Crime Salad

Explore the chilling and unsolved mystery of Amy Mihaljevic, the 10-year-old girl who vanished on October 27, 1989, after leaving Bay Village Middle School. Learn about her last known moments, the iconic turquoise horse-head earrings she wore, and the ongoing investigation into her disappearance. Dive into the heart of this true crime case that continues to baffle authorities and captivate the pub...

Two women who lived in the same city, shared the same name, and even looked alike with dark hair and similar haircuts were murdered just four days apart. Mary Lou Henderson Morris and Mary McGinnis Morris were both reported missing by their families and found dead inside their cars hours later; neither were robbed, and both cases are still unsolved. Were these murders an eerie coincidence? Did som...

In this episode, we delve into the chilling case of Mike Williams, who vanished without a trace in December 2000. Mike woke up early that morning, eager for a duck hunting trip on Lake Seminole, before celebrating his wedding anniversary with his wife, Denise. As the day progressed with no word from Mike, Denise's concern turned into panic. Desperate to find him, she enlisted the help of his best...

Betty Bowman, 32, and her husband, Connor, 30, appeared to have an idyllic life. They met at the University of Kansas School of Pharmacy; after graduation, she became an operating room pharmacist, and he started medical school, moonlighting as a poison control specialist. The couple openly maintained an open relationship, agreeing to see other people on the condition of full transparency about any...

In the heart of Milwaukee, a vibrant city known for its brewing history and beautiful lakefront, Kelly Dwyer lives life to the fullest. At twenty-seven, she's a yoga enthusiast with a passion for Milwaukee’s nightlife, and her infectious spirit makes her a beloved figure among her peers. But beneath the surface of her seemingly carefree existence on social media and trendy dating apps, a mystery b...

In the spring of 2012, a tragic story unfolded in the small, scenic town of North Bend, Washington, which revealed the dark undercurrents running beneath the life of the Keller family. Peter Keller, a 41-year-old man, led his family into a disastrous spiral driven by his own inner demons and possible financial troubles. His wife, Lynnettee, also 41, and their 18-year-old daughter, Kaylene, were ou...

In the quiet town of Vidor, Texas, the story of Katelynn Nicole Stone, a 16-year-old whose life was tragically cut short, unfolds amidst whispers of a love triangle gone awry. Born and raised in this close-knit community, Katelynn's sudden disappearance and untimely death not only captured widespread attention but also unraveled a complex web of emotions and secrets. This episode delves into the h...

In the heart of Virginia and the bustling streets of Washington DC, a real-life horror unfolded, chillingly dubbed "The Shopping Cart Killer." Anthony Robinson's heinous acts left a trail of victims, sparking a massive investigation. Though he's been caught, the shadow of possibly more undiscovered victims looms large. Delve into the eerie reality behind the nickname, a story that blurs the line b...

On the morning of March 12, 2011, the manager of a LuLuLemon store, was on her way to work that was located in Bethesda, Maryland. From the moment she opened the unlocked door she knew something was terribly wrong. The store was in complete disarray with bloody footprints all over the ground. The actual horror of what lay inside was far worse than she ever could have imagined. From the looks of it...

Discover the chilling motives behind the crimes and the meticulous detective work that led to the capture of "The Zombie Hunter." Explore how modern technology played a crucial role in solving these cold cases and bringing peace to the victims' families. FUM: Start the Good Habit at https://tryfum.com/SALAD to save 10% off the Journey Pack today! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.f...

Riley Crossman, a 15-year-old girl from West Virginia, vanished on Wednesday night, May 7, 2019. Riley was lying in bed facetiming with her boyfriend when a man she knew entered her room. Riley quietly texted him that she was afraid and not to talk but her boyfriend had fallen asleep. Whatever occurred soon after this text led to the disappearance of Riley Crossman, a careful and strong search whe...

In the heart of Texas, where family values and church Sundays mesh seamlessly with the landscape, lived Nancy Shore and her husband, John Franklin Howard, a son of a preacher who went by the name Frank. Frank was a doting husband. He financially supported the family as they raised their three children. create a short description of this The case took a chilling twist when it was revealed that Fran...

