Discerning Geeks Portal
Discerning Geeks Portal
Discerning Geeks Portal is a gateway into the exploration of all things geek: Star Wars, Star Trek, Marvel, ‘80s movies, TV, and more. Dave, Todd, Andruw, and Preston, take a discerning look into the world of geek fandom. We care about intriguing storytelling, compelling characters, and thought-provoking themes, but we also love action, special effects, and comedy. We break down the positives, negatives, and mixed feelings about everything we cover. Step through the portal with us for fun and analytical discussions about geek culture, for fans, by fans.
Author
Discerning Geeks Portal
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 8, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
#079 - Holiday Topic - What Are We Thankful For? - Geek Edition (2021) 24.11.2021 1:09:00
The holidays are upon us. In this special quasi-Thanksgiving-themed episode we (eventually) discuss things we're thankful for in the geek realm. We discuss some of our favorite movies & TV shows that made an impression on us this year, potential upcoming projects we're thankful are in development, and even some YouTube pages and other podcasts that we're thankful for. - Which...
#078 - Movie Review - Tag 21.11.2021 1:08:45
Based on a real story & an article in the Wall Street Journal, we review the movie "Tag." In real life, 10 friends from Spokane, Washington, continue playing tag every February, even into adulthood, as a way of staying in each others' lives. In the movie, Hogan, Bob, Chilli, and Sable, work together in the month of May to tag their other best friend Jerry before he gets married and...
#077 - Movie Review - Tomorrowland 14.11.2021 1:19:18
This week we venture into a realm of discovery, vision, and innovation, as we review the (somewhat?) inspirational sci-fi family film "Tomorrowland." The film is based on the future-themed attraction that has a version at each of Disney's resorts in Anaheim, Orlando, Tokyo, Paris, Hong Kong, and Shanghai. - Did this movie's message go deep enough or remain "surface level"? - As o...
#076 - Whatcha' Doin'? - Early Nov. 2021 - Dune, Eternals, Fear Street, Foundation, What If...?, Legends of Tomorrow, Lost Symbol, Leverage: Redemption, Fantasy Island, The Orville, 4400, and more... 09.11.2021 1:10:49
In this week's Whatcha' Doin'? episode for early November 2021, we cover a lot of TV and movie topics, including things we've watched recently and things we're looking forward to in the near future. Here's our list of main topics... - “Foundation” (Apple TV+) - “Legends of Tomorrow” (The CW) - “Fear Street” trilogy (Netflix) - “Dune” (2021) (in theat...
#075 - Movie Review - Ocean's Eleven 29.10.2021 1:25:19
This week, we take a slight departure from science fiction & fantasy as we review the Las Vegas heist film, "Ocean's Eleven" -- a movie that's a remake, not a sequel, despite what a number in the title might imply (even the original 1960 version had the number). Continuing our recent and unintentional tradition of contentious reviews, opinions were further apart on this movie than you might ex...
#074 - Movie Review - Men In Black 22.10.2021 1:17:27
This week, we review the 1990s sci-fi action-comedy, "Men In Black." - Which co-host was seeing the movie for the first time, and was it what he expected? - Which co-host(s) disliked the movie, and what aspects of it did he/they find to be redeeming qualities? - How well did the special effects hold up? - Which co-star in this movie allegedly had a reputation for being hard...
#073 - Alpha-Movie-Bet #02 - Favorite Movies E to H 10.10.2021 1:05:50
We continue our new special mini-series, Alpha-Movie-Bet, with our 2nd installment covering our favorite movies starting with the letters E, F, G, and H. Among our favorites and honorable mentions, we list... - 7 science fiction movies - 5 fantasy movies - 7 dramas - 4 comedies - 2 animated movies - 1 horror movie - 2 horror-comedies - And, 2 horror...
