Friends Who Crime

Egg (yes, Egg) and I discuss FWC's first serial killer case: the I-35 Killer. He operated in Texas and paid for it at the end- despite glaring missteps from the penal system.  Sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Eyler    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_McDuff    https://www.cga.ct.gov/2011/JUDdata/tmy/2011SB-01035-R000307-Keri%20O%27Creene,%20Principals%20of%20Sociology%20SOCH101,%20...

This week, I have Kaity back on the podcast! She's a perfect guest for the case of Billy Milligan. Milligan suffered from D.I.D. and his crimes were horrific. Kaity and I dive into how D.I.D. played into his crimes and his later acquittal. Follow the pod on instagram @friendswhocrime! Sources: "Billy Milligan." Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billy_Milligan. "The Crowded Roo...

This week on FWC, my dad, Kurtis, joins me as we unravel the chilling and perplexing Keddie Cabin Murders, a quadruple homicide that has haunted a small California mountain town for over four decades. In 1981, a horrific scene was discovered: a mother, her son, and his friend brutally murdered, while her 12-year-old daughter, Tina, was missing, only for her remains to be found years later. We'll d...

This week, my bestie Morgan joins me as we unravel the tragic, yet utterly wild, story of Selena Quintanilla's murder. We're diving deep into the Queen of Tejano's rise to superstardom and the shocking betrayal that cut her life short. Expect a heavy dose of meticulously researched details, a few gasps, and plenty of our signature laughs and jokes as we try to cope with the sheer absurdity of it a...

Gather 'round for our second special "campfire stories" edition! This week, I'm joined by the one and only Neiko as we delve into the chilling tales of Austin, Texas, from the haunted Littlefield House on UT campus to the restless spirits of Oakwood Cemetery. It's a bittersweet episode, as this will be Neiko's final appearance as the Friends Who Crime editor. Tune in for a double dose of history,...

This week on Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my friend Christian to unravel one of the most haunting missing persons cases I’ve ever researched: the 2006 disappearance of Brian Shaffer. Brian was a 27-year-old med student who seemed to vanish into thin air after a night out in Columbus, Ohio. No evidence, no suspects, and no footage of him ever leaving the bar. We go through the timeline, dig int...

In this solo episode, Brynn dives deep into the mysterious 2006 death of Kari Baker, a beloved teacher and pastor’s wife whose apparent suicide unraveled into a chilling murder case. As the layers peel back, listeners follow the relentless efforts of Kari’s family to uncover the truth after authorities initially failed to investigate. From a suspicious suicide note to a mistress’s explosive courtr...

Four young lives, a quiet college town, and a crime that shocked the nation. In this episode, my brother Blaine joins me as we unravel the chilling details of the Idaho College Murders and the arrest of Bryan Kohberger. We dig into the timeline, the evidence, and the theories swirling around his alleged motive, all while the world waits for the trial to begin. It's a case full of twists, unanswere...

This week, my friend James joins me to talk about the chilling and tragic death of Toni Bertolet Henthorn, a beloved doctor who fell to her death during what was supposed to be a romantic anniversary hike. But as we dig deeper, it becomes clear that her husband Harold had more than just a scenic walk planned. From secret life insurance policies to a suspiciously similar incident years earlier, thi...

​In this TENTH episode of Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my little brother, Logan, as we delve into the chilling legend of Elizabeth Báthory, the Blood Countess. Together, we explore the gruesome tales of her alleged crimes, the political intrigues of 16th-century Hungary, and the enduring mysteries that surround her story. Was she truly the most prolific female serial killer in history, or a vi...

In this episode of Friends Who Crime, I'm joined by friend Savanna to dive into the chilling, decades-old mystery of Reyna Angélica Marroquín. When a sealed barrel is discovered in a Long Island crawl space, the horrifying secret inside unravels a story of love, betrayal, and murder. Together, Brynn and Savanna piece together Reyna’s tragic story and the shocking twist that finally brought her kil...

In this episode of Friends Who Crime, Brynn is joined by Don to unravel the wild, bizarre, and tragic case of the Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker, Caleb Lawrence McGillvary. What started as a viral internet hero moment quickly spiraled into a shocking murder case that left the world stunned. Was Kai a vigilante drifter caught in a nightmare, or was there a darker truth behind his free-spirited persona...

This week on Friends Who Crime, we’re diving into the haunted history of Austin, TX, with two of its most infamous paranormal hotspots: The Driskill Hotel and The Clay Pit. From ghostly brides and eerie paintings to spirits lingering in an old Bertram family trading post, these stories will send chills down your spine. Joining me for this episode is my friend Neiko, who also happens to be the wiza...

In this episode, we delve into the infamous Malcolm MacArthur case, a chilling double murder that rocked Ireland in 1982 and led to the coining of the term "GUBU" (Grotesque, Unbelievable, Bizarre, and Unprecedented). We'll explore the shocking details of the crimes, MacArthur's unexpected arrest in the Attorney General's home, and the profound political fallout that ensued. Joining us this week i...

In this episode of Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my friend Braden to unravel the chilling case of Mirna Salihin. What was meant to be a casual coffee date ended in a shocking murder, leading to one of Indonesia’s most controversial trials. Was Jessica Wongso truly guilty, or is there more to the story? Grab your favorite drink—just maybe not an iced coffee—and tune in for this mysterious deep d...

In this episode, we delve into the tragic murder case of Rebecca Schaeffer, a promising young actress whose life was abruptly taken by an obsessed fan. I'm thrilled to have my mom, Katherine, join me as we explore the personal and cultural impact of this notorious case. Together, we unpack the events of that fateful day and discuss how it reshaped Hollywood's approach to celebrity safety and anti-...

Step back to 1976 and uncover the chilling events of the Chowchilla kidnapping—a day when a peaceful, small-town morning turned into a nightmare. In this episode, Cortney and I trace the timeline of that fateful day, explore the impact on a tight-knit community, and delve into the investigation that followed. Through detailed accounts and expert insights, we reveal how an 11‑hour ordeal shattered...

In this episode of Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my friend, Andy, as we dive into the bizarre and unsettling unsolved murder of Donna Doll. In 1970, the quiet college town of DeKalb, Illinois, was rocked by the mysterious death of the NIU student, whose body was found with an eerie and unexplained detail—six pounds of potatoes in her stomach. Was this a crime of passion? A case of poisoning? Or...

In the very first episode of Friends Who Crime, Brynn is joined by her friend Kaity to dive into the shocking case of Ryan Poston’s murder. They unravel the toxic relationship between Ryan and Shayna Hubers, the chilling 911 call, Shayna’s bizarre police interrogation, and the dramatic trial that captivated the nation. Was this self-defense or cold-blooded murder? Tune in for wild details, dark tw...

In this Friends Who Crime trailer, host Brynn introduces the podcast, sharing her love for true crime and the idea behind the show. Each episode features a different friend reacting to a case Brynn has researched, blending storytelling with humor while keeping the focus on the victims. Tune in for a mix of mystery, friendship, and lighthearted crime talk! First full episode releases on February 4t...