Eye for an Eye

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as we return to the deeply controversial case of Ellen Greenberg, the 27-year-old Philadelphia teacher whose death has continued to raise questions more than a decade later. We first covered Ellen’s case in Episode 90, examining the circumstances surrounding her 2011 death and the controversial ruling that her multiple stab wounds were the result of suicide. Now, we...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they dive into the deeply controversial case of Marcellus Williams, a Missouri death row inmate whose execution in 2024 sparked intense debate surrounding DNA evidence, wrongful convictions, racial bias, eyewitness testimony, and the death penalty. In this episode, we examine the murder case that ultimately sent Williams to death row and the evidence th...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa for a chilling conversation with historian and author Peter Vronsky, as we explore the dark world of serial killers, cold cases, and the terrifying legacy of Richard Cottingham, known as the Torso Killer. Peter, a Toronto-based historian and author who has spent years researching serial murder, takes us deep into his work surrounding the Cottingham case an...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they take an especially personal look at the heartbreaking case of Christina Spicuzza, a Pittsburgh-area mother of four whose life was tragically cut short while working as an Uber driver. In 2022, Christina accepted a ride in the Monroeville area—never knowing it would be her last. What followed was a horrifying kidnapping and murder that devastated her fam...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they take a deep dive into the tragic death of Pittsburgh music icon Mac Miller, whose life was cut short by a drug overdose in September 2018 at just 26 years old. In this emotional true crime podcast episode, we explore Mac Miller's connection to Pittsburgh's legendary music scene and the stories surrounding artists, producers, and figures who helped shape...

Join Lisa, Matt, and Jules for a gripping conversation with Lieutenant Raul J. Diaz and Sean Oliver, co-authors of Killing the Lieutenant, a firsthand account of crime, corruption, and survival during Miami’s notorious cocaine wars. Raul Diaz’s story sounds like something out of a crime movie—but it’s real. After immigrating to the United States from Cuba, Diaz went from being involved i...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they take a chilling deep dive into the life and crimes of one of America’s most notorious serial killers: Ed Kemper, the “Co-Ed Killer.” In this episode, we explore the disturbing story of a man whose horrific crimes were matched by his remarkable ability to articulate his thoughts and seemingly understand the gravity of what he had done. From his deeply tr...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they take a deep dive into one of the most polarizing true crime cases in recent memory: the death of Boston police officer John O'Keefe and the murder trial of Karen Read. Did Karen Read deliberately strike O'Keefe with her SUV and leave him to die in the snow? Or was she framed as part of a larger cover-up designed to protect powerful insiders? In a case filled...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they dive into the latest shocking twist in one of the most infamous true crime cases in recent history—the granting of a new trial for convicted killer Alex Murdaugh. Once found guilty of murdering his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, in a case that captivated the nation, Murdaugh is now seeking another chance in court. But this isn't just a story about murder. It's...

Join Lisa, Matt, and Noa as we sit down with Judge Michael Randazzo for an inspiring and thought-provoking true crime podcast episode that goes beyond the courtroom and into the life experiences that shape those who uphold the law. In this episode, Judge Randazzo shares his powerful journey from a challenging upbringing in rural Missouri to serving as a circuit judge. He opens up about early life...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules and Noa as we unpack the powerful influence of social media algorithms and how they shape the way we see the world. In this episode, we explore how platforms like TikTok can create completely different realities for users, fueling echo chambers and reinforcing personal beliefs. We discuss why engaging with multiple perspectives is more important than ever in a world where yo...

Join Lisa & Matt as we sit down with Paul, a former clinical psychologist whose life took a shocking turn from running a thriving private practice to serving time in federal prison for healthcare fraud. Get your copy of Paul's book 'Cruel and Unusual Punishment: A Memoir of the Psychological Realities of Federal Prison' here: https://amzn.to/3QHVs4c Paul shares how he built a successful psychology...

Join Lisa, Matt, Jules and our newest cohost Noa as we delve into the deception and deaths surrounding the Murdaugh family in this gripping true crime podcast episode. From the shocking boat crash that first drew national attention to a string of suspicious deaths, alleged financial crimes, and decades of power-fueled cover-ups. In this episode, we break down the complex web of legal battles and c...

