Eric Rutin & Andrea Claassen
Hallmark Mysteries & More
The podcast Sleuthers can’t stop talking about. If you love Hallmark’s cozy whodunnits, sharp sleuths, and slow-burn romances, you’ve found your new favorite podcast. Hallmark Mysteries and More is the only podcast dedicated entirely to Hallmark’s beloved mystery movies and series, including fan-favorites like Mystery 101 , Aurora Teagarden , Curious Caterer , The Cases of Mystery Lane , Signed, Sealed, Delivered , and beyond. Hosted by real-life mystery buffs Andrea and Eric, each episode delivers smart, funny, and passionate deep dives into new releases and classic Hallmark mysteries. Expect...
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: hallmarkmysteriesandmore.com
Author
Eric Rutin & Andrea Claassen
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 20, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Our Review of Mystery 101: Playing Dead - Stage Frights & Sleuthing Delights 29.05.2025 29:46
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. The curtain is up, the body count is rising, and Amy and Travis are back in action! In this episode, Andrea and Eric review the second installment in Hallmark’s fan-favorite series Mystery 101 — Playing Dead . Set against the backdrop of a local theater production, this whodunnit brings drama on and off the stage. Andrea dives i...
(Updated) Our Review of Private Eyes: Mise En Place - Restaurant Rivalries & Right Hooks 27.05.2025 17:29
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week, Andrea and Eric return to Toronto for a full review of Private Eyes Season 1, Episode 2 – “Mise En Place” – where murder is on the menu and the restaurant world gets a spicy spotlight. The duo breaks down the episode’s culinary crime, character growth, and just the right amount of banter between Matt Shade and Angie E...
Mystery 101 Pilot Review – Does the Most Beloved Hallmark Mystery Still Hold Up? 22.05.2025 28:07
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. It’s the episode everyone has been waiting for—Eric and Andrea finally take on the pilot of Hallmark’s most beloved mystery series , Mystery 101 . Fans are fiercely loyal, emotions run high, and expectations are sky-high… so does the very first installment still earn its reputation as the gold standard of Hallmark whodunnits? In...
We reviewed Season 1, Episode 1 of Private Eyes—and we’re officially hooked. 20.05.2025 14:34
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this episode, Andrea and Eric lace up their skates and hit the ice as they review the first episode of Private Eyes , the Canadian mystery drama now gaining traction with Hallmark fans. Starring Jason Priestley and Cindy Sampson , the show kicks off with a compelling mix of hockey, heart, and a suspicious medical collapse tha...
Garden Gloves & Grave Secrets: Our Deep Dive Into Rosemary & Thyme Season 1! 15.05.2025 46:12
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Would YOU hire a pair of gardeners who seem to uncover a dead body at every job site? In this delightfully unhinged and wildly entertaining episode, Andrea and Eric dig into the British cozy classic Rosemary & Thyme , now streaming on Hallmark Movies Now and BritBox. From poisoned plants and slow-motion elevators to awkward...
Postmarked for the Moon: Reviewing Signed, Sealed, Delivered 08.05.2025 37:31
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week on Hallmark Mysteries and More , we’re zooming in on the Signed, Sealed, Delivered franchise with an in-depth review of To the Moon and Back . Is it a heartwarming hit or a confusing miss? Eric and Andrea break it down, sharing their thoughts on the movie’s gripping mystery, the emotional dynamics of the Postables, and...
My Hallmark Takeover: 5 Big Changes I’d Make If I Ran the Network 02.05.2025 25:19
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this special solo episode, Eric takes the reins—and the keys to the Hallmark Media kingdom—with five bold (and slightly fanatical) ideas that could revolutionize the network we all love. From network consolidation and smarter streaming to elevated mysteries and influencer-powered marketing, this episode is a passionate, funny...
Secret Societies, Plot Holes & A Surprisingly Cute Kiss – Reviewing Emma Fielding: More Bitter Than Death 29.04.2025 32:20
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week, Andrea and Eric complete their journey through the Emma Fielding Mysteries series with More Bitter Than Death —and it’s a wild ride! From secret societies under Keyser College to surprisingly entertaining (and unintentionally hilarious) fight scenes, they break down everything that worked—and everything that had them...
Spring Into… Red Flags? Our Take on Hallmark’s Latest Love Stories 🌸 25.04.2025 42:52
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this episode, Andrea and Eric tackle Hallmark’s Spring Into Love lineup—and let’s just say, it’s a bumpy ride through romance, red flags, and questionable plots. From Jenna’s First Love to Kiki’s Fourth Ingredient , they break down all four interconnected movies (plus Journey to You ) with their signature humor and honest tak...
Emma Fielding: Past Malice – Castles, Curses & Killer Twists 23.04.2025 33:50
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week, Andrea and Eric return to Hartley Castle for their review of Emma Fielding Mysteries: Past Malice , and this time—it’s personal (and possibly cursed). From improved character chemistry to surprise villain reveals, they break down why this second film in the Emma Fielding series is a big step up from the first. They di...
April Telek on Kindness, Chaos & Killer Roles (Literally!) 17.04.2025 1:07:24
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. She’s been a red herring, an accomplice, a therapist, and even a murderess—but no matter the role, April Telek brings heart, humor, and unforgettable energy. In this episode, Andrea and Eric sit down with the beloved Hallmark star for a wide-ranging, wildly entertaining conversation that covers everything from Garage Sale Myster...
Digging Into “Site Unseen” – Emma Fielding Mystery Review 15.04.2025 41:50
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this week’s episode, Andrea and Eric take a deep dive into Emma Fielding Mysteries: Site Unseen , the archaeology-themed Hallmark mystery that kicked off Courtney Thorne-Smith’s return to television in a leading role. They dig into everything—from questionable historical facts and subdued romance to that surprisingly action-p...
