Robinson Ralph

Having A NatteRR

Business EN ↓ 109 episodes

Welcome to the Robinson Ralph podcast in which we discuss recent cases from the fascinating world of Employment Law. With an educational and entertaining spin for listeners along the way, this podcast is sure to leave you wanting more. If you wish to contact us then please email us at info@robinsonralph.com

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: rrp.podbean.com

Author

Robinson Ralph

Category

Business

Podcast website

rrp.podbean.com

Latest episode

Nov 10, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Series 10 Episode 4 09.04.2024

In this episode, Simon and David discuss the case of McLaren V Hiflow Property Services, a pregnancy discrimination case in which the Claimant won and received a £22k reward. They look at what respondent did wrong in terms of case preparation, talk through the judgment and look at the lessons all employers can learn from this. It also includes the ever-popular ‘banter bit’ in which Dave discusses...

Series 10 Episode 3 07.03.2024

In this week’s episode of Having a NatteRR, David and Simon discuss the case of In Richardson v West Midlands Trains Ltd, in which the Claimant won his claim of unfair dismissal after being sacked for played two pranks, involving placing, firstly, a tarantula’s shed exoskeleton, and, subsequently, a snakeskin in a colleague’s pigeonhole. The  Tribunal ordered the Respondent to pay the Claimant £22...

Series 10 Episode 2 22.02.2024

In the second episode of this series of Robinson Ralph’s Having a Natter podcast, David and Simon discuss the case of Ms Lad v Lily Head Dental Practice. The Claimant in this case was removed from a work whatsapp group whilst on maternity leave and brought a claim for maternity leave discrimination. There were other aspects to the case, but that is the aspect they focus on; there are lessons to be...

Series 10 Episode 1 19.02.2024

In this episode, the first of a new series of Robinson Ralph’s Having a NatteRR podcast, Simon and David discuss the case of Muir v AstraZeneca, where the employee was dismissed in December 2020 for misconduct relating to bullying and harassment. The Tribunal criticised the employer for failing to have due regard to Mr Muir’s mental health disability, which had impacted on his behaviour. The tribu...

Having a NatteRR - Series 9 Episode 1 16.06.2023

This week, Simon and David discuss the case of P v Crest Nicholson Operations Ltd. It's a truly awful case of sexual harassment and vicarious liability relating to a manager's behaviour both during and after a works organised party. David and Simon raise the importance of both reminding employees that they are still subject to codes of conduct at work dos and also the requirement to challenge bad...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 10 25.05.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the EAT case of Mr Darrell Miles v Driver and Vehicles Standards Agency. They focus on the Health and Safety detriment and dismissal aspect of the claim, which arose because of the Covid-19 pandemic. The question in the case was whether the Claimant reasonably believed there were circumstances that placed him in serious and imminent danger. The case also had to co...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 9 18.05.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of D Martin v Jet Maintenance Limited. They discuss the Claimant’s summary dismissal ‘in the heat of the moment’ during an altercation with a co-owner of the business. The facts of that altercation were disputed. The Claimant acknowledged swearing but denied acting in an aggressive manner. An internal Hearing was then carried out to hear the allegations i...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 8 20.04.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Maxwell v HBOS Plc. The Claimant had a long-term sickness absence and the Tribunal had to consider whether that was sufficient reason for dismissal. They discuss the Tribunal’s considerations in respect of whether a fair process had been conducted. The Tribunal concluded that the Claimant was in an entrenched position with a loss of faith in the Respon...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 7 31.03.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Mrs Dumigan v The Mount School Limited. All staff members were requested by email on a Saturday to attend a meeting on Monday. This was a day off for the Claimant and she was due to meet her family to discuss the care of her elderly mother suffering with cancer. Following the Claimant raising that she could not attend the meeting, she was told it was n...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 6 23.03.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Mr Bryce v Sentry Consulting Limited. The Claimant suffered with Asperger’s Syndrome and Dyslexia. As a result of his condition the Claimant’s timekeeping and ability to plan ahead were impacted. The Respondent decided not to offer more shifts to the Claimant following his lateness and performance on site, namely not monitoring the site, spending time...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 5 09.03.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Ian Drury v Ministry of Defence. The Claimant succeeded with claims of Unfair and Wrongful Dismissal. The Claimant stated he had suspended himself and there were concerns for the Claimant’s mental ill health. The Claimant was then dismissed for gross misconduct relating to his absence without leave, irrespective of these concerns. They also discuss the...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 4 24.02.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Mrs V Nimoni v London Borough of Croydon. They discuss the successful claims for unfair dismissal, failure to make reasonable adjustments and discrimination arising from a disability. The Claimant worked as a Travel Trainer. The Claimant later became unable to work in this role because of her disability. They discuss the Respondent’s failure to make re...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 3 17.02.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Ms T Webb v London Underground Ltd, in which the Claimant alleged unfair dismissal and race discrimination. The Claimant’s dismissal was because of posts on social media that the Respondent determined were offensive, inflammatory, and racially divisive following the death of George Floyd, in breach of their policies and guidance. The Tribunal agreed wi...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 Episode 2 09.02.2023

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Earl Shilton Town Council v Ms K Miller. They discuss the Employment Appeal Tribunal judgment regarding the provision of inadequate toilet facilities for women. They discuss this in the context of the EAT finding that the Tribunal did not err in law in finding that this subjected the Claimant to direct sex discrimination. The case involved whether the...

