Elli Fischer

Down The Rabbi Hole

Religion EN ↓ 41 episodes

Deep dives into forgotten corners of Jewish culture and social, material, and intellectual history.

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: hamapah.org

Author

Elli Fischer

Category

Religion

Podcast website

hamapah.org

Latest episode

Jun 10, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Tattoos According to R. Chaim Kanievsky and... Lenny Bruce (lehavdil)? 04.04.2022

In this episode we delve into R. Chaim Kanievsky's treatise on tattoos, called Patshegen HaKetav, as an example of how he thought, organized, and wrote. Along the way, we get a bit sidetracked by halakhic questions pertaining to tattoos and even suggest a "mekor" for the mistaken belief that someone with a tattoo cannot be buried in a Jewish cemetery. Link to the first page of R. Chaim Kanievsky's...

On Rav Chaim Kanievsky zt"l and on the "New" Role of Sar HaTorah 19.03.2022

On what made R. Chaim Kanievsky unique. And on the social leadership role that he held - or that was foisted upon him - in his later years.

Rav Melamed and Peninei Halakha 4: Responsa vs. Codes, Wholesale vs. Retail Halakha 11.03.2022

In this final episode of the series on Peninei Halakha we get into the meat of the current controversy and its roots. We also discuss "wholesale" vs. "retail" Halakha and the importance of this distinction.

R Melamed and Peninei Halakha 3: Codes, Commentaries, and Responsa 18.02.2022

In this episode, I discuss three genres of halakhic writing: codes, commentaries ("nosei Kelim"), and responsa (teshuvot). Each genre has specific objectives and goals. After a discussion of commentaries, I begin the discussion of codes vs. responsa by looking at the rulings of Rav Melamed and Rav Asher Weiss on a particular issue, one that is the subject of much controversy. Through this we start...

Rav Melamed and Peninei Halakha II: R. Melamed's "Civilizational" Approach to Halakha 07.02.2022

For Rav Melamed, the Torah is the blueprint for an ideal Jewish society in Eretz Yisrael. The details of halakha fit into a broader vision of that ideal society, and sometimes seemingly disparate areas of halakha work together in surprising ways.

Rav Eliezer Melamed and Peninei Halakhah I: Introducing a Phenomenon 03.02.2022

Rav Eliezer Melamed has recently been criticized harshly by leading rabbis from the right wing of Religious Zionism. This affords an opportunity to introduce Rav Melamed and his ongoing magnum opus, Peninei Halakha. In this first episode, I detail who he is, what the Peninei Halakha project is, and where it fits in the history of halakha. The upshot: His is the first successful reorganization of p...

The Torah's Rhetoric/Punishment Gap on Sexual Transgression; Thoughts on Responses to Walder 21.01.2022

Episode 10: We discuss an interesting phenomenon: Sometimes, the punishment that the Torah prescribes for sexual transgressions are not commensurate with the rhetorical severity ascribed to those same transgressions. This tendency becomes even more pronounced in the Neviim and Chazal. I cannot provide a reason for this gap, but I find that it can justify our outrage even in cases where the Torah's...

Down the Rabbinate Hole II: Halakhah and Hierarchy 02.01.2022

In this episode we describe the essential structure of halakhic authority as a social phenomenon (not as a matter of doctrine). We describe two models - the formal hierarchical model and the horizontally distributed model - and contend, elaborating on the view of Jacob Katz, that Halakhah operates according to a third model - an informal, emergent hierarchy. The implication of this model is that t...

Down the Rabbinate Hole I: Conversion in the State of Israel 30.12.2021

Conversion and its regulation is a major political fight in Israel today. Who is right? What's the debate? In this episode, I begin to take a broader look at institutionalized religion in Israel and try to situate the conversion conundrum within that. We get into the nitty gritty of the Halakhah and address an important graphic feature of how the laws of conversion were codified. We take issue wit...

Episode 7: A Little on Nittel 24.12.2021

On the origins of Jewish customs for "Nittel Nacht", or Christmas Eve. It's not the Chassidishe custom you thought it was. It actually originates somewhere else entirely... Some notes on this episode. Here's a thread I did last year on Twitter. You can see that here. It includes links to a source sheet and some nice pics/scans. https://twitter.com/Adderabbi/status/1342153328709545985?t=jKnOcnxM-N9...

The 8th of Teves and Chasam Sofer's Fascination with it 12.12.2021

In this episode we cover:  A bit on the Chabad celebration of 5 Teves, "Yom Didan Natzach" Background on Megillas Taanis - both the Tannaitic and Geonic versions Attitudes toward the translation of the Torah into Greek - in Chazal and among other groups The Chasam Sofer's fascination with the 8th of Teves as the day commemorating the translation Links  to articles mentioned: Moshe Simon-...

Judaizers 05.12.2021

Throughout Chanukah, we heard about Hellenizers, the Jews who took on elements of Greek culture. But what about Judaizers - non-Jews who are attracted to and take on elements of Jewish culture and religion? They have existed for thousands of years. Do we have a way of thinking about them?

Rav David Zvi Hoffmann, part 4 (and final) 28.11.2021

Final episode, on RDZH, discussing his combination of different ways of learning Torah (academic, pilpulistic, halakhic), commentary on the Germany of his era, and his hopes for the future. Link to a poster with the schedule of the conference on RDZH on January 3, 2022.

Rav David Zvi Hoffmann, part 3 21.11.2021

Using Rav Hoffmann's introduction to Melamed Le-ho'il as a jumping off point, we discuss his life, work, unique combination of styles and methods, and important contributions to different areas of Torah. In this episode, we discuss a major turning point in R. Hoffmann's life: The death of R. Azriel Hildesheimer

Rav David Zvi Hoffmann, part 2 14.11.2021

Using Rav Hoffmann's introduction to Melamed Le-ho'il as a jumping off point, we continue our discussion of his life, work, unique combination of styles and methods, and important contributions to different areas of Torah.

Rav David Zvi Hoffmann, part 1 07.11.2021

Using Rav Hoffmann's introduction to Melamed Le-ho'il as a jumping off point, we discuss his life, work, unique combination of styles and methods, and important contributions to different areas of Torah.

Listen to the Down The Rabbi Hole podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.