#072 - Movie Review - Dune (1984) 03.10.2021 1:32:18
Listen now as we take a discerning look into the 1984 science fiction (or maybe fantasy) film "Dune" -- one of our most divisive movie reviews since "The Space Between Us" (who am I kidding; no review is more divisive than "The Space Between Us"). This 92 minute review is overflowing with opinion and analysis. At a running time this unintentionally epic, we possibly could have split th...
#071 - Special Report - BABYLON 5 REBOOT Is In Development by JMS at The CW 29.09.2021 52:51
BREAKING NEWS... Babylon 5, the all-time favorite TV show of one of our co-hosts, is getting a reboot that, basically, no one ever expected. Or, technically, it's being developed. There's still a chance it might not happen, but it least it's possible. We discuss our cautious optimism about the news, the long tweet from show creator J. Michael Straczynski confirming and clarifying...
#070 - Dragon Con 2021, Part 2 of 2 - Post-Con - How Did It Go? 26.09.2021 59:40
In this episode, Dave asks Todd how Dragon Con 2021 went. The discussion takes place a few days after it was over. We discuss how well the COVID safety measures worked, how well people followed the safety rules, what were some of the best panels & guests, what Dave would like to do when he finally gets to go to Dragon Con, and more. Check out episode #069 for Part 1 of the discussi...
#069 - Dragon Con 2021, Part 1 of 2 - Pre-Con - What is Dragon Con? 25.09.2021 46:23
This week's episode was recorded on Wednesday 01 September, the day before the start of Dragon Con 2021. Todd had arrived in Atlanta, Georgia, to attend the con, and discussed with Dave what Dragon Con is all about. Topics covered... - The size & scope of the con (5 host hotels & two buildings of the AmericasMart in downtown Atlanta) - COVID safety measures taken to have...
#068 - Movie Review - Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe 19.09.2021 1:10:42
This week, we review "The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe." While previous on-screen incarnations have existed as TV movies or mini-series, this is the theatrical film from 2005. This is the first of three Narnia movies and is based on the first of seven Narnia children's novels written by C. S. Lewis in the 1950s. - Is it a product of our era that it'...
#067 - Special Topic - The Lord of the Rings Film Trilogy - Part 2 of 2 12.09.2021 1:02:29
This week, we conclude our discussion about the "Lord of the Rings" film trilogy, a special topic too epic to contain in just one episode. Last week we focused on characters. This week, we focus on what Dave calls Moments of Awesomeness -- and, there are many. Two moments were so awesome, in an emotional way, one co-host's voice cracked a bit just describing them. This topic was too ep...
#066 - Special Topic - The Lord of the Rings Film Trilogy - Part 1 of 2 07.09.2021 1:07:48
We're finally doing it... We're finally taking a discerning look into one of the greatest (if not *thee* greatest) film trilogies of all time, "The Lord of the Rings." We discuss the theatrical versions vs. the extended editions, the movies vs. the books, and the awesomeness of the characters. Much of this first part is taken up with the following character superlatives. - Cooles...
#065 - Movie Review - Back to the Future, Part II 30.08.2021 1:09:03
This week, we review the classic middle installment of an almost-certainly-never-to-be-rebooted trilogy, "Back to the Future, Part II." We discuss the movie's story structure, tone, pacing, character focus, and the excellent cliffhanger ending. How much (or how little) does the movie's depiction of 2015 hold up to the 2015 we now know in our real world past? Do the special effects depi...
#064 - Alpha-Movie-Bet #01 - Favorite Movies A to D 22.08.2021 1:07:35
And, this week, something completely different. Again. This week, one of the Daves couldn't make it, so we postponed our review of (spoilers) "Back to the Future, Part II" and improvised with something we're calling...eh...Alpha-Movie-Bet. (There are mixed feelings about the name.) The concept is simple. We took turns discussing 2 or 3 of our favorite movies beginning with a cert...
