Thomas Smith

Gavel Gavel

Gavel Gavel is the podcast that takes you inside the courtroom! Comedian Thomas Smith asks questions and cracks jokes while real legal experts with actual trial experience provide unique analysis.

Author

Thomas Smith

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

sites.libsyn.com

Latest episode

Jul 4, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Lively v. Baldoni 28 - Wayfarer's (Copied and Pasted) Countercomplaint 08.07.2025

There's lot of copy and paste in this one, but also some realllly interesting stuff. How is Wayfarer going to defend themselves against Stephanie Jones' incredibly straightforward and coherent case?  

Lively v. Baldoni 27 - More with More with MJ Morley on Jen Abel's Countercomplaint 06.07.2025

This will conclude Jen Abel's countercomplaint. Next, we'll be onto Wayfarer's countercomplaint!  

Lively v. Baldoni 26 - MJ Morley on Jen Abel's Counterclaims 05.07.2025

We're so lucky to have MJ Morley ( @morewithmj ) back on the show, this time to give us the legal breakdown of Jen Abel's counterclaims against Stephanie Jones and Jonesworks!  

Lively v. Baldoni 25 - "All of This Because Abel Dared to Leave Jonesworks" 02.07.2025

It's part 3 of Jen Abel's countercomplaint against Jones and Jonesworks!

Lively v. Baldoni 24 - Jen Abel KIDNAPPED! MISSING AND PRESUMED PHONELESS. 01.07.2025

We're in our alternate timeline to catch up on the bustling Jones v. Abel docket! It's part 2 of Jen Abel's Countersuit against Jones and Jonesworks.

Lively v. Baldoni 23 - Her Disarming Southern Twang 01.07.2025

*RECORD SCRATCH* Hey folks. We had to do a bit of a pivot for a really cool reason. That reason is, we're going to be interviewing Stephanie Jones' lawyers. But in order to do that, we need to catch you up on the Jones v. Abel docket. But that's still also good news, because this docket is really fascinating and honestly pretty fun to analyze. We tell you more about it in the outro to this episode...

Lively v. Baldoni 22 - The Great Subpoena Mystery SOLVED. - with MJ Morley 05.06.2025

GG22 - We're taking a slight detour from our docket order to bring you a very interesting resolution to the subpoena mystery. MJ Morley was kind enough to take us through it, AND give us some breaking news that possibly no one else has discovered!

Lively v. Baldoni 21 - The Contract Was neither Implied, nor in Fact. And It Wasn't a Contract. 03.06.2025

GG21 - Part 21 of LvB is Part 11 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times The FINAL part of Baldoni et al v. NYT! FINALLLY. Attorney Anne Linder takes us through the final 3 causes of action.  

Lively v. Baldoni 20 - Baldoni v. NYT v. Sullivan 01.06.2025

GG20 - Part 20 of LvB is Part 10 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times Now that we've finished the... facts... it's time to actually analyze the law, and to do that, we're going to summon our attorney Anne Linder! How do the legal claims in this complaint stack up? Is there any there there?  

Lively v. Baldoni 19 - He's Trying the Pumping Text a 3rd Time and We're in Literal Hell 25.05.2025

GG19 - Part 19 of LvB is Part 9 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times We've made it! The last parts of this complaint actually talk about The New York Times (you know, the defendant in this case) a little and we give our closing thoughts on the Wayfarer's telling of this whole story. Next up: LAWYER PORTAL! This is the complaint we're working from if you want to follow along. Support the show, ge...

Lively v. Baldoni 18 - What She Promised the Cast Remains Unclear 25.05.2025

GG18 - Part 18 of LvB is Part 8 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times We're getting closer and closer! Join us as we examine a number of 'graphs related to the editing bay, the different versions of the film, and other post-production goings-on, including Sony's response throughout. We also talk about the premiere from Baldoni's perspective from the theater's basement, and his engagement with Mel...

Lively v. Baldoni 17 - Signing a 17-Point List + Calling the 30-Point Version "Defamation" = Boy Math 24.05.2025

GG17 - Part 17 of LvB is Part 7 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times That's right! Let's hear how the Wayfarer folks present the 17-point list from Blake Lively's lawyers during the filming of It Ends With Us. Before we get into the attorney-drafted protections for return to production, we also dig into the Wayfarer spin on the circumstances when Lively alleged Baldoni and Heath did not respect...

Lively v. Baldoni 16 - An Increasingly Aggressive and Erratic Effort to Control the Production 24.05.2025

GG16 - Part 16 of LvB is Part 6 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times We dig into some key defenses from the Wayfarer parties, including Baldoni's intentions in asking a trainer on the film about Lively's weight, Lively's supposed production "takeover" through script revisions (and how her husband, Ryan Reynolds, was involved with those pages), as well as Wayfarer's position regarding Lively's co...

