Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith
Everything Vaguely Paranormal
Everything Vaguely Paranormal is a paranormal podcast exploring true stories, dark history, and unexplained phenomena. Each episode dives into hauntings, demons, UFOs, witchcraft, and cryptids, breaking down real encounters, folklore, and the patterns that connect them. We focus on what’s documented, what’s reported, and what still can’t be explained. Blending research with conversation, the show balances eerie storytelling with grounded discussion, making space for both skepticism and belief without forcing an answer. If you’re drawn to ghost stories, supernatural cases, and mysteries that li...
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.facebook.com
Author
Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 4, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Haunted | Special Guest: Christie Ayers 21.06.2023 1:08:23
Send us Fan Mail We're sitting down to speak with Paranormal Investigator, Christie Ayers. She's been on shows such as Destination Fear and Most Terrifying Places in America. We'll delve into her journey in the paranormal world, as well as hear some of stories along the way. Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/H3qer9NBUgo Don't forget, you can watch us live o...
Lizardman of Bishopville, South Carolina 14.06.2023 1:12:08
Send us Fan Mail Since the late 1980s, South Carolina folklore has told of cryptid known as The Lizardman of Bishopville. It started with an investigation of a car that had been mauled, with teeth and claw marks, muddy footprints, and even blood left behind. Over the years sightings of the Lizardman began to grow and coalesced into a legend bigger than the state itself. But one question remains… w...
The Loch Ness Monster 07.06.2023 1:18:37
Send us Fan Mail Since 1933, a monster - affectionately known as “Nessie” - has lurked within Loch Ness in the Scottish Highlands. Nessie has been described as a “monster fish”, “sea serpent”, or “dragon”, with a large, long neck and one or more humps protruding from the water. Has a creature survived this long or is it a long-standing hoax? Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/...
Death House Landlady: Dorothea Puente 31.05.2023 1:50:04
Send us Fan Mail In the 1980s, Dorothea Puente ran a boarding house in Sacramento, California. Little did neighbors know that this seemingly quiet, grandmotherly woman was harboring a dark secret. She housed and worth with the underserved, underprivileged, and disadvantaged, and those that lived in her home seem to “disappear” on a whim – That is until 7 bodies were exhumed in her backyard, and 2...
The Blood Countess: Elizabeth Bathory 24.05.2023 1:26:46
Send us Fan Mail The most prolific female serial killer of the western world. Elizabeth Bathory was said to practice vampirism, reportedly torturing hundreds of young girls in the 16th and 17th century. With previous accusations ignored, Elizabeth Bathory wasn’t found out until much later when rumors of her cruelty began to surface. By then, some claim as many as 600 girls had been killed, and it...
Most Hated Woman in America Part Two: Madalyn Murray O'Hair 17.05.2023 1:34:06
Send us Fan Mail The conclusion to last week's episode... “Woman, Atheist, Anarchist. That’s me.” Madalyn Murray O’Hair made herself known as an activist and founder of American Atheists. She made waves all the way to the United States Supreme Court, on Johnny Carson, and made headlines around America, when she sought to prohibit Bible readings and prayer in schools… then suddenly she disappe...
Most Hated Woman in America: Madalyn Murray O'Hair 10.05.2023 1:39:01
Send us Fan Mail “Woman, Atheist, Anarchist. That’s me.” Madalyn Murray O’Hair made herself known as an activist and founder of American Atheists. She made waves all the way to the United States Supreme Court, on Johnny Carson, and made headlines around America, when she sought to prohibit Bible readings and prayer in schools… then suddenly she disappeared. The Most Hated Woman in America was neve...
Damsel of Death: Aileen Wuornos 03.05.2023 1:51:21
Send us Fan Mail Kicking off our "Ferocious Females" Month... Sentenced to death for 6 murders, Aileen Wuornos would turn the FBI’s profile of a serial killer on its head. Flagging down motorists, she would rob and then kill the men she hitched a ride with. From her never-had-a-chance beginnings to her life of crime, Aileen Wuornos would leave a trail of destruction behind her. Watch the...
Infamous: Pretty Boy Floyd 26.04.2023 1:30:28
Send us Fan Mail Charles Arthur “Pretty Boy” Floyd was an American bank robber, infamous for operating mainly in the central and western states. Gaining notoriety for ridding people of their debts, he was often seen in a more positive light. In the end, Floyd would become “Public Enemy No. 1”, and would be shot down in a hail of bullets. But was this notorious outlaw a criminal or product of his t...
David Koresh: The Bad Messiah 19.04.2023 1:44:12
Send us Fan Mail American religious cult leader, David Koresh, played a central role in the Waco Siege – a 51-day standoff between the religious group, The Branch Davidians, and the ATF. As the final prophet of the Davidians, Koresh’s apocalyptic teachings, including his interpretations of the Book of Revelations, attracted various followers. But, how did this one man garner such admiration? Watc...
Haunted | Special Guest: Aaron G Thompson 12.04.2023 1:11:10
Send us Fan Mail From Netflix’s paranormal investigation series, “28 Days Haunted”, we welcome our special guest Aaron G Thompson. We sit down to talk about Aaron’s 28 days inside Captain Grant’s, his journey in the paranormal world, his most memorable moments, and his upcoming adventures. Watch the video version: https://youtu.be/N77Qg7P89kk Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nig...
Elk Valley Paranormal | Special Guest: Cyn Shrader Hill 05.04.2023 1:31:07
Send us Fan Mail Founder of Elk Valley Paranormal, Cyn Shrader Hill, joins Everything Vaguely Paranormal for a jam packed EVP episode. As a paranormal investigator and paranormal author, Cyn speaks about her journey in this field as well as what caused her to author 4 books about her paranormal experiences. Watch the video version: https://youtube.com/live/7Ty8Xuo4_Xo Don't forget, you can wa...
