Extra Butter

Extra Butter

Tv EN ↓ 78 episodes

Three guys. Zero credentials. One movie at a time. Extra Butter is the podcast where we pick a movie, watch it, and then proceed to unpack it with unqualified opinions, questionable takes, and just enough passion to almost sound like we know what we're talking about. No film is safe—classics, cult classics, or total flops—we watch them all, so you don’t have to (but you totally should). Lower your expectations, grab some popcorn, and make sure to add some extra butter.

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: podcasters.spotify.com

Author

Extra Butter

Category

Tv

Podcast website

podcasters.spotify.com

Latest episode

Oct 30, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android almost 10M downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Before Sunset, Netflix Shows, and the Book Wheel! 07.11.2025

In today's episode, the gang's all here again to do a call back to episode 1!! Brendan and Crit give their reviews on what else they watched this week. We got a gears to grind, Oscars, and get into Before Sunset! Things got heated.. We finally got to spin the book wheel this week since Brendan made an audible last week. Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link bel...

Paranormal Activity, Shelby Oaks, and Showers at a Truck Stop 31.10.2025

Happy Halloween!! In today's episode, Trav is back!! Brendan saw Shelby Oaks. We got a gear to grind that showed Geese's true colors, Oscars, and get into Paranormal Activity! We made a new wheel for when it will debut next week. Good times having the whole gang together again. Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc...

House of Wax, Travel Woes, and Monopoly(again) 24.10.2025

In today's episode, Crit is back and we get into football and his trip to Notre Dame! We have SOOO many gears to grind, Oscars, and get into House of Wax! This one is a fun one folks! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter

Killer Klowns From Outer Space, Monopoly is BACK!, and Football 17.10.2025

In today's episode, Geese and Brendan are alone as they talk football, their gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into Killer Klowns From Outer Space! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter

Thir13en Ghosts, a scream unseen, and IKEA 09.10.2025

In today's episode, we talk football, our gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into Thir13en Ghosts! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter

Draft Day and a Salem, MA trip 03.10.2025

In today's episode, we talk football again(get used to it) our gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into Draft Day! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter Football (00:00:00 - 00:29:00) Gears to Grind (00:29:00 - 00:33:00) Oscars (00:29:00 - 33:00) Draft Day Review (00:35:00 - 01:25:00) THE NEW WHEEL! (01:25...

Episode 23: The Blind Side 26.09.2025

In today's episode, we talk football again(get used to it) and Brendan gives his review of Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba Infinity Castle!! We per usual do our normal gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into The Blind Side! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter Football (00:00:00 - 00:29:00) Demon Slayer R...

Episode 22: We Are Marshall 19.09.2025

In today's episode, we got the whole gang back together! We welcome back Trav now that he's got better wi-fi! We talk football, do our normal gears to grind, Oscars, and then dive into We Are Marshall! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutterOnly one of us is 0-1 (00:00:00 - 00:16:00)Gears to Grind (00...

Episode 21: Jerry Maguire 12.09.2025

In today's episode, we kickoff the football series! We got the 2 man game again with Brendan and Crit! We do our usual gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into Jerry Maguire! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutterThe boys' CFB teams lost.. (00:00:00 - 00:16:00)Screen Unseen! (00:16:00 - 00:28:00)Gears t...

Episode 20: E.T. 05.09.2025

In today's episode, we wrap up the space series with E.T! We got Critter back in the saddle! We do our usual gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into some new movies that the crew has seen this past week, stick around because at the end we finish it up with our space themed popcorn draft and our new wheel! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listen...

Episode 19: Spaceballs 29.08.2025

In today's episode, we continue the space series with Spaceballs! We do our usual gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into some new movies that the crew has seen this past week. Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutterNew Movies and Screen Unseen Review (00:00:00 - 00:18:00)Gears to Grind (00:18:00 - 00:25:00...

Episode 18: The Martian 22.08.2025

In today's episode, we are continue the space series with The Martian. We do our usual gears to grind, Oscars, and dive into some new movies that the crew has seen this past week. Including a screen unseen! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter New Movies and Screen Unseen Review (00:00:00 - 00:16:00) G...

Episode 17: Independence Day 15.08.2025

In today's episode, we are beginning the space series with Independence Day. We do our usual gears to grind, Oscars, and another screen unseen review. Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabutter Screen Unseen and a bonus movie review of Together - (00:01:00 - 00:17:00) Gears to Grind - (00:17:00:00:25:00) Osc...