Marilu Henner - Hollywood Icon (Replay) 10.04.2025 52:26
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. To celebrate Hallmark Mystery airing Aurora Teagarden: A Lesson in Murder, we decided to replay this fantastic conversation with Marilu Henner. She shares so many amazing stories about her illustrious career as well as great BTS stories about playing Aida Teagarden. Enjoy. Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hal...
Aurora Teagarden – Reap What You Sew Review (and Maybe Snooze?) 08.04.2025 38:46
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this episode, Andrea and Eric dive into Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reap What You Sew —but does this cozy caper stitch together a satisfying story or unravel before the final scene? Spoiler alert: one of your hosts may have literally slept through the climax (twice). They discuss the absence of key characters like Martin and...
Kaitlyn Leeb Talks The Spencer Sisters, Heartland & Life On and Off Screen 03.04.2025 44:44
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. his week, Andrea and Eric are joined by the incredibly talented Kaitlyn Leeb , known to Hallmark fans as Lindsay from The Spencer Sisters and Bianca in Crossword Mysteries . Kaitlyn opens up about her acting journey—from competitive figure skater to Hallmark star—and shares heartfelt stories about her early auditions, behind-the...
British Mysteries, Good Witch Magic & A Holiday Football Fumble? 31.03.2025 45:31
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week, Andrea and Eric dive into the latest Hallmark news and bring plenty of laughs along the way! From the network’s big announcement about adding British mystery imports (hello, Rosemary & Thyme and Shakespeare & Hathaway !) to Good Witch: The Grey Lady Secrets getting the full nostalgic rewatch treatment, this ep...
Kylee Evans on Good Witch, Mistletoe Murders & Finding Strength Through Storytelling 27.03.2025 54:58
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week, we welcome the delightful Kylee Evans , beloved for her roles as Stephanie on Good Witch and Brooke on Mistletoe Murders . In this heartwarming and hilarious interview, Kylee opens up about her journey from small-town Nova Scotia to Hallmark stardom, shares behind-the-scenes stories from the Good Witch set, and gives...
Should You Watch A Fixer Upper Mystery – A Deadly Deed. We Watched It to Let You Know if You Shoul 24.03.2025 31:34
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this episode, Andrea and Eric take on the final installment of Hallmark Mystery Channel’s Fixer Upper Mystery trilogy: A Deadly Deed . Is it a satisfying finale or a crumbling renovation? The co-hosts dig into everything from plot pacing and character development to mismatched outfits and confusing casting choices. Andrea fin...
Inside the Mystery: Tess Atkins on Hallmark’s Hannah Swensen Series 21.03.2025 58:06
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. In this episode, we take a deep dive into the world of Hallmark mysteries with actor Tess Atkins , best known for her role as Michelle in the Hannah Swensen series. Tess shares her journey into acting, from childhood inspirations to landing roles in hit shows like Supernatural , The Flash , and of course, Hallmark’s beloved myst...
Crowns, Castles, and Chemistry: A Hallmark Royal Recap 19.03.2025 29:03
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Grab a cup of tea and settle in—this week, we’re diving into Hallmark’s latest royal rom-com lineup! From a Bostonian princess forced into an arranged marriage to a Philadelphia mechanic discovering his inner Duke, we’re ranking, reviewing, and royally roasting all the tiara-worthy moments Which leading lady stole the show? Did...
Murder, Mayhem, and Mystery Island: Breaking Down Hallmark’s Latest Whodunit. 17.03.2025 30:40
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Calling all Hallmark mystery fans! This week, we’re diving deep into Mystery Island: Winner Takes All , where a game of make-believe murder turns into the real deal. Was the latest installment a thrilling Agatha Christie-inspired closed-room mystery or just another predictable whodunit? Join hosts Eric and Andrea as they debate...
Peter Benson Talks Acting, Directing & Hallmark Mysteries 14.03.2025 51:42
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. This week, Andrea and Eric sit down with the one and only Peter Benson , a Hallmark favorite known for his work in both front of and behind the camera. From his extensive acting career—including Aurora Teagarden, Mystery 101, and The Chronicle Mysteries —to his growing success as a director, Peter shares behind-the-scenes storie...
Discussing A Fixer Upper Mystery: Concrete Evidence and Eric's Hallmark Conspiracy Theory 12.03.2025 29:39
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Is Hallmark about to shake up its network? Andrea and Eric dive into Conspiracy Corner to discuss the potential consolidation of Hallmark’s channels and what it could mean for mystery lovers. They also break down the second installment of Fixer Upper Mysteries , debating the eerie vibes, high school nostalgia, and unexpected twi...
Season Finale Deep Dive – The Way Home & The Spencer Sisters 10.03.2025 41:00
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. It’s time for a dramatic season finale discussion! In this episode, Andrea and Eric take their final dip into the pond—at least for now—as they break down the emotional and twist-filled ending of The Way Home Season 3. From time-traveling mysteries and unexpected revelations to standout performances by Jefferson Brown and Sadie...
Unraveling Hallmark Mysteries with Legendary Hallmark Writer: John Christian Plummer” 🎬🔍 07.03.2025 53:27
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. n this special episode, we sit down with Hallmark mystery mastermind John Christian Plummer , the writer behind Mystery 101 , Curious Caterer , and Mystery Island ! He takes us behind the scenes of his creative process, revealing how he crafts gripping whodunits while balancing Hallmark’s signature romance. Plummer also opens up...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.