Evan & Tiki

Jose Caballero takes one of the strangest called third strikes imaginable, leaving broadcasters and fans searching for an explanation. Was he fooled, expecting a walk, or simply caught guessing on the wrong pitch? The conversation also examines the Anthony Volpe position change rumor, Michael Kay’s quick retraction, and why the allegation may follow Volpe regardless of the truth. Plus, the Yankees...

The Yankees are stumbling through another extended summer slide, but the numbers suggest this is not simply a normal part of a long baseball season. Evan examines why these prolonged downturns keep happening, how heavily the team depends on Aaron Judge, and whether the organization has built a roster that is too vulnerable when its biggest star is unavailable or struggling. The conversation also t...

Evan is solo with Shaun and Tiki out, he breaks down the Yankees' struggles and why they need Tarik Skubal, what happened on Jose Cabellero's weird strikeout, Mets fans who went to last night's game, and much, much more.

Evan Roberts and Connor Green analyze the New York Jets' offensive expectations, questioning if they can outscore the high run totals from recent Mets and Royals games. They field calls regarding the New York Yankees' over-reliance on Aaron Judge and the polarizing leadership of Francisco Lindor. The discussion also covers LeBron James' potential return to Cleveland and the importance of Garrett C...

C-Mac joins Evan for a blunt conversation about Anthony Volpe, the controversy over a possible move to second base, and why frustrated Yankees fans are now ready to believe almost any negative story about him. They also examine how prospect expectations can trap a player, whether Volpe can reinvent himself as a versatile role player, and why a fresh start elsewhere may be his best path forward. Th...

Connor Green serves up a Cinco de Luncho ranking of the NFL’s most memorable fan traditions, from the Packers chant and the Bills shout song to the Terrible Towel and the unmistakable Jets chant. Evan then turns back to baseball and examines whether the Yankees’ annual summer collapse is really normal for a good team. The numbers suggest these prolonged slumps are unusually common in the Bronx, le...

A local pitcher’s feel good Mets debut turns into a brutal night at Citi Field, raising an awkward question: when can his friends finally start giving him a hard time about it? Evan also debates how aggressively the Yankees should pursue Tarik Skubal, where the line should be drawn in a prospect package, why the organization cannot quit Anthony Volpe, and whether a viral World Cup controversy was...

The Yankees may not be able to fix their struggling offense, so Evan Roberts argues they should pursue a bold alternative and build an overwhelming starting rotation. With Aaron Judge’s return uncertain and several pitchers carrying injury concerns, a blockbuster move for Tarik Skubal could become their best path to a championship. The conversation also examines Francisco Lindor’s difficult return...

Michael Kay says there is no truth to the rumor that Anthony Volpe refused to play second base in the minor leagues, but the original claim may have already changed how Yankees fans view him. Evan Roberts examines the retraction and the questions that still remain. The conversation explores whether the Yankees pushed back on the story, why false or unverified claims can be impossible to erase, and...

Jose Caballero produced one of the strangest at bats of the season when he appeared to give up on a full count pitch before it reached the plate. Evan Roberts breaks down the confused reactions from the Yankees television and radio broadcasts and searches for a reasonable explanation. The discussion also turns to the energy Caballero brings compared with Anthony Volpe, the limitations of defensive...

Evan pushes back on the idea that strikeouts alone are sinking the Yankees, pointing out that they still scored against Tampa Bay’s starters. With Aaron Judge’s return uncertain, he argues that New York should stop searching for a perfect offensive fix and instead become dominant in the rotation. Callers debate whether the Yankees truly need Tarik Skubal, while Evan explains why elite pitching cou...

Evan celebrates biking back to work, reflects on the risks of riding through New York City and jokes about what Tiki may have to endure when he returns to the studio. The conversation then shifts to the loyal Mets fans who sat through a cold, misty and completely chaotic night at Citi Field. Callers explain why they refused to leave early, even as the Mets stumbled through a 28 run spectacle fille...

