A man's dream of romance with an NFL cheerleader is thwarted by death threats. Also, a woman winds up in danger after trying to find love in Las Vegas. This week's sponsors:...

Surprise folks! We're bidding farewell to Disappeared with a return to where this podcast started. Enjoy a newly redone version of our pilot with current AND former hosts Ellyn, Joey and Patrick! In Tyler, Texas, 23-year-old Brandi Wells disappears after going to a nightclub. It takes five days for investigators to link her disappearance to a car abandoned on the side of a highway, and they must s...

When 23-year old Lauryn Garrett vanishes after calling her father for a ride home, the family embark on a journey to find her and uncover startling clues linked to her past. JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL BONUS EPISODES PER MONTH! Right now there are over 50 full ad-free bonus episode to download and binge right this second! Including our coverage of "I Almost Got Away With it",...

The big news has finally arrived people! We're rebranding! Welcome to I Think Not! Give the trailer a listen, and enjoy a description of the new show below: From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast Obsessed with Disappeared, you’ll love this new show from co-hosts...