Join Lisa, Matt and Jules as we cover the most chilling and perplexing unsolved disappearances at sea—the case of 23-year-old Amy Bradley. In 1998, Amy vanished without a trace from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship, leaving behind more questions than answers. In this episode, we break down the timeline of events and explore the leading theories: Did Amy accidentally fall overboard? Did she leave the...

Join Lisa, Matt, and Jules as we dive deep into the disturbing case featured in the Netflix documentary The Unknown Number—a chilling true crime story centered around cyberbullying, deception, and a shocking betrayal. A teen girl and her boyfriend face relentless harassment from an unknown caller, with months of psychological torment pushing them to their limits. As police begin to investigate, wh...

Podcast Episode Description — Through the Looking Glass: Eye for an Eye Welcome back to Season 5 of Eye for an Eye! We’re excited to kick off a brand-new season filled with intriguing interviews, compelling cases, and even a new host we can’t wait to introduce you to. In this episode of Through the Looking Glass, hosts Matthew and Lisa sit down with Tad Nelson, a seasoned criminal defense attorney...

 Sometimes, the line between fiction and reality is thinner than we’d like to believe—especially when it comes to supervillains. In this season finale episode, 2024’s most infamous defendant takes center stage. Join Lisa, Matt, special returning host Gab, and our new guest host Shay as we unravel the shocking alleged truths and unsettling deceptions surrounding the case of Sean Combs—aka Diddy, Pu...

Join Lisa, Matt and our special guest Christina to go back over the horrific case of Chris, Joan, and Peter Porco. Christina grew up close to where this grisly crime took place- and she gives us insight on how it affected her town. The details of this case make it chilling, however, the question that is on everyones minds is the power of a mothers love shielding Joan from the truth- or is she priv...

While many of the cases we cover are tragic and disturbing, some hit closer to home than others. In this case, one of our hosts shared a habitation situation with the subject of our case. Join Lisa, Matt, and Julia as we discuss a young man who murdered his own father in a psychotic rage, and posed with his head on the Internet. He also just so happened to live in the same dorm as Matt and Julia’s...

Join Lisa and Matt as we delve into one of the most perplexing mysteries of the 20th century: the Dyatlov Pass Incident. What led nine experienced hikers to their untimely and bizarre demise in the frigid Ural Mountains in 1959? From cryptic journal entries and strange injuries to theories involving avalanches, secret military experiments, and the paranormal, we explore every angle of this endurin...

Our Eye for an Eye cases have a tragic element to them, as well as an element of satisfaction Blind Eye cases leave us wanting from. When we have a chance to peel back the onion layers, we try to for our listeners. This case, one of the most mystifying tragedies we’ve ever covered, has shocked us with its brutality. The victim was a grandmother, a person we would think would be hard enough to kill...

Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa and Matt do...at least once a day. While an Eye for an Eye covers the more serious cases, we wanted to bring you a new mini series, the grand baby-- if you will, of the most absurd, funny, confusing cases we could grasp our crime obsessed phalanges on.  We promise by the end of every minisode of WTH3, you too...

Serial killers have long perplexed normal members of society, for a number of reasons. One of the main questions we ask is, ‘How do they get away with it?’ Some people operate with total anonymity by being ruthless and yet blend in, staying in motion, or being undetectable based on their personality traits. But, was Keith Hunter Jespersen really one such killer? Using the façade of “family” man an...

Anti-Semitism is alive and active in today’s day and age. In American society, we battle a gun addiction and a growing anti-Semitic movement daily. When the two combine, tragedy knows no bounds. Join Eye for an Eye as we delve into one of the most awful incidents of mass shooting in the 21st century, and dig deep into the “reason” behind it and why these manifestations of evil continuously reoccur...

New details are always welcome in unsolved cases, but for the high profile cases we cover- nothing shakes the earth like a confession! Join Matt and Lisa as we revisit the latest developments in the murders of Tupac Shakur and the Notorious BIG. Be sure to check out our friends over at Magic Mind by clicking the link below and using code : EYEFOR20 https://magicmind.com/eyefor Special thanks to th...