#063 - Whatcha' Doin'? - Early Aug. 2021 - Masters of the Universe, Star Wars: Bad Batch, Space Jam 2, Teen Titans, and more 15.08.2021 57:44
This week, we have another Whatcha's Doin'? episode, where we talk about anything we're watching, reading, playing, or thinking about in the geek sphere (okay, admittedly no reading or playing this particular week, but we've covered books & games in other Whatcha' Doin'? episodes; check those out). In an effort to catch up after our two-week hiatus, we recorded this the same night as our...
#062 - Movie Review - Blade Runner 08.08.2021 1:00:35
And...we're back! Sorry for the unexpected hiatus, but a couple of co-hosts were out of town on a vacation. This week, we are back on track with a review of the 1982 sci-fi classic film, "Blade Runner." Does this film stand the test of time? How well do its story, characters, and dialogue stack up against its impressive visuals? Are its visuals good enough to make up for an...
#061 - What Should Andruw Watch? #01 - TV Series Premieres 25.07.2021 1:05:09
And, this week, something completely different… We’ve chosen TV Series Premieres as the inaugural topic in our new series we tentatively refer to as…”What Should Andruw Watch?” (Let us know by e-mail or social media whether you prefer “Educating Andruw” or have an even better name.) You see, three of us on this podcast have been geeks longer than Andruw has been alive. We’ve accepted t...
#060 - TV Review - Loki - Episodes 1.05 & 1.06 20.07.2021 40:40
This week, we review the last two episodes of the Disney+ MCU series "Loki." We discuss how episodes 5 & 6 stack up against the other four episodes, the relationship between Loki & Sylvie, the major new character introduced in the finale, and the nature of the timelines. What was the creature in the jar buried in the ground on the alien world? Where did all the lunch trays come...
#059 - Movie Review - Black Widow (NON-Spoiler Review) 17.07.2021 19:59
We started podcasting exactly 12 months ago in the midst of the pandemic, but finally, FINALLY, we have, FOR THE FIRST TIME, a review of not a years-old classic but a BRAND NEW RELEASE, in theaters, RIGHT NOW, in July 2021. This week we review the 24th MCU film, "BLACK WIDOW." And... Eh, it's okay. We discuss the overall feel of the movie, its value & placement within the larger Ma...
#058 - Movie Review - Back to the Future 13.07.2021 1:08:51
This week, we journey back to 1985 and 1955, in our review of the period piece, teen coming-of-age story, bizarre family drama, and yes, sci-fi time travel classic, "Back to the Future." We discuss the film's extremely well-crafted story, the music and sound, some of the changes from the original premise to the finished story, the replacement of the lead actor weeks into production, and comparison...
#057 - Movie Review - The Avengers 08.07.2021 1:07:32
This week, we review the culmination of the MCU Phase 1 and the first Marvel movie to earn $1 billion, "The Avengers." We discuss the movie's moments of humor, our favorite moments, Loki as the antagonist, and the visuals. Does "The Avengers" hold up over time? How strong (or weak) is the story compared to the visuals and the coolness factor? Do parts of the plot even make sense?...
#056 - TV Review - Loki - Episodes 1.01 to 1.04 04.07.2021 56:07
This week, we review the first four episodes of the Disney+ MCU series, "Loki." We discuss the series' surprising turning points, the witty humor, and the buddy-cop-like chemistry between Tom Hiddleston as Loki and Owen Wilson as TVA agent Mobius. How does the "Loki" series compare to "WandaVision" and "Falcon and the Winter Soldier"? How do we think this TV show and the other shows are clai...
#055 - Movie Review - Captain America: The First Avenger 26.06.2021 1:14:39
This week, we review the World War II historical drama -- and the 5th movie of the Marvel Cinematic Universe -- "Captain America: The First Avenger." We discuss the story, pacing, characters, excellent casting of characters (not just in this movie but for the entire MCU), the movie's handling of 1940s technology, and the portrayal of the friendship between Steve and Bucky. We also continue to spin...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.