The Yankees struck out at an alarming rate, but Evan argues that their problems go far beyond missed swings. Will Warren struggled against the bottom of Tampa Bay’s lineup, Cody Bellinger made another costly mistake, and the uncertainty surrounding Aaron Judge has left the offense without an obvious solution. Instead of trying to patch every weakness, Evan believes the Yankees should make one aggr...

Team USA entered its showdown with Belgium carrying huge expectations, but a lack of aggression, costly defensive mistakes, and an untimely Christian Pulisic injury left Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering whether the team was ever ready for the moment. Evan and Tiki also explain why one Yankees win changed their outlook on the American League East, from Cam Schlittler delivering eight scoreles...

The Yankees may already have their best shortstop on the roster, but are they willing to admit it? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Jose Caballero has surpassed Anthony Volpe and why the organization remains committed to a former top prospect after thousands of plate appearances. The conversation also turns to the Mets and the difficult decisions surrounding Bo Bichette, David Stearns a...

Could tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto be affecting the Mets, or is their relationship being overanalyzed? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine how the arrival of Soto may have changed the clubhouse dynamic, whether Lindor should remain part of the Mets’ future, and why trading a star shortstop is easier to suggest than execute. The conversation also turns to the Yankees’ flaws, Aaro...

FULL SHOW: Unfortunately, the U.S. got eliminated from the World Cup as the guys react, plus the Yankees must win the A.L. East considering the talent on the Rays, Jalen Brunson will miss a few months, Jose Caballero at shortstop over Volpe, and much more.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the Yankees' true rivals, from the Dodgers to the Rays, while questioning the culture of Florida baseball. They take calls on the Mets' defensive woes, the logic of out-of-market NFL fandom, and Mitchell Robinson’s departure from the Knicks. Finally, Evan dives into Yankee history and the hypothetical trade scenarios involving Giancarlo Stanton and Bryce Harper....

The Yankees are chasing Tampa Bay, but does a rivalry with the Rays generate any real emotion? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the matchup lacks the atmosphere, history and intensity of the Yankees battles with Boston, Baltimore and Toronto. The conversation also examines whether the Yankees should replace Austin Wells, how Anthony Volpe should be used and why one misleading statistic fail...

Sean Payton reportedly considered stepping aside so Bill Belichick could chase the NFL wins record in Denver, creating one of the most fascinating coaching scenarios that never happened. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the partnership could have worked or whether two powerful personalities would have eventually collided. The conversation also covers the United States soccer disappointm...

Did one missing welcome message create lasting tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the reported origin of their strained relationship, how Soto changed the Mets clubhouse hierarchy, and whether any realistic Lindor trade could actually improve the team. The conversation shifts to the Yankees and their continued faith in Anthony Volpe despite mounting...

Jalen Brunson is facing a two month recovery after surgery on his right forearm and wrist, but should Knicks fans be worried? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why the timing may actually benefit Brunson and create opportunities for the rest of the roster. The guys also revisit their old soccer opinions, debate the pressure facing host nations and examine the growing frustration surrounding the...

Has Anthony Volpe received more chances than his performance warrants? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Jose Caballero has earned the Yankees’ everyday shortstop job and whether Volpe should be recast as a utility player after four inconsistent seasons. The conversation also examines how criticism can motivate athletes, why former top prospects such as Brett Baty may need reduced roles...

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine why MLS struggles to capture American sports fans when the world’s best players remain in Europe. They debate what it would take for soccer to earn the same local loyalty as baseball, basketball, and football. The conversation returns to the Yankees as Jose Caballero delivers the clear turning point with a three run homer against Tampa Bay. Belgium celebrates i...

The Yankees offense raises serious concerns without Aaron Judge, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit their wildly different Team USA predictions and celebrate CM Punk winning another championship. They also take an unexpected dive into NBA Summer League, discuss which young Nets could make a leap, and explain why Belgium matched the moment while the United States looked disconnected. Evan e...