Episode 16: Just Go With It 08.08.2025

In today's episode, we are sadly wrapping up the Sandman series. We dive into both Just Go With It. Some of us did a little extra credit and watched Sandy Wexler, so we’ll dive into that a bit, too. We do our usual gears to grind, Oscars, and another screen unseen review. Stick around for the end to see what we've got cooking for our new series of 4! Make sure to rate, review, and subscrib...

Episode 15: Happy Gilmore 1 & 2 01.08.2025

In today's episode, we are shaking things up a bit. We dive into both Happy Gilmore and Happy Gilmore 2. We do our usual gears to grind, oscars, and another screen unseen review. In addition to all of that we do a snake draft aka popcorn draft to pick our perfect 3 partners to play with in a golf foursome and a caddy!! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and t...

Episode 14: Murder Mystery 25.07.2025

In this episode, the boys the live-action adaptation of How to Train Your Dragon . We have some gears to grind and we give out our Oscars again. This week we dive into Adam Sandler's Murder Mystery. The twists and turns in this movie kept us on our toes and laughing as any one would at an Adam Sandler movie! Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for l...

Episode 13: Jack and Jill 18.07.2025

Enter Sandman!! Our new Happy Madison Productions series of 4 is here! The first movie we dive into is Jack and Jill . We also introduce a new segment where we give out our Oscar’s to whoever we want! As always we got some gears to grind and Brendan’s Screen Unseen movie review.   Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening!  https://cosoc.com...

Episode 12: Caddyshack 11.07.2025

We wrap up the summer series with the 1980s classic comedy, Caddyshack. Hear all about the weekend in Denver, featuring the F1 movie, Metallica concerts, golf, and some pool time. As always, they grind some gears and unveil a brand new wheel for the next series of episodes. Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, and thanks for listening! https://cosoc.com/extrabu...

Episode 11: National Lampoon's Vacation 04.07.2025

We’re hitting the road and taking a trip to Wally World with the Griswolds! Trav is BACK and the guys draft their top 4 movies for the first edition of the Fantastic 4. Brendan was in the theatre for AMC's screen unseen again. This time it was an absolute BANGER! As always we dive into National Lampoon's Vacation. Make sure to rate, review, and subscribe to the pod using the link below, an...

Episode 10: The Sandlot 27.06.2025

Welcome back for another episode of Extra Butter! We are in a pickle once again this week with Trav without Wi-Fi. Crit steps in from the bullpen once again! The trio reflects on recent concerts, comedy shows, and their gear to grind about said shows. Brendan shares his experience with AMC’s Screen Unseen. Nostalgia begins to set in as we dive into a review of The Sandlot! Make sure to rate, revie...

Episode 9: The Goonies 20.06.2025

HEY YOU GUYS!! The trio is making a call to the bullpen—our very own Crit is stepping up for his co-hosting debut! In this episode, we take a deep dive into a movie we know you’ve all seen and loved: The Goonies . Whether you’re a little sibling, a big sibling, or just an adventure seeker, this one’s for you. We’ve got some gears to grind that might just get yours turning too. And as always, stick...

Episode 8: Mohawk 13.06.2025

The trio kicks things off with gears to grind, but not before Brendan unveils some breaking news. After that, it's time for a deep dive into Mohawk! Their reviews may shock you! As they wrap up the critics vs. audience theme, Brendan and Crit unveil a new theme and wheel! Stay tuned as you will surely be excited for our next watch! As always, rate, review, and subscribe wherever you listen to your...

Episode 7: It Comes at Night 06.06.2025

The trio kicks things off with a story about their favorite Chihuahua before diving into a nostalgic review of the live-action Lilo & Stitch . As always they do a deep dive into It Comes at Night. SPOILER ALERT, they get into the "Horror Movie Triangle" again. (00:02:00) Brendan's Gear to Grind (00:08:20) Lilo & Stitch Preview (00:14:00) More Gears to Grind (00:24:00) It Comes at Night Dee...

Episode 6: Drag Me to Hell 30.05.2025

The trio takes a deep dive into the 2009 horror film Drag Me to Hell , unpacking everything from its plot twists and jump scares to its special effects and supernatural themes. They get side tracked at the beginning on rotten tomato critics vs. audience scoring sytems, state coin collecting, and more. (01:15) Trav has a gear that he needs to grind and we dive into Rotten Tomatoes' scoring sytem (1...

Episode 5 : Warcraft 23.05.2025

The trio discusses the movie Warcraft , analyzing the character development, pace, CGI, and the contrasting opinions of critics and audiences. They also discuss the potential for sequels, while reflecting on the challenges video game adaptations face in film. Thanks for tuning into another episode of Extra Butter! Where'd Episode 4 Go!? (2:00 - 3:52) Brendan's Sinners Review w/ a theatre seat choi...

Listen to the Extra Butter podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.