This episode tells the story of the murder of Barbara Weaver, who lived in the quiet Ohio Amish community. Despite being married, Eli was involved in secret relationships with other women. His life took a dark turn when he decided he wanted to get rid of his wife. With the help of one of his girlfriends, he went to extreme lengths to come up with a plan. This episode highlights the steps some peop...

This story is hard to listen to, but I feel so drawn to it and have this need to share it on the podcast because I grew up in the same area where this happened, so it’s very near and dear to my heart. I came across this story from someone who shared it with me that I know personally. This may not be a very lengthy episode, but it’s a big one, especially for the family affected. This week’s story i...

At first glance, the Stockdale family appeared to be your average close-knit American family, residing in a rural area and being very interested in both music and religion. The parents and their four boys appeared on the well-liked ABC program Wife Swap back in 2008. However, tragedy struck at the Stockdale residence on June 15, 2017. It was the first time police had ever heard from the Stockdale...

If you haven’t listened to that episode yet, go check out the episode called, “Moms of Truth - Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt” on our Crime Salad podcast feed. https://podcasts.apple.com/za/podcast/moms-of-truth-ruby-franke-and-jodi-hildebrant/id1457141569?i=1000629553884 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

This is part 2 of The Deadly Voyage: The Disappearance of Pegye Bechler. In this episode, we finish up what we left out in part one. Was there some crazy motive behind Pegye's murder or did she fake her death like some still believe to this day because of their financial struggles? Listen to Part 1 before beginning this episode. Also, don't forget about our amazing sponsors this week: FUM - Start...

A married couple sets sail on the ocean to celebrate their five-year anniversary when tragedy strikes; Pegye Bechler falls overboard in a terrible accident and is never seen again. Immediate suspicions about this incident revolve around Pegye's disappearance. Could a champion swimmer simply disappear into the water after falling off a boat, never to be seen again, or do investigators suspect a mot...

It was first confusing to learn that the 5-year-old was not asleep in her bed when the terrible discovery was made in the early morning hours around 3 a.m. However, once her dad's girlfriend, who was there watching his two kids, noticed the back door was left wide open, it created a terrifying level of terror. Was she kidnapped by someone who broke into the house? Or had she escaped? In a situatio...

You initially see the eccentric, solitary next-door neighbor as an ordinary individual who voluntarily monitors the neighborhood and gives a helping hand to those in need, giving you a sense of security—a thought that makes you realize there’s still good people in the world. However, you are shocked to learn that the person who you thought was harmless lives right next door is in fact a serial kil...

In Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, nine family members, including parents David and April and their children, experienced the worst criminal event in Broken Arrow history on July 23, 2015. Authorities arrived at the scene as a result of 12-year-old Daniel Bever's brave 911 call. Upgrade your sleep with Miracle Made! Go to TryMiracle.com/CRIMESALAD and use the code CRIMESALAD to claim your FREE 3-PIECE TOW...

In this episode, we cover the case that involves three children whose lives were turned upside down by their very own mother, Diane Downs. A mother who seemed to take in the attention of the media in multiple interviews while her kids were in the hospital.  Did she want to put an end to her previous life and begin a new one with someone else? Visit aeropress.com/CRIMESALAD to save up to 20%. It's...

Join Ashley and Ricky as they examine the puzzling case of the McStay family, who mysteriously vanished from their California home in 2010. Years later, when investigators discovered the truth, shocking revelations and unexpected twists emerged, shocking a community and forever changing the lives of those involved. This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhe...

In a small town that prided itself on tight-knit community bonds, the murder of Sierah Joughin sent shockwaves through the hearts of its residents. A vibrant young woman with a promising future ahead, her tragic and untimely death exposed the darkness lurking beneath the surface of this seemingly idyllic place. Sierah Jougin was riding her bike along a rural road when she crossed paths with a mons...

Join Ashley and Ricky as they discuss a case that occurred in Knoxville, Tennessee, in the fall of 2016. While they believed they were doing everything in their power to keep their 16-year-old daughter safe and away from her possessive 18-year-old boyfriend, Emma Walker's parents were shocked to learn of her murder the following morning. In this case, a family's attempt to shield their high school...