Doppelganger: The Evil Twin 29.03.2023 1:23:24
Send us Fan Mail Maybe you’ve seen it… you turn the corner and you see someone you know walking away, and you call for them, only for them to pop their head out behind you. Or, perhaps, you’re halfway across the globe and you see a familiar face. Once you look back, they’re gone. It’s a phenomenon known as a “doppelgänger”, but what is it? Are you simply thinking of that person or is there a more...
Brodhead Manor | Special Guest: Owner, Bill Wolter 22.03.2023 1:22:34
Send us Fan Mail Located in Brodhead, Wisconsin sits an old school building that still has spirits roaming the halls. Come join us as we sit down with the owner of Brodhead Manor, Bill Wolter. Hear his first hand stories of the activity found inside this haunted manor that has brought investigators from around the US to its doors. Watch the video version: https://youtube.com/live/yfQA6Sl1fjA?featu...
The Jersey Devil 15.03.2023 1:09:05
Send us Fan Mail In the northeastern portion of the United States, specifically South Jersey and Philadelphia, there is a legendary creature known as the “Jersey Devil”. Many variations exist, but common descriptions tell of a leathery bat-like winged creature, kangaroo-like, with horns and small arms, clawed hands, and cloven hooves. It’s high-pitched, “blood-curdling” scream stops you in your tr...
Olde Park: A True Tale of a West Texas Haunt | Special Guest: Billy Lewis 08.03.2023 1:08:17
Send us Fan Mail Located in Ballinger, Texas sits the Haunted Circa 1886 Olde Park Hotel. You’ve seen the episodes we’ve covered on this location. We teamed up with documentarian and filmmaker, Billy Lewis, as well as Eric Connor with Epic Paranormal for a night of investigating at the Olde Park Hotel that we will never forget. We sit down and discuss the upcoming documentary over the Olde Park Ho...
The Boyd House | Special Guest: Jill Shelley 01.03.2023 1:07:11
Send us Fan Mail Located in Boyd, Minnesota sits a house that is seemingly innocent, but it's four walls run rampant with paranormal activity. From apparitions and footsteps, to doors opening and objects moving, we sit down with owner and paranormal investigator, Jill Shelley of St. Croix Paranormal to discuss not just the Boyd House, but the activity inside. Check out the video version: htt...
Haunted | Special Guest: Nick Simons 22.02.2023 1:16:31
Send us Fan Mail Prepare to laugh... From Netflix’s paranormal investigation series, “28 Days Haunted”, we sit down and talk with Nick Simons about his journey with the paranormal world, including his 28 day stint inside Captain Grant’s Inn, as well as his most memorable moments. We’ll discuss his upcoming adventures and get to know our guest, Nick Simons. Don't forget, you can watch us live...
Medusa: Victim or Villain 15.02.2023 1:24:46
Send us Fan Mail Just in time for Valentine's Day... Those who dared to gaze upon her were turned to stone... The myth of Medusa is as legendary as her gaze, or the snakes that inhabited her scalp. But interpretations throughout time have cast Medusa both in light... and dark. Who was this Gorgon, in her own story? Victim or Villain? Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights...
The Shoemaker: Joseph Kallinger 08.02.2023 1:43:29
Send us Fan Mail Due to extremely graphic nature of the content in this episode, listener discretion is heavily advised. “The Shoemaker: Joseph Kallinger”, was an American serial-killer, who killed three individuals and tortured four families during the span of his crimes. Not only did he gain entrance into most of the homes by pretending to be a salesman, but he also did it with the help of his...
Shadow Hunters | Special Guest: Nick Sarlo 01.02.2023 1:33:43
Send us Fan Mail With over 18 years of paranormal experience, we sit down and talk with PARAflixx Paranormal Plus sensation, and Investigator of Shadow Hunters Paranormal Investigations & Events, Nick Sarlo. He'll be bringing his view of the paranormal as we discuss his locations, experiences, and the Paranormal Convention, Spirits in the Spring 2023. Don't forget, you can watch us l...
"Best of..." 2022 | All Paranormal Caught on Camera 25.01.2023 1:48:50
Send us Fan Mail Everything Vaguely Paranormal presents their "best of..." moments, captures, paranormal activity, experiences, and locations of 2022, with BRAND NEW, UNRELEASED evidence. Come join the live as we retell our best, funniest, and scariest moments of 2022. Watch the video version: https://youtu.be/Jpqjr_8TTn8 Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM...
Heaven's Gate: The UFO Cult 18.01.2023 1:49:46
Send us Fan Mail Founded in 1974 by Ti and Do, Heaven's Gate was a religious movement who's followers believed they would "exit" this world, board a spacecraft, and enter the Kingdom of Heaven. As the group progressed through the decades, events would change just HOW they made their exit. Could there be any truth to their set of beliefs? Don't forget, you can watch us liv...
Hijacked: D.B. Cooper 11.01.2023 1:36:34
Send us Fan Mail In 1971, a passenger boarded a plane, and parachuted off the plane an American legend. This passenger would become known as "D.B. Cooper" in the media, and would lead government agencies on a wild goose chase that is still unsolved to this day. Who was D.B. Cooper? Did he escape or did he suffer a fatal demise? Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights...
Hopkinsville Goblins 04.01.2023 1:27:32
Send us Fan Mail Hopkinsville, Kentucky – 1955… A family is under siege from “small alien creatures”, attacking their farmhouse. This close encounter would end up being regarded as one of the most significant and well-documented UFO incidents in America, causing Project Blue Book to get involved. So, what were they? Aliens? Goblins? Or were they simply a hoax that got out of control? Don't f...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.