Jennifer James and Jill Stanley

Common Mystics

Religion EN ↓ 175 episodes

Ride shotgun with psychic sisters Jennifer James and Jill Stanley as they road trip to uncover extraordinary stories (we’re talking ghosts, murder, mayhem) in ordinary places (shout out to middle America!). Giving voice to the voiceless, these sisters use their intuitive powers, incredible research skills and wicked humor to “tune in” and bring untold history to life. So, hop in, buckle up and get ready for a smart, silly, spooky good time.

Author

Jennifer James and Jill Stanley

Category

Religion

Podcast website

commonmystics.net

Latest episode

Jul 9, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

130: The Enduring Allure of Tallulah Bankhead in Huntsville, AL 24.07.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics , Jen and Jill delve into the fascinating life of Tallulah Bankhead (1902–1968), the legendary stage and screen actress from the golden age of entertainment.* Whether shining on Broadway, captivating audiences on London stages, or making waves in Hollywood, Tallulah's larger-than-life persona always set her apart. Yet, her personal life often eclipsed her professi...

129: A Walk of Bravery in Gadsden, AL 10.07.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill uncover the inspiring yet tragic story of Bill Moore, a white man with an unshakable commitment to civil rights.* Driven by his belief in equality, Bill embarked on bold solo marches to expose the injustices faced by black Americans. His third march, in April 1963 from Chattanooga, TN, to Jackson, MS, took a devastating turn when, just outside Gadsde...

128: The Confession of Charlie Johnson, The First Legally Hanged Man in Etowah County, AL 26.06.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill explore the chilling story of a man condemned to death under dubious circumstances in the deep South of 1889.* The post-Reconstruction era brought significant challenges for people of color across the United States, including in communities like Etowah County, Alabama. Black residents endured constant threats of violence and intimidation, often with...

127: Mystics in the Making- Our Grandpa Stanley 12.06.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill honor the life and legacy of their Grandfather Stanley—a man who quietly stood tall among the strong women in his family. As the husband of their beloved Grandma Irena and father to their mom Stella and her three sisters, Grandpa Stanley often stayed in the background. But recently, his spirit has been making itself known, nudging Jen and Jill to unc...

126: Brothers at Odds- A Cherokee Tale of Politics and Pride in Fort Payne, AL 29.05.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill uncover a surprising twist as a new voice emerges to share his perspective on the Trail of Tears. While creating Episode 124, which focused on Cherokee Chief John Ross, we had no idea about the deep rift between him and his younger brother, Andrew. Now, Andrew's voice comes through with anger and a strikingly different account of the events leading u...

125: A Legacy of Love in Chattanooga, TN 15.05.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, we continue our discussion of Chattanooga, Tennessee. After the Civil War, many families were left shattered with poverty, disease, and hardship forcing countless children into desperate situations. Orphanages emerged, yet support remained tragically scarce for children of color or those living with disabilities or illness. That’s where Almira Steele’s story begi...

124: The Trail of Tears in Chattanooga, TN 01.05.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill explore the haunting history of the Trail of Tears—the forced removal of the Cherokee people and other tribes from their lands to territories west of the Mississippi in the 1830s. Along the way, the sisters connect with the spirit of John Ross, the Cherokee Nation’s Principal Chief, elected in 1828. Ross spent his life fighting for his people’s rights...

Boo Review #12: The Merman's Prophesies 24.04.2025

Welcome back to The Boo Review, where we dive into the most haunting tales from yesterday's news sources.  Today’s tale of a mystical merman draws inspiration from a fascinating article in The American Weekly Mercury out of Philadelphia, published on September 6, 1739. It begins with an ambitious Englishman, desperate for quick riches, and two honorable Dutch brothers who team up to start a fishin...

123: More Voices from the Road- The Hemings of Monticello 17.04.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics  the sisters dive into one of America's most controversial icons: Thomas Jefferson. Celebrated as the author of the Declaration of Independence and the nation's third President, Jefferson's legacy isn't without its darker chapters. Rumors of an illicit relationship with Sally Hemings, an enslaved woman at his Monticello plantation, have swirled for centuries. Whil...

Common Mystics' Mini Meditation for Psychic Protection 10.04.2025

Welcome to Common Mystics' Mini Meditation series! These brief episodes are crafted to assist you in manifesting your ideal life in just a few minutes. Feeling drained or overwhelmed by others' energy? In this episode, we’re guiding you through a powerful meditation to strengthen your psychic protection and reclaim your energetic space. Whether you’re dealing with challenging environments or simpl...

122: More Voices from the Road- The Black Widow of La Porte, IN 03.04.2025

In this gripping episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill dive into a chilling tale of greed, betrayal, and cold-blooded murder.* Following a trail of cryptic clues, including the activities of infamous serial killer H.H. Holmes, the sisters uncover the horrifying story of Belle Gunness, a calculating murderer who lured men into marriage only to murder them for their money. The mystery begins when...

Boo Review #11: Death By Witchcraft in Quindaro, KS 27.03.2025

Welcome back to The Boo Review, where we dive into the most haunting tales from yesterday's news sources. Today's story, out of Quindero, Kansas, is a haunting tale of a once-thriving town that vanished under mysterious and tragic circumstances. Legend has it, the town was home to witches skilled in casting curses and dark incantations, fueling fear and paranoia among the townsfolk and driving the...

