Everything Scary

Send us Fan Mail On December 7th of 2020, at the height of covid, while everyone's nerve were shot, Katie Sorensen, a mother to 3 young children, posted a warning to her blog. According to Katie, while on a trip out to Michaels Craft Store, with her two youngest children, a 4 year old boy and a 1 year old girl.  They had narrowly avoided the unthinkable, what Katie perceived to be an attempte...

Send us Fan Mail HUGE TRIGGER WARNING! This one is upsetting. Physical and sexual abuse on a child, death of a child, and the evil sack of bones that commits these acts is an actual nightmare of a human being, proceed with caution. This case took place on May 16th of 2005, Shasta Rae Groene was asleep, in her home, when her mother frantically ran into her room at 6am to wake her. Shastas mother wo...

Send us Fan Mail What does the name Anna Nicole Smith mean to you? A Playboy Playmate, a reality TV star, a drug-addict, or an infamous gold-digger? Dive headfirst with us into the controversial and tragic life of Anna Nicole Smith, as we debunk the stereotypes and reveal the woman beneath the scandalous headlines. From her small-town beginnings to her meteoric rise to fame, we uncover the lesser-...

Send us Fan Mail In part 2 of our coverage of Edmund Kemper AKA The Co-Ed killer, we will continue to learn of the awful things that Ed did, we will also learn that there was actually TWO serial killers active at the exact same time in the exact same area.  But, when one is caught, the police find out that there wildest fears are confirmed. And, sadly Ed would continue on with his displacement kil...

Send us Fan Mail After killing his grandparents, in cold blood at the age of 15, Edmund Kemper the 3rd was only sentenced to time in a mental health hospital until he was deemed well enough to be released.  In this case, that was only 5 years.  The hospital strongly suggested that Ed, not be released into the custody of his mothers, due to some, very worrisome behavior and thoughts that they had o...

Send us Fan Mail Prepare yourself for a chilling tale of obsession, tragedy, and the dark underbelly of fame. We unravel the harrowing narrative of rising star Rebecca Schaefer's life, dreams, and untimely demise at the hands of an obsessive stalker. You'll see the world of '80s television through her eyes as she navigates her way to stardom. From her early days in modeling in Tokyo...

Send us Fan Mail Hold onto your seats as we dive into the enigmatic world of Everything Scary - a journey that intersects humor, horror, and bafflingly true crime. Ever heard of a murder by a clown? Or a meat inspector turned shady car salesman? Well, you're in for a wild ride! We kick things off with some unusual reviews. Yes, we've heard your critique about our tangents! On May 26, 199...

Send us Fan Mail HAPPY HALLOWEEN! Black eyed children, will typically show up in pairs, with a simple favor that they need from you, and in order for you to do it, they will have to enter your space, but 1st you must give them permission.  Most, who have encountered the BEC will claim to have felt a surge of terror run through them, even before noticing their eyes.  The children will try to coax y...

Send us Fan Mail Happy Friday!! Here, is part 2 of The West Memphis 6. I wanted to release this early, this story is important, and again, please listen with discretion.  TRIGGER WARNING for child murder, and sexual assault. In part two we will get into the unfair incarceration of The West Memphis 3, we will see people who once wanted them 'burned at the stake' change their stance, we wi...

Send us Fan Mail TRIGGER WARNING: for child death. Our journey takes us through Robin Hood Hills, the haunting site where the bodies of three young victims were found. We unravel the disturbing details of the case, navigating from the frightful speculations of satanic rituals surrounding the murders to the backdrop of the 1980s satanic panic that swayed public opinion. We guide you through the sag...

Send us Fan Mail This is part 2 of the Darlie Roulie case.  in this half we will discuss; the trial... The silly sting... all the evidence against Darlie....but.. even if you really believe she did this... and the evidence does point to her.. but,   why?   Darin had a 250,000 life insurance policy on Darlie..  maybe she was the target.  But, is a hired hitman, just going to come in and murder the...

Send us Fan Mail TRIGGER WARNING. Todays episode is a well known, highly controversial case. Sadly, it does involve child murder, so listeners, please use your own discretion. On June 6th of 1996, according to 26 year old Darlie Routier, a man wearing a dark shirt, dark baseball cap, and jeans broke into the home that she lived in with her husband Darin, their two eldest sons; Damon and Devon, and...

