Crime with Holly

In September of 2012, Faith Hedgepeth was a college student at UNC Chapel Hill.  After a night out with friends she came home and was attacked in her own home.  Her murder went unsolved for 9 years before her killer was finally identified. Listen to her tragic story now told by Holly. The Faith's Smile Scholarship: https://www.facebook.com/donate/770033614310043/10226610020668760/ The YouTube vide...

🎃 The Candyman: Timothy O’Bryan In 1974, eight-year-old Timothy O’Bryan died after eating poisoned Halloween candy, sparking nationwide fear, until investigators uncovered the unthinkable truth: the killer was his own father. This episode unpacks the chilling case of Ronald Clark O’Bryan, forever known as “The Candyman,” and the crime that changed Halloween safety forever. NOW AVAILABLE: CRIME WI...

When beloved schoolteacher Stephanie Scott went missing just days before her wedding, the small town of Leeton, New South Wales, was shaken to its core. What began as a desperate search for a bride-to-be soon turned into a horrifying discovery — one that revealed brutality and a shocking abuse of trust within her own school. In this episode, we uncover the life of Stephanie Scott, the community th...

In July of 2017, Susan Osborne's mother Linda reported her daughter and grandson missing after not having heard from them for two months.  Responding authorities showed up at the home Susan shared with her third husband Jerry for him to tell them she and Evan ran off with another man. Listen to Susan & Evan's story now! If you or anyone you know has information on their disappearance you can c...

Hey Fam, This week I was unable to record due to my work schedule but I will be back Monday for a Missing Monday episode! Leah Dee from Least of these shared with me a very special episode that she worked on with the victims family. This story is tragic and Mandey's brother Randey wants everyone to know what happened to his sister! “90 Percent Lie” - The Case of Mandey Noe - Weakley County, Tennes...

Randy Ferguson was a family man who finally found love at the age of 40.  After 5 years of marriage he mysteriously vanished after leaving his home after a fight with his wife.  It wasn't long before he was found murdered.  Randy was a victim of domestic violence at the hands of his wife.  Listen to his story now! Domestic Violence Resources: Thehotline. Org is an incredible resource and is a nati...

In March 2012, 15-year-old Annie Kasprzak vanished in Draper, Utah. The next day, her body was discovered in the Jordan River, and what looked like a tragic runaway story quickly turned into a murder investigation. Annie’s death revealed secrets, lies, and a tangled trail that would take years to fully unravel. NOW AVAILABLE: CRIME WITH HOLLY PATREON! www.patreon.com/crimewithholly Enjoy ad free f...

In this episode of Crime with Holly , Holly speaks with Jenn Buta , mother of Jordan DeMay , a 17-year-old who tragically took his life on March 25, 2022 , after being targeted in a financial sextortion scheme. This crime is rapidly growing, the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children received over 26,000 reports in 2023 , with most victims being teen boys between 14 and 17 years old...

It was November 1987 when newlyweds Gail and Rick Brink’s promising future was suddenly stolen in the most brutal way imaginable. Found murdered at their Michigan home, the crime shook a quiet community and left investigators scrambling for answers. For decades the case remained unsolved and behind it all was a secret that someone thought was worth killing for. Listen to their story now! Grab your...

From birth the cards were stacked against Tina but she fought hard to overcome all the hurdles and obstacles that she faced.  But after the loss of her father at just 12-years-old her life started on a downward spiral.  Tina was failed her entire life by the system in Canada and many interventions could've been done to save her. In August 2014, 15-year-old Tina's body would be pulled from the Red...

On this episode of Crime with Holly , I sit down with the incredible Angeline Hartmann , Director of Communications for the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children . Angeline opens up about her remarkable career in crime reporting, shares insights into a case she has been connected to for more than 20 years , and gives us a look into a new case she’s currently working on . We also div...

In 1999, three young employees were found murdered inside a Tucson Pizza Hut—a crime so brutal it shook the city to its core. Who could have carried out such a cold-blooded attack, and why? Join us as we dive into the Pizza Hut murders, the investigation, and the lingering questions that still haunt Arizona. Homicide Survivors Organization: https://homicidesurvivorsinc.org NOW AVAILABLE: CRIME WIT...

In 2011, 16-year-old Alexis “Lexi” Rasmussen disappeared after a babysitting job. For weeks she remained missing and those who were closest to her stayed tight lipped. Eventually people started to come forward and the truth was incredibly shocking. Did Lexi run away or was she influenced, manipulated, and taken advantage of by two adults who she considered friends? Listen to her story now! Dea Mil...

