Dark Roast: Caffeine Casefiles Podcast

Welcome back. Grab a mug, fill it with something dark and unforgiving, and let’s get started. For years, Toronto’s LGBTQ+ Village felt a predator in their midst as men vanished without a trace—immigrants, refugees, those living on the margins. Police said there was no evidence of a serial killer. But in a quiet apartment, a landscaper who played Santa Claus at the mall was hiding a nightmare in ba...

They were Canadian pharma royalty—beloved philanthropists with a billion-dollar fortune. But on December 15, 2017, Barry and Honey Sherman were found murdered in their Toronto home, staged in a chilling pose by their basement pool . Eight years later, the question still haunts Canada: who killed the Shermans? In this episode, we unravel the twisted investigation that has been plagued by missteps,...

In 2017, Canadian billionaire Barry Sherman and his wife Honey Sherman were found strangled in their Toronto home. At first, police suggested murder - suicide. Then the narrative changed. In this episode of Dark Roast: Caffeine Casefiles, Cait explores one of Canada’s most unsettling unsolved cases - digging into wealth, power, investigative missteps, and the questions that still refuse to go away...