Having a NatteRR - Series 8 - Episode1 01.02.2023

This week in the first episode of a brand-new series, Simon and David discuss the case of Mr A Tunnicliff v Baytree Car Sales and others. They discuss the case and the findings of unfair and wrongful dismissal. They also discuss the fact that the Respondent’s main witness was away on a cruise at the time of the Hearing, meaning that no live evidence was given on behalf of the Respondent, as well a...

Having a NatteRR - Series 7 Episode 3 03.11.2022

  This week Simon and David talk about the case of X v Y & Z, in which a female executive who was bombarded with peach emojis by her boss and was eventually awarded £420,000 after successfully claiming sex-related harassment and victimisation. We will discuss the harassment suffered by the claimant, as well as the problems the Respondent caused itself by its approach to the grievance investigation...

Having a NatteRR Series 7 Episode 2 25.10.2022

In this week’s case Simon and David discuss the case of Mr D Duployen v Whyte & Mackay Ltd. This week’s case reiterates the importance of properly exploring reasonable adjustments and working with an employee collaboratively to reduce the impact of their absences. They also consider how a blanket approach to absence management and trigger points will rarely be reasonable. The Tribunal in this case...

Having a NatteRR - Series 7 Episode 1 10.10.2022

In this week’s podcast Simon and David discuss the case of Mr D Finch v Clegg Gifford & Co Ltd and S Bellamy. The Claimant brought claims of direct discrimination and harassment on age and disability grounds, discrimination arising from a disability, failure to make reasonable adjustments and victimisation. Simon and David discuss the details of the claims, noting that not all claims succeeded. Th...

Having a NatteRR - Series 6 Episode 8 22.07.2022

This week on the podcast Simon and David discuss the case of Miss M Doran v Pearl Holdings NW Limited.  They discuss the Claimant's intermittent chronic migraines amounting to a disability and the Tribunal's finding of a failure to make reasonable adjustments by her employer.  They discuss this in the context of the Claimant's employer refusing to let the Claimant leave her shift early due to her...

Having a NatteRR - Series 6 Episode 7 12.07.2022

This week Simon and David discuss the case of Mrs Regnante v Essex Cares Ltd. We discuss the judgment upholding the Claimant’s Constructive (Unfair) Dismissal claim relating to the Covid-19 pandemic and the Claimant requesting to work from home due to her husband’s clinically extremely vulnerable status. We discuss the Tribunal’s assessment of the employer’s decision not to allow the Claimant to c...

Having a NatteRR - Series 6 Episode 6 29.04.2022

This week, Simon, David, and Imogen discuss the case of Miss Allen v Primark Stores Limited. We discuss the Claimant’s successful appeal to the EAT and the decision that in claims for indirect discrimination, the comparison pool should be matched to the relevant provision, criterion, or practice (PCP). The case involved the Claimant making a flexible working request and having a requirement impose...

Having a NatteRR- Series 6 Episode 5 18.03.2022

This week, Simon, David, and Imogen discuss the case of Catriona Robinson v Mind Monmouthshire Ltd. The former employee of Mind, mental health charity, succeeded in her claims for automatic unfair dismissal (public interest disclosures), failure to make reasonable adjustments and victimisation. We discuss the issues in the case, focussing on the need to address bullying and harassment in the workp...

Having a NatteRR - Series 6 Episode 4 01.03.2022

In the latest episode of this series, Simon, David, and Imogen discuss the case of Cassidy v Iceland Frozen Foods Ltd. The case involved the dismissal of Miss Cassidy for eating a chocolate bar and giving some to a customer, caught on CCTV, with the chocolate bar believed to be the stock of Iceland. We discuss the issues in the case, focussing on the flaws of the investigation conducted into the s...

Having a NatteRR - Series 6 Episode 3 23.02.2022

In the third episode of this series, Simon, David, and Imogen discuss the rules on taking evidence from abroad via video conference in the Employment Tribunal.    We discuss the case of Agbabiaka, which is about the process for what you need to do if witnesses you intend to call will be out of the country, but are otherwise available and willing to give evidence virtually. We also discuss the rele...

Having a NatteRR - Series 6 Episode 2 03.02.2022

In the second episode of our new series, Simon, David and Imogen discuss the Employment Tribunal case of Allette v Scarsdale Grange Nursing Home Ltd.   We discuss the case, including how a situation will be assessed when a mandatory vaccination requirement has been adopted by an employer before the appropriate legislation has been introduced to mandate that. We also discuss the relevance of the ca...

Listen to the Having A NatteRR podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.