121: A Vision of Murder in Oak Park, IL 20.03.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill explore the remarkable yet haunting story about Steve Linscott, a man whose life was forever altered by his unexpected connection to a horrific crime.* In 1980, Steve, a Bible college student in Oak Park, Illinois, sat down with police for what seemed like an innocent interview. He described a vivid dream he had—one that coincidentally occurred on th...

Common Mystics' Mini Meditation for the Full Moon 13.03.2025

Welcome to Common Mystics' Mini Meditation series! These brief episodes are crafted to assist you in manifesting your ideal life in just a few minutes. Today’s Mini Meditation is thoughtfully designed for the full moon—a powerful moment of closure and release. The full moon invites us to let go of what no longer serves us, while offering a moment to reflect on our connection to nature’s rhythms. I...

120: Astrological Insights for March 2025 – Eclipses, Energy Shifts, and New Beginnings 06.03.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, we’re thrilled to welcome our friend Michelle Holland as we delve into the cosmic forces set to influence us this month. March 2025 is shaping up to be a month of profound cosmic shifts! Join us in this episode as we explore the powerful energy of this month’s eclipses. We’ll break down how these celestial events are pushing us all to release the past and step in...

Boo Review #10: The Séance on Twenty-Seventh Street in Rochester, NY 27.02.2025

Welcome back to The Boo Review, where we dive into the most haunting tales from yesterday's news sources. Rochester, New York is steeped in spiritualist traditions and eerie tales of the paranormal. Back in March 1890, the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle documented a chilling story of a haunted house that still haunts the imagination. Our latest Boo Review dives into the fictional story of Susan...

119: Truth in Harmonia, MI 20.02.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, Jen and Jill share a captivating story uncovered by a Common Mystics retreat group in August 2024. While exploring Bedford Township, MI, the group followed psychic impressions that guided them to a nearly forgotten village and the legendary freedom fighter and civil rights icon, Sojourner Truth. However, the spirit that emerged wasn’t Truth herself, but one of he...

Common Mystics' Mini Meditation for Releasing Rage 13.02.2025

Welcome to Common Mystics' Mini Meditation series! These brief episodes are crafted to assist you in manifesting your ideal life in just a few minutes. Today's Mini Meditation is designed to help you release your rage. If you’re like us, the start of this year has come with its fair share of challenges. If you’re feeling overwhelmed by anxiety, fear, or anger, this mini meditation is here to help....

118: Return to Nashville, MI 06.02.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics , Jen and Jill return to Nashville, Michigan, where the voiceless spirit from their very first episode speaks once more. During the summer of 2024, while hosting a Common Mystics retreat in Battle Creek, MI, the group made an unplanned visit to the Putnam House, now home to the Nashville public library. What followed was a captivating chain of events, drawing the...

Boo Review #9: The Milkwoman’s Daughter in Endfield, PA 30.01.2025

Welcome back to The Boo Review, where we dive into the most haunting tales from yesterday's news sources. Set in 1729, this tale unfolds in the rural settlement of Endfield, Pennsylvania, within a family of dairy farmers. Adelaide, the family’s formidable matriarch, is a woman of stern demeanor, while her husband, Henry, is a quiet and humble presence. Their 13-year-old daughter, Marlene, stands o...

117: Encore Presentation-Mystery & Legend in Nashville, MI 23.01.2025

On the first episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill stumble upon a 127 year old mystery in Nashville, MI surrounding a tragic death in the mansion of a prominent local family.* What happened at the home of Charles M. Putnam? Was it murder? Suicide? A potential cover up? Listen in as Jennifer and Jill sort through fact, legend, and clues from beyond the grave to relate their psychic adventure...

Common Mystics' Mini Meditation for Receiving Clarity From Your Higher Self 16.01.2025

Welcome to Common Mystics' Mini Meditation series! These brief episodes are crafted to assist you in manifesting your ideal life in just a few minutes. Today's Mini Meditation is designed to help you receive clarity from your higher self. Meeting your higher self during meditation isn’t just a spiritual exercise—it’s a way to unlock clarity, self-awareness, growth, and peace. Whether you’re seekin...

116: Stories of Hope 09.01.2025

On this episode of Common Mystics, we share uplifting stories of hope from a few of our friends and listeners—stories that capture moments when Spirit reveals itself. Perfectly timed for the new year, these tales are meant to inspire wonder, joy, and a renewed sense of optimism. Join us as we look ahead to brighter, more glorious days with hearts full of hope. Support Common Mystics on Patreon her...

Boo Review #8: The Quaker Visitant in Lancaster, PA 02.01.2025

Welcome back to The Boo Review, where we dive into the most haunting tales from yesterday's news sources. This week, we’re taking you back to 1753 in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, to explore the chilling tale of Jacob Wilhelm—a man whose stubbornness and cruelty led to a shocking and poetic fate. Who was Jacob Wilhelm? Why did the townsfolk despise him? And what led to his untimely death in the very gr...

115: Encore Presentation- Holiday Special 2022 26.12.2024

Please enjoy this encore presentation of the Common Mystics podcast originally posted in December 2022. On this holiday episode, Jennifer and Jill dive into the roots of Christmas. If nothing else, tune in to hear Jill's versions of the Nativity and the Immaculate Conception.  Then stick around for some interesting history and thoughtful contemplation on the meaning of the holiday season. Support...

Listen to the Common Mystics podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.