Send us Fan Mail Here is the second half of the lululemon murder,  We now know that Jayna has been murdered, and her co worker Brittany was 'badly' injured. But what exactly happened in the Lululemon store that night, in this affluent town.  What could have possibility happened that could have provoked the type of rage that could make you stab a person over 300 times? This is part 2 of t...

Send us Fan Mail On March 12th a 26 year old man waited in line out front of an Apple store, to hopefully be able to snag, the newly released Ipad 2. upon waiting for the store to open, a young woman emerged from the Lululemon store that was directly beside Apple.  The woman looked rattled, and was on the phone with 911. When she had entered the high end yoga clothing store to start her shift, she...

Send us Fan Mail In February of 2013, a man driving a black Oldsmobile Alero, intentionally pinned a city worker, in between his car and a utility vehicle.  The man then proceeded to get out of his car a launch into a manic rant, about how he is Jesus Christ.  As he was doing this, civilians were trying to come to the aid of the man who had been pinned.  One of those people was a woman named Tonya...

Send us Fan Mail Jimmy Snuka was THE ONLY superstar to be removed from the WWE Hall of Fame.  This was the result of an incident that took place of May 10th of 1983. Superfly had arrived in Pennsylvania to pre record a wrestling event.  His 'on the road' girlfriend Nancy Argentino, would stay behind at the motel and wait for Jimmy to return. After arriving home after the event, according...

Send us Fan Mail TRIGGER WARNINGS once again,  In the final act, we uncover the harrowing details of Alcala's trial and the controversial actions of the California Supreme Court. We also share the bone-rattling encounter of Cheryl Bradshaw, a contestant on the Dating Game, with Alcala. The gut feelings that saved her life stand as a stark reminder of the importance of trusting one's inst...

Send us Fan Mail SURPRISE EPISODE!!, In full disclosure, this is the 1st episode we recorded we recorded for patreon. The reason I am releasing this today, is because we love all of our listeners, but also...  we are so close to hitting the 50k downloads!  And I cant wait to see it!  This is the Murder of Amie Harwick.  Amie was a beautiful PhD holding sex therapist.  Amie sadly had just ended her...

Send us Fan Mail TRIGGER WARNING I consider this guy to be one of the infamous, most evil serial killers of all time.  In my opinion, he is right up there with the Ted Bundy's, the BTK's, Son of Sam....the worst of the worst. And these stories just get told, and retold, there's tons of documentaries about them, and it almost starts to feel like fiction, and then we give them these c...

Send us Fan Mail In Part 1, we finished off, when 8 year old Christie, (who had suffered a stroke after, her mother said, a bushy haired stranger had gunned them down in the middle of a secluded street) was finally able and willing to write down, and share who had truly, hurt her and he siblings that night.  The paper had simply read: "my mom".  The authorities finally had that last miss...

Send us Fan Mail On May 19th 1983, Diane Downs was driving down a secluded country road, with her three children Christie (8) Cheryl(7) and Danny (3).  They were out sight seeing after dusk, on the way home from Diane's friends home.  Everything, was going fine, until a 'bushy haired stranger' stepped out into the road, seemingly flagging down Diane as she drove.  Diane, not one to...

Send us Fan Mail Buckle up as we navigate through Amanda's roller-coaster journey. Feel the electrifying energy as bands like Journey rally to her cause, be moved by the love shown by restaurants like Chili's on her 30th birthday, and witness her starring moment in a Rachel Platten music video. But as we wade deeper, the gloss begins to fade. We uncover a web of alleged illness, treatmen...

Send us Fan Mail In todays case we will dive into an alleged miracle pregnancy against a terrible prognosis of stage 4 terminal cancer. We examine the twists and turns of Amanda's journey, the sizable community support, the riveting incident at her church that relieved her medical bills, and the incredible deception of self-remission. Nancy, our investigative producer, painstakingly fact-chec...

Send us Fan Mail Brace yourselves as we pull back the curtain on the life of renowned comedian Phil Hartman. This episode of Everything Scary is a candid exploration of Hartman's illustrious career and a behind-the-scenes tour of his intimate world. From his successful collaborations, his struggles, and the tragic end, the journey is a gripping rollercoaster ride of laughter, tears, and eyebr...

Send us Fan Mail In part one of our coverage of the late, great; Phil Hartman. As we dig deeper, we'll uncover Hartman's hilarious journey from his Groundlings days to his surprise appearance on The Dating Game. You won't want to miss the uproarious recounting of Phil's attempt to win a date. Our little tour de force doesn’t end there; we also critique the fashion merits of ban...