Lively v. Baldoni 15 - Blake Livelys Hate This One Weird Trick to Double Your Evidence by Repeating It 23.05.2025

GG15 - Part 15 of LvB is Part 5 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times We've made it through...the INTRODUCTION! There's plenty more to dig into, and this episode focuses on the behavior during post-production between the parties. Complete with more screenshots! Some are even legible! This is the complaint we're working from if you want to follow along. Support the show, get rid of ads, and get bo...

Lively v. Baldoni 14 - It's Not Retaliation If You Wait a Little While Until You Do It, Right? 23.05.2025

GG14  - Part 14 of LvB is  Part 3 of  Wayfarer et al v The New York Times We're moving along through this document and tackle some of Wayfarer's major talking points as they dispute Lively's characterization of the various conflicts. Simultaneously, Wayfarer's counsel continues to try to find something defamatory from the NYT article. Will they finally land on something in this episode? This is th...

Lively v. Baldoni 13 - He Said That She Said That She Said She Was Sexually Assaulted 22.05.2025

GG13 - Part 13 of LvB is Part 3 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times Let's get to some more 'graphs! The screenshots that are part of this section of the complaint highlight the seedy world of Hollywood tabloids and Public Relations personalities - its also the stuff that was "corrected" a couple of days later in a revised filing from Bryan Freedman, but we're sticking to the original so you, de...

Lively v. Baldoni 12 - The Emoji Heard Round the World 22.05.2025

GG12 - Part 12 of LvB is Part 2 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times Oh boy! We finally arrived for those who have heard the reference but have been unclear what it meant: the infamous emoji! What emoji was it, why was it missing from The New York Times article, does it matter that it's not there, and who bears the responsibility for its exclusion? We dig into the details as we continue through...

Lively v. Baldoni 11 - "But the Times Did Not Care" 21.05.2025

GG11 - Part 11 of LvB is Part 1 of Wayfarer et al v The New York Times On the same day that Blake Lively filed her legal complaint, Baldoni et al filed this complaint against the NYT for defamation and some other things. It is... something. It's very long. But we're dedicated to covering this the right way, so here we go! Join us as we delve into the Baldoni side of things for the first time!  Thi...

Lively v. Baldoni 10 - Lawyer MJ Morley Breaks Down the Law in Jones v. Abel, Part 2 31.03.2025

It's part 2 with MJ Morley! We've walked through the factual allegations of the Jones v Abel lawsuit, but we called in for legal reinforcements to walk us through the law! We are thrilled to be joined by MJ Morley ( @morewithmj ) who has extremely relevant experience in New York employment law, and has also been covering the Lively v Baldoni suits online from a neutral perspective and allowing the...

Lively v. Baldoni 9 - Lawyer MJ Morley Breaks Down the Law in Jones v. Abel 28.03.2025

We've walked through the factual allegations of the Jones v Abel lawsuit, but we called in for legal reinforcements to walk us through the law! We are thrilled to be joined by MJ Morley ( @morewithmj ) who has extremely relevant experience in New York employment law, and has also been covering the Lively v Baldoni suits online from a neutral perspective and allowing the facts to inform her positio...

Lively v. Baldoni 8 - Jonesin' for Breach of Contract Damages 24.03.2025

We finish our thorough review of the Jones v Abel complaint. In the next episode, we'll be speaking to a lawyer with expertise in this specific area of law in this jurisdiction. But from where we're sitting, this looks really bad for Abel et al... Support the show, get rid of ads, and get bonus stuff over on patreon.com/gavelpod!

Lively v. Baldoni 7 - Who's Afraid of Stephanie Jones? Well, Abel et al. Probably Should Be... 21.03.2025

While the It Ends with Us controversy carried out in front of the world, there was significant drama behind-the-scenes in the PR world, culminating in a breach of contract lawsuit filed against Jennifer Abel, Melissa Nathan, Justin Baldoni, and Wayfarer Studios. Lydia kicks off the episode with some background on the Plaintiffs in that suit - Stephanie Jones and Jonesworks - before we dive head fi...

Lively v. Baldoni 6 - Crisis PR Firms Are Literal Satan 20.03.2025

This begins a chunk of episodes on Jones v Abel. But you know us, we first need to lay a lot of foundation. After Blake Lively's CRD complaint and the story in the New York Times became public, folks spoke out in support of Lively, and expressed shock at the alleged actions of Justin Baldoni and the Wayfarer team. We detail the fallout in timeline order, and discuss the repercussions of Jennifer A...

Lively v. Baldoni 5 - Lawyer Reacts to Blake's Complaint 04.03.2025

It's high time we had some real law talkin folk back on this show. So, Anne Linder joins us to answer some of my law theories, including THE MISSING SUBPOENA, and then give us a breakdown of the legal claims in Blake's complaint. Anne talks us through the law on what Blake would need in order to prevail on each cause of action! Support the show, get rid of ads, and get bonus stuff over on patreon....

Lively v. Baldoni 4 - He Wants to Feel Like She Can Be Burned 28.02.2025

We finish out Blake's complaint talking about the alleged retaliatory campaign. Support the show, get rid of ads, and get bonus stuff over on patreon.com/gavelpod!

Listen to the Gavel Gavel podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.