Austin Texas, 1983. A close-knit family is experiencing a wave of terror and domestic violence connected to a recent break-up. By the time everything played out, there would be burglary, threats, stalking, arson, false allegations to a workplace, attempted shootings, assault, and eventually there would be murder. So much of this heartbreaking situation has been left unresolved, with everything lea...

In March 2014, eight-year-old Relisha Rudd vanished without a trace from a homeless shelter in Washington, D.C. She was living with her mother and siblings at the former D.C. General Hospital shelter when she formed a bond with Kahlil Malik Tatum, a janitor at the facility with a criminal past. Surveillance footage shows Relisha walking with Tatum in a local hotel hallway on March 1, 2014, this wa...

Samantha Josephson was a beautiful 21-year-old University of South Carolina student who was weeks away from graduating.  She had just been accepted into Drexel University School of Law and went out to celebrate with friends on March 28th, 2019.  After a few hours out Samantha ordered herself an Uber to go home but she never made it. Listen to her story now told by Holly. What's My Name Foundation:...

On Super Bowl Sunday, 2004, 11-year-old Carlie Brucia vanished in broad daylight from a Sarasota car wash. Within days, a chilling surveillance video would shock the nation—showing Carlie being led away by a stranger. In this gripping episode, we retrace the events leading up to her disappearance, explore the disturbing footage, and recount the desperate manhunt for her abductor. Listen to her sto...

In November 1997, pregnant 28-year-old Jodie Bordeaux was spending an evening at home with her husband Shawn when shots were fired at the home. Sadly one of the bullets struck Jodie in the head, killing her instantly. For nearly 3 decades this case has remained unsolved despite the authorities having a solid suspect. Who could want to murder Jodie? Listen to her story now! NOW AVAILABLE: CRIME WIT...

Hey Everyone, I decided to take the week off due to family passing through Las Vegas and the holiday weekend. But never fear!!!! Please allow me to introduce to you my dear friend Megan from A Simpler Time True Crime. Her style is very similar to mine and I think you all will find that she's a new podcast to add to your list! Love y'all and see you next week! On an early Wednesday morning in 1992,...

Kelley Clayton appeared to have it all. A beautiful life, a loving husband, and two incredible children. But on the night of September 28th, 2015 that picture perfect life would come to a brutal end and the only witness was Kelley's 7-year-old daughter. Listen to her story now! FilmRise Documentary mentioned in episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JehX-WSRyAE&t=2053s NOW AVAILABLE: CRIME W...

On January 7th, 2016, 19-year-old Tyarra Williams had spent the morning getting enrolled in college courses that she was eager to begin.  Later that evening after visiting with her mom she enjoyed dinner at her grandma's house with her boyfriend and brother.  Around 8:30pm she told them she was going to meet up with a guy named Travis and she would be back within an hour.  Tyarra never came back....

A phone call, a housekeeper, and a crackpipe. On May 17th, 2023, 34-year-old Anthony Corrado called his grandparent's housekeeper and told her he needed help cleaning up a mess at the home. When the housekeeper arrived, she stumbled into a horrific scene. 82-year-old, Mary Schaivone had been brutally murdered. As the housekeeper went for help, 74-year-old, Tony Schaivone arrived home. If you or so...

On June 2nd, 2007, 18-year-old Kelsey Smith went to Target to shop for an anniversary gift for her boyfriend. When she didn't return home everyone knew this was out of character for the reliable and responsible teen. They quickly began searching for Kelsey but she remained missing for four days before she was found deceased. Listen to her story now! Kelsey's Army: Kelseysarmy.org Statistics Show T...

After several tragic losses in her life, 18-year-old Rachel Burkheimer got mixed up with the wrong crowd of people. In September 2002, Rachel was forced to watch her very own grave be dug by people who she once considered her friends.  Listen to her tragic story now. NOW AVAILABLE: CRIME WITH HOLLY PATREON! www.patreon.com/crimewithholly Enjoy ad free for just $2 a month! Enjoying the show?  Here'...

In January 2025, 14-year-old Emily Pike snuck out of her group home in Mesa, Arizona. She was never seen alive again. Nearly three weeks later her dismembered body would be found 100 miles away near Globe, Arizona. What happened to Emily Pike and who could do this to such a sweet young girl? Listen to her story now! If you or anyone you know has information contact the Gila County Sheriffs Office...