Cryptid Cocktail Party

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are joined by friend of the show Jeremy London (Mallrats, Party Of Five) to discuss one of, and I say this all the time but really mean it, the wildest alien abduction stories to come out of Japan—or anywhere, for that matter. For real. So...enjoy!

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave took the day off and left Sarge unattended. Hours later, covered in sweat, and his mind exploding with information, Sarge tells his best friend and long suffering neighbor, Maynerd, about the phenomenon of gangstalking. If you or a family member suffers from symptoms associated with gangstalking, please check out these reso...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we kick off 2025 strong, not really, with an alien abduction case that we feel is underrated, sick as hell, and rad as fuck, but also changed how people in the community looked at group abductions. This week we cover...the Allagash Abductions (as well as some of the myths on Hypnotic Regression Therapy) Enjoy!

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are covering one of Dave's all-time favorite theories...Hollow Moon! Is it a space station built by an ancient alien civilization? Was it built by humans in the distant future and brought back through time and placed here to save humanity? Or is it a hologram meant to shield us from the truth? I dunno. Maybe to all of it? Give...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we celebrate the Winter Solstice and cover one of the most well-known and terrifying figures of holiday folklore...Krampus! The goat-horned demon of Pagan turned Christian tradition known for his horrifying imagery and harsh punishments. His story and journey through the centuries is wildly fascinating and super fun so sit back a...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week Sarge, Maynard, and I dust off the old tinfoil hats to discuss some good old conspiracy theories. We go over Project Blue Beam, a conspiracy theory popularized in the '90s claiming that NASA along with the UN and other global elites will use multiple tactics to bring about the New World Order, and we also talk about how it ties i...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This episode, we are joined by our good friend Mathew to cover not one but TWO subspecies of Sasquatch—the infamous Sheepsquatch of West Virginia and the terrifying winged beast known as Batsquatch of the Pacific Northwest. And as an added bonus we pit the two together to see who will be crowned the superior Squatch! Enjoy! Follow Mathew o...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by none other than Jonathan Perez of Latinos Against Spooky Shit and The Spooky Guys podcast to cover a cryptid that is rooted in both factual history and Old West superstition. We are covering the infamous Red Ghost! This story is wild and this episode is a lot of fun. Enjoy! Find Jonathan, Latinos Against Spooky S...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by Jordan Holmes of the podcast Knowledge Fight to discuss a Slavic folklore story that some of you may be familiar with image-wise, but not so much the story. On this episode we discuss...Baba Yaga! From her grotesque appearance to her famous hut on chicken legs to her dual nature as both a villain and a savior. Th...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! In light of the recent news that Info Wars as we know it is dead, we thought it would be fun to go down memory lane and discuss some of the more outlandish and less dangerous and hateful conspiracies Alex Jones has discussed in his almost 30 years of broadcasting. And then we decided to rank them into a good old-fashioned Top 3 List. Some...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week marks the first proper episode Sarge and Dave have done together in close to a month!!! On this episode, in honor of us being invited to be Cryptid Camp Councilors, we cover a cryptid/folkloric creature we have been meaning to cover but haven't, until now. That being the metal beaked, one eyed, molten metal clawed creature of ger...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! Sarge got the week off to do whatever people in Massachusetts do to relax...fight a cop, drink a Dunkins, I don't know. So Dave is joined instead by friend of the show and host of Oh Look! Another Ghost! Nick Einstman, We dive into a few cases of shared delusions this week but focus mainly on one specific story. That of Gloria Ramirez, als...

Welcome back to a VERY special episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! Every wonder what happens when you tried to take the plot of a horror movie and turn it into a true crime podcast? Well, you get our Halloween Special, that’s what! Dave tries to trick Sarge once again by turning the plot of the 1978 horror movie classic Halloween into a dramatic true-crime podcast. And it kind of works! The podcast...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave is still MIA in the great white north so Sarge takes the reigns once again with the help of Cam and Amanda to discuss one of the weirdest sightings ever caught on film. The infamous Fresno Nightcrawlers!

Welcome back to another episode of the AWARD WINNING Cryptid Cocktail Party. Dave is attending to a maple syrup emergency in Canada, so Sarge landed the plane with help from our special guest, Cam from Narragansett. Cam and Sarge investigate a monstrous crab-like being and the part it played in a decades old mystery involving a true American hero.

Welcome back to another episode of the AWARD WINNING Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, the boys return to solve the case of a decades-old mystery involving the Irving family and their time living with the mischievous entity known as Gef the Talking Mongoose. Enjoy!

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week Dave and Sarge wrap up their series on time travel conspiracies with Project Pegasus Part Two! On this episode we go over some of Andrew Basiago's exploits during his time in Project Pegasus including his trip to witness the Gettysburg Address and his meeting with George Washington. We also discuss his time in the CIA's Mars Jump...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week Dave and Sarge continue their journey of Time Travel-based conspiracies with Project Pegasus! Another "Top Secret" child experiment based on Tesla technology. Man, the Government sure does seem to love this trope. In this episode, we cover why children make the best test subjects and the different types of technology used in thes...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week Dave and Sarge dive deep into the world of conspiracy theories to figure out the truth, kind of, of one of the most popular theories out there...The Montauk Project!

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave and Sarge cover the lesser-known conflict known as the Bigfoot War of 1855! It all started when a series of mysterious raids and kidnappings occurred in Choctaw settlements by unknown perpetrators resulting in a band of warriors facing off with a group of vicious and brutal bigfoot. It's a very wild story. So tune in and en...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week Dave and Sarge are joined by Dave's cousin Devin for a trip down to good ole West Virginia to talk about a vampiric house plant come to life...the Vegetable Man of West Virginia aka The Veggie Man! This one has got twists and turns galore so strap in and enjoy!

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by very special guest, Matthew Schang! For those of you unaware, he is the cohost of the Mothboys Podcast, the organizer of Cryptid Bash and the Veggie Man Festival, and an accomplished author. So we invited him to play a stupid game called "One Off Cryptids!" Three stories, one is fake, and Sarge and Matt have to f...

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week Sarge and Dave make their way down south to discuss the absolutely true tale of the Dogman and his part in the Land Between the Lakes Massacre. Its definitely a true story even though you won't find any police reports, news coverage, or eyewitnesses. So...believe its true and enjoy!

Welcome back to a BONUS episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! On this episode Dave lets Sarge choose his own adventure by prompting CHAT GPT to come up with one of the better AI Creepypastas we have ever read on the show. Enjoy!

Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave and Sarge travel again to the Pacific Northwest to discuss an alien encounter that is definitely a top 5 regarding weirdness. Enjoy!