Crimenelia Street

Send us Fan Mail This week on Crimenelia Street , we’re digging into the baffling 2007 disappearance of Andrew Gosden — a 14-year-old who bought a one-way ticket to London and vanished like a Reputation promo post. Was it a planned escape, foul play, or something else? As always, we close with a Taylor Swift–themed palette cleanser to emotionally rebalance our listeners — this week we’re discussin...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Tori and Sam discuss the murder of Kathleen Peterson and the subsequent trial of her husband, Michael Peterson, who was charged with her murder. This is a twisty-turny one that spans continents and decades, spawning numerous internet theories about what really happened that night in December 2001.  For our palate cleanser, we discuss YET another Rep TV theory and...

Send us Fan Mail This week on Crimenelia Street , we’re donning our scrubs and diving into the case of Charles Cullen—a seemingly mild-mannered nurse who may be one of the most prolific serial killers in American history. Over a sinister 16-year career, Cullen moved from hospital to hospital across New Jersey and Pennsylvania, leaving a trail of unexplained deaths and unanswered questions in his w...

Send us Fan Mail Welcome clowns far and wide, to a special episode of Crimenelia Street. In anticipation of this year's American Music Awards, Tori and Sam discuss the many Easter Eggs being dropped and what we hope to happen *cough reputation Taylor's Version cough*.  But we also realize it could be anything, or maybe nothing at all. Schrodinger's Taylor's version? Only time w...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Crimenelia St, Sam and Tori discuss the disturbing case of Anneliese Michel and the circumstances surrounding her death after she went through a total of 67 of exorcisms sanctioned by the Catholic Church. Blending faith, fear, and questions about mental illness, Anneliese's story forces us to confront the blurred lines between spiritual belief and personal...

Send us Fan Mail This week on Crimenelia Street , we’re straddling the line between chilling true crime and glitter-drenched Swiftie speculation. We kick things off with the latest updates in the true crime world before diving deep into one of LA’s most infamous homes—the Los Feliz Murder House. What's haunted history and what is Hollywood myth? We dissect the eerie lore that’s kept this mans...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Sam tells Tori about the chilling case of Danielle Redlick, the woman accused of murdering her husband, former NBA executive Michael Redlick, and waiting hours to call 911 — all while allegedly cleaning up the scene.  Afterwards, we clown around about traffic lights and horses wearing friendship bracelets. If you think you may be experiencing domestic violence, fo...

Send us Fan Mail This week on Crimenelia Street , we’re taking a detour down a dark alley that leads into a frustrating case: the tragic story of 13-year-old Madeline Soto.  We’ll break down the timeline of Madeline’s disappearance, and the red flags no one seemed to notice. You're going to be yelling at your speakers. It’s a tough one—but you know we’ll guide you through it with a balance of...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Sam tells Tori about the infamous Heaven's Gate cult that spanned decades until members decided to take their fate into their own hands. We follow up the story with more Era's Tour speculation and theories...spoiler alert: we were SO wrong. TW: Suicide Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at c...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Tori tells Sam about Ellen Greenberg, a young woman with a promising future who was found deceased in her apartment. Authorities ruled it a suicide, but the circumstances and evidence might prove otherwise.  Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @Cr...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we dive into the dark and disturbing story of Israel Keyes, a serial killer whose methodical and terrifying crimes shocked the nation. Operating with chilling precision, Keyes left a trail of mystery and terror across the U.S. for years before his arrest. With no clear motive and no pattern to his killings, his crimes seemed to come out of nowhere—making him one o...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we dive into the dark and disturbing story of Israel Keyes, a serial killer whose methodical and terrifying crimes shocked the nation. Operating with chilling precision, Keyes left a trail of mystery and terror across the U.S. for years before his arrest. With no clear motive and no pattern to his killings, his crimes seemed to come out of nowhere—making him one o...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we dive into the dark and disturbing story of Israel Keyes, a serial killer whose methodical and terrifying crimes shocked the nation. Operating with chilling precision, Keyes left a trail of mystery and terror across the U.S. for years before his arrest. With no clear motive and no pattern to his killings, his crimes seemed to come out of nowhere—making him one o...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we dive into the dark and disturbing story of Israel Keyes, a serial killer whose methodical and terrifying crimes shocked the nation. Operating with chilling precision, Keyes left a trail of mystery and terror across the U.S. for years before his arrest. With no clear motive and no pattern to his killings, his crimes seemed to come out of nowhere—making him one o...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we unravel the chilling tale of the gruesome murder of Betty Gore in a small, sleepy town in Texas in 1980. With friendship, betrayal, and an axe at the center of this story, we delve into the events that led to her untimely death and the sensational trial that followed.  Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Sam and Tori get into a Penn State mystery: the murder of Betsy Aardsma. On a quiet November day in 1969, Betsy, a young graduate student at Penn State, was fatally stabbed in the university’s library, and despite the crowded scene, Betsy and her family never got the justice they deserved. Who would want to harm this bright, promising woman, and how did the case g...

Send us Fan Mail This week we're dressed in our Halloween costumes as we explore the tragic story of Brittany Murphy, the beloved actress known for her roles in Clueless and 8 Mile . We’ll explore the circumstances surrounding her untimely death and the theories that emerged in its aftermath. Join us as we examine the details of her personal life from the unsettling relationships with those c...

Send us Fan Mail Join us as we set sail on a haunting journey through the storied past of the Queen Mary, one of the most iconic ocean liners in history. In this episode, we delve into the ship's illustrious beginnings, from its role in WWII to its transformation into a luxurious cruise liner. But the Queen Mary is not just a marvel of engineering; it's also a hotbed of paranormal activi...

Send us Fan Mail Nicholas Barclay was just 13 years old when he vanished out of thin air in 1994. Years later, he is miraculously found alive, but things-and people-are not always what they seem.  Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

Send us Fan Mail In this episode we dive into the truly haunting story of underserved citizens of Vancouver being taken advantage of by the disgusting pig farmer serial killer Robert Pickton. Join us as we explore the dark underbelly of the missing women's cases that spanned over 20 years in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside and how Pickton exploited systemic vulnerabilities to commit his horrifi...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we try to unravel the chain of events that led to the deaths of two individuals, Max Shacknai and Rebecca Zahau.  Sources:  https://www.sdsheriff.gov/bureaus/media-relations/common-questions/coronado-death-investigation https://radaronline.com/exclusives/2011/10/rebecca-zahau-investigation-forensic-expert-forced-case/ https://abcnews.go.com/US/coronado-mansion-vic...

Send us Fan Mail On today's episode we discuss the horrific true stories of the victims of David Carpenter, The Trailside Killer. Sources: The Sleeping Lady by Robert Graysmith https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Carpenter https://thehauntghosttours.com/blog/trailside-serial-killer-san-francisco/ https://allthatsinteresting.com/david-carpenter https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6ziP0AJpnU https...

Send us Fan Mail Today we delve into the true story of Andrew Cunanan and his killing spree across America, taking the lives of 5 innocent men and leaving us with more questions than answers. Sources: "Vulgar Favors" by Maureen Orth https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/serial-killers-part-6-andrew-cunanan https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/cunanan